New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Mere Christianity

Arkady

President
Christian sects differ from each other on a range of doctrines (papal infallibility, the permissibility of divorce, the belief in a trinity, the veracity of Joseph Smith's discoveries, and so on). So, I'm curious what people here think are the core beliefs required to make a person a "Christian" -- the common denominators shared by all sects that can legitimately be given that name.

As a non-Christian here is my initial stab at it:

Christianity is the belief that Jesus of Nazareth was the son of God, that his teachings offer extremely important guidance, and that his death in some way redeemed mankind.

Can any of those be dropped while still being a Christian? For example, if you believed that Jesus was the son of God, and an extremely important moral guide, but thought that Jesus' death was merely a tragedy, which could not in any way address any other person's sins, would you still be a Christian? What if you saw Jesus as an extremely important prophet, but not the son of God?

On the flip side, are there any beliefs I'm leaving out that are critical for a person to be Christian? For example, does one need to believe that Jesus was divine? That he was both man and God? That his teachings are infallible? That he was without sin? That he rose from the dead? That he performed other miracles? That his mother was a virgin? That he will return at the end of the world? That he was betrayed by Judas? That faith in Jesus is a necessary element of salvation? Obviously, lots of that stuff is common to many or nearly all Christian faiths, but if a person rejects one of those, is he no longer a Christian?
 
Who are we to judge?

If someone likes the idea of being called a "Christian", then they are a Christian. Doesn't really seem to matter what they believe.
 
Christian sects differ from each other on a range of doctrines (papal infallibility, the permissibility of divorce, the belief in a trinity, the veracity of Joseph Smith's discoveries, and so on). So, I'm curious what people here think are the core beliefs required to make a person a "Christian" -- the common denominators shared by all sects that can legitimately be given that name.

As a non-Christian here is my initial stab at it:

Christianity is the belief that Jesus of Nazareth was the son of God, that his teachings offer extremely important guidance, and that his death in some way redeemed mankind.

Can any of those be dropped while still being a Christian? For example, if you believed that Jesus was the son of God, and an extremely important moral guide, but thought that Jesus' death was merely a tragedy, which could not in any way address any other person's sins, would you still be a Christian? What if you saw Jesus as an extremely important prophet, but not the son of God?

On the flip side, are there any beliefs I'm leaving out that are critical for a person to be Christian? For example, does one need to believe that Jesus was divine? That he was both man and God? That his teachings are infallible? That he was without sin? That he rose from the dead? That he performed other miracles? That his mother was a virgin? That he will return at the end of the world? That he was betrayed by Judas? That faith in Jesus is a necessary element of salvation? Obviously, lots of that stuff is common to many or nearly all Christian faiths, but if a person rejects one of those, is he no longer a Christian?
Christian sects differ from each other on a range of doctrines (papal infallibility, the permissibility of divorce, the belief in a trinity, the veracity of Joseph Smith's discoveries, and so on). So, I'm curious what people here think are the core beliefs required to make a person a "Christian" -- the common denominators shared by all sects that can legitimately be given that name.

As a non-Christian here is my initial stab at it:

Christianity is the belief that Jesus of Nazareth was the son of God, that his teachings offer extremely important guidance, and that his death in some way redeemed mankind.

Can any of those be dropped while still being a Christian? For example, if you believed that Jesus was the son of God, and an extremely important moral guide, but thought that Jesus' death was merely a tragedy, which could not in any way address any other person's sins, would you still be a Christian? What if you saw Jesus as an extremely important prophet, but not the son of God?

On the flip side, are there any beliefs I'm leaving out that are critical for a person to be Christian? For example, does one need to believe that Jesus was divine? That he was both man and God? That his teachings are infallible? That he was without sin? That he rose from the dead? That he performed other miracles? That his mother was a virgin? That he will return at the end of the world? That he was betrayed by Judas? That faith in Jesus is a necessary element of salvation? Obviously, lots of that stuff is common to many or nearly all Christian faiths, but if a person rejects one of those, is he no longer a Christian?


Jesus said, "If you bring forth what is within you, what you bring forth will save you. If you do not bring forth what is within you, what you do not bring forth will destroy you."

