New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Militarized Liberalism

Arkady

President
Recently I've been doing a bit of reading about the 1950s. One thing I find interesting is that, despite the reputation of the era for conservatism in the US, there were a lot of initiatives that seem like the work of big-government liberals or progressives. The Eisenhower years saw an incredible expansion of those budget areas people on the left are always looking to expand. For example, here is the annual percentage growth of each of the following budget areas in the Eisenhower and Obama eras:

Education, Training, Employment, and Social Services
Eisenhower: 14.0%
Obama: 4.7%

Transportation
Eisenhower: 17.7%
Obama: 2.5%

Community and Regional Development
Eisenhower: 15.0%
Obama: 3.8%

General Science Space and Technology
Eisenhower: 36.7%
Obama: 0.2%

Of course, nearly any era looks liberal and progressive compared to the severe austerity of the Obama era. But even compared to eras not so plagued by conservatism as today, the Eisenhower-era budgeting can look surprisingly liberal. And I think the way they got there, as a culture, was to talk themselves into regarding these things as being military priorities, rather than civilian ones.

Most famously, look at the Interstate Highway System. It was a classic, New-Deal-style gigantic federal public works project to put people to work and expand the nation's economic potential. But it was sold as a way to make it easier to move troops around the country. That was never terribly honest, since the whole layout was built around where the population centers were, rather than where military materials and defensive interests were greatest. But the sales pitch got it done at a time when being more honest about the overwhelming goal of the spending might have gotten the initiative killed.

There are other examples, too. There was a fantastic increase in federal involvement in education in the 50s. But, again, it would have spooked the anti-communists if it hadn't been sold as a military effort. In fact, it was even officially called the National Defense Education Act, and was sold as part of the effort to get American science up to speed, by bringing along a new generation of scientists and mathematicians, in the face of the Russkies beating us into space.

Speaking of the anti-communists, the ultimate defeat of the Red Scare is another example of the triumph of liberalism only by way of alliance with militarism. Looney Joe McCarthy and other red-baiters were very popular for years, as they went after everyone from academics to entertainers to staff at the State Department. People were afraid to speak up against the madness, for fear that they'd, in turn, be accused of being Communists. But then McCarthy made the mistake of holding hearings on the Army, and that was the end of him. The liberal/military alliance swatted him down like he was nothing, and he promptly wound up censured and irrelevant.

I think there's also a broader way this dynamic has played out in American life, even beyond the 1950s. Military employment, even today, represents something close to a socialist ideal. In the military, you have fairly secure employment by the federal government. You have very low income inequality (the multiplier of income between the highest-paid generals and the lowest-paid privates is tiny compared to similar private sector multipliers). You have socialized medicine -- including hospitals owned by the government and doctors working directly for the government, and universal health insurance. You also get European-level vacation time (30 days per year), and again, it's rather socialistic in the sense that everyone gets the same amount of vacation, from the highest to the lowest ranks. For retirees, you have extremely generous retirement options, relative to the private sector (generally, half one's income after only 20 years, along with highly subsidized health insurance for life, and access to countless other benefits like tax-free on-base shopping). The military also provides extremely strong subsidies for education (the GI Bill), home ownership, etc. And pay, these days, is pretty good. The average soldier is paid, in cash and benefits, more than 80% of civilians with similar education and job skills. Ordinarily, all these things would set off screaming alarms for conservatives, but in the context of the military, they're typically seen as just fine.

So, maybe that's the trick, to recover from the austerity that continues to cripple our economy. We know what works. We know how to fix the problem. We just can't overcome the partisan opposition. Maybe all that's needed is to sell it as a defense imperative. It'll take some creativity to sell, say, universal pre-school or high-speed rail, as being about beating Al Qaeda. But if the Interstate Highway System, which was clearly laid out to address civilian needs, could be sold as being about defense, that kind of thing can be done.
 
this is a common misperception among people on the left.

that more spending on a particular topic is "left wing trope"

coming out of world war 2, and the depression, the nation had an aging and deplorable road and rail insfrastructure. Many schools and other buildings dated to the 19th century. Simply put, there weren't enough people working, and paying taxes during the FDR years to fund those sort of investments.

so they took place in the 1950s, when there was (nearly) full employment and prosperity.

what those on the left appear to be immune to is the notion that you cannot spend infinitely, in bad times. you need a booming economy to justify those sorts of investments.

if we had not been saddled with 6 years of recession, high unemployment, and falling expectations among both the unemployed and those who are fortune enough to have jobs, you would have the tax base and enthusiasm to make new investments.

democrats have only themselves to blame.
 
