freyasman
Senator
of the dynamic, IMO.
https://opensourcedefense.org/blog/...round-checks-are-a-debate-and-how-to-solve-it
From the link;
"Game theory and guns: why universal background checks are a debate — and how to solve it
Kareem Shaya
August 26, 2019 | 19 minute read
If you follow gun stuff, you’ve been hearing a lot about universal background checks. So let’s get the lay of the land. This article is especially for people who are roughly aware of the issue but don’t know the details of it, or the details of why it’s a debate at all.
And yeah, why is it a debate? The question “Would you favor or oppose background checks on all potential gun buyers?” really does poll at 90% support. That’s surprising. You can’t get 90% of people to agree on a flavor of ice cream, let alone a gun law.
What’s going on here? There are three key questions to answer:
If universal background checks have 90% support, why haven’t they already become law?
This is the simplest of the three, and it comes down to a difference between support for the general concept and support for how it works in real life. The thing that polls in the 80-90% range is this exact wording (with minor variations in different polls): “Would you favor or oppose background checks on all potential gun buyers?”
Background checks have been mandatory under federal law for all gun store purchases since 1993. That requirement doesn’t apply to sales between private individuals, because forcing background checks for all sales (e.g. sales between friends) was politically unpopular and didn’t have the votes in Congress. So private sales were offered as a compromise to get the law passed.
“Universal background checks” is the term for now revoking that compromise and expanding the law to cover all firearm transfers, whether the seller/transferor is a gun shop or just a private individual. But an actual law has to go into more detail than:
Run background checks on all potential gun buyers. Thanks.
– Congress
What kinds of detail? I’m going to set a timer for 60 seconds and start thinking of edge cases a universal background check law would have to account for. Ok, here goes:
If you don’t live in a high-gun-ownership area, I know these edge cases seem silly. “What, you’re going to give your teenager a rifle for Christmas?”
The answer, believe it or not, is “Actually, yes.” In much of the country, gun ownership is swirled into foundational cultural rituals like it’s Neapolitan soft serve. Giving your kid a rifle for Christmas isn’t just utterly normal, it’s a time-honored rite of passage. Telling a ranch hand to grab the rifle out of your truck before he leaves to guard some livestock for a few days isn’t just a convenience, it’s how you keep the ranch running. Loaning your new pistol to a friend so he can try it out isn’t just a favor, it’s a way to deepen that friendship just like loaning him a book or going out to dinner.
(For more on edge cases, see David Kopel’s detailed breakdown of the universal background check bill from earlier this year.)
(And while I’m writing parentheticals, suicidal ideation is an edge case I didn’t think of in the 60-second sprint above. But it’s a big one. Two-thirds of shooting deaths are suicides. We should all want it to be incredibly, trivially easy for someone to say to a friend or family member, “I’m going through a deep depression. Could you hang onto my guns for a while?” Universal background checks make that illegal. People with severe depression aren’t going to drag a friend to a gun store, involve the gun shop owner in their private mental health issues, and pay a transfer fee for each gun. BJ Campbell wrote a piece specifically about this non-obvious suicide risk of UBCs.)
Again, this will all seem easy to dismiss if you live in a place where these things aren’t normal. But that’s the point — there are a lot of places where these things are normal. People aren’t going to drive an hour to the gun store with their friend or family member, pay a fee, do a background check, loan the gun, and then do the whole thing over again when the person gives the gun back. They’re just not. And not only are they not going to do it, they’re going to resent whoever tried to make them. That’s all purely descriptive — whether a UBC law is good, bad, or indifferent, as an empirical matter people will break it pretty much universally.
Cam Edwards described this with a different cultural touchstone that could help bring the problem closer to home: “Trying to enforce a law requiring background checks on gun owners selling one of their firearms to another individual would be like trying to enforce a law requiring you to show ID before you can get a beer from your buddy’s cooler at the neighborhood BBQ.”
So the answer to this section’s question — “If universal background checks have 90% support, why haven’t they already become law?” — is coming into focus. The vaguely-worded question of whether buying a gun should require a background check is what gets 90% support. And yes, you’d expect 90% of people to “sure, why not” that general idea in a quick phone survey. But once people see what the details of a UBC law look like in real life, things change. Rephrase the question to capture those details — “Should it be a felony to lend your hunting buddy a gun if his gun breaks?” or “How much jail time should you get for giving your cousin a gun for his birthday?” — and people sour on it quickly.
That’s descriptive, not speculative. Empirically, these laws are a lot more contentious than the 90% talking point suggests. David Kopel summed up how UBCs fare in state-level referendums: “Actual election polls tell a different story. Defeated in Maine, passed by less than 1% in Nevada. Passed with 59% in Washington. Once voters learn how miswritten these bills are, including HR8 in Congress, support plunges.”
UBCs only got 59% of the popular vote in Washington, a state that hasn’t elected a Republican senator since 1994 or a Republican governor since 1980. UBCs were rejected by Congress in the 1993 Brady Bill, specifically as a compromise to get the bill to pass — and the early ’90s were a high-water mark for support for gun control. Shortly thereafter, the public began a 25+ year trend of steadily declining support for gun control across nearly every demographic, and that trend continues through the present. In terms of long-term trends, statistically gun control has never been less popular than it is today.
Taking all this together, it’s just not plausible that UBCs actually have popular support. Once people see the details, they read it as an attack on their lifestyle. These laws have gotten traction in places where that lifestyle has been extinguished (or never existed) as a significant cultural bloc. Everywhere else, UBCs simply do not have support outside of phone surveys.
