New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Prayer

Then you are the singular exception in the whole wide world. Would that I could be so fortunate and so favored. I suggest you pray for money. Enjoy!!
Why would I pray for money?
That's not the source of my happiness, so meh............
If money is what I wanted most in the world, there are plenty of other ways of getting that than prayer. What I want most are things money can't buy = love, happiness - stuff like that.
 
God answering may well be a subjective personal assessment of an outcome..that others might call..dumb luck..
You can call it "dumb luck" but when a series of event come to pass after you've prayed about it, it's more than just "dumb luck".
 
I don't see that a prayer not being answered in the way "I" want it to to be a negative answer. Sometimes you don't know the reason for the answer right away. This is why we're told to always be aware of what's going on around us.

GOD+ANSWER+IN+3+WAYS.jpg
The way I pray is not to ask for something specific. I don't always know exactly what I need. So I put the problem/ issue/ situation before God and ask God to resolve it in His way. There is always an answer. Doors close or doors open in just the right order and the solution is always perfect.

We had a sudden (completely out of the blue) job offer for Alaska. My prayer was just that God open or shut doors to show us the path. We had little time to decide whether or not we would take the offer. In a matter of weeks things (and I won't detail here - too long) happened so that we had a buyer for our house without putting it on the market and I had a job in Alaska. From the time we found out about the job and were in Alaska with our house sold was less than 3 months. You'll never convince me that that was just "dumb luck".

We don't pray "God I need a thousand bucks by next Saturday" and expect either a "yes", "no" or "wait". We pray "here's the problem I'm facing, God. I need your help". And the answer is always "Yes." God will help. I have never ever gotten a "no" when praying that way.
 
You can call it "dumb luck" but when a series of event come to pass after you've prayed about it, it's more than just "dumb luck".

What is it when you've prayed for it and they dont come to pass...
 
What is it when you've prayed for it and they dont come to pass...
God is not a genie in a bottle. If you pray for a thousand virgins to knock at your door, don't expect it to happen. You have to pray in a way that allows God to answer in his own way, not yours. I've outlined that in my post to Caroljo.
 
God is not a genie in a bottle. If you pray for a thousand virgins to knock at your door, don't expect it to happen. You have to pray in a way that allows God to answer in his own way, not yours. I've outlined that in my post to Caroljo.

Did I suggest I was praying for a thousand virgins? I suggest that God is not a selective type, responding only to some but not others..
 
Did I suggest I was praying for a thousand virgins? I suggest that God is not a selective type, responding only to some but not others..
The virgin thing was an example, Phil.
geez.gif

And God is not selective. He responds to everyone. Some see that God has responded, others call it "dumb luck".
 
The virgin thing was an example, Phil.
geez.gif

And God is not selective. He responds to everyone. Some see that God has responded, others call it "dumb luck".

of course it was.

i would posit that he does not.
 
If you've never prayed, how can you say she's an exception? In that case, I am too....and so are most believers. There's many times I've prayed for one thing, but when I got my answer...it wasn't what I prayed FOR, but it did end up better than what I'd hoped. I'm sorry you don't have that in your life. You have no idea how it feels to know God is responding to you. I've had many struggles through life, and He's gotten me through every one of them.

Perhaps, but I have watched as children died, and lives were ruined while all the while being the subject of a multitude of prayers. Perhaps god cared less for them than for you.
 
Perhaps, but I have watched as children died, and lives were ruined while all the while being the subject of a multitude of prayers. Perhaps god cared less for them than for you.
The way I see it is that we are here for the challenge. For the experience. If we only experienced good, it would have no value. Horrific things happen....yes, they do. I don't believe God causes the bad things to happen but God does allow us to have the experience of those bad things. And he can turn those bad things into good.

Do you have children? Do you save them from every single negative experience or do you allow them to learn how to get through negativity? Would they be better people if you saved them from anything that might hurt them or their feelings? I don't think they would be better at all.

What belief in God gives us is a better ability to roll with the huge waves that life brings us rather than drowning in every storm that comes our way. God is a way to go with the waves rather than against them. God doesn't remove the waves he just provides a surfboard for them. So even if God doesn't exist, the belief that he is there enables us to survive life a little easier.