The Interstate Highway system was not merely "sold" as a means to move troops around. There was another reason the legislation was called the Defense Highway Act.

That reason was plain and simple. There is no constitutional authority to build interstate highways. To cloak the program in a constitutional authority, it was couched as a defense priority -- meaning it could be paid for and authorized via the "provide for the common defense" clause in the U.S. Constitution.

That was the good old days -- when you actually had to find a constitutional authority for doing something instead of invoking your telephone and your pen, and doing it anyway.
 
The Interstate Highway system was not merely "sold" as a means to move troops around. There was another reason the legislation was called the Defense Highway Act.

That reason was plain and simple. There is no constitutional authority to build interstate highways. To cloak the program in a constitutional authority, it was couched as a defense priority -- meaning it could be paid for and authorized via the "provide for the common defense" clause in the U.S. Constitution.

That was the good old days -- when you actually had to find a constitutional authority for doing something instead of invoking your telephone and your pen, and doing it anyway.

almost everyone on the east coast lives within 15 minutes of I-95. It's one of the greatest public works for economic development imaginable. more so even than the transcontintental railway during the Grant administration in the 1800's.
 
almost everyone on the east coast lives within 15 minutes of I-95. It's one of the greatest public works for economic development imaginable. more so even than the transcontintental railway during the Grant administration in the 1800's.

No disagreement. I used to be stationed at Fort Belvoir back when dinosaurs walked the earth. We were adjacent to 95.
 
Recently I've been doing a bit of reading about the 1950s. One thing I find interesting is that, despite the reputation of the era for conservatism in the US, there were a lot of initiatives that seem like the work of big-government liberals or progressives. The Eisenhower years saw an incredible expansion of those budget areas people on the left are always looking to expand. For example, here is the annual percentage growth of each of the following budget areas in the Eisenhower and Obama eras:

Education, Training, Employment, and Social Services
Eisenhower: 14.0%
Obama: 4.7%

Transportation
Eisenhower: 17.7%
Obama: 2.5%

Community and Regional Development
Eisenhower: 15.0%
Obama: 3.8%

General Science Space and Technology
Eisenhower: 36.7%
Obama: 0.2%

Of course, nearly any era looks liberal and progressive compared to the severe austerity of the Obama era. But even compared to eras not so plagued by conservatism as today, the Eisenhower-era budgeting can look surprisingly liberal. And I think the way they got there, as a culture, was to talk themselves into regarding these things as being military priorities, rather than civilian ones.

Most famously, look at the Interstate Highway System. It was a classic, New-Deal-style gigantic federal public works project to put people to work and expand the nation's economic potential. But it was sold as a way to make it easier to move troops around the country. That was never terribly honest, since the whole layout was built around where the population centers were, rather than where military materials and defensive interests were greatest. But the sales pitch got it done at a time when being more honest about the overwhelming goal of the spending might have gotten the initiative killed.

There are other examples, too. There was a fantastic increase in federal involvement in education in the 50s. But, again, it would have spooked the anti-communists if it hadn't been sold as a military effort. In fact, it was even officially called the National Defense Education Act, and was sold as part of the effort to get American science up to speed, by bringing along a new generation of scientists and mathematicians, in the face of the Russkies beating us into space.

Speaking of the anti-communists, the ultimate defeat of the Red Scare is another example of the triumph of liberalism only by way of alliance with militarism. Looney Joe McCarthy and other red-baiters were very popular for years, as they went after everyone from academics to entertainers to staff at the State Department. People were afraid to speak up against the madness, for fear that they'd, in turn, be accused of being Communists. But then McCarthy made the mistake of holding hearings on the Army, and that was the end of him. The liberal/military alliance swatted him down like he was nothing, and he promptly wound up censured and irrelevant.