Gospel of St Thomas

. . . the companion of the [Savior is] Mary Magdalene. [But Christ loved] her more than [all] the disciples, and used to kiss her [often] on her [mouth]. The rest of [the disciples were offended] . . . They said to him, "Why do you love her more than all of us?" The Savior answered and said to them, "Why do I not love you as (I love) her?"

Gospel of Philip
 
Is a person who tries to IMITATE Christ, but does not believe in his DIVINITY, a "Christian"...or not?

Is a person who claims divinity to Christ a "Christian"....if they live their lives in direct oppostion to many of the teachings of Jesus?

Traditional Christian dogma teachs the former is false, but the latter is true.

As well, a person who lives their life as Jesus led it...but who does not "accept Jesus as the Son of God and their personal Saviour"....goes to Hell. While the person who contantly violates the teachings of Jesus, but affirms their belief that he was the Son of God and is their personal Saviour....goes to Heaven.

((Apologists can try the "Only God knows who gets into Heaven" argument....but if they do, as shown on other threads, they directly contradict Church teachings, which are as I stated above. No spin or wordsmithing changes that.))
 
Is a person who tries to IMITATE Christ, but does not believe in his DIVINITY, a "Christian"...or not?

Is a person who claims divinity to Christ a "Christian"....if they live their lives in direct oppostion to many of the teachings of Jesus?

Traditional Christian dogma teachs the former is false, but the latter is true.

As well, a person who lives their life as Jesus led it...but who does not "accept Jesus as the Son of God and their personal Saviour"....goes to Hell. While the person who contantly violates the teachings of Jesus, but affirms their belief that he was the Son of God and is their personal Saviour....goes to Heaven.

((Apologists can try the "Only God knows who gets into Heaven" argument....but if they do, as shown on other threads, they directly contradict Church teachings, which are as I stated above. No spin or wordsmithing changes that.))

The only things shown on other threads Gordon is that 1)you ask what a religion believes and then claim that the person of that religion has it wrong and do so by citing what OTHER religions believe. And 2) people grow bored with the game you play and eventually realize that you're not capable of honest debate, walk away, and leave you to your "see, see.....they can't answer me!"
 
gigi, if you know a person claims to be a Christian....yet cheats on their spouse....

you naturally say....nothing, right? Or "Who am I to judge?"....right?

BTW, when have I cited Islam or Hinduism or some "OTHER relgiion" to "claim a person has their religion wrong"? Give me a quote of me doing that.


Also, the fact you run out of arguments or whatever apologia you were taught in school....is not MY fault. :D
 
Christian sects differ from each other on a range of doctrines (papal infallibility, the permissibility of divorce, the belief in a trinity, the veracity of Joseph Smith's discoveries, and so on). So, I'm curious what people here think are the core beliefs required to make a person a "Christian" -- the common denominators shared by all sects that can legitimately be given that name.

As a non-Christian here is my initial stab at it:

Christianity is the belief that Jesus of Nazareth was the son of God, that his teachings offer extremely important guidance, and that his death in some way redeemed mankind.

Can any of those be dropped while still being a Christian? For example, if you believed that Jesus was the son of God, and an extremely important moral guide, but thought that Jesus' death was merely a tragedy, which could not in any way address any other person's sins, would you still be a Christian? What if you saw Jesus as an extremely important prophet, but not the son of God?

On the flip side, are there any beliefs I'm leaving out that are critical for a person to be Christian? For example, does one need to believe that Jesus was divine? That he was both man and God? That his teachings are infallible? That he was without sin? That he rose from the dead? That he performed other miracles? That his mother was a virgin? That he will return at the end of the world? That he was betrayed by Judas? That faith in Jesus is a necessary element of salvation? Obviously, lots of that stuff is common to many or nearly all Christian faiths, but if a person rejects one of those, is he no longer a Christian?

Almost. Those beliefs you stated that "Christianity is the belief that Jesus of Nazareth was the son of God, that his teachings offer extremely important guidance, and that his death in some way redeemed mankind" are the commonality of all Christian religions. But the word "only" must be added before "son".

Yes, that would exclude LDS and JW, but if the word "only" is not there, the only Christian religions it describes are JW and LDS. That one word is VERY important to Christian religions.

If Jesus was not infallible, then how can the Pope be infallible?
In order for Jesus to be who he is: the Savior of us from the evil of our sins, all of those attributes listed for him must be true.
 
