New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Our Monkey Brains at Work

Arkady

President
It's fascinating to see how humans obsess over relatively small risks when those risks push various subconscious mental buttons for us. A classic example, which comes from the book "The Culture of Fear" is that when Americans are traveling to Israel, they tell pollsters their primary concern is terrorism, when in fact it's an infinitesimal risk. If they were rational and informed, their biggest concern should probably be a traffic death, since Israeli roads are a lot more dangerous than US roads, such that the increased risk of death they're assuming by traveling to Israel primarily takes the form of an increased risk of traffic death. But traffic accidents don't push those subconscious mental buttons the way terrorist attacks do.

Compare the Texas fertilizer plant explosion with the deaths related to the Marathon attacks, for example. The former was a whole lot deadlier and more destructive than the latter, but the latter pushed deeper mental buttons (our fear of foreign things, our stronger reaction to intentional killings, etc.) and so the Marathon attacks have gotten much more media attention. The result of this irrationality is for us to spend inordinate amounts of attention and money on trying to prevent the next terrorist attack at a big public event, rather than trying to prevent the next deadly manufacturing plant accident. If we focused on more EPA and OSHA inspections, we could save more lives for less money and less of an imposition on our personal liberties. But we're not set up that way, psychologically.

There are even more important stories than the Texas explosion that get a lot less media attention, because they show up as a statistical risk, which naturally fade into the mental background. Take America's infant mortality rate, which is severely elevated relative to most wealthy nations (and even some not-so-wealthy ones). Countries with more modern healthcare systems than ours have a lot fewer people dying in infancy. 6.81 infants die, in the US, per 1000 born, which is between 50% and 250% higher than in other leading nations (and no, before you trot out the right-wing talking point, this is not primarily due to different counting methods when it comes to premature births... similar stats show up for childhood mortality). If we could lower our infant mortality even to the level of mediocre nations like the UK, Canada, and Cuba (which fall far behind the pack leaders), we'd be saving around 1.7 lives per 1000 births. That's nearly 7000 innocent lives saves per year... more than all the major terrorist attacks in American history combined. Yet, because infant mortality happens in the background, without clear lines between a particular decision (underfunding prenatal and neonatal treatment for poor pregnant women), and a particular death, we mostly just ignore it. For the kind of money we spend preventing the next terrorist attack, we could probably save the lives of tens of thousands of infants over the course of the next several years. But, again, we're not set up that way, psychologically.

Or consider the recent story, which got relatively little play in the press, that showed that the academic underpinnings of austerity policies were based on a gamed numbers set and poorly scripted Excel spreadsheet, by a couple economists who had refused to show their work. Turns out the claims of the austerians (that countries with debt above 90% of GDP have negative economic growth on average) were simply incorrect. The result of the wrong-headed austerity measures (both direct results from cutting spending people were depending on, and indirect results from resulting economic shrinkage), could very likely run into the MILLIONS of lives pointlessly shortened through public stinginess.

Because such statistical outcomes are hard to establish on an individual-death basis, they don't push our psychological buttons the way a terrorist at a marathon does. We don't know that a PARTICULAR workplace accident, for example, was caused by decreased regulatory scrutiny attributable to austerity cuts. We don't know that a particular death from illness was due to inadequate epidemic control measures in the wake of such cuts. Etc. So, we allow the results of those austerity cuts to fade into the background of our minds. But, it's pretty damned likely that those academics with their bogus paper ultimately cost more lives than any mere terrorist bombers could. It's possible that millions of premature deaths could be indirectly attributable to them. But those aren't the bogeymen who haunt our dreams.
 
How about the extremely low societal risk of "assault" weapons versus the abject terror of them and constant desire to outlaw them (from some people)?
 
Trap's response hints at one of the reasons for this phenomenon. If 26 people are killed with high-capacity weapons, some part of us digs in its heels in defense of high-capacity weapons and out of fear/hate of those who might speak ill of them. If a Texan fertilizer concern blows up and kills 20 or so, some of us dig in our heels in defense of Texans, small-guvmint kooks, and out of fear/hate of those who might speak ill of Texans and small-guvmint kooks.

BUT..in the case of plane crashes, AND putative terr'sts, they've got no lobbies. Nobody likes plane crashes and terr'sts. So, it's "safe" to obsess over those, even IF the numbers don't fit. Although..."BostonBomberGate" throws an extra little twist into all this. Sure..nobody LIKES terr'sts. But, the Fox/GOP desperately NEEDS terr'sts, so it's in their interest to pimp the fear factor as much as they possibly can.
 
Trap's response hints at one of the reasons for this phenomenon. If 26 people are killed with high-capacity weapons, some part of us digs in its heels in defense of high-capacity weapons and out of fear/hate of those who might speak ill of them. If a Texan fertilizer concern blows up and kills 20 or so, some of us dig in our heels in defense of Texans, small-guvmint kooks, and out of fear/hate of those who might speak ill of Texans and small-guvmint kooks.

And if 26 kids are killed, some people will blame 100 million uninvolved gun owners over the infinitesimal risk. I don't think you'll find any organization in Texas that will block prosecution of that plant's owners for breaking the rules.

BUT..in the case of plane crashes, AND putative terr'sts, they've got no lobbies. Nobody likes plane crashes and terr'sts. So, it's "safe" to obsess over those, even IF the numbers don't fit. Although..."BostonBomberGate" throws an extra little twist into all this. Sure..nobody LIKES terr'sts. But, the Fox/GOP desperately NEEDS terr'sts, so it's in their interest to pimp the fear factor as much as they possibly can.

Actually, some terrorists also have lobbies, but setting that aside, we're talking about risks. We didn't ground every pilot, permanently, because of the 9/11 attacks.
 
Were it not for paranoia, there would be no reason for anyone whose net worth is less than that of Mitt Romney's to vote Republican.
 
How about the extremely low societal risk of "assault" weapons versus the abject terror of them and constant desire to outlaw them (from some people)?

It's fair to point out that assault weapons are extremely low risk. However, it's a balancing test, and a gun control advocate would just argue that the relatively minor imposition of outlawing assault weapons (which doesn't infringe meaningfully on your ability to hunt, protect your home, or enjoy target shooting) is so small that even the extremely low risk posed by those guns predominates in the balance.
 
And if 26 kids are killed, some people will blame 100 million uninvolved gun owners over the infinitesimal risk. I don't think you'll find any organization in Texas that will block prosecution of that plant's owners for breaking the rules.

Are you sure? There was some Texas Congressman who was savagely criticizing President Obama for "persecuting" British Petroleum, "shaking them down", after that catastrophic BP oil volcano (more than a 'spill') in the Gulf........
 
ark - we agree on this one, for sure

until the terrorist threat can be contained/eliminated, we need to spend WAY more attention on guarding oil refineries, civilian ammunition plants, chemical plants. (want to see what 10,000 gallons of chlorine released into a watershed can do?)

it's problematic whether a "fracking pipeline" is safer than putting oil/natural gas in thousands of tankers and driving it from the sourcepoint to the refinery. but we already have thousands of miles of gas pipleines, high tension wires, and even nuclear plants that need protecting.

that said, i've been a skeptic of the viability of "ultra high speed rail" for some time. I'm talking about the trains that go 250+ mph - not the 95 mph "Acela" that whizzes between Washington and NYC. You derail a train at 250 mph, and EVERYONE is going to die. How do you keep someone from throwing a supermarket shopping cart onto hundreds of miles of tracks as a train approaches?

its seems intuitive that its much easier to guard passenger boarding areas in terminals, and screen baggage, than try to extend risk management to vast tracks of high speed rail in the middle of nowhere.
 
Back
Top