New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Pretty sobering.

.but how exactly can this doctor assure us that he “is confident that we can bring this disease under control in 4, 6, or 8 weeks if Americans all wear masks”??

I’ve asked this DOZENS of times: where does this virus magically disappear to in 4-8 weeks of mask-wearing? Let’s say that, on week 9, we remove our masks

Under control means infections decline until they are manageable with a tracking and tracing program.


No, if we take off the mask the virus will spread faster and possible get to the point where tracking and tracing is not possible.

Right now it is not possible to track and trace 70k new infections a day. Even with a shutdown if might not be possible to prevent hospitals from being overwhelmed in the near term. We are at the verge of that happening in some places and it will continue to progress beyond capacity even if everyone in the area put on a mask right now.
 
No we won’t. As people are social distancing and practicing additional safety measures, flu stats will surely be lower.

There are 136,000 COVID deaths so far and the number continues to rise. That exceeds even the worst flus and it’s only July.

Where are people social distancing?
Protest
Beaches
Target
Wal-Mart
COVID-19 house parties all across America

Additional safety measures:)
Mask that don't cover the eyes
Mask that don't fit correct


How many of the 136,000 are all from RONA............you have no idea.

School starts soon............
 
Under control means infections decline until they are manageable with a tracking and tracing program.


No, if we take off the mask the virus will spread faster and possible get to the point where tracking and tracing is not possible.

Right now it is not possible to track and trace 70k new infections a day. Even with a shutdown if might not be possible to prevent hospitals from being overwhelmed in the near term. We are at the verge of that happening in some places and it will continue to progress beyond capacity even if everyone in the area put on a mask right now.
And how do you know a lot of these cases weren’t cases that have been around for a while? We just wrapped up our testing abilities. Who’s the say that these cases aren’t leftovers from then? In other words are the new cases actually new?
 
It’s effectively a protein RNA strand. It isn’t a life form. Even if it were, though, it wouldn’t die out in 4-8 weeks of mask-wearing...nor would “shelter in place” that isn’t staggered relieve hospitals of being overtaxed.
Ok. So then....what?
 
my assumption is that if the virus does not have a host to replicate within... it dies..

no?
That is the case. This is why viruses only last for a small amount of time on surfaces; no host body to keep it warm, provide it with proteins, etc...

I think there is some merit to what the guy said about week 9.

I'm willing to try it and see what happens. Lets lock down one of those towns nobody ever uses like Omaha and see what the case rate is on week 9.
 
I'm willing to try it and see what happens. Lets lock down one of those towns nobody ever uses like Omaha and see what the case rate is on week 9.

What do you think the economic conditions would be in Omaha on week 9 if they did that? Small businesses? Unemployment? There has been less than 300 deaths total in the entire state of Nebraska due to Covid. Kind of a stupid suggestion, isn't it?
 


pretty dire declarations...
We've come full circle sine fauci and the CDC downplayed risks as the viruscemergedvin 1Q2020.

Is this latest prediction a tacit admission that their primary job - a vaccine - isn't going well?
 
Under control means infections decline until they are manageable with a tracking and tracing program.


No, if we take off the mask the virus will spread faster and possible get to the point where tracking and tracing is not possible.

Right now it is not possible to track and trace 70k new infections a day. Even with a shutdown if might not be possible to prevent hospitals from being overwhelmed in the near term. We are at the verge of that happening in some places and it will continue to progress beyond capacity even if everyone in the area put on a mask right now.
Just to clarify - I wasn’t advocating mask removal, any sort of timetable, etc. I am saying that the experts continually offer statements that do not pass muster of basic common sense as I noted above. This doctor’s “4-8 weeks under control” statement is but one example...and virtually no one drills down on this stuff.
 
Ok. So then....what?
Exactly. Then what? This is my point. I don’t think shutting down and waiting it out is a viable option...nor was it ever. I think we do the yellow light thing and “proceed with caution”.
 
Just to clarify - I wasn’t advocating mask removal, any sort of timetable, etc. I am saying that the experts continually offer statements that do not pass muster of basic common sense as I noted above. This doctor’s “4-8 weeks under control” statement is but one example...and virtually no one drills down on this stuff.
The 4- 8 weeks is to get it to a level where you can start to manage the new infections. Right now there is no chance of using the normal protocols needed to stop the spread and its further taxing of the medical system.
 
