NightSwimmer
Senator
At the root of the recent dust up over Todd Akin's gaffe are Republican abortion policy initiatives that are considered extreme by most Americans. The most extreme of these positions proposes that any fertilized human ovum should be granted "personhood", reflecting a belief that life begins at conception.
What does "personhood" actually mean? Legislation to address personhood would have no effect unless this newly defined status included granting citizenship to the unborn. That would place any fertilized human blastocyst within the borders of the United States under the full protection of the United States Constitution. You might want to think about that for a moment.
Passage of personhood rights for the unborn would certainly make abortion illegal, and that is the motivating force behind the movement. But there would be other consequences as well. Most forms of contraception would also become illegal, as would in vitro fertilization as it is currently practiced. Expectant mothers could be held criminally liable for miscarriages, if their conduct during pregnancy were brought into question for any reason.
Another aspect of personhood that should be carefully considered is the automatic granting of US citizenship to anyone who is conceived, naturally or artificially, within the borders of the United States. If you don't care for the idea of "anchor babies", then you're probably not going to be too thrilled by the addition of "anchor zygotes". The tourist industry might well enjoy all of the business that they would pick up from "citizenship vacationers" seeking dual citizenship for their unborn persons?
Hmmm...
What does "personhood" actually mean? Legislation to address personhood would have no effect unless this newly defined status included granting citizenship to the unborn. That would place any fertilized human blastocyst within the borders of the United States under the full protection of the United States Constitution. You might want to think about that for a moment.
Passage of personhood rights for the unborn would certainly make abortion illegal, and that is the motivating force behind the movement. But there would be other consequences as well. Most forms of contraception would also become illegal, as would in vitro fertilization as it is currently practiced. Expectant mothers could be held criminally liable for miscarriages, if their conduct during pregnancy were brought into question for any reason.
Another aspect of personhood that should be carefully considered is the automatic granting of US citizenship to anyone who is conceived, naturally or artificially, within the borders of the United States. If you don't care for the idea of "anchor babies", then you're probably not going to be too thrilled by the addition of "anchor zygotes". The tourist industry might well enjoy all of the business that they would pick up from "citizenship vacationers" seeking dual citizenship for their unborn persons?
Hmmm...