Continued below
https://opensourcedefense.org/blog/...round-checks-are-a-debate-and-how-to-solve-it
From the link;
"Game theory and guns: why universal background checks are a debate — and how to solve it
Kareem Shaya
August 26, 2019 | 19 minute read
If you follow gun stuff, you’ve been hearing a lot about universal background checks. So let’s get the lay of the land. This article is especially for people who are roughly aware of the issue but don’t know the details of it, or the details of why it’s a debate at all.
And yeah, why is it a debate? The question “Would you favor or oppose background checks on all potential gun buyers?” really does poll at 90% support. That’s surprising. You can’t get 90% of people to agree on a flavor of ice cream, let alone a gun law.
What’s going on here? There are three key questions to answer:
- If universal background checks have 90% support, why haven’t they already become law?
- Why does each side insist on a path that the other side genuinely believes is insane? Why does each side only try to win by force?
- Is there a law that will give everyone what they want at the same time? What would that look like?
If universal background checks have 90% support, why haven’t they already become law?
This is the simplest of the three, and it comes down to a difference between support for the general concept and support for how it works in real life. The thing that polls in the 80-90% range is this exact wording (with minor variations in different polls): “Would you favor or oppose background checks on all potential gun buyers?”
Background checks have been mandatory under federal law for all gun store purchases since 1993. That requirement doesn’t apply to sales between private individuals, because forcing background checks for all sales (e.g. sales between friends) was politically unpopular and didn’t have the votes in Congress. So private sales were offered as a compromise to get the law passed.
“Universal background checks” is the term for now revoking that compromise and expanding the law to cover all firearm transfers, whether the seller/transferor is a gun shop or just a private individual. But an actual law has to go into more detail than:
Run background checks on all potential gun buyers. Thanks.
– Congress
What kinds of detail? I’m going to set a timer for 60 seconds and start thinking of edge cases a universal background check law would have to account for. Ok, here goes:
- Loaning guns on a ranch
- Loaning guns to a hunting buddy
- Inheritances
- Gifting to family members
- Gifting to a friend
- Loaning to friends or family
- Repair
- Safe keeping for trav
If you don’t live in a high-gun-ownership area, I know these edge cases seem silly. “What, you’re going to give your teenager a rifle for Christmas?”
The answer, believe it or not, is “Actually, yes.” In much of the country, gun ownership is swirled into foundational cultural rituals like it’s Neapolitan soft serve. Giving your kid a rifle for Christmas isn’t just utterly normal, it’s a time-honored rite of passage. Telling a ranch hand to grab the rifle out of your truck before he leaves to guard some livestock for a few days isn’t just a convenience, it’s how you keep the ranch running. Loaning your new pistol to a friend so he can try it out isn’t just a favor, it’s a way to deepen that friendship just like loaning him a book or going out to dinner.
(For more on edge cases, see David Kopel’s detailed breakdown of the universal background check bill from earlier this year.)
(And while I’m writing parentheticals, suicidal ideation is an edge case I didn’t think of in the 60-second sprint above. But it’s a big one. Two-thirds of shooting deaths are suicides. We should all want it to be incredibly, trivially easy for someone to say to a friend or family member, “I’m going through a deep depression. Could you hang onto my guns for a while?” Universal background checks make that illegal. People with severe depression aren’t going to drag a friend to a gun store, involve the gun shop owner in their private mental health issues, and pay a transfer fee for each gun. BJ Campbell wrote a piece specifically about this non-obvious suicide risk of UBCs.)
Again, this will all seem easy to dismiss if you live in a place where these things aren’t normal. But that’s the point — there are a lot of places where these things are normal. People aren’t going to drive an hour to the gun store with their friend or family member, pay a fee, do a background check, loan the gun, and then do the whole thing over again when the person gives the gun back. They’re just not. And not only are they not going to do it, they’re going to resent whoever tried to make them. That’s all purely descriptive — whether a UBC law is good, bad, or indifferent, as an empirical matter people will break it pretty much universally.
Cam Edwards described this with a different cultural touchstone that could help bring the problem closer to home: “Trying to enforce a law requiring background checks on gun owners selling one of their firearms to another individual would be like trying to enforce a law requiring you to show ID before you can get a beer from your buddy’s cooler at the neighborhood BBQ.”
So the answer to this section’s question — “If universal background checks have 90% support, why haven’t they already become law?” — is coming into focus. The vaguely-worded question of whether buying a gun should require a background check is what gets 90% support. And yes, you’d expect 90% of people to “sure, why not” that general idea in a quick phone survey. But once people see what the details of a UBC law look like in real life, things change. Rephrase the question to capture those details — “Should it be a felony to lend your hunting buddy a gun if his gun breaks?” or “How much jail time should you get for giving your cousin a gun for his birthday?” — and people sour on it quickly.
That’s descriptive, not speculative. Empirically, these laws are a lot more contentious than the 90% talking point suggests. David Kopel summed up how UBCs fare in state-level referendums: “Actual election polls tell a different story. Defeated in Maine, passed by less than 1% in Nevada. Passed with 59% in Washington. Once voters learn how miswritten these bills are, including HR8 in Congress, support plunges.”
UBCs only got 59% of the popular vote in Washington, a state that hasn’t elected a Republican senator since 1994 or a Republican governor since 1980. UBCs were rejected by Congress in the 1993 Brady Bill, specifically as a compromise to get the bill to pass — and the early ’90s were a high-water mark for support for gun control. Shortly thereafter, the public began a 25+ year trend of steadily declining support for gun control across nearly every demographic, and that trend continues through the present. In terms of long-term trends, statistically gun control has never been less popular than it is today.
Taking all this together, it’s just not plausible that UBCs actually have popular support. Once people see the details, they read it as an attack on their lifestyle. These laws have gotten traction in places where that lifestyle has been extinguished (or never existed) as a significant cultural bloc. Everywhere else, UBCs simply do not have support outside of phone surveys.
Continued below