Prayer doesn't demand that God save a child or a life. It asks for the best outcome and for strength to deal with whatever that is. I lost a toddler many years ago and I lost my marriage in the aftermath. It was a horrific experience. But from the ashes of that came my present marriage of 31 years and 3 more children none of whom would have been born without my going through the initial experience. I see no way my path would have crossed with my husband's path without all of the events that took place. I believe that God led me through that and to where I am now.
 
Perhaps, but I have watched as children died, and lives were ruined while all the while being the subject of a multitude of prayers. Perhaps god cared less for them than for you.

Is it God you don't believe in, onecut, or has organized religion so turned you off that you threw it out - God included?
 
Is it God you don't believe in, onecut, or has organized religion so turned you off that you threw it out - God included?

I believe myself to be a realist. I am open to argument. Just give me one objective fact that even points to the existance of God, any god. It has been 6000 years and it has not yet happened.

They don't call it "faith" (belief without objective proof) for nothing.

The mainstream denominations bother me not a bit. They are mostly good people who do a lot of good things without the threats and apocolyptic BS of the fundamentalists but that makes their core belief no more valid.
 
The way I see it is that we are here for the challenge. For the experience. If we only experienced good, it would have no value. Horrific things happen....yes, they do. I don't believe God causes the bad things to happen but God does allow us to have the experience of those bad things. And he can turn those bad things into good.

Do you have children? Do you save them from every single negative experience or do you allow them to learn how to get through negativity? Would they be better people if you saved them from anything that might hurt them or their feelings? I don't think they would be better at all.

What belief in God gives us is a better ability to roll with the huge waves that life brings us rather than drowning in every storm that comes our way. God is a way to go with the waves rather than against them. God doesn't remove the waves he just provides a surfboard for them. So even if God doesn't exist, the belief that he is there enables us to survive life a little easier.

Prayer doesn't demand that God save a child or a life. It asks for the best outcome and for strength to deal with whatever that is. I lost a toddler many years ago and I lost my marriage in the aftermath. It was a horrific experience. But from the ashes of that came my present marriage of 31 years and 3 more children none of whom would have been born without my going through the initial experience. I see no way my path would have crossed with my husband's path without all of the events that took place. I believe that God led me through that and to where I am now.

Great!!! Too bad for the kid though, right?
 
Was it? Your story. Apparently it was all worth while. God loves you.
You missed the point.
Your rejection of God is your choice, but you are so committed to your narrative that you wear blinders to and block anything that doesn't agree with that narrative you have built. That isn't a good way to discover truth. But. It is your choice.
 
The virgin thing was an example, Phil.
geez.gif

And God is not selective. He responds to everyone. Some see that God has responded, others call it "dumb luck".

Can one say that god has "responded" when that response is impossible to see?
 
Can one say that god has "responded" when that response is impossible to see?
Impossible for you looking in to see.
Not impossible for the person experiencing it.
If one rejects God, he doesn't bother them. He respects your rejection. Thus it will always be unless you stop rejecting him then he's there instantly.
 
Impossible for you looking in to see.
Not impossible for the person experiencing it.
If one rejects God, he doesn't bother them. He respects your rejection. Thus it will always be unless you stop rejecting him then he's there instantly.

Once again returning to your story. God was willing to make you stronger. (you say) For that he decided not to spare your child? Was he teaching you a lesson? Was there not an easier, less cruel way to do that? A way that did not punish an innocent?

I truly hope god chooses not to interfere in my life the way he has (supposedly) stepped into yours.

All other things aside, I am extremely sorry for the loss of your child.
 
Once again returning to your story. God was willing to make you stronger. (you say) For that he decided not to spare your child? Was he teaching you a lesson? Was there not an easier, less cruel way to do that? A way that did not punish an innocent?

I truly hope god chooses not to interfere in my life the way he has (supposedly) stepped into yours.

All other things aside, I am extremely sorry for the loss of your child.

God didn't take my child. He allowed the natural events to unfold and didn't step in to stop it. I was secular at that point (not atheist, just not religious) and I didn't ask anything of God. ... not in a real way anyway. Many years later I still mourn my baby's death every single day. But if he had lived I would have had to be associated with his father who was a physically and emotionally abusive man. I was freed from that bondage and have been for well over 30 years. Maybe that's why it was "allowed" to happen. I don't know. Had I had my way I wouldn't have lost the child and I would have put up with the father. But then my hell on earth would have lasted a lot longer than the few years it did. Maybe God knew best.
 
Back
Top