New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Personhood

NightSwimmer

Senator
At the root of the recent dust up over Todd Akin's gaffe are Republican abortion policy initiatives that are considered extreme by most Americans. The most extreme of these positions proposes that any fertilized human ovum should be granted "personhood", reflecting a belief that life begins at conception.

What does "personhood" actually mean? Legislation to address personhood would have no effect unless this newly defined status included granting citizenship to the unborn. That would place any fertilized human blastocyst within the borders of the United States under the full protection of the United States Constitution. You might want to think about that for a moment.

Passage of personhood rights for the unborn would certainly make abortion illegal, and that is the motivating force behind the movement. But there would be other consequences as well. Most forms of contraception would also become illegal, as would in vitro fertilization as it is currently practiced. Expectant mothers could be held criminally liable for miscarriages, if their conduct during pregnancy were brought into question for any reason.

Another aspect of personhood that should be carefully considered is the automatic granting of US citizenship to anyone who is conceived, naturally or artificially, within the borders of the United States. If you don't care for the idea of "anchor babies", then you're probably not going to be too thrilled by the addition of "anchor zygotes". The tourist industry might well enjoy all of the business that they would pick up from "citizenship vacationers" seeking dual citizenship for their unborn persons?

Hmmm...
 
It's definitely a sticky wicket.

Take, for example a just fertilzed egg that fails to implant in the wall of the uterus. Is the failed mother responsible for collecting her post coital vaginal discharges on the off chance that there might be a constitutionally protected person in there? Is she responsible for taking steps to preserve it's life for future implantation, putting it in a cryogenic prison so to speak?

Who's going to pay for the storage of all that post coital effluvian? Who's going to pay for the in vitro fertilization necessary to free all those embryos trappend in cryogenic prison? Will fertile women be conscripted into service to carry these trapped souls to term?

Lots of unintended consequences associated with "personhood" laws.
 
I agree, Cerulean Mutt. That's why I think it's important for people who might support this initiative to expand the breadth of their thinking on the issue and consider more of the possible consequences. I am of the opinion that if the Republicans really want to make abortion illegal, they should just do so in an honest and straightforward manner, rather than tinkering around with all of these vaginal probing requirements, late term abortion limitations and "personhood" amendments. They're trying to back-door an abortion prohibition without calling it what it is. That will make for bad law.
 
Mr. Swimmer,

The US Constitution grants citizenship to a baby born on US soil, not an unborn child. As for your first point, the Laws of the United States protects and apply to all within the jurisdiction of the United States, not just citizens.

Sorry that bit of logic screws up your strawman premise.
 
Mr. Swimmer,

The US Constitution grants citizenship to a baby born on US soil, not an unborn child. As for your first point, the Laws of the United States protects and apply to all within the jurisdiction of the United States, not just citizens.

Sorry that bit of logic screws up your strawman premise.


Mr. YaYa,

You assume a lot of stupid things, don't you? Why must you post when you have nothing of substance to add to the discussion?


BTW: Which "premise" did you mistake as a strawman?
 
At the root of the recent dust up over Todd Akin's gaffe are Republican abortion policy initiatives that are considered extreme by most Americans. The most extreme of these positions proposes that any fertilized human ovum should be granted "personhood", reflecting a belief that life begins at conception.

What does "personhood" actually mean? Legislation to address personhood would have no effect unless this newly defined status included granting citizenship to the unborn. That would place any fertilized human blastocyst within the borders of the United States under the full protection of the United States Constitution. You might want to think about that for a moment.

Passage of personhood rights for the unborn would certainly make abortion illegal, and that is the motivating force behind the movement. But there would be other consequences as well. Most forms of contraception would also become illegal, as would in vitro fertilization as it is currently practiced. Expectant mothers could be held criminally liable for miscarriages, if their conduct during pregnancy were brought into question for any reason.

Another aspect of personhood that should be carefully considered is the automatic granting of US citizenship to anyone who is conceived, naturally or artificially, within the borders of the United States. If you don't care for the idea of "anchor babies", then you're probably not going to be too thrilled by the addition of "anchor zygotes". The tourist industry might well enjoy all of the business that they would pick up from "citizenship vacationers" seeking dual citizenship for their unborn persons?

Hmmm...

The folks who support these laws generally fall into two groups:

True believers who figure that all the sorts of pesky details that you've mentioned will be worked out in due time and are willing to risk unintended consequences in pursuit of their their paramount goal of saving innocent unborn babies from being murdered, and;

Cynics who don't worry about the certain complications because they know good and well that the “personhood” laws/amendments they champion are extremely unlikely ever to pass and simply want to use the issue to “take a stand” and/or gin up political support.

I suppose the former group is marginally less tedious than the latter. In any case, I tend to agree that it can be pernicious to use “death by a thousand cuts” political tactics to attempt to achieve a broad social policy goal. Often satisfies no one and keeps longstanding feuds simmering...

Of course, for a lot of folks the feud is exactly the point, no? Abortion is to some degree merely a proxy in a larger fight over sexuality, gender roles, and culture. The misdirection is more than tactical, it's an integral part of the strategy.

Cheers.
 
NightSwimmer,

Margaret Atwood wrote an excellent novel, Tbe Handmaid's Tale that took the implications of the Personhood Amendment to their logical conclusion. They made a pretty good movie out of the novel as well.

[video=youtube;k-c80TeoonM]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k-c80TeoonM[/video]
 
Back
Top