New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Muddying the waters

Havelock

Mayor
I was chatting with an acquaintance the other day who happens to be gay. The topic turned to same-sex marriage and the advances in equal treatment that have come down the pike ever more quickly for gays and lesbians in recent years. The conversation drifted into the topic of plural marriage. We debated the pros and cons briefly, and then my friend laid out her final thoughts.

Look, she said, it's okay to talk about where we might go from here in the abstract. I'm not necessarily opposed to polyamorous marriages, but anyone who wants that needs to make their case, work out the details, and win over the public. If they can; if and when there are enough of them to make themselves heard... They need to do the hard work of persuading people, just as we have. They shouldn't try to ride on our coattails. And right now, to be honest, I think they should shut up. Until we've got all the rights we deserve, they're just muddying the waters and giving ammunition to the people who want to shut us down.

I paraphrase, but that was the gist of it.

That was more or less the end of that conversation, but I've heard those basic thoughts expressed a lot over the last several years, with greater or lesser degrees of annoyance and even anger. Whether the topic is plural marriage or some other “down the road” fear or concern or prediction, a similar response is fairly common. It's usually some variation on “That's different!” and/or “Not now!” and/or “They should pull their own weight!”

I get that. I understand the rationale. And from the standpoint of tactics and strategy, I can acknowledge the value of advocating a measured, “first things first” approach. Certainly it's normal to prioritize one's own particular goals. Necessary even... And Lord knows that most people who want to argue that acceptance of same-sex marriage is bound to lead to acceptance of other, more radically unorthodox “lifestyle choices” aren't really interested in arguing the merits of anything in particular. Rather, they're mainly interested in ginning up opposition to same-sex marriage by any means necessary.

And yet, there's at least a whiff of something unpleasant in some of those conversations that have taken place.

Even though it now appears that the depth of the opposition may have been somewhat overstated, it was conventional wisdom that African-Americans were as a group less supportive of gay rights in general and same-sex marriage in particular than Whites as a group. This caused some consternation in the gay community, particularly around the time that Proposition 8 originally passed in California with a lot of Black votes. Plenty of folks were upset and confused about how someone who has known oppression could be so callous about the oppression of others.

Well, some folks need to look in the mirror.

With acceptance comes some degree of assimilation – that's inevitable, and it's healthy for the most part as long as not too much is lost in the process. But there's a danger in assimilation, and that danger is tied to forgetfulness and a tendency to assume that all is right with the world, everything is as it should be, and everyone has just what they deserve.

Yes, those who want plural marriage, to pick an example, have an obligation to make their case. But if and when they do, they'll be part of a long tradition of civil rights activists. They'll be building on the efforts of those who came before, just as gays and lesbians and others have done. If the work is a little easier because of that, we should all be glad, not resentful. And no, they shouldn't shut up or be shouted down whether their voices are convenient to any other particular cause or not. They deserve at least to be heard, whether they can turn out a thousand to march or only ten.

Cheers.
 
Back
Top