Is a person who tries to IMITATE Christ, but does not believe in his DIVINITY, a "Christian"...or not?

Is a person who claims divinity to Christ a "Christian"....if they live their lives in direct oppostion to many of the teachings of Jesus?

Traditional Christian dogma teachs the former is false, but the latter is true.

As well, a person who lives their life as Jesus led it...but who does not "accept Jesus as the Son of God and their personal Saviour"....goes to Hell. While the person who contantly violates the teachings of Jesus, but affirms their belief that he was the Son of God and is their personal Saviour....goes to Heaven.

((Apologists can try the "Only God knows who gets into Heaven" argument....but if they do, as shown on other threads, they directly contradict Church teachings, which are as I stated above. No spin or wordsmithing changes that.))
For the last couple days, I've been reading about Calvinism, which has a really weird approach to salvation. Basically, they think everything is predestined. They think that God decided, before he even created the world, who would be saved and who would be damned, and there's not a thing you can do to interfere with that plan. You could commit every unspeakable evil imaginable, and if God chose you to be among the elect before you were ever born, you're going to Heaven. And you could live the most saintly life imaginable, dedicating your every breath to helping your fellow man, and if God decided you weren't among the elect, before you were born, you're going to Hell. I find it bizarre that a faith that essentially dispenses with free will tha way could take off the way Calvinism did, and still be around today.
 
Almost. Those beliefs you stated that "Christianity is the belief that Jesus of Nazareth was the son of God, that his teachings offer extremely important guidance, and that his death in some way redeemed mankind" are the commonality of all Christian religions. But the word "only" must be added before "son".

Yes, that would exclude LDS and JW, but if the word "only" is not there, the only Christian religions it describes are JW and LDS. That one word is VERY important to Christian religions.

If Jesus was not infallible, then how can the Pope be infallible?
In order for Jesus to be who he is: the Savior of us from the evil of our sins, all of those attributes listed for him must be true.
I don't think that leaving "only" out excludes any religion. If I introduce someone to my son and say "this is my son," that doesn't imply I have more than one son. It takes no position on that.

As for LDS and JW, do they take the position that God had more than one son? I didn't realize that.
 
For the last couple days, I've been reading about Calvinism, which has a really weird approach to salvation. Basically, they think everything is predestined. They think that God decided, before he even created the world, who would be saved and who would be damned, and there's not a thing you can do to interfere with that plan. You could commit every unspeakable evil imaginable, and if God chose you to be among the elect before you were ever born, you're going to Heaven. And you could live the most saintly life imaginable, dedicating your every breath to helping your fellow man, and if God decided you weren't among the elect, before you were born, you're going to Hell. I find it bizarre that a faith that essentially dispenses with free will tha way could take off the way Calvinism did, and still be around today.

It has a logic to it.

If we accept "God" as a "Supreme Being" then He would possess that "supreme characteristic" of ....Omniscience. Not just Knowledge of Everything happening now...or in the Past....but the Future as well. Otherwise it wouldn't be "true Omniscience" and thus He would not be the "Most Powerful Concept Imaginable"....He'd be "God-Lite".

So, accepting Omniscience....God would have known....back to Creation or the Big Bang....who was going to be "saved" and who was not. And if Heaven and Hell are real, then who was going to go to Heaven and who to Hell....millenia before that person was even born.

Or at the least, that a person born in 1875 AD was NOT going to be "saved" and go to Heaven.....way back in 10,000,000,000 BC.

Ergo....no Free Will as it effects Salvation. It's not possible. For a person to become "saved" that God did not already see was going to be saved, would be impossible.

Now throw in Omnipotence, God as All-Powerful and the One who sets all into motion. The Primum Mobile, the First Cause of all things.

If so....not only did God KNOW who was not going to be saved....He deliberately CREATED the person (or the circumstances for the birth of that person).....that He was either going to allow to live and die and stay dead....or who had a soul that HE HIMSELF doomed to Hell, as I said, millenia before they were born.

From that point onward, Calvinists had to determine a method for "spotting" the Saved and a Christian denomination that taught that and taught that there was some "greater likelihood of being saved"....if you belonged to the Calvinist Church, naturally. :)
 
It has a logic to it.

