New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Need some help here!

Boca

Governor
Lemme ask if somebody can sort this out for me....accordin' to the 5th Amendment of Constitution....

No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger.....
So...how is it Florida' s state attorney can say I don't need no stinkin' grandjury? Was this Zimmerman feller in the Navy or a militia....?

I'm seriously confused?
 
He can't be charged for Murder One. Which is a 'capital' crime. Manslaughter, is not.

Guessin' ya skipped this part....or otherwise infamous crime

Are ya sayin' ABC, NBC, the New Times, the White House and the blogosphere ain't made this infamous?
 
LOL...no, I'm betting my gold dust that Manslaughter, isn't as 'infamous' as Murder one.

I could be wrong, but that's my take on it.
 
Sorry...we still ain't addressed the basic question...can a State's Attorney ignore the 5th Amendment?
 
Columbia Encyclopedia:
grand jury
Top

Home > Library > Miscellaneous > Columbia Encyclopedia

grand jury, in law, body of persons selected to inquire into crimes committed within a certain jurisdiction. It usually comprises a greater number than the trial, or petit (also, petty) jury, having since early common law days had between 12 and 23 members. In the United States, federal grand juries have between 16 and 23 jurors. The grand jury receives complaints and accusations in criminal cases, hears evidence adduced by the state, and approves an indictment when satisfied that there is enough evidence against the accused to warrant a trial. It was not until the 17th cent. that the grand jury acquired its modern functions as a check on the discretion of prosecutors and a way of preventing unjustified and politically motivated prosecutions. Grand juries have investigative functions as well, and are sometimes impaneled to issue reports on, e.g., suspected official wrongdoing.
The rules governing grand jury proceedings are very different from those governing trials by (petit) jury. The public is not admitted to hearings, and witnesses can be compelled to testify. The procedure is inquisitorial rather than adversarial: the defense is not allowed to call witnesses, and the prosecutor is not obliged to present both sides of the case. Hearsay and other evidence that might be excluded at a jury trial may be introduced.

The use of grand juries has declined in the 20th cent., in part because they were perceived as prone to either prosecutorial domination or abuse of their investigatory role. Britain abandoned them in the 1930s, and today fewer than half of U.S. states employ them. The information, a written statement issued by a prosecutor, has largely replaced the indictment. The Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, however, guarantees a grand jury inquiry to anyone accused in federal court of a capital "or otherwise infamous" (i.e., a felony) crime.

Read more: http://www.answers.com/topic/grand-jury#ixzz1rb9uY9cp


Grand jury is only "guaranteed" in a Federal trial.

I posted this when the same question was asked in another thread.
 
Sooo....now I get it...any old encyclopedia trumps the Constitution....which don't begin to say that


No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury....

After givin' it some thought mebbe "held to answer" means the trial and the grand jury will follow after the state's attorney brings charges.

Whadda ya think?
 
Boca, given you're a Birther, who thinks the President wouldn't be a citizen, despite the fact he was born in Hawaii, because his father wasn't a citizen....your interpretations of the Constitution are suspect. :)
 
Back
Top