This case was not tried or decided on SYG at all.The law used in Florida, syg, is part of the problem here.
This case was not tried or decided on SYG at all.The law used in Florida, syg, is part of the problem here.
Because there are not a convincing set of circumstances, evidence, or witness testimony to make a convincing case for it. It's not practical to say being "tracked" by someone at 7:30pm on a public street makes you afraid for your life.
That's why the prosecution had the right to call eyewitnesses to the stand. They can review someone's history and record for evidence of any previous questionable behavior, they can review the 911 calls, and hear what was said over the phone to Trayvon's friend. Nowhere did he express fear, nowhere did he articulate he saw Zimmerman produce a gun, and then according to testimony backed by physical evidence, Trayvon then hit Zimmerman in the nose, minutes after the phone call ended. There's no evidence he feared for his life, nor did he ever express it. It was impractical to think he was.Tough to give said evidence when you're dead. Convenient.
Dino, you are taking Zimmerman's word that Martin started the fight. That is because Martin isn't here to give you his version because Zimmerman made sure it would never come out by KILLING HIM>Between Trayvon and Zimmerman, the first person to commit an ILLEGAL act, was Trayvon. Not guilty
And he "made sure" of this by 1. calling 911 first, 2. getting slugged in the face first, 3. drawing his weapon as a perceived last resort, and then 4. shooting just once?Dino, you are taking Zimmerman's word that Martin started the fight. That is because Martin isn't here to give you his version because Zimmerman made sure it would never come out by KILLING HIM>
That's why the prosecution had the right to call eyewitnesses to the stand. They can review someone's history and record for evidence of any previous questionable behavior, they can review the 911 calls, and hear what was said over the phone to Trayvon's friend. Nowhere did he express fear, nowhere did he articulate he saw Zimmerman produce a gun, and then according to testimony backed by physical evidence, Trayvon then hit Zimmerman in the nose, minutes after the phone call ended. There's no evidence he feared for his life, nor did he ever express it. It was impractical to think he was.
And he "made sure" of this by 1. calling 911 first, 2. getting slugged in the face first, 3. drawing his weapon as a perceived last resort, and then 4. shooting just once?
Nope, I'm not buying it. You didn't make a good case there.
That's what a jury is for. They have to think of what a "reasonable person" was thinking at all phases of the encounter. In my opinion (and theirs) Trayvon Martin was never in a position where he was necessarily afraid for his life. By assaulting Zimmerman, and dropping him to the ground, Martin put Zimmerman in a position where he was afraid for his life. That makes the shooting justified.Again. Nowhere is there any testimony from Trayvon Martin. Nowhere. it's impractical to think he was or he was not fearing for his life. We don't know. He didn't say so (in evidence) but we don't know. We also don't have any corroborating evidence that Zimmerman feared for his life - EXCEPT THAT HE SAID SO after the fact. But then again, he was alive to say so wasn't he?
That's what a jury is for. They have to think of what a "reasonable person" was thinking at all phases of the encounter. In my opinion (and theirs) Trayvon Martin was never in a position where he was necessarily afraid for his life. By assaulting Zimmerman, and dropping him to the ground, Martin put Zimmerman in a position where he was afraid for his life. That makes the shooting justified.
I don't know why I need to restate it, the law was followed correctly here. And the prosecution acted overzealous with an unprovable charge.
You act as though Zimmerman had some reason to do this before that night, or dervies some benefits from his actions. Think for one second how his life is hell from this point on. There's no upside other than being out of jail he gains from this ruling. What was his upside to committing this act? You're delusional if you think all of this is what he wanted.Yes I agree. That is what the jury thought. Interesting how you and the jury can decide whether Trayvon was or was not in fear for his life. And no, you don't need to restate it. The law decided that Zimmerman's testimony was superior and the fact that the dead kid had no say or opinion to offer in what happened was immaterial. There ya go.
People fear for their younger kids when they play out front of the house, because some stranger might come along and kidnap them. Who knew we needed to additionally fear for our teenagers because some stranger might come along and decide that they didn't belong where they were and stalk and follow them and, if our teenagers react aggressively, might shoot them? Is that seriously the world where you want to raise your kids?
He called 911 (and called Trayvon a "suspect"). He got out of his car. We have HIS WORD that he got slugged first (because, you know, the other witness is dead so we don't actually know what happened). He drew his weapon as a last resort (again, on his word because, you know, the other witness is dead so we don't know what actually happened). And then yeah, he shot just once. Thru the heart. Pretty good shot for someone freaked out for his life and having his head (no evidence of this, but on his word alone and with no corroborating physical evidence) bashed in. Damn that dude is good with a gun!
You act as though Zimmerman had some reason to do this before that night, or dervies some benefits from his actions. Think for one second how his life is hell from this point on. There's no upside other than being out of jail he gains from this ruling. What was his upside to committing this act? You're delusional if you think all of this is what he wanted.
I'll teach my kids the best I can not to make ANY fatal mistake..and that might still not be enough. I'm aware of that reality.
It is clear that you made up your own evidence, that the evidence presented didn't count and that you had your mind made up whose fault it was that Trayvon was shot. Pffffft.........with you around, who needs laws? Who needs evidence? Who needs a fair trial?![]()
Nor did I ...........offer opinions until the trial was almost over withOh bullshit, get over yourself. I didn't even begin to offer opinions on this until near the end of the trial.
I guess if he wanted to "mind his own business" and didn't care about the security of the homes and property of his neighbors, he never would have signed on to be neighrhood watch captain.I know, right? It's most inexplicable that Zimmerman would decide that following this kid was so important that, against the advice of the 911 operator he called, he would still get out of his vehicle and follow him! Isn't that strange? It's almost as if following this kid and catching him in some untoward action was THE MOST important thing Zimmerman could do, right? Isn't that odd? Put yourself in his shoes: you see someone you decide is "suspicious" (for what reason again exactly?) and you decide that you simply DO NOT have time for the police to respond. So you decide to follow the guy in your vehicle and then later on foot. Because it's SO IMPORTANT that you know exactly what his kid is up to (because, again, why?). So I don't think Zimmerman was thinking of his future (except maybe a future of "oh my gosh what a HERO you are!!!) at all. But what the hell was he thinking? Why do you suppose it was SO IMPORTANT for him to follow this kid? Because nothing, NOTHING, of what transpired afterwards would have happened if Zimmerman had just either 1) minded his own damn businesses, or 2) stayed in his vehicle as instructed.
Nor did I ...........offer opinions until the trial was almost over with
And it's always obvious when you know you've lost................ you make some insult about me. Now trot on to bed, loser.![]()
\I guess if he wanted to "mind his own business" and didn't care about the security of the homes and property of his neighbors, he never would have signed on to be neighrhood watch captain.
But being that is what he did do, then I suppose we can presume he meant to do that job, and took it seriously.
Anything relevant you'd like to gripe about?
He WAS watching...and then got assaulted.\
He didn't take it all that seriously if he didn't bother to follow the rules for neighborhood watch, eh? If the 'neighborhood watch' in my neighborhood believes it's in their charter to go armed and follow "suspects" that are not, in fact "suspects" in any real sense except their own minds, I would relieve that neighborhood watch dude from his duties. How would he know if it were my grandson coming over to my house to take care of my garden while I'm out of town (which my grandson did for five weeks over May and June)? I don't need a neighborhood watch guy to follow or shoot people. I need the neighborhood watch guy to WATCH. Hence the neighborhood watch rules.
He WAS watching...and then got assaulted.
Try to pay attention.