New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Nina Pham

Zam-Zam

Senator
A courageous and caring human being, and a devout Christian:

Nina Pham, a Dallas nurse who has been battling Ebola after treating a patient in Texas, has now been declared free of the disease, and gave thanks to God and all those who have prayed for her in recent weeks.

“I feel fortunate and blessed to be standing here today,” Pham said in a press conference Oct. 24. “I would first and foremost like to thank God, my family and friends. Throughout this ordeal, I have put my trust in God and my medical team.”

Pham thanked everyone who had been involved in her care, both in Texas and Maryland. She offered special gratitude to Ebola survivor Dr. Kent Brantly for donating plasma, calling it a “selfless act.”

“I believe in the power of prayer because I know so many people all over the world have been praying for me,” she continued. “I join you in prayer now for the recovery of others.”

The 26-year-old nurse, described by friends as a devout Catholic, is believed to have contracted Ebola while caring for a Thomas Eric Duncan, a patient at Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital in Dallas. Duncan passed away from Ebola Oct. 8.

Pham was transferred to the National Institutes of Health in Maryland on Oct. 16. Numerous tests have now shown her to be Ebola free, and she will return to Texas to continue regaining strength.

Ebola continues to devastate parts of West Africa. The World Health Organization said that nearly 5,000 deaths had been reported as of Oct. 19, but the true numbers could be as high as 15,000.

Pham’s fellow nurse, Amber Vinson, had also contracted Ebola after caring for Duncan. Vinson is currently being treated. Her family said Oct. 22 that she had tested free of the disease.



http://www.ewtnnews.com/catholic-news/US.php?id=11016
 
A courageous and caring human being, and a devout Christian:

Nina Pham, a Dallas nurse who has been battling Ebola after treating a patient in Texas, has now been declared free of the disease, and gave thanks to God and all those who have prayed for her in recent weeks.

“I feel fortunate and blessed to be standing here today,” Pham said in a press conference Oct. 24. “I would first and foremost like to thank God, my family and friends. Throughout this ordeal, I have put my trust in God and my medical team.”

Pham thanked everyone who had been involved in her care, both in Texas and Maryland. She offered special gratitude to Ebola survivor Dr. Kent Brantly for donating plasma, calling it a “selfless act.”

“I believe in the power of prayer because I know so many people all over the world have been praying for me,” she continued. “I join you in prayer now for the recovery of others.”

The 26-year-old nurse, described by friends as a devout Catholic, is believed to have contracted Ebola while caring for a Thomas Eric Duncan, a patient at Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital in Dallas. Duncan passed away from Ebola Oct. 8.

Pham was transferred to the National Institutes of Health in Maryland on Oct. 16. Numerous tests have now shown her to be Ebola free, and she will return to Texas to continue regaining strength.

Ebola continues to devastate parts of West Africa. The World Health Organization said that nearly 5,000 deaths had been reported as of Oct. 19, but the true numbers could be as high as 15,000.

Pham’s fellow nurse, Amber Vinson, had also contracted Ebola after caring for Duncan. Vinson is currently being treated. Her family said Oct. 22 that she had tested free of the disease.



http://www.ewtnnews.com/catholic-news/US.php?id=11016
I have nothing but respect for people who put themselves in harm's way to heal others. However, the "power of prayer" has been tested repeatedly and never been substantiated. Fortunately, whatever she may think of the "power of prayer," her whole profession relies not on praying for people to recover, but instead on using tested, scientific methods that actually improve the probability of a recovery.
 
I have nothing but respect for people who put themselves in harm's way to heal others. However, the "power of prayer" has been tested repeatedly and never been substantiated. Fortunately, whatever she may think of the "power of prayer," her whole profession relies not on praying for people to recover, but instead on using tested, scientific methods that actually improve the probability of a recovery.

I just knew it would annoy you......
 
I just knew it would annoy you......
It's only annoying to the extent people rely on it. If you want to pray, or make a burnt offering of a dove, or do a ritual dance to summon the mojo of your ancestors, or rub your lucky penny, or bury a dead toad by moonlight, or whatever else you want to do to give you a sense you have supernatural aid, there's no harm in it (and conceivably a placebo effect if you believe strongly). But, since blind, placebo-controlled experiments have repeatedly ruled out any actual effectiveness of supernatural interventions, it would be a mistake to put any faith in such things, if that results in any less attention to the real-world things that make a genuine difference.

People crave a sense of control, and so when stuff is largely out of our hands, we like to create an illusion of a sense of control through any means necessary, including through superstitious rituals of various sorts. There's nothing terribly wrong with that, as long as it's kept in its little box, and people don't really rely on it (the way, for example, people relied on faith healing in West Africa in a way that contributed to the spread of Ebola):

http://www.ibtimes.com/faith-healer-helped-spread-ebola-sierra-leone-report-1663694
 
It's only annoying to the extent people rely on it. If you want to pray, or make a burnt offering of a dove, or do a ritual dance to summon the mojo of your ancestors, or rub your lucky penny, or bury a dead toad by moonlight, or whatever else you want to do to give you a sense you have supernatural aid, there's no harm in it (and conceivably a placebo effect if you believe strongly). But, since blind, placebo-controlled experiments have repeatedly ruled out any actual effectiveness of supernatural interventions, it would be a mistake to put any faith in such things, if that results in any less attention to the real-world things that make a genuine difference.

