New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ombudsman correction here.

Driving is a regulated right in order for you to exercise other constitutional rights.

Driving is a privilege parents allow children. If your politician or other authority figure tells you, an adult, that driving is a privilege he is in effect trying to treat you like his child.
 
Last edited:
Driving is a regulated right in order for you to exercise other constitutional rights.

Driving is a privilege parents allow children. If your politician or other authority figure tells you, an adult, that driving is a privilege he is in effect trying to treat you like his child.

"Typically, if a right is going to be limited, restricted or revoked, there must be 'due process' – the right to a hearing – and there must be a good basis for the revocation or restriction,” Lykins said. “The privilege to drive is a benefit that is extended based upon certain requirements being satisfied."

“While the 'right of travel' is a fundamental right, the privilege to operate a motor vehicle can be conditionally granted based upon being licensed and following certain rules,” Lykins said. “If rules are broken or laws are violated, the State reserves the right to restrict or revoke a person’s privilege.”

Case cited:

Donald S. MILLER, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Sally R. REED, California Department of Motor Vehicles;  Daniel E. Lungren, Attorney General, Defendants-Appellees 9th Circuit of the U.S. Court of Appeals - 1999
 
Driving is a regulated right in order for you to exercise other constitutional rights.

Driving is a privilege parents allow children. If your politician or other authority figure tells you, an adult, that driving is a privilege he is in effect trying to treat you like his child.


Thanks for this. For the most part, this right vs. privilege thing is a matter of inconsequential semantics, except perhaps, when people are trying to contrast driving with some other presumed right.

Nevertheless, the conventionally wisdomed "privilege" thing in the context of driving, has never made sense to me. After all, I pay taxes for those roads. How can anyone say it's a privilege for me to use those roads AND..who extends me that "privilege"?
 
"Typically, if a right is going to be limited, restricted or revoked, there must be 'due process' – the right to a hearing – and there must be a good basis for the revocation or restriction,” Lykins said. “The privilege to drive is a benefit that is extended based upon certain requirements being satisfied."

“While the 'right of travel' is a fundamental right, the privilege to operate a motor vehicle can be conditionally granted based upon being licensed and following certain rules,” Lykins said. “If rules are broken or laws are violated, the State reserves the right to restrict or revoke a person’s privilege.”

Case cited:

Donald S. MILLER, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Sally R. REED, California Department of Motor Vehicles;  Daniel E. Lungren, Attorney General, Defendants-Appellees 9th Circuit of the U.S. Court of Appeals - 1999

You prove the point. Authority figures playing at being your parents. It is quite literally a sickness.
 
You prove the point. Authority figures playing at being your parents. It is quite literally a sickness.

nonsense - driving has significant responsibility associated with the activity. If one refuses to learn the "rules" of the road and demonstrate how to effectively operate a motor vehicle one is not granted the privilege of driving with the rest of society. If one wants to drive on their own property - great.
 
nonsense - driving has significant responsibility associated with the activity. If one refuses to learn the "rules" of the road and demonstrate how to effectively operate a motor vehicle one is not granted the privilege of driving with the rest of society. If one wants to drive on their own property - great.

I said regulated right, not right. Quite a big difference. A privilege can be arbitrary while a right is not. Privilege connotes good graces of the state. What if the state because of state of emergency decides to suspend all driving "privileges". Is that cool with you? Clear your mind jamma boy and see the light. :0)
 
I said regulated right, not right. Quite a big difference. A privilege can be arbitrary while a right is not. Privilege connotes good graces of the state. What if the state because of state of emergency decides to suspend all driving "privileges". Is that cool with you? Clear your mind jamma boy and see the light. :0)

...I am now at peace.

...BTW it has happened - remember April 2013, Boston, Patriots Day? The "Shelter in Place" request. This is also done when a governor declares a "state of emergency", during a major storm for example...

...I also forgot to add 9/11/01 - did you try to fly for the week after 9/11? I did but couldn't - was our constitutional right of free movement infringed upon then?
 
I said regulated right, not right. Quite a big difference. A privilege can be arbitrary while a right is not. Privilege connotes good graces of the state. What if the state because of state of emergency decides to suspend all driving "privileges". Is that cool with you? Clear your mind jamma boy and see the light. :0)


Aren't all rights "regulated rights"? And, aren't all rights a function of the state? Before you answer this one, try to think of a right that is NOT regulated and/or exists independently of the state.
 
