New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Our Would-Be Dictators

Zam-Zam

Senator
Stossel nails it:

Dictator Envy

Some Western leaders envy dictators’ powers.

President Donald Trump said, when North Korea’s Kim Jong-un speaks, “his people sit up at attention. I want my people to do the same.”

President Barack Obama told reporters it would be so much easier to be the president of China.

Canada’s foolish Prime Minister, Justin Trudeau, said he admires China because “their basic dictatorship is allowing them to actually turn their economy around on a dime.”

These are stupid and dangerous fantasies.

Some people have a “utopian dream that if only someone at the top could just point us in a certain direction, everything would go well,” says historian Johan Norberg in my new video.

“People like a strong leader,” I point out.

“A strong leader of their own imagination,” Norberg responds.

One example he gives: “Thomas Friedman of The New York Times famously said that he wanted to be China for a day to solve global warming.”

If Friedman were dictator, he could solve global warming? I doubt it.

Yes, China has built lots of wind turbines.

“But those wind turbines don’t produce more power!” Norberg points out. “Around 30% of them are not even connected to the grid. And why is that? Because they didn’t build them to make money. They built them because they wanted to meet a political goal.”

So China has useless wind turbines and, for power, builds more coal plants.

Another example: American media said we should look to China to contain COVID-19. NBC’s Chuck Todd asked Dr. Anthony Fauci, “How uncomfortable is it that perhaps China’s authoritarian ways did prevent this?”

Fauci replies that China “prevented a broader spread.”

But China’s “‘Zero COVID’ policy turned into a nightmare,” says Norberg. China locked people into homes. One city even killed COVID patients’ pets. China is still the one country that will not acknowledge that we may have to learn to live with COVID.

“That’s what you get with dictators,” says Norberg. “If government is big enough to give you anything, it’s big enough to take everything away from you.”

At the beginning of the pandemic, America imitated China’s lockdowns. The mayor of Los Angeles threatened to shut off power to people who did not follow his orders.

There was lots of political bickering about what our COVID rules should be. People don’t like the bickering, but Norberg calls it one of democracy’s strengths.

“Because it means that we see different things and we bring different ideas to the table.” By contrast, “when we have one guy at the top, they begin to fall for their own propaganda.”

That’s probably what led to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

“Putin thought that his own military was in excellent shape,” says Norberg. “Ukraine was seen as a joke of a country, a place of latte-drinking comedians.”

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy was a comedian before becoming president.

Putin assumed Ukrainians “would just run away the moment they saw muscular Russian paratroopers,” says Norberg. “But it’s been a disaster for them.”

In freer countries, Norberg points out, “journalists (and) people online would’ve seen those problems and brought them forth.”

But Putin’s advisers fear telling him the truth. It’s fun to watch one of his flunkies groveling.

I understand why his adviser stammers. Pointing out a problem might get him jailed, if not killed. It’s why dictators get bad information. They make bad decisions because there’s no open dissent.

“That’s what happens when you centralize,” says Norberg. “You lose individual initiative … local knowledge. If you can mobilize everybody in one direction, sometimes they mobilize us all over the cliff.”

I’m glad America has a government with limited powers.

“Democracy cannot guarantee the best governance, but it can prevent the worst from happening,” concludes Norberg. “That is enough. That’s really what freedom and democracy is about. It doesn’t guarantee us heaven, but at least it makes us sure that we won’t end up in hell.”



Dictator Envy - Stossel TV (johnstossel.com)


Democracy isn't perfect - It's just preferable to every other man-made government.
 
Stossel nails it:

Dictator Envy

Some Western leaders envy dictators’ powers.

President Donald Trump said, when North Korea’s Kim Jong-un speaks, “his people sit up at attention. I want my people to do the same.”

President Barack Obama told reporters it would be so much easier to be the president of China.

Canada’s foolish Prime Minister, Justin Trudeau, said he admires China because “their basic dictatorship is allowing them to actually turn their economy around on a dime.”

These are stupid and dangerous fantasies.

Some people have a “utopian dream that if only someone at the top could just point us in a certain direction, everything would go well,” says historian Johan Norberg in my new video.

“People like a strong leader,” I point out.

“A strong leader of their own imagination,” Norberg responds.

One example he gives: “Thomas Friedman of The New York Times famously said that he wanted to be China for a day to solve global warming.”

If Friedman were dictator, he could solve global warming? I doubt it.

Yes, China has built lots of wind turbines.

“But those wind turbines don’t produce more power!” Norberg points out. “Around 30% of them are not even connected to the grid. And why is that? Because they didn’t build them to make money. They built them because they wanted to meet a political goal.”

So China has useless wind turbines and, for power, builds more coal plants.

Another example: American media said we should look to China to contain COVID-19. NBC’s Chuck Todd asked Dr. Anthony Fauci, “How uncomfortable is it that perhaps China’s authoritarian ways did prevent this?”

Fauci replies that China “prevented a broader spread.”

But China’s “‘Zero COVID’ policy turned into a nightmare,” says Norberg. China locked people into homes. One city even killed COVID patients’ pets. China is still the one country that will not acknowledge that we may have to learn to live with COVID.

