New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Poverty

By the way, let me help you with your lack of understanding of basic psychology:

"Learned helplessness is a behaviour in which an organism forced to endure aversive, painful or otherwise unpleasant stimuli, becomes unable or unwilling to avoid subsequent encounters with those stimuli, even if they are escapable. Presumably, the organism has learned that it cannot control the situation and therefore does not take action to avoid the negative stimulus."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Learned_helplessness

Learned helplessness is believed to run rampant in poverty stricken communities, and is the first obstacle to overcome when dealing with poverty.

So, by that reasoning, if government assistance allows people to see a route for escaping unpleasant circumstances, people will make the effort. If, on the other hand, they are left to endure the unpleasant circumstances without any clear exit, they will learn to simply be passive.
 
How's about we just peg taxes back at those Kennedy rates, and call it good? From a historical standpoint, JFK lowered marginal rates significantly, resulting in an actual , albeit small INcrease in effective rates. Lowering marginal rates has always been a useful tool in our fiscal toolbox. Although, our history suggests that it's positive impact is limited. As soon as JFK and his peeps recognized that that taxcut had timed itself out, they moved on in a different direction.

We've got two problems with this these days. One of course, is the redwing "feeling" that taxcuts are always good under all circumstances. Thefore, why even bother analyzing their effectiveness? We know they're good and that's all we gotta know! Another problem, as elucidated in the Mitt campaign, is that the redwing refuses to even consider possible increases in effective rates. Clear up through the GHWB presidency, accepted Republican wisdom was that by cutting rates, we INcrease revenue. Alas nowadays, "increased revenue" are dirty words.
Here's what the Kennedy tax brackets look like, adjusted for inflation:



Married Filing Jointly
Marginal Tax Brackets
Tax Rate Over But Not Over
16.0% $0 $7,406
16.5% $7,406 $14,813
17.5% $14,813 $22,219
18.0% $22,219 $29,625
20.0% $29,625 $59,250
23.5% $59,250 $88,875
27.0% $88,875 $118,500
30.5% $118,500 $148,125
34.0% $148,125 $177,750
37.5% $177,750 $207,375
41.0% $207,375 $237,000
44.5% $237,000 $266,625
47.5% $266,625 $296,250
50.5% $296,250 $325,875
53.5% $325,875 $385,125
56.0% $385,125 $474,001
58.5% $474,001 $562,876
61.0% $562,876 $651,751
63.5% $651,751 $740,626
66.0% $740,626 $888,751
68.5% $888,751 $1,036,876
71.0% $1,036,876 $1,185,001
73.5% $1,185,001 $1,333,126
75.0% $1,333,126 $1,481,252
76.5% $1,481,252 $2,962,503
77.0% $2,962,503 -
 
So, by that reasoning, if government assistance allows people to see a route for escaping unpleasant circumstances, people will make the effort. If, on the other hand, they are left to endure the unpleasant circumstances without any clear exit, they will learn to simply be passive.
No, learned helplessness means that a subject will ignore routes of escape if presented. In other words, even if you give a person the means to escape poverty, if they are a victim of learned helplessness, they will, none the less, continue whatever behaviors kept them in poverty. Simply throwing money at people is a sure way of perpetuating generational poverty.
 
So, by that reasoning, if government assistance allows people to see a route for escaping unpleasant circumstances, people will make the effort. If, on the other hand, they are left to endure the unpleasant circumstances without any clear exit, they will learn to simply be passive.

The only thing you can do to make a difference Arky is to go to the ghetto and take people by the hand you yourself. Nothing else has ever worked as well or for as cheaply (for you or the government). You go and mentor someone and convince others to join you in that effort.

Your government planning and policy making don't amount to a hill of beans. Come out of your ivory tower and directly reach out to your fellow man, Arky.
 
Yes, wages will increase when illegals are not granted amnesty and return to their home countries. That will help the poor with more jobs with better pay.

As a reminder, the question was "Do people have other ideas about what has been shown, in real-world experience, to succeed or fail when it comes to lowering poverty?"

Is there a real-world example of illegals not being granted amnesty, returning to their home countries, and this resulting in a fall in the poverty rate? Considering there's been no amnesty since Reagan was president, and yet poverty rates have been mostly climbing over the last 15 years, I'm skeptical.
 
As a reminder, the question was "Do people have other ideas about what has been shown, in real-world experience, to succeed or fail when it comes to lowering poverty?"

Is there a real-world example of illegals not being granted amnesty, returning to their home countries, and this resulting in a fall in the poverty rate? Considering there's been no amnesty since Reagan was president, and yet poverty rates have been mostly climbing over the last 15 years, I'm skeptical.
Do those poverty rates count ILLEGALS as in poverty? ;0)
 
Poverty has increased in my opinion because of the break up of the family. With men's wages stagnant for 40 years it forced women to start working to bring two incomes into the family. With two adults working the family isn't as happy as it used to be and the divorce rate went up. With broken single parent homes it is hard to keep up with the quality of life so those homes fall into poverty.
I'm a little skeptical, since the era when women were mostly in the home, the 1950s, had absolutely brutal poverty by modern standards. And the breakup of the family, in terms of divorce rates rising quickly, first started to show up strongly in the 1960s and early 70s, even as the poverty rate was plummeting. Plus, the divorce rate has been falling pretty consistently since about 1981, yet poverty has mostly risen in that time.

But, maybe there's something to it. Maybe once you factor in the fall of the marriage rate there's still more and more people in single-parent homes, despite the divorce rate falling. And with the breakdown of the non-nuclear family (fewer extended families to help out), maybe you're onto something.