People crave a sense of control, and so when stuff is largely out of our hands, we like to create an illusion of a sense of control through any means necessary, including through superstitious rituals of various sorts. There's nothing terribly wrong with that, as long as it's kept in its little box, and people don't really rely on it (the way, for example, people relied on faith healing in West Africa in a way that contributed to the spread of Ebola):

http://www.ibtimes.com/faith-healer-helped-spread-ebola-sierra-leone-report-1663694


I don't know why you choose to be bothered by it, but it's your choice.

I'm at peace with the fact that Nina Pham is a spiritual person. If you can't be, perhaps there is a flaw in your logic.
 
I don't know why you choose to be bothered by it, but it's your choice.

I'm at peace with the fact that Nina Pham is a spiritual person. If you can't be, perhaps there is a flaw in your logic.
I have no problem with people being spiritual. I just recognize the risk of people believing in unscientific things when it comes to matters like infectious disease -- a problem emphasized by the role that faith-healing played in the spread of the Ebola epidemic.
 
I have no problem with people being spiritual. I just recognize the risk of people believing in unscientific things when it comes to matters like infectious disease -- a problem emphasized by the role that faith-healing played in the spread of the Ebola epidemic.


I see no evidence of Ms. Pham having done that. So, what is your problem with her?
 
I see no evidence of Ms. Pham having done that. So, what is your problem with her?
I don't have a problem with her. As I said at the start "I have nothing but respect for people who put themselves in harm's way to heal others." I'm just pointing out the problem with a faith in prayer.
 
I don't have a problem with her. As I said at the start "I have nothing but respect for people who put themselves in harm's way to heal others." I'm just pointing out the problem with a faith in prayer.


I have no problem with faith in prayer. I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree.
 
I have no problem with faith in prayer. I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree.
One of us is being rational, one isn't. If you could show me well-designed studies (e.g., ones controlling for the placebo effect) showing a convincing pattern of prayer influencing outcomes in medical issues, I could be won over. If, on the other hand, I show you well-designed studies establishing the absence of such a pattern, you will not be won over. For me, the question of the efficacy of prayer is a question of fact, which can be examined systematically to reach an answer. For you, it is a question of identity, where any real-world evidence will only be meaningful to the extent it supports your starting prejudice.
 
One of us is being rational, one isn't. If you could show me well-designed studies (e.g., ones controlling for the placebo effect) showing a convincing pattern of prayer influencing outcomes in medical issues, I could be won over. If, on the other hand, I show you well-designed studies establishing the absence of such a pattern, you will not be won over. For me, the question of the efficacy of prayer is a question of fact, which can be examined systematically to reach an answer. For you, it is a question of identity, where any real-world evidence will only be meaningful to the extent it supports your starting prejudice.


You just can't stand no everyone thinking the same way you do, can you?

Get over it, or stay that way, your call. I will continue to believe in the power of prayer either way, and if you choose not to, that's fine with me. You can label me any way you feel you need to in order to make yourself feel better. I promise I won't mind, or even care.
 
You just can't stand no everyone thinking the same way you do, can you?

If people think correct things that differ from what I think, I should change. If I believe correct things that differ from what others think, they should change. If we differ on matters where there's no clearly correct or incorrect option, neither needs to change.

When it comes to the efficacy of prayer in treating disease, that's one of the things that can be established as either correct or incorrect. If I'm wrong, I'm happy to change. Everything I've seen, though, tells me I'm right.
 
If people think correct things that differ from what I think, I should change. If I believe correct things that differ from what others think, they should change. If we differ on matters where there's no clearly correct or incorrect option, neither needs to change.

When it comes to the efficacy of prayer in treating disease, that's one of the things that can be established as either correct or incorrect. If I'm wrong, I'm happy to change. Everything I've seen, though, tells me I'm right.


People don't all have to think the same way. Even if you insist.
 
One of us is being rational, one isn't. If you could show me well-designed studies (e.g., ones controlling for the placebo effect) showing a convincing pattern of prayer influencing outcomes in medical issues, I could be won over. If, on the other hand, I show you well-designed studies establishing the absence of such a pattern, you will not be won over. For me, the question of the efficacy of prayer is a question of fact, which can be examined systematically to reach an answer. For you, it is a question of identity, where any real-world evidence will only be meaningful to the extent it supports your starting prejudice.
LOL. Arkady = I'm not crazy, the rest of the world is...
 
Nah. There are lots of non-crazy people in the world. Those who believe in faith healing just aren't among us.


There you are - Think as Arkady does, or you're clinically insane.

How's that old saying go? "If you think liberals are tolerant, try disagreeing with one."

We may not agree, but I always seem to manage to get a good laugh out of it. I suppose that's because I'm crazy....
 
There you are - Think as Arkady does, or you're clinically insane.

How's that old saying go? "If you think liberals are tolerant, try disagreeing with one."

We may not agree, but I always seem to manage to get a good laugh out of it. I suppose that's because I'm crazy....
As I mentioned earlier, it's quite possible that someone who doesn't think the way I do is right and I'm wrong, in which case I ought to change. If someone can offer me compelling evidence that the power of prayer in relation to disease is such an example, then I will switch. I'd love it if we had another tool in our arsenal of fighting disease, whether that's burnt offerings to the gods, or what have you. If I were to cling to the idea that prayer is ineffectual, despite repeated evidence from well-designed experiments showing otherwise, then I'd be nuts. But, in the same way, if a person clings to the idea that prayer is effectual, despite repeated evidence from well-designed experiments showing otherwise, that's nuts.
 
Back
Top