I think there's also a broader way this dynamic has played out in American life, even beyond the 1950s. Military employment, even today, represents something close to a socialist ideal. In the military, you have fairly secure employment by the federal government. You have very low income inequality (the multiplier of income between the highest-paid generals and the lowest-paid privates is tiny compared to similar private sector multipliers). You have socialized medicine -- including hospitals owned by the government and doctors working directly for the government, and universal health insurance. You also get European-level vacation time (30 days per year), and again, it's rather socialistic in the sense that everyone gets the same amount of vacation, from the highest to the lowest ranks. For retirees, you have extremely generous retirement options, relative to the private sector (generally, half one's income after only 20 years, along with highly subsidized health insurance for life, and access to countless other benefits like tax-free on-base shopping). The military also provides extremely strong subsidies for education (the GI Bill), home ownership, etc. And pay, these days, is pretty good. The average soldier is paid, in cash and benefits, more than 80% of civilians with similar education and job skills. Ordinarily, all these things would set off screaming alarms for conservatives, but in the context of the military, they're typically seen as just fine.

So, maybe that's the trick, to recover from the austerity that continues to cripple our economy. We know what works. We know how to fix the problem. We just can't overcome the partisan opposition. Maybe all that's needed is to sell it as a defense imperative. It'll take some creativity to sell, say, universal pre-school or high-speed rail, as being about beating Al Qaeda. But if the Interstate Highway System, which was clearly laid out to address civilian needs, could be sold as being about defense, that kind of thing can be done.

This is why I counsel Democrats not to be TOO eager about cuts in defense spending, at least while a Democrat is in the Whitehouse.
 
The Interstate Highway system was not merely "sold" as a means to move troops around. There was another reason the legislation was called the Defense Highway Act.

That reason was plain and simple. There is no constitutional authority to build interstate highways. To cloak the program in a constitutional authority, it was couched as a defense priority -- meaning it could be paid for and authorized via the "provide for the common defense" clause in the U.S. Constitution.

That was the good old days -- when you actually had to find a constitutional authority for doing something instead of invoking your telephone and your pen, and doing it anyway.

There is constitutional authority to build post roads. With the task of getting mail to all, any road built could fall as easily into the post road consideration. Ike liked the autobahn and saw it as an important improvement to defense capabilities.

In my case...there are plenty of military installations alongside the interstates...Ft Meade, Ft Detrick, Aberdeen...all pretty close to a highway ramp...
 
There is constitutional authority to build post roads. With the task of getting mail to all, any road built could fall as easily into the post road consideration. Ike liked the autobahn and saw it as an important improvement to defense capabilities.

In my case...there are plenty of military installations alongside the interstates...Ft Meade, Ft Detrick, Aberdeen...all pretty close to a highway ramp...

Yes, but post roads were excluded from other uses traditionally.
 
Excluded?

I phrased it badly -- post roads were traditionally exclusively for the mails. Others could use them, but if you traveled by "post chaise" you were traveling, essentially, as mail (this system basically expired by the 1830s).
 
almost everyone on the east coast lives within 15 minutes of I-95. It's one of the greatest public works for economic development imaginable. more so even than the transcontintental railway during the Grant administration in the 1800's.


Maybe so, but if trapdoor had been the one who made the decision as to whether to build the Interstate Highway System, he'd have nixed it as an unconstitutional abridgment of his right to refuse to participate in society.
 
I phrased it badly -- post roads were traditionally exclusively for the mails. Others could use them, but if you traveled by "post chaise" you were traveling, essentially, as mail (this system basically expired by the 1830s).

Yeah...so you're working off a definition that you admit expired 18o years ago...but is "tradition".
 
Maybe so, but if trapdoor had been the one who made the decision as to whether to build the Interstate Highway System, he'd have nixed it as an unconstitutional abridgment of his right to refuse to participate in society.