If it's true, what can we do to combat this trend? Maybe some clues can be found in the data about where single-parent families are found in greater numbers:

svf04a_fig3.jpg

It looks like a real cultural problem throughout much of the bible belt, though perhaps less so in areas with greater Latino immigration (Texas, California), possibly due to Catholic attitudes about divorce.
 
No, learned helplessness means that a subject will ignore routes of escape if presented. In other words, even if you give a person the means to escape poverty, if they are a victim of learned helplessness, they will, none the less, continue whatever behaviors kept them in poverty. Simply throwing money at people is a sure way of perpetuating generational poverty.
So, the key is making sure they never learn helplessness in the first place, so we need to start young with the efforts to make sure people aren't locked by the market into hopeless situations.
 
The only thing you can do to make a difference Arky is to go to the ghetto and take people by the hand you yourself. Nothing else has ever worked as well or for as cheaply (for you or the government). You go and mentor someone and convince others to join you in that effort.

Your government planning and policy making don't amount to a hill of beans. Come out of your ivory tower and directly reach out to your fellow man, Arky.
What evidence do you see that such one-off personal efforts work? Judging by the fact that our biggest progress against poverty came in the late 60s and early 70s, which were an era of large, systematic anti-poverty programs, doesn't that seem more likely to work? I'm a pragmatist, so I'm looking for evidence from the real world, rather than just raw theories.
 
I'm a little skeptical, since the era when women were mostly in the home, the 1950s, had absolutely brutal poverty by modern standards. And the breakup of the family, in terms of divorce rates rising quickly, first started to show up strongly in the 1960s and early 70s, even as the poverty rate was plummeting. Plus, the divorce rate has been falling pretty consistently since about 1981, yet poverty has mostly risen in that time.

But, maybe there's something to it. Maybe once you factor in the fall of the marriage rate there's still more and more people in single-parent homes, despite the divorce rate falling. And with the breakdown of the non-nuclear family (fewer extended families to help out), maybe you're onto something.

If it's true, what can we do to combat this trend? Maybe some clues can be found in the data about where single-parent families are found in greater numbers:

svf04a_fig3.jpg

It looks like a real cultural problem throughout much of the bible belt, though perhaps less so in areas with greater Latino immigration (Texas, California), possibly due to Catholic attitudes about divorce.

Latinos definitely have a different culture for the most part. Many homes in latino communities have the parents, the kids, and the kids children and girl friends/wives all living under the same roof. I guess that lowers the single parent family rate. Also lowers the total households rate. Could be the same in the Bible belt. Lots of people living under the same roof.
 
So, the key is making sure they never learn helplessness in the first place, so we need to start young with the efforts to make sure people aren't locked by the market into hopeless situations.
The genie is out of the bottle on that one. Many impoverished areas are drowning in apathy and helplessness. This leads to frustration and depression, and eventually to violence, perpetuating learned helplessness in the community. You can't just say "go to school" because they place no value in it, even if you offer to pay for it. It's why the drop out rates in these areas is so high.
 
Latinos definitely have a different culture for the most part. Many homes in latino communities have the parents, the kids, and the kids children and girl friends/wives all living under the same roof. I guess that lowers the single parent family rate. Also lowers the total households rate. Could be the same in the Bible belt. Lots of people living under the same roof.
This may sound like the bigotry of the lapsed Catholic, but I think there's something culturally diseased in Protestantism -- at least the Baptist/Methodist/Pentecostal charismatic variety you find throughout the Bible Belt (as opposed to the Anglicans, Episcopalians, Lutherans, and Mormons). It seems that wherever that mode of Protestantism is culturally dominant, you get poverty, lousy educational performance, obesity, rampant racism, sexism, homophobia, violence, teen pregnancy, divorce, etc. Maybe letting more Catholic immigrants into those areas, from Latin America, would help to fix the culture.
 
This may sound like the bigotry of the lapsed Catholic, but I think there's something culturally diseased in Protestantism -- at least the Baptist/Methodist/Pentecostal charismatic variety you find throughout the Bible Belt (as opposed to the Anglicans, Episcopalians, Lutherans, and Mormons). It seems that wherever that mode of Protestantism is culturally dominant, you get poverty, lousy educational performance, obesity, rampant racism, sexism, homophobia, violence, teen pregnancy, divorce, etc. Maybe letting more Catholic immigrants into those areas, from Latin America, would help to fix the culture.

What are the racial makeup of the southern "Bible belt" states?

Maybe the south has never recovered from the Civil War?
 
The genie is out of the bottle on that one. Many impoverished areas are drowning in apathy and helplessness. This leads to frustration and depression, and eventually to violence, perpetuating learned helplessness in the community. You can't just say "go to school" because they place no value in it, even if you offer to pay for it. It's why the drop out rates in these areas is so high.
I wonder if we have models of neighborhoods that have really turned around, that we could learn from. Most of them that occur to me were more a case of gentrification, where a new population pushed in to displace the old one (e.g., Brooklyn). But I wonder if there are "economic miracles" where a population that mostly remained in situ really managed to recover. If so, we could learn lessons from that.

Local to myself, we had the "Massachusetts Miracle." In the 70s, Massachusetts, which had relied on mills and other failing industries, looked like it was heading towards the same fate as rust-belt communities from Syracuse to Cleveland to Detroit. There was growing poverty and social dysfunction. But then the area completed a rare successful transition from that kind of manufacturing to the knowledge economy, with computer equipment, financial services, medical devices, pharmaceuticals, and universities forming the basis for prosperity. It might make sense to dig into what, specifically, people like Dukakis were doing differently to aid that transformation, as compared to a place like Detroit that tried to hold onto past glories and ended up in a deep rut.
 
Back
Top