If we accept "God" as a "Supreme Being" then He would possess that "supreme characteristic" of ....Omniscience. Not just Knowledge of Everything happening now...or in the Past....but the Future as well. Otherwise it wouldn't be "true Omniscience" and thus He would not be the "Most Powerful Concept Imaginable"....He'd be "God-Lite".

So, accepting Omniscience....God would have known....back to Creation or the Big Bang....who was going to be "saved" and who was not. And if Heaven and Hell are real, then who was going to go to Heaven and who to Hell....millenia before that person was even born.

Or at the least, that a person born in 1875 AD was NOT going to be "saved" and go to Heaven.....way back in 10,000,000,000 BC.

Ergo....no Free Will as it effects Salvation. It's not possible. For a person to become "saved" that God did not already see was going to be saved, would be impossible.

Now throw in Omnipotence, God as All-Powerful and the One who sets all into motion. The Primum Mobile, the First Cause of all things.

If so....not only did God KNOW who was not going to be saved....He deliberately CREATED the person (or the circumstances for the birth of that person).....that He was either going to allow to live and die and stay dead....or who had a soul that HE HIMSELF doomed to Hell, as I said, millenia before they were born.

From that point onward, Calvinists had to determine a method for "spotting" the Saved and a Christian denomination that taught that and taught that there was some "greater likelihood of being saved"....if you belonged to the Calvinist Church, naturally. :)
A truly Supreme Being of the non-God-lite variety is impossible to imagine within the confines of the universe as we know it. It is possible to conceive of a being so great that his greatness fills every possible space of existence fully (true omnipresence), thus leaving no room for anything that is not fully God, and therefore necessitating that there be no sin, no Hell, no people, no animals, no gravity, no time, etc. So, in the same sense as a Calvinist might say that a God without omniscience isn't the greatest God imaginable and therefore can't be God, I can say that a Calvinist God isn't the greatest God imaginabe and can't be God. It is a concept that falls short of the most powerful concept imaginable because it falls short of absolute omnipresence.

And it's not like Calvinism is just an outgrowth of the assumption of Divine Omniscience. An omniscient God could know before the beginning of the world who would be saved and damned based on foreknowledge of what their moral choices would be, and although that's problematic for free choice, it still preserves a little room for it and for the impotance of morality. But Calvinists go a perverse further step and actually insist that God's foreknowledge of who would be damned and saved was not based on foreknowledge of their moral choices, but rather based on that election being unrelated to any moral consideration. In the Calvinist view, we are all fully corrupt, and the only difference between the saved and damned is God's grace -- essentially a free gift given to some and not others for reasons wholly unrelated to merit. It all winds up a kind of lottery, depriving life of any meaning.

I don't get how anyone can be attracted to that -- except, I suppose, for people who know themselves to be especially depraved, and who therefore find comfort in the idea that there's no free will and no connection between human choices and salvation, so they can stop sweating about trying to be better people. Given Calvin's own murderous ways and twisted personality, that might go a long way towards explaining why he was attracted to that theology. But it's amazing there were so many others who also latched on to that message that life is essentially completely inconsequential.
 
I don't think that leaving "only" out excludes any religion. If I introduce someone to my son and say "this is my son," that doesn't imply I have more than one son. It takes no position on that.

As for LDS and JW, do they take the position that God had more than one son? I didn't realize that.

There would be some religions that would exclude themselves if the word "only" wasn't there. LDS believes we are all "God's sons". We are siblings of Jesus. Other Christian religions absolutely do not share that belief, so the word "only" is definitely necessary.

I was wrong about the JW. Their belief is the same as mainstream Christians regarding Jesus and the word "only" would probably be their requirement too.
 
gigi, if you know a person claims to be a Christian....yet cheats on their spouse....

you naturally say....nothing, right? Or "Who am I to judge?"....right?

BTW, when have I cited Islam or Hinduism or some "OTHER relgiion" to "claim a person has their religion wrong"? Give me a quote of me doing that.


Also, the fact you run out of arguments or whatever apologia you were taught in school....is not MY fault. :D

More questions you won't answer:

1) How do you know what I do and don't say to someone who is cheating on their spouse?

2)What am I required to do as a Catholic when I become aware of someone committing a grave sin?

Seems you'd have to know the answers to the above questions before you can make the statements you did and pass the judgement you did, so why don't you share with all of us?