Aren't all rights "regulated rights"? And, aren't all rights a function of the state? Before you answer this one, try to think of a right that is NOT regulated and/or exists independently of the state.

My right to life. To be fat or skinny. To shave myself bald. To dress with a pink top and and orange hot pants. To believe in the flying spaghetti monster. To write really bad poetry. To play a guitar. To sit in the sand and work 2nd order differential equations. Whether to buy this or that. To not have health insurance... oops. You got me there foursheets. :0)

To put it plainly Obamasucks as bad if not worse than Bush. Power corrupts. It's only a matter of time before the creeps take out all un-regulated rights with their view of right and wrong. They will have killed the 'pursuit of happiness'.
 
...I am now at peace.

...BTW it has happened - remember April 2013, Boston, Patriots Day? The "Shelter in Place" request. This is also done when a governor declares a "state of emergency", during a major storm for example...

...I also forgot to add 9/11/01 - did you try to fly for the week after 9/11? I did but couldn't - was our constitutional right of free movement infringed upon then?

1) Shelter in place my ass. If I believe that to survive I have to move I will. Sheltering in place did not catch a kid but rather a person securing his property did. If they had asked everybody to grab their guns and check out their property they'd have spared the expense of ten's of millions of dollars and the destruction of our rights.

2) Arbitrary how they let the Saudi bin laden clan scatter like airborne roaches, huh? If I needed to fly in a small plane because one of these Islamic turds flew into a nuke reactor. I'd fly and your blocking me from saving my family's lives would be immoral.
 
Driving is a regulated right in order for you to exercise other constitutional rights.

Driving is a privilege parents allow children. If your politician or other authority figure tells you, an adult, that driving is a privilege he is in effect trying to treat you like his child.

I'm sure that the "founders" just forgot to include driving in the BoR...
 
Thanks for this. For the most part, this right vs. privilege thing is a matter of inconsequential semantics, except perhaps, when people are trying to contrast driving with some other presumed right.

Nevertheless, the conventionally wisdomed "privilege" thing in the context of driving, has never made sense to me. After all, I pay taxes for those roads. How can anyone say it's a privilege for me to use those roads AND..who extends me that "privilege"?
I think I posted it before, but back in the 70's a rather famous Texas lawyer got pulled over and it was discovered that he did not have, nor had he ever had (he was in his 60's), a drivers license. He fought the ticket in court and cited pretty much the same grounds you did, that his taxes paid for construction and maintenance of the roads, and he had every right to utilize them. He beat the ticket.....
 
I think I posted it before, but back in the 70's a rather famous Texas lawyer got pulled over and it was discovered that he did not have, nor had he ever had (he was in his 60's), a drivers license. He fought the ticket in court and cited pretty much the same grounds you did, that his taxes paid for construction and maintenance of the roads, and he had every right to utilize them. He beat the ticket.....

Back when men were men and women were... uhh... successfully steering men through life (i.e. women). :0)
 
I'm sure that the "founders" just forgot to include driving in the BoR...
No, its right there in the right of freedom of association. Along with the freedom of speech right. To hold property. And the right to privacy. And pursuit of happiness concept of America.
 
I think I posted it before, but back in the 70's a rather famous Texas lawyer got pulled over and it was discovered that he did not have, nor had he ever had (he was in his 60's), a drivers license. He fought the ticket in court and cited pretty much the same grounds you did, that his taxes paid for construction and maintenance of the roads, and he had every right to utilize them. He beat the ticket.....

If someone has enough money to play the appeals game, then they can cost a municipal court more than they are worth to them for a traffic fine. It's all about the money.
 
Driving is a regulated right in order for you to exercise other constitutional rights.

Driving is a privilege parents allow children. If your politician or other authority figure tells you, an adult, that driving is a privilege he is in effect trying to treat you like his child.

politicians (and authority figures in the private sector) commonly attempt to rescind our rights, to enhance their own authority and extract concessions from the rank and file.

recent egregious examples of this would be "it takes a village" by hillary clinton, which postulates that parents are incapable of parenting, and michelle obama's ghost written coffee table book extolling the glories of collective urban gardening on government provided plots
 
Back
Top