Arkady
President
Recently I've been doing a bit of reading about the 1950s. One thing I find interesting is that, despite the reputation of the era for conservatism in the US, there were a lot of initiatives that seem like the work of big-government liberals or progressives. The Eisenhower years saw an incredible expansion of those budget areas people on the left are always looking to expand. For example, here is the annual percentage growth of each of the following budget areas in the Eisenhower and Obama eras:
Education, Training, Employment, and Social Services
Eisenhower: 14.0%
Obama: 4.7%
Transportation
Eisenhower: 17.7%
Obama: 2.5%
Community and Regional Development
Eisenhower: 15.0%
Obama: 3.8%
General Science Space and Technology
Eisenhower: 36.7%
Obama: 0.2%
Of course, nearly any era looks liberal and progressive compared to the severe austerity of the Obama era. But even compared to eras not so plagued by conservatism as today, the Eisenhower-era budgeting can look surprisingly liberal. And I think the way they got there, as a culture, was to talk themselves into regarding these things as being military priorities, rather than civilian ones.
Most famously, look at the Interstate Highway System. It was a classic, New-Deal-style gigantic federal public works project to put people to work and expand the nation's economic potential. But it was sold as a way to make it easier to move troops around the country. That was never terribly honest, since the whole layout was built around where the population centers were, rather than where military materials and defensive interests were greatest. But the sales pitch got it done at a time when being more honest about the overwhelming goal of the spending might have gotten the initiative killed.
There are other examples, too. There was a fantastic increase in federal involvement in education in the 50s. But, again, it would have spooked the anti-communists if it hadn't been sold as a military effort. In fact, it was even officially called the National Defense Education Act, and was sold as part of the effort to get American science up to speed, by bringing along a new generation of scientists and mathematicians, in the face of the Russkies beating us into space.
Speaking of the anti-communists, the ultimate defeat of the Red Scare is another example of the triumph of liberalism only by way of alliance with militarism. Looney Joe McCarthy and other red-baiters were very popular for years, as they went after everyone from academics to entertainers to staff at the State Department. People were afraid to speak up against the madness, for fear that they'd, in turn, be accused of being Communists. But then McCarthy made the mistake of holding hearings on the Army, and that was the end of him. The liberal/military alliance swatted him down like he was nothing, and he promptly wound up censured and irrelevant.
I think there's also a broader way this dynamic has played out in American life, even beyond the 1950s. Military employment, even today, represents something close to a socialist ideal. In the military, you have fairly secure employment by the federal government. You have very low income inequality (the multiplier of income between the highest-paid generals and the lowest-paid privates is tiny compared to similar private sector multipliers). You have socialized medicine -- including hospitals owned by the government and doctors working directly for the government, and universal health insurance. You also get European-level vacation time (30 days per year), and again, it's rather socialistic in the sense that everyone gets the same amount of vacation, from the highest to the lowest ranks. For retirees, you have extremely generous retirement options, relative to the private sector (generally, half one's income after only 20 years, along with highly subsidized health insurance for life, and access to countless other benefits like tax-free on-base shopping). The military also provides extremely strong subsidies for education (the GI Bill), home ownership, etc. And pay, these days, is pretty good. The average soldier is paid, in cash and benefits, more than 80% of civilians with similar education and job skills. Ordinarily, all these things would set off screaming alarms for conservatives, but in the context of the military, they're typically seen as just fine.
So, maybe that's the trick, to recover from the austerity that continues to cripple our economy. We know what works. We know how to fix the problem. We just can't overcome the partisan opposition. Maybe all that's needed is to sell it as a defense imperative. It'll take some creativity to sell, say, universal pre-school or high-speed rail, as being about beating Al Qaeda. But if the Interstate Highway System, which was clearly laid out to address civilian needs, could be sold as being about defense, that kind of thing can be done.
Education, Training, Employment, and Social Services
Eisenhower: 14.0%
Obama: 4.7%
Transportation
Eisenhower: 17.7%
Obama: 2.5%
Community and Regional Development
Eisenhower: 15.0%
Obama: 3.8%
General Science Space and Technology
Eisenhower: 36.7%
Obama: 0.2%
Of course, nearly any era looks liberal and progressive compared to the severe austerity of the Obama era. But even compared to eras not so plagued by conservatism as today, the Eisenhower-era budgeting can look surprisingly liberal. And I think the way they got there, as a culture, was to talk themselves into regarding these things as being military priorities, rather than civilian ones.
Most famously, look at the Interstate Highway System. It was a classic, New-Deal-style gigantic federal public works project to put people to work and expand the nation's economic potential. But it was sold as a way to make it easier to move troops around the country. That was never terribly honest, since the whole layout was built around where the population centers were, rather than where military materials and defensive interests were greatest. But the sales pitch got it done at a time when being more honest about the overwhelming goal of the spending might have gotten the initiative killed.
There are other examples, too. There was a fantastic increase in federal involvement in education in the 50s. But, again, it would have spooked the anti-communists if it hadn't been sold as a military effort. In fact, it was even officially called the National Defense Education Act, and was sold as part of the effort to get American science up to speed, by bringing along a new generation of scientists and mathematicians, in the face of the Russkies beating us into space.
Speaking of the anti-communists, the ultimate defeat of the Red Scare is another example of the triumph of liberalism only by way of alliance with militarism. Looney Joe McCarthy and other red-baiters were very popular for years, as they went after everyone from academics to entertainers to staff at the State Department. People were afraid to speak up against the madness, for fear that they'd, in turn, be accused of being Communists. But then McCarthy made the mistake of holding hearings on the Army, and that was the end of him. The liberal/military alliance swatted him down like he was nothing, and he promptly wound up censured and irrelevant.
I think there's also a broader way this dynamic has played out in American life, even beyond the 1950s. Military employment, even today, represents something close to a socialist ideal. In the military, you have fairly secure employment by the federal government. You have very low income inequality (the multiplier of income between the highest-paid generals and the lowest-paid privates is tiny compared to similar private sector multipliers). You have socialized medicine -- including hospitals owned by the government and doctors working directly for the government, and universal health insurance. You also get European-level vacation time (30 days per year), and again, it's rather socialistic in the sense that everyone gets the same amount of vacation, from the highest to the lowest ranks. For retirees, you have extremely generous retirement options, relative to the private sector (generally, half one's income after only 20 years, along with highly subsidized health insurance for life, and access to countless other benefits like tax-free on-base shopping). The military also provides extremely strong subsidies for education (the GI Bill), home ownership, etc. And pay, these days, is pretty good. The average soldier is paid, in cash and benefits, more than 80% of civilians with similar education and job skills. Ordinarily, all these things would set off screaming alarms for conservatives, but in the context of the military, they're typically seen as just fine.
So, maybe that's the trick, to recover from the austerity that continues to cripple our economy. We know what works. We know how to fix the problem. We just can't overcome the partisan opposition. Maybe all that's needed is to sell it as a defense imperative. It'll take some creativity to sell, say, universal pre-school or high-speed rail, as being about beating Al Qaeda. But if the Interstate Highway System, which was clearly laid out to address civilian needs, could be sold as being about defense, that kind of thing can be done.