New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Nuclear War?

Agreed, but that's a long way off and a lot of space to clean up. When even a paint chip can rip a hole through a suit or panel, metal shrapnel would be very hard to clean up. It might take something like nukes to vaporize entire sections of space. I don't know.

All I know is, if they used satellite killers, the satellite age would be over for our lifetime.

Agreed on your final sentence, but I don't like the idea of nukes in space. I would think (for one thing) that that just might make matters worse. At some point within the last six months or so, I was reading somewhere about an ongoing effort to develop a satellite garbage collector, so it may not be quite as far off as we think; but I can't remember where I read that. Would have to search for it.
 
While there are some 18 wars going on right now in the world and a spark could ignite a world war I don't see the US or Russia using nukes on each other. Seems far fetched.
It won't start that way, but it could end up that way.
 
Agreed on your final sentence, but I don't like the idea of nukes in space. I would think (for one thing) that that just might make matters worse. At some point within the last six months or so, I was reading somewhere about an ongoing effort to develop a satellite garbage collector, so it may not be quite as far off as we think; but I can't remember where I read that. Would have to search for it.
Re nukes in space; if you mean "weaponizing" space, then I'm in complete agreement. However, nuclear power has many peaceful applications and using a nuclear device to clean up space in a coordinated international effort is as different as using explosives to build a canal and using explosives to mine a harbor. They are tools. How they are used determines whether it's for good or bad, not if they are used.

We have a problem with space garbage now, so there's definitely a need, but launching satellite killers would turn a simply "litter" problem into being buried in garbage.

https://www.sciencenews.org/blog/science-public/growing-need-space-trash-collectors
On April 2, for the fifth time in less than three years, the International Space Station fired its engines to dodge a piece of orbital debris that appeared on a collision path. Other spacecraft also regularly scoot out of the way of rocket and satellite debris. Such evasive action will be needed increasingly frequently, a new study finds.....

....Space agencies around the world have been discussing a need to actively remove aerospace debris. One reason: The number of pieces has been steadily rising, driven in part by collisions between orbiting pieces of trash or trash and spacecraft. Among the biggest debris multipliers: a spectacular 2009 crash between the dead Russian Kosmos 2251 spacecraft and the U.S. Iridium-33 telecommunications satellite.
14777
 
Re nukes in space; if you mean "weaponizing" space, then I'm in complete agreement. However, nuclear power has many peaceful applications and using a nuclear device to clean up space in a coordinated international effort is as different as using explosives to build a canal and using explosives to mine a harbor. They are tools. How they are used determines whether it's for good or bad, not if they are used.

We have a problem with space garbage now, so there's definitely a need, but launching satellite killers would turn a simply "litter" problem into being buried in garbage.

https://www.sciencenews.org/blog/science-public/growing-need-space-trash-collectors
On April 2, for the fifth time in less than three years, the International Space Station fired its engines to dodge a piece of orbital debris that appeared on a collision path. Other spacecraft also regularly scoot out of the way of rocket and satellite debris. Such evasive action will be needed increasingly frequently, a new study finds.....

....Space agencies around the world have been discussing a need to actively remove aerospace debris. One reason: The number of pieces has been steadily rising, driven in part by collisions between orbiting pieces of trash or trash and spacecraft. Among the biggest debris multipliers: a spectacular 2009 crash between the dead Russian Kosmos 2251 spacecraft and the U.S. Iridium-33 telecommunications satellite.
14777
they screwed up this graphic, they show the debris in polar orbit instead of equatorial orbit.
 
What? lol
Uranium breaks down into a different element, the famed transmutation all the alchemists of old searched for. The bombs induce the breakdown by gathering the Uranium 235 I think it is, or is it 238? Anyway, its the unstable atom that wants to kick out a neutron when it breaks into fragments and forms a different element. The deal is, it kicks out 2 neutrons which cause more atoms to break down and so it is a chain reaction that occurs as a result of all the uranium being packed together. Actually the transmutation repeats, like 11 times or something like that, changing elements over and over until I think it ends up as lead. Anyway, the bomb just utilizes the first break down. They induce the transmutation by kicking neutrons into the "fuel" .... after that, it takes off on its own.

German scientist discovered it just prior to the war, was afraid the nazis would get it so he traveled to America and showed it to Einstein. Einstein showed it to American govt. The whole realization that it would give off a tremendous amount of energy was based upon e=mc2, because when the atom broke down, it loses some matter, and that formula states that the matter becomes energy; an awful lot of energy.
 
Uranium breaks down into a different element, the famed transmutation all the alchemists of old searched for. The bombs induce the breakdown by gathering the Uranium 235 I think it is, or is it 238? Anyway, its the unstable atom that wants to kick out a neutron when it breaks into fragments and forms a different element. The deal is, it kicks out 2 neutrons which cause more atoms to break down and so it is a chain reaction that occurs as a result of all the uranium being packed together. Actually the transmutation repeats, like 11 times or something like that, changing elements over and over until I think it ends up as lead. Anyway, the bomb just utilizes the first break down. They induce the transmutation by kicking neutrons into the "fuel" .... after that, it takes off on its own.

