New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Mass shootings

I think you need to.

The discussion is very different here.

I know that a few police in the UK carry guns now. Every American cop does, and so do a lot of other public safety officials and private ones as well.

The US is a very violent society, and we enable it by making guns easy to get.

The industry in the US is very wealthy, powerful and influential. It does everything it can to perpetuate this tragic state of affairs.

We are the world's number one munitions maker, with 50% of the world market.

Mass killings like the one that initiated this discussion are very rare in your country. They are commonplace now, here.

And there are people who want to make excuses for it, pass it off as routine, or suggest that it would be better if everyone you saw was carrying a gun.

It's the kind of paranoid vigilante world that exists in adolescent video games.
 
I wouldn't argue for the principle, but when you get done arguing your politics, we still live in a world where 20 year-olds are breaking into schools with assault weapons and opening fire. Yes, I think it should be illegal to possess an assault/automatic weapon, except in the line of military duty. But winning that political battle and then enforcing the law is a long way off... in the mean time; a female principal was just shot to death trying to tackle a 20 year-old kid firing an assault rifle... she would have been far better off trying to stop the kid with a colt .45
 
I think you need to.

The discussion is very different here.

I know that a few police in the UK carry guns now. Every American cop does, and so do a lot of other public safety officials and private ones as well.

The US is a very violent society, and we enable it by making guns easy to get.

The industry in the US is very wealthy, powerful and influential. It does everything it can to perpetuate this tragic state of affairs.

We are the world's number one munitions maker, with 50% of the world market.

Mass killings like the one that initiated this discussion are very rare in your country. They are commonplace now, here.

And there are people who want to make excuses for it, pass it off as routine, or suggest that it would be better if everyone you saw was carrying a gun.

It's the kind of paranoid vigilante world that exists in adolescent video games.


In the years I lived in the US fear never left me .......I know it is very very violent and crazily so, and, but your History is different to mine and the Constitution and all that........... I cannot see any drastic gun laws being bought in without a real war. And I do see the arguments, I'm not agreeing with them I am just trying to understand them.

And I do think you should look at the Drugs, the legal ones. Legal Drugs and legal Guns.
 
I wouldn't argue for the principle, but when you get done arguing your politics, we still live in a world where 20 year-olds are breaking into schools with assault weapons and opening fire. Yes, I think it should be illegal to possess an assault/automatic weapon, except in the line of military duty. But winning that political battle and then enforcing the law is a long way off... in the mean time; a female principal was just shot to death trying to tackle a 20 year-old kid firing an assault rifle... she would have been far better off trying to stop the kid with a colt .45


You make it sound like the Wild West .................. is that where you are going ?
 
If we may, I will seperate the US from the rest of the World for the sake of this list.

Because the gun is intrinsic to your culture but not all others.

Yes all of the points are valid and when people do not feel safe then their choice to own a gun in the USA should be respected.

That so many powerful weapons are felt to be necessary is again a statement of the state of things.

And AILs' point in this debate so far, that of drugs, is the most important so far. Don't ya think ?

Drugs to me are the biggest problem, and I'm not talking about illegal drugs. I seriously doubt if there are any other countries that have as many of their kids on drugs as this one does. I have read all kinds of studies about what these do to people. They definitely cause people to be more suicidal and/or violent.

Somehow the time frame of the extreme use of these drugs tends to coincide with the time frame of the increased mass shootings.
 
The Wild West was never this wild. I drive a cab, and I don't carry a weapon, but lots of cab drivers do. Any public school, community college or University has an office and an administrative staff. Maybe it is time to demand that all those offices have a contingency plan for attacks with automatic weapons. Obviously the police are too slow to stop this type of event. The administrative staff tried to stop it at this school, but they were woefully unprepared to do so. Flying flags at half staff all over the nation for a week isn't going to stop the next attack and the next attack may come before the flags are raised from this one.
 
The Wild West was never this wild. I drive a cab, and I don't carry a weapon, but lots of cab drivers do. Any public school, community college or University has an office and an administrative staff. Maybe it is time to demand that all those offices have a contingency plan for attacks with automatic weapons. Obviously the police are too slow to stop this type of event. The administrative staff tried to stop it at this school, but they were woefully unprepared to do so. Flying flags at half staff all over the nation for a week isn't going to stop the next attack and the next attack may come before the flags are raised from this one.

I don't know what to say, what a terrible situation when children need an armed guard.
 
Drugs to me are the biggest problem, and I'm not talking about illegal drugs. I seriously doubt if there are any other countries that have as many of their kids on drugs as this one does. I have read all kinds of studies about what these do to people. They definitely cause people to be more suicidal and/or violent.

Somehow the time frame of the extreme use of these drugs tends to coincide with the time frame of the increased mass shootings.

I know, I too have done loads of reading up on the whole ugly Big Pharma take over as well as seeing first hand how some of these terrible drugs can destroy people.

But children on drugs ! The World really has gone mad.
 
terrible it is. But to be over run by a single whacko when almost any school could muster at least three armed responders... just having the contingency plan in place would likely ward off the single attacker. This week alone, that would have saved 26 lives.
 
As I told another poster earlier today, I am on my county Board of Education. I can assure you that the very idea of arming teachers and staff in schools would be looked on with outright terror.
 