“That’s what you get with dictators,” says Norberg. “If government is big enough to give you anything, it’s big enough to take everything away from you.”

At the beginning of the pandemic, America imitated China’s lockdowns. The mayor of Los Angeles threatened to shut off power to people who did not follow his orders.

There was lots of political bickering about what our COVID rules should be. People don’t like the bickering, but Norberg calls it one of democracy’s strengths.

“Because it means that we see different things and we bring different ideas to the table.” By contrast, “when we have one guy at the top, they begin to fall for their own propaganda.”

That’s probably what led to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

“Putin thought that his own military was in excellent shape,” says Norberg. “Ukraine was seen as a joke of a country, a place of latte-drinking comedians.”

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy was a comedian before becoming president.

Putin assumed Ukrainians “would just run away the moment they saw muscular Russian paratroopers,” says Norberg. “But it’s been a disaster for them.”

In freer countries, Norberg points out, “journalists (and) people online would’ve seen those problems and brought them forth.”

But Putin’s advisers fear telling him the truth. It’s fun to watch one of his flunkies groveling.

I understand why his adviser stammers. Pointing out a problem might get him jailed, if not killed. It’s why dictators get bad information. They make bad decisions because there’s no open dissent.

“That’s what happens when you centralize,” says Norberg. “You lose individual initiative … local knowledge. If you can mobilize everybody in one direction, sometimes they mobilize us all over the cliff.”

I’m glad America has a government with limited powers.

“Democracy cannot guarantee the best governance, but it can prevent the worst from happening,” concludes Norberg. “That is enough. That’s really what freedom and democracy is about. It doesn’t guarantee us heaven, but at least it makes us sure that we won’t end up in hell.”



Dictator Envy - Stossel TV (johnstossel.com)


Democracy isn't perfect - It's just preferable to every other man-made government.
Whew! What a scorching hawt take! democracy is ok. Give me some spice.
 
The “dictator envy” and election of demagogic “strongmen” like Trump reflect the increasing incompatibility of capitalism with constitutional democracy and civil liberties.

Meanwhile our insanely corrupt Democratic paryt and our Adminstrative State in Washington DC erode our constitutional democracy every single day and you........... defend them.
 
And have always ended up under the thumb of a dictator.

Every. Single. Time.

Democracy tisn't perfect, but it's a lot better than Communism, as history has proven.

My two cents.
No. The dictatorships are brought in by the enemies of communism in order to contain it or put an end to it. When communism is not sufficiently powerful to control much of the world, communists do not have the power to stop counterrevolutionary dictatorships to be forced on the revolutionary states they’ve set up by the enemies of those states and of communism.
 
No. The dictatorships are brought in by the enemies of communism in order to contain it or put an end to it. When communism is not sufficiently powerful to control much of the world, communists do not have the power to stop counterrevolutionary dictatorships to be forced on the revolutionary states they’ve set up by the enemies of those states and of communism.

You can rationalize it anyway you wish - Communism leaders to despotism in every instance. Period.

It's no good.
 
You can rationalize it anyway you wish - Communism leaders to despotism in every instance. Period.

It's no good.
No, intense class struggle leads to despotism. This was as true in the period of the rise of capitalism, which brought forth such leaders as Savonarola, Henry VIII, Cromwell, Ivan the Terrible, and Robespierre (to name a few of the more honorable ones), as in the period of the infancy of socialism. Indeed, the same can be seen with the fall of capitalism and the dictatorships spawned by capitalist weakness. Meanwhile, Cuba has been under semi-communist leadership for decades and despite some abuses (of less weight than the sort you excuse in the case of the U.S.) it remains a constitutional democracy that respects human rights; in fact it is more democratic now than before the victory of the Vietnamese opened up greater possibilities for communism.
 
No, intense class struggle leads to despotism. This was as true in the period of the rise of capitalism, which brought forth such leaders as Savonarola, Henry VIII, Cromwell, Ivan the Terrible, and Robespierre (to name a few of the more honorable ones), as in the period of the infancy of socialism. Indeed, the same can be seen with the fall of capitalism and the dictatorships spawned by capitalist weakness. Meanwhile, Cuba has been under semi-communist leadership for decades and despite some abuses (of less weight than the sort you excuse in the case of the U.S.) it remains a constitutional democracy that respects human rights; in fact it is more democratic now than before the victory of the Vietnamese opened up greater possibilities for communism.

Communism leads to despotism.

Without exception.

History proves that.

Propaganda can't change that.

Sorry, no sale.
 
Communism leads to despotism.

Without exception.

History proves that.

Propaganda can't change that.

Sorry, no sale.
The alternative to building communism is watching the world fall under the grip of fascist dictatorship. Those wanting a fascist dictatorship greatly exaggerate the “despotism” of the earliest socialist societies (where the state grows powerful due to the relatively matched balance of power between contending classes, and is … history confirms … always weakened by the advance of communism) in their propaganda in order to usher in the truly brutal despotism that is fascism.
 
Back
Top