Arkady
President
I'm curious what people here think of the the language about pornography in the Republican platform.
As you may have heard, in order to get the backing of the evangelicals, Trump threw them two bones: (1) he picked a radical religious extremist as his VP, rather than someone who would help him in a swing state and with minorities, like Rubio, or someone with whom he had more personal affinity, like Christie, and (2) he let the evangelicals write the platform (other than insisting on gutting the GOP's stance on the Ukraine, to keep Putin happy). The result of their platform-writing was the most theocratic Republican platform ever. That included mimicking Utah's declaration that pornography is a "public health crisis," that is "destroying the lives of millions."
Is there any evidence that pornography actually is a "public health crisis" or that it has destroyed millions of lives? I get that sexual pleasure makes theocrats uncomfortable, other than within the very limited scope of plain vanilla relations between heterosexual spouses for purposes of procreation. But isn't that message one for the pulpit, not the platform of a major party?
In reality, it's entirely possible that the increasing availability of pornography in the web era has contributed to public health improvements, by facilitating harmless release for natural urges. The first popular web browser dates to 1993. The year before that, the rate of forcible rape in this country was 42.8. Now it's 26.4. Since around 1995, we've also had a decline in new HIV infections, and since around 1991, we've had a decline of teen birth rates (which are now at an all-time low). Divorce rates have also been plunging in that time period. There just aren't the kinds of real-world negative side effects we'd expect to see if pornography were a public health crisis.
I suppose one can dismiss this as a meaningless bone Trump threw to a faction he needed. One could argue that even if they'd like to impose Christian Shariah on the nation, Trump is a shameless libertine and has no plans to act on their desire. Perhaps. But to keep these people happy, presumably he'll have to throw some other bones their way, with regard to pornography, if he gets elected. It's tough to say that something is a public health crisis destroying millions of lives and then do nothing about it. The most likely outcome will be that money will get steered to addressing this "crisis" -- buying anti-porn propaganda, subjecting the porn industry to Meese-style grilling, etc. That's money and effort that would otherwise have gone to other ACTUAL public health crises. If we piss away money on theocratic preoccupations, we need to consider the opportunity cost. When policy is set not based on real-world considerations, but based on the taboos of powerful political groups, the result is lots of tax money being wasted on ineffectual and even counter-effective efforts (see, for example, abstinence-only education).
As you may have heard, in order to get the backing of the evangelicals, Trump threw them two bones: (1) he picked a radical religious extremist as his VP, rather than someone who would help him in a swing state and with minorities, like Rubio, or someone with whom he had more personal affinity, like Christie, and (2) he let the evangelicals write the platform (other than insisting on gutting the GOP's stance on the Ukraine, to keep Putin happy). The result of their platform-writing was the most theocratic Republican platform ever. That included mimicking Utah's declaration that pornography is a "public health crisis," that is "destroying the lives of millions."
Is there any evidence that pornography actually is a "public health crisis" or that it has destroyed millions of lives? I get that sexual pleasure makes theocrats uncomfortable, other than within the very limited scope of plain vanilla relations between heterosexual spouses for purposes of procreation. But isn't that message one for the pulpit, not the platform of a major party?
In reality, it's entirely possible that the increasing availability of pornography in the web era has contributed to public health improvements, by facilitating harmless release for natural urges. The first popular web browser dates to 1993. The year before that, the rate of forcible rape in this country was 42.8. Now it's 26.4. Since around 1995, we've also had a decline in new HIV infections, and since around 1991, we've had a decline of teen birth rates (which are now at an all-time low). Divorce rates have also been plunging in that time period. There just aren't the kinds of real-world negative side effects we'd expect to see if pornography were a public health crisis.
I suppose one can dismiss this as a meaningless bone Trump threw to a faction he needed. One could argue that even if they'd like to impose Christian Shariah on the nation, Trump is a shameless libertine and has no plans to act on their desire. Perhaps. But to keep these people happy, presumably he'll have to throw some other bones their way, with regard to pornography, if he gets elected. It's tough to say that something is a public health crisis destroying millions of lives and then do nothing about it. The most likely outcome will be that money will get steered to addressing this "crisis" -- buying anti-porn propaganda, subjecting the porn industry to Meese-style grilling, etc. That's money and effort that would otherwise have gone to other ACTUAL public health crises. If we piss away money on theocratic preoccupations, we need to consider the opportunity cost. When policy is set not based on real-world considerations, but based on the taboos of powerful political groups, the result is lots of tax money being wasted on ineffectual and even counter-effective efforts (see, for example, abstinence-only education).