3)What do YOU say to someone who is cheating on their spouse? I understand that atheists and agnostics are just as consumed with morality, right VS wrong, and fairness as anyone else. So, while your source of inspiration may be different, surely you, too, must feel compelled to speak up when you find out someone you know is being unfaithful in their marriage. So what do you say to that person?

OF course you offer that you didn't bring up Hinduism or Islam. How very convenient. No mention from you though of the fact that you ask me, a person who follows one religion, a question, and then yell "Conflict with Church teaching" citing the beliefs of other Christian religions to force your fake point.

The only thing I feel like I'm out of is patience for your 7th grade sleight of hand approach to discussion.
 
Beliefs are cheap. I can believe in an imaginary friend, should I choose to.

It appears to me that unless one's religious convictions actually affect the way that one behaves, then one's beliefs are of no more consequence than is my hypothetical imaginary friend.
 
More questions you won't answer:

1) How do you know what I do and don't say to someone who is cheating on their spouse?

Because I've pointed out people going against the Bible on this board, who claim to be "Bible Believers"....and you defend them. I realize as a Catholic you think there are "degrees of sin" and some are worse than others....but it's only a matter of degrees from violating Titus 3:2....to violating "Thou shalt not commit adultery", isn't it?


2)What am I required to do as a Catholic when I become aware of someone committing a grave sin?

Say nothing.....or criticize it. But criticize it EQUALLY, without favoritism to folks you share a political allegiance with or dismissing it as a "minor sin" if it suits you.

Seems you'd have to know the answers to the above questions before you can make the statements you did and pass the judgement you did, so why don't you share with all of us?

I just answered them....you will NEVER answer mine honestly. Now, because you'd contradict your earlier stances when I brought up Titus 3:2 and what our supposed "Bible Believing" bloggers post.

3)What do YOU say to someone who is cheating on their spouse? I understand that atheists and agnostics are just as consumed with morality, right VS wrong, and fairness as anyone else. So, while your source of inspiration may be different, surely you, too, must feel compelled to speak up when you find out someone you know is being unfaithful in their marriage. So what do you say to that person?

I tell them in my opinion...it's wrong. Even if they are normally my political "allies".

OF course you offer that you didn't bring up Hinduism or Islam. How very convenient. No mention from you though of the fact that you ask me, a person who follows one religion, a question, and then yell "Conflict with Church teaching" citing the beliefs of other Christian religions to force your fake point.

YOU claimed that I used "OTHER religions" to say thngs against "Christians".......back up your claim. QUOTE me using Hinduism or Islam or Confucianism or any "OTHER religion" against Christianity. Or admit you made a false claim.

BTW, what's the Bible's view on "making false claims"? Or do you dismiss that sin as well....for yourself?

The only thing I feel like I'm out of is patience for your 7th grade sleight of hand approach to discussion.

Titus 3:2 Quote it.[/quote]
 
I don't get how anyone can be attracted to that -- except, I suppose, for people who know themselves to be especially depraved, and who therefore find comfort in the idea that there's no free will and no connection between human choices and salvation, so they can stop sweating about trying to be better people. Given Calvin's own murderous ways and twisted personality, that might go a long way towards explaining why he was attracted to that theology. But it's amazing there were so many others who also latched on to that message that life is essentially completely inconsequential.

Self-righteousness.....as we see around here...is not in short supply among Believers. (Even as they say "We are all sinners"...five minutes later, they talk about the "depravity" of others with just as much ease and amnesia).

So why not a religion that (A) is in accordance with God as Omniscient (As a concept, a SUPREME Being would have to be) and (B) their own self-assuredness that the adherents to the religion are among the "saved"?

Your average halo-polisher theist would certainly feel even MORE superior "knowing" that God "chose me for salvation all the way back to Creation"....AND that nothing they do, no "minor sins" nor "white lies" or "occasional" violations of Biblical teaching, could EVER remove that salvation.

The problem for Calvinists was...how to show to the Outside World that they WERE preordained saved. Their answer....prosperity.

And thus the "Protestant work ethic" also called the "Calvinist work ethic" was born and laid as one of the key societal foundations of the United States. A Calvinist who was RICH showed that he had "God's favor"...and thus "proved" to others (inside and outside the Church) that he was saved. So naturally everybody wanted to be as prosperous as possible....and worked hard to achieve prosperity.