Tom, once again, you're wrong man.

When a mass murder occurs, it receives instant and pervasive news coverage. Unfortunately, we are prone to overestimate the frequency of an event by its prominence in our minds, and mass murder is no exception. This is a very rare phenomenon and is neither increasing nor decreasing in the US. Since 1976 there have been about 20 mass murders a year. 2003 was the most violent year for mass murder, with 30 incidents and 135 victims. Virginia Tech, Fort Hood, Edmund Oklahoma, and San Ysidro still resonate in the public consciousness, however, reminding us that these events do happen.

http://blog.oup.com/2012/09/seven-myths-of-mass-murder/

You claim 14 is a high number, it's not. It's below average.

You liberals do this an awful lot, and on a LOT of topics.
 
Your link provided 8 examples of an armed citizen stopping the commission of murder in which a gun was also the weapon. If all 8 are true, the time the 8 examples are from 1991 through 2012. That's 21 years.

What that means is that among gun related murders (~11,500/yr), an armed citizen stops a murder to be committed by a gun once every 2.6 years. Meanwhile, if you accept a average murder rate of ~9,000/yr* by gun over that same 21 year period, ~190,000 gun caused murders have accumulated. That's ~4thousandths of 1 percent of the total gun caused murders.

What that proves is that armed citizens have stopped gun caused murders. It also says that armed citizens are not a significant deterrent.

The problem with your case here is that armed citizens are also the greatest cause of murder by gun.
 
Those who want everyone to have guns are largely from Texas. Here is a law on the books in Texas-----

"When two trains meet each other at a railroad crossing, each shall come to a full stop, and neither shall proceed until the other is gone."

.....Yes that, my dear friends, is Republican / Right Wing / Texas thinking.

End the Right Wing. Better for all.
 
A contingency plan would secure three to four guns in a spot only accessible by administrators. It wouldn't arm anyone. But in an emergency, it would give a principal a much better option than tossing herself into a hail of bullets.
 
A contingency plan would secure three to four guns in a spot only accessible by administrators. It wouldn't arm anyone. But in an emergency, it would give a principal a much better option than tossing herself into a hail of bullets.

Contrary to conventional feel-goodism, even the majority of GOPs choose not to own guns. The idea that we should select educators and administrators on the basis of their willingness to shoot people, is silly. We'd end up..to put it nicely, with a "skewed sample" of educators and administrators.

And of course...as soon as we made these people responsible for shooting any and all baddies - per the wet-dreams of the gun-worshippers, then they WOULD be held responsible for every untoward death. And, that....wouldn't be good.
 
Contrary to conventional feel-goodism, even the majority of GOPs choose not to own guns. The idea that we should select educators and administrators on the basis of their willingness to shoot people, is silly. We'd end up..to put it nicely, with a "skewed sample" of educators and administrators.

And of course...as soon as we made these people responsible for shooting any and all baddies - per the wet-dreams of the gun-worshippers, then they WOULD be held responsible for every untoward death. And, that....wouldn't be good.


A school district in Texas has been allowing teachers to carry arms since 2008. There hasn't been one incident of violence.

Concealed carry works.

A North Texas school district allows its teachers to carry guns in class as long as they have a concealed handgun license, and the superintendent said he wouldn't have it any other way.

The Harrold Independent School District is near Wichita Falls. The nearest law enforcement agency is 30 minutes away. So Harrold ISD superintendent David Thweatt said guns are allowed for everyone's protection.

In the five years it has been in place, Thweatt said there have been no incidents at the school. He attributes that to the extra security measures they have taken.

http://www.click2houston.com/news/N...32786/-/format/rsss_2.0/-/bls1or/-/index.html
 
Your link provided 8 examples of an armed citizen stopping the commission of murder in which a gun was also the weapon. If all 8 are true, the time the 8 examples are from 1991 through 2012. That's 21 years.

What that means is that among gun related murders (~11,500/yr), an armed citizen stops a murder to be committed by a gun once every 2.6 years. Meanwhile, if you accept a average murder rate of ~9,000/yr* by gun over that same 21 year period, ~190,000 gun caused murders have accumulated. That's ~4thousandths of 1 percent of the total gun caused murders.

What that proves is that armed citizens have stopped gun caused murders. It also says that armed citizens are not a significant deterrent.

The problem with your case here is that armed citizens are also the greatest cause of murder by gun.

Well-said! I'd also point out that you could extend the same point even farther if you didn't just consider gun-related murders, but also gun-related suicides and accidental deadly shootings. Then we're more in the ballpark of 30,000 per year.

Of course, some of those murders and suicides would have happened even if a gun hadn't been present -- the person would have chosen a different means. Admittedly, guns seem to play a particularly small role in enhancing the suicide rate.... if a gun isn't on hand, a depressed person has plenty of time to come up with infinite other means to kill himself, so only in a small percentage of cases will the lack of a firearm make the difference, by causing the person to reflect on the matter long enough to come to his senses. But, be that as it may, all the international evidence we have suggests that guns are, in fact, a very significant net contributor to early mortality. They bump up suicide rates a little, murder rates quite a bit, and once you throw in all those accidents, you're talking significant numbers. If we restricted firearms more, it would almost certainly be a meaningful way to lower early mortality rates.
 
Back
Top