No -- I actually see three possible constitutional justifications for the interstate highway system.

1) The one that was used. Eisenhower had seen how the autobahn system aided Germany's war effort and wanted it emulated in this country. Defense is a legitimate reason for the construction of the system.

2) The Post Roads argument offered by Craig. Although they were traditionally not seen that way, I'd say that's a wholly valid constitutional argument for the construction.

3) Regulation of interstate trade. "Regulation" doesn't really mean "control." It means "to make regular" -- the interstate highway system makes interstate trade regular.

I'm a strict constructionist, not an anarchist.
 
this is a common misperception among people on the left.

that more spending on a particular topic is "left wing trope"

coming out of world war 2, and the depression, the nation had an aging and deplorable road and rail insfrastructure. Many schools and other buildings dated to the 19th century. Simply put, there weren't enough people working, and paying taxes during the FDR years to fund those sort of investments.

so they took place in the 1950s, when there was (nearly) full employment and prosperity.

what those on the left appear to be immune to is the notion that you cannot spend infinitely, in bad times. you need a booming economy to justify those sorts of investments.

if we had not been saddled with 6 years of recession, high unemployment, and falling expectations among both the unemployed and those who are fortune enough to have jobs, you would have the tax base and enthusiasm to make new investments.

democrats have only themselves to blame.
What six-year recession are you talking about? The only six-year-long recession in American history was in the 1870s. The longest recession of the modern era was a little under four years: the recession we fell into during the third of three consecutive Republican presidencies, in the late 1920s.
 
What six-year recession are you talking about? The only six-year-long recession in American history was in the 1870s. The longest recession of the modern era was a little under four years: the recession we fell into during the third of three consecutive Republican presidencies, in the late 1920s.

That's true only if you take the narrow, technical view of a "recession" that it means a loss of growth for at least three quarters. Yes, in that sense we've been "out of recession" for something like four years.

But the man in the street is still bearing most of the effects of that recession. Employment hasn't recovered to nearly pre-recession levels, and job growth is slower than the number of new employees that enter the job market each month. There's no recession on the stock market -- it's still pretty recessed everywhere else.
 
this is a common misperception among people on the left.

that more spending on a particular topic is "left wing trope"

coming out of world war 2, and the depression, the nation had an aging and deplorable road and rail insfrastructure. Many schools and other buildings dated to the 19th century. Simply put, there weren't enough people working, and paying taxes during the FDR years to fund those sort of investments.

so they took place in the 1950s, when there was (nearly) full employment and prosperity.

what those on the left appear to be immune to is the notion that you cannot spend infinitely, in bad times. you need a booming economy to justify those sorts of investments.

if we had not been saddled with 6 years of recession, high unemployment, and falling expectations among both the unemployed and those who are fortune enough to have jobs, you would have the tax base and enthusiasm to make new investments.

democrats have only themselves to blame.

Additionally Arkady is ignoring the effect of Scale...percentages are a handy tool but sometimes very misleading. What was the GDP then....What is the GDP now....how do we equalize the numbers? What are the coefficients of increase .....??? So on and so forth. In the final analysis he may be partially correct about the comparisons however it is not accurate simply to stack the numbers side by side and pretend that they don't need to be adjusted ...especially with nearly sixty years of monetary evolution in between the two groups.

As I have commented before about the general status of inflation and the value of a wage in relation to its era specific buying power the only real currency that we can measure with any type of consistency is the man hour.

How many man hours did it take to put a roof over one's head in the fifties and sixties?
How many does it take today?

That is how you examine these things....simply stackng the money numbers side by side will only create confusion.
 
Last edited:
The Interstate Highway system was not merely "sold" as a means to move troops around. There was another reason the legislation was called the Defense Highway Act.

That reason was plain and simple. There is no constitutional authority to build interstate highways. To cloak the program in a constitutional authority, it was couched as a defense priority -- meaning it could be paid for and authorized via the "provide for the common defense" clause in the U.S. Constitution.