German scientist discovered it just prior to the war, was afraid the nazis would get it so he traveled to America and showed it to Einstein. Einstein showed it to American govt. The whole realization that it would give off a tremendous amount of energy was based upon e=mc2, because when the atom broke down, it loses some matter, and that formula states that the matter becomes energy; an awful lot of energy.

But Einstein was a fraud --- so mmmm I dunno if I believe there is such a thing. Those mushrooms are all fake
 
But Einstein was a fraud --- so mmmm I dunno if I believe there is such a thing. Those mushrooms are all fake
Einstein had a little help... mushroom clouds happen from explosions, doesn't have to be nuclear. Microscopic mushroom signature in 09/11 WTC dust gave away that explosives were used.
 
Re nukes in space; if you mean "weaponizing" space, then I'm in complete agreement. However, nuclear power has many peaceful applications and using a nuclear device to clean up space in a coordinated international effort is as different as using explosives to build a canal and using explosives to mine a harbor. They are tools. How they are used determines whether it's for good or bad, not if they are used.

That was not my objection to your proposal. Yes, I'm aware that nuclear power has many peaceful applications.

The primary objection is this: It is extremely unlikely that you could identify a 'section' of low-Earth orbit that contains nothing but debris, without any extremely valuable satellites happening to be in the same area. Explode a nuke there, and you would also be destroying very valuable satellites. Explode a nuke in low-Earth orbit, and you would also be creating an EMP, an electromagnetic pulse, that would destroy satellite electronics even at a considerable distance...

I don't think you thought this idea through very carefully......
 
they screwed up this graphic, they show the debris in polar orbit instead of equatorial orbit.

You're right; we're just so used to seeing a picture of the globe that way, with the equator in the middle. I've known some folks to actually get offended when you show them a map of the world, 'upside-down', with the South Pole at the top and the North Pole at the bottom....
 
That was not my objection to your proposal. Yes, I'm aware that nuclear power has many peaceful applications.

The primary objection is this: It is extremely unlikely that you could identify a 'section' of low-Earth orbit that contains nothing but debris, without any extremely valuable satellites happening to be in the same area. Explode a nuke there, and you would also be destroying very valuable satellites. Explode a nuke in low-Earth orbit, and you would also be creating an EMP, an electromagnetic pulse, that would destroy satellite electronics even at a considerable distance...

I don't think you thought this idea through very carefully......
1) Geosynchronous orbits aren't "low Earth" orbits (99-1200 miles); they're at 22,236 miles.

2) The scenario I mentioned where Putin did launch his satellite killers and it generated a "Gravity" cascade scenario wiping out everything in that orbit. There'd be nothing to damage because there'd be no operational GPS or other geosynchronous satellites remaining.
 
1) Geosynchronous orbits aren't "low Earth" orbits (99-1200 miles); they're at 22,236 miles.

2) The scenario I mentioned where Putin did launch his satellite killers and it generated a "Gravity" cascade scenario wiping out everything in that orbit. There'd be nothing to damage because there'd be no operational GPS or other geosynchronous satellites remaining.

Heh. I DO know that geosynchronous orbits are not low-Earth orbits, Max. I did work for NASA at one time. In your previous post, you highlighted the fact that the ISS has had to occasionally move, to avoid orbiting debris. The ISS is in low-Earth orbit. [In fact, no human has been beyond low-Earth orbit since Apollo 17.]

Yes, in the AFTERMATH of an event like you describe, where all the operational satellites have ALREADY been destroyed, your nuke idea might be worth considering....
 
1) Geosynchronous orbits aren't "low Earth" orbits (99-1200 miles); they're at 22,236 miles.

2) The scenario I mentioned where Putin did launch his satellite killers and it generated a "Gravity" cascade scenario wiping out everything in that orbit. There'd be nothing to damage because there'd be no operational GPS or other geosynchronous satellites remaining.

By the way, so far as I know, ALL the 'experiments' with satellite hunter-killers have been conducted in low-Earth orbit. I have never heard of any nation testing out a hunter-killer in geosynchronous orbit. I'm sure we agree, though, that both China and Russia have been EXTREMELY irresponsible in monkeying around with this kind of thing.....
 
By the way, so far as I know, ALL the 'experiments' with satellite hunter-killers have been conducted in low-Earth orbit. I have never heard of any nation testing out a hunter-killer in geosynchronous orbit. I'm sure we agree, though, that both China and Russia have been EXTREMELY irresponsible in monkeying around with this kind of thing.....
That's so the debris will fall into the atmosphere and not just add to the garbage in orbit.

The initial post by ASOT mentioned GPS and commsats, both of which are usually in geosynchronous orbits.
in related news, Russia this week tested a missile capable of destroying satellites (such as GPS, spy, and communication satellites) orbiting earth

It's not my nuke idea, just one one of several floated in such a contingency. Such an event would not just shatter global communications and navigational capabilities, but the global economy. It would be epic and the death toll Biblical.
 
The initial post by ASOT mentioned GPS and commsats, both of which are usually in geosynchronous orbits.

It would have been 'nice' if ASOT had provided a link for that. I haven't heard anything about it. To be fair, though, I haven't really searched.....
 
Back
Top