You would need to raise the average IQ of the Republican base by, oh, some 20 or 30 points. Which is not likely to happen until some clever scientists come along and invent a 'smart pill'. Let's hope for that.
What's interesting, though, is that Democrats don't seem to be in quite the same trap, and I don't think that's plausibly attributable to Democratic voters, on the whole, being a lot smarter. Most Democratic voters, like most people generally, are embarrassingly stupid. So, how is it that Democrats have managed to elect some unabashedly brainy and even sometimes wonky politicians to major office?
I suspect the answer lies in the way the GOP has managed to stoke the worst impulses of its base for short-term gain. It's not that their side is naturally dumber. It's just that they've been encouraged in their dumbness more aggressively.
Both parties use anti-elitist rhetoric to get the masses to vote for people who --let's be honest-- are members of the elite and who disproportionately work for other members of the elite. The nature of the anti-elitist rhetoric is different on each side, though. Among the Democrats, it tends to be an attack on the economic elite, and big corporations in particular. Among the Republicans, it tends to be an attack on the academic and cultural elite.
I think that stoking that anti-intellectual sentiment, over the long-term, has made the Republican base behave stupider than they have any natural right to be. They've been encouraged to be suspicious of egg heads, and they've been trained to respond positively to imbecilic arguments, and now the Republicans have some hard work to do in de-conditioning those responses.
It may take a while, when you think of how long the current state of affairs was brewing. You can argue it dates back to Nixon, with things like the Southern Strategy, and efforts to turn the "hard hats" against the college kids who were protesting the war. Republicans have spent four decades taking the deep anti-elitist instincts of the American populace and reworking them into something that won't turn against the wealthy and the powerful, but instead against the "coastal snobs," the Bo-Bos, the artists, and the Ivory Tower types. Tough to undo forty years of work now that it's painted them into a corner.