New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

NSA Stalking

Arkady

President
A few weeks ago, a poster demanded to know why anyone who'd done nothing wrong would be concerned about the NSA spying without warrants. I came up with a list of ways that people who'd done nothing wrong could be harmed by NSA agents snooping into their private business (aside from the automatic harm to privacy caused by the invasion itself). Among the scenarios I mentioned was NSA agents abusing their spying powers to stalk love interests. The authoritarians dismiss this like it was a paranoid fear: surely no NSA agent would dare do that, right? Turns out that not only does it happen, but it happens enough to have its own code name:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_t...ees_have_deliberately_abused_their_power.html

The people actually manning these government powers are human beings. They'll abuse powers without sufficient checks and balances. That's the reason the Constitution was built around the idea of checks and balances... Including warrant requirements for most searches. Short circuit that and the results are predictable.
 
A few weeks ago, a poster demanded to know why anyone who'd done nothing wrong would be concerned about the NSA spying without warrants. I came up with a list of ways that people who'd done nothing wrong could be harmed by NSA agents snooping into their private business (aside from the automatic harm to privacy caused by the invasion itself). Among the scenarios I mentioned was NSA agents abusing their spying powers to stalk love interests. The authoritarians dismiss this like it was a paranoid fear: surely no NSA agent would dare do that, right? Turns out that not only does it happen, but it happens enough to have its own code name:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_t...ees_have_deliberately_abused_their_power.html

The people actually manning these government powers are human beings. They'll abuse powers without sufficient checks and balances. That's the reason the Constitution was built around the idea of checks and balances... Including warrant requirements for most searches. Short circuit that and the results are predictable.


I'd think that would be one of the most obvious and likely abuses arky, if available.
 
I'm sure you're aware of similar abuses during the 2001-2006 warrantless era. At that time, the NSA would listen in on conversations between the troops in Iraq and Afghanistan and loved ones stateside. Even the most well-intentioned analyst might not be able to resist eavesdropping in on juicy but innocent conversations -- perhaps considering it to be a victimless crime since the parties don't know.
 
I'd think that would be one of the most obvious and likely abuses arky, if available.
It's human nature. Picture that you're an NSA staffer who went through a rough divorce and now you're paying alimony. And let's say that you think the alimony is no longer owed, because your wife is now living with a guy who earns plenty of money, but she testifies to the court she's still living alone and needs your support. If you thought you could pry into their communications with no warrant and little risk of detection, wouldn't it be hard as hell to resist that temptation? Or how about if you thought your girlfriend might be cheating on you? Wouldn't it be tempting to see who she was calling?
 
A few weeks ago, a poster demanded to know why anyone who'd done nothing wrong would be concerned about the NSA spying without warrants. I came up with a list of ways that people who'd done nothing wrong could be harmed by NSA agents snooping into their private business (aside from the automatic harm to privacy caused by the invasion itself). Among the scenarios I mentioned was NSA agents abusing their spying powers to stalk love interests. The authoritarians dismiss this like it was a paranoid fear: surely no NSA agent would dare do that, right? Turns out that not only does it happen, but it happens enough to have its own code name:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_t...ees_have_deliberately_abused_their_power.html

The people actually manning these government powers are human beings. They'll abuse powers without sufficient checks and balances. That's the reason the Constitution was built around the idea of checks and balances... Including warrant requirements for most searches. Short circuit that and the results are predictable.


Now I see we're bugging the UN.

Isn't that special?
 
I'm sure you're aware of similar abuses during the 2001-2006 warrantless era. At that time, the NSA would listen in on conversations between the troops in Iraq and Afghanistan and loved ones stateside. Even the most well-intentioned analyst might not be able to resist eavesdropping in on juicy but innocent conversations -- perhaps considering it to be a victimless crime since the parties don't know.
I didn't know about that, specifically, but it's a great example. People should ask themselves, honestly, whether, if they had a magic ability to spy on others without any risk of detection, they could really resist the urge to use it. Given the popularity of voyeuristic culture (reality TV, for example, or soapy TV dramas based around sexy, intimate relationships), the temptation for most people would be very, very strong. Some would be moral enough to resist it, but I suspect most of us would give in, from time to time.

Sometimes, we'd even convince ourselves we were doing it for the right reason. For example, what if you were worried your mother, who'd been having problems lately, was depressed, and was just putting up a brave face. It would be very tempting to use NSA-like powers to pry into her private communications in the name of helping her. And even if all you had access to was the identity of the numbers she'd called (not even the contents of the calls), that could tell you a lot of things she might not want you to know. Has she been calling a psychologist's office? A male escort service? The phone number of some ex boyfriend?
 
Back
Top