That was the good old days -- when you actually had to find a constitutional authority for doing something instead of invoking your telephone and your pen, and doing it anyway.
That ultra-narrow reading of the Constitution has been a dead issue since 1816, when people tried to argue that the lack of express language allowing the chartering of a national bank meant that Congress didn't have the authority to do so, and the Supreme Court interpreted the "necessary and proper" clause broadly to say otherwise. And that was already a shaky read of the Constitution even before 1816, since the First Bank of the United States actually dates all the way back to the start of the Republic. The bill that instituted it was introduced in the very first Congress, and was signed into law by George Washington himself, over the objections of a minority of Congress members who took your ultra-narrow view of the Constitution, and insisted that if the Constitution didn't expressly say Congress could create a bank, then it was prohibited from doing so.

There's no way in Hell a Supreme Court in the 1950s would have rolled back 140 years of Constitutional jurisprudence to invalidate the interstate highway projects even if they weren't sold as being about defense. To do so would have invalidated a vast number of things the Congress had been doing since shortly after the founding, including dam-building, canal building, making easements for railroads, practically the entirety of the New Deal, and on and on. It would render the management of a modern nation unworkable, by requiring an amendment to do pretty much anything new (e.g., setting up a national air traffic control system).

Also, the "provide for the common defense" clause, in the enumerated powers of Congress, is part of something saying Congress can "provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States." If you interpret providing for the common Defence as broad enough to allow building a highway system that makes defense easier, then you can interpret providing for the general Welfare as broad enough to allow building a highway system that enhances that welfare. The only reason to interpret one broadly and one narrowly is because you have a personal preference for a federal government that focuses narrowly on war.
 
This is why I counsel Democrats not to be TOO eager about cuts in defense spending, at least while a Democrat is in the Whitehouse.
The problem is that such a vast amount of the military spending, these days, isn't being spent on domestic infrastructure or even wages and benefits for the soldiers. It's being spent on building expensive crap that costs a huge amount of money to drive around the world and keep maintained, or which we then blow up in counter-productive wars half-way around the world. It's billion-dollar B-2s, multi-billion-dollar aircraft carriers, great fleets of C-130s that we fly directly to boneyards because nobody needs them, and so on. They're actually worse than spending the same money to have people dig holes and then fill them back in, since they impose a long-term maintenance, security, and environmental cost.
 
The problem is that such a vast amount of the military spending, these days, isn't being spent on domestic infrastructure or even wages and benefits for the soldiers. It's being spent on building expensive crap that costs a huge amount of money to drive around the world and keep maintained, or which we then blow up in counter-productive wars half-way around the world. It's billion-dollar B-2s, multi-billion-dollar aircraft carriers, great fleets of C-130s that we fly directly to boneyards because nobody needs them, and so on. They're actually worse than spending the same money to have people dig holes and then fill them back in, since they impose a long-term maintenance, security, and environmental cost.

The facts don't support your feelings - as least as of today. BUT...if you have issues with how a Democrat spends this dough, you're better off taking them up with that Democrat, whilst leaving that dough at her disposal. If the dough is taken away completely, the problem you refer to becomes moot.

Of course once having taken the money away, you COULD complain that it's all the GOP's fault for not anteing up more money for your social projects. But, that won't change the fact that they won't do it.
 
There is constitutional authority to build post roads. With the task of getting mail to all, any road built could fall as easily into the post road consideration. Ike liked the autobahn and saw it as an important improvement to defense capabilities.

In my case...there are plenty of military installations alongside the interstates...Ft Meade, Ft Detrick, Aberdeen...all pretty close to a highway ramp...
I used to live on Fort Meade. Van Noy Loop, to be exact.

Anyway, I don't doubt the interstate highway system has military value. But it wasn't laid out to deal narrowly with military issues. You don't need big multi-lane roads around all the big cities just to handle military needs. You wouldn't have so many on and off ramps, either or all those rest stops. If you were to build a road system with military needs in mind, it would look very different, in terms of where it was concentrated and how it was built, than the way the interstate highway system was designed. The vast majority of the design considerations were obviously civilian.
 
Back
Top