If the hard work paid off, the person could claim it as a "sign". If it didn't, they risked being shown to be "damned"...and worked even harder.
 
Because I've pointed out people going against the Bible on this board, who claim to be "Bible Believers"....and you defend them. I realize as a Catholic you think there are "degrees of sin" and some are worse than others....but it's only a matter of degrees from violating Titus 3:2....to violating "Thou shalt not commit adultery", isn't it?




Say nothing.....or criticize it. But criticize it EQUALLY, without favoritism to folks you share a political allegiance with or dismissing it as a "minor sin" if it suits you.



I just answered them....you will NEVER answer mine honestly. Now, because you'd contradict your earlier stances when I brought up Titus 3:2 and what our supposed "Bible Believing" bloggers post.



I tell them in my opinion...it's wrong. Even if they are normally my political "allies".



YOU claimed that I used "OTHER religions" to say thngs against "Christians".......back up your claim. QUOTE me using Hinduism or Islam or Confucianism or any "OTHER religion" against Christianity. Or admit you made a false claim.

BTW, what's the Bible's view on "making false claims"? Or do you dismiss that sin as well....for yourself?



Titus 3:2 Quote it.
[/quote]

I didn't make a false claim. You just did it again half an hour ago...

"Or gigi's attempt to explain how the Native American who died in 1491 with NO knowledge of Jesus, still gets into Heaven....despite the Bible clearly saying "None come to the Father, but by me", which indicates that you have to believe in Jesus to get into Heaven."
https://www.politicaljack.com/threa...ting-of-christ-dubious-of-christ.63350/page-5

I'll say it again to you. You've asked this question several times. I, a Catholic, answer you according to what I believe to be true. What I believe to be true was taught to me by the Catholic Church. You hold up the interpretation made by another Christian religion to tell me that I am telling you something that conflicts with Catholic teaching. And you know you do it. What's more, you continually say "Christianity" as if no one here knows that there is more than one Christian religion and different interpretions that go with them.

And this ridiculous nonsense about viewing the sins of other people and showing 'favoritism" to people I share political beliefs with.....I don't have enough breadcrumbs to find my way back home from that one. That's your fantasy. You let us know how that one ends. You've tried to pull us into it before.

Do you own that book you sourced yesterday? Did you read that book?
 
I didn't make a false claim. You just did it again half an hour ago...

"Or gigi's attempt to explain how the Native American who died in 1491 with NO knowledge of Jesus, still gets into Heaven....despite the Bible clearly saying "None come to the Father, but by me", which indicates that you have to believe in Jesus to get into Heaven."
https://www.politicaljack.com/threa...ting-of-christ-dubious-of-christ.63350/page-5

And where did I use "OTHER religions", gigi? Show me....did I cite the Koran? Did I cite the Bhagavad Gita? Did I quote Confucius? Or quote some Buddhist monk?

If not....you made a false claim.



I'll say it again to you. You've asked this question several times. I, a Catholic, answer you according to what I believe to be true. What I believe to be true was taught to me by the Catholic Church. You hold up the interpretation made by another Christian religion to tell me that I am telling you something that conflicts with Catholic teaching. And you know you do it. What's more, you continually say "Christianity" as if no one here knows that there is more than one Christian religion and different interpretions that go with them.

Did the Church teach you to ignore all sins and never criticize others for being sinners? If so.....you go againsst Church teachings. Most recently....your rant against Nancy Pelosi.

On the other hand, if the RCC taught you to "point to sin, and rebuke it".....you go against Church teachings, but ignoring "some people" and "some sins"....if they are your "blog buddies" violating Titus 3:2....

or even YOURSELF violating Titus 3:2.


And this ridiculous nonsense about viewing the sins of other people and showing 'favoritism" to people I share political beliefs with.....I don't have enough breadcrumbs to find my way back home from that one. That's your fantasy. You let us know how that one ends. You've tried to pull us into it before.

All the people who came after me on pointing out Titus 3:2 were rightwingers.....you sided with them. That's pretty obviouis political.

Do you own that book you sourced yesterday? Did you read that book?

The question on "fetal souls" embarasses you....so you dodge it.
 
Back
Top