And how do you know a lot of these cases weren’t cases that have been around for a while? We just wrapped up our testing abilities. Who’s the say that these cases aren’t leftovers from then? In other words are the new cases actually new?
So you think these people have been infected and infectious for 4 months ? I think they would have been dead by now. Either your system fights if off or it kills you are really the only two outcomes it doesn't take 4 months. Why do you think they tell people who have been exposed to quarantine for 14 days if the virus is still active after 4 month ?
 
Where are people social distancing?
Protest
Beaches
Target
Wal-Mart
COVID-19 house parties all across America

Additional safety measures:)
Mask that don't cover the eyes
Mask that don't fit correct


How many of the 136,000 are all from RONA............you have no idea.

School starts soon............

CDC says 136,000. Cut it in half and it’s still way more than any flu.
 
Where are people social distancing?
Protest
Beaches
Target
Wal-Mart
COVID-19 house parties all across America

Additional safety measures:)
Mask that don't cover the eyes
Mask that don't fit correct


How many of the 136,000 are all from RONA............you have no idea.

School starts soon............
I social distance anywhere I go. If people stay 6' or more away from me, I don't walk up to them. If I'm in a store and someone is looking at something that i want to get on a shelf, I stand back until they move on. But I have always done that. It's just a simple courtesy.
Now, because we have a governor with only one testicle, if that, we have to wear face diapers when going into any business. I bought the type that fits over your head, like a tube, and stays around your neck. You can pull it up as you walk into a store or restaurant and pull it down as you walk out.
 
The 4- 8 weeks is to get it to a level where you can start to manage the new infections. Right now there is no chance of using the normal protocols needed to stop the spread and its further taxing of the medical system.
Those are similar comments to why we needed to shelter in place March thru May. The virus doesn’t care about our hibernation season - and not staggering exposures will lead to infrastructure over-saturation over and over again. All out, all in, all out again, all in again - see a pattern yet? There’s no doubt in my mind that these experts are quite talented in their medical fields...but I see little evidence that these folks are capable “program managers”. Mind you, they’re certainly not worse at it than our pols...but they don’t seem to grasp basic strategies regarding managing headcounts and re-introducing folks to exposure in an incrementally staggered approach. I’m no physican, let alone anything resembling an epidemiologist. I have made a career of conceiving, planning, programming, and executing extremely large scale projects all around the world - with varied peoples of diverse cultural orientations. I recognize a completely dysfunctional program when I see one. I don’t care if you blame Trump, China, or subject matter experts who are not “planning and execution guys”. This stuff is a mess - and the stuff they are driving won’t fix it.
 
So you think these people have been infected and infectious for 4 months ? I think they would have been dead by now. Either your system fights if off or it kills you are really the only two outcomes it doesn't take 4 months. Why do you think they tell people who have been exposed to quarantine for 14 days if the virus is still active after 4 month ?
Are we sure the positives aren’t hitting on antibodies? Are the tests standard across the country? How long can people carry it and not know? Or develop symptoms? How do we know?
 
Those are similar comments to why we needed to shelter in place March thru May. The virus doesn’t care about our hibernation season - and not staggering exposures will lead to infrastructure over-saturation over and over again. All out, all in, all out again, all in again - see a pattern yet? There’s no doubt in my mind that these experts are quite talented in their medical fields...but I see little evidence that these folks are capable “program managers”. Mind you, they’re certainly not worse at it than our pols...but they don’t seem to grasp basic strategies regarding managing headcounts and re-introducing folks to exposure in an incrementally staggered approach. I’m no physican, let alone anything resembling an epidemiologist. I have made a career of conceiving, planning, programming, and executing extremely large scale projects all around the world - with varied peoples of diverse cultural orientations. I recognize a completely dysfunctional program when I see one. I don’t care if you blame Trump, China, or subject matter experts who are not “planning and execution guys”. This stuff is a mess - and the stuff they are driving won’t fix it.
Sure staggering might have been an option early on if everyone had shutdown all at once. But it's already exploding as we speak. How do you stagger an ongoing explosion ?

There is a standard procedure. It has worked all over the world against all kinds of diseases. It worked for this virus all around the world where it has been implemented with a strict top down plan by their national governments.

This national government did not follow that tried and true procedure and that is why it is a disaster. This was wilful ignorance. There is no need for a new plan. The normal one works if you actually enact it. The last admin left task force in place to specifically to do that very thing.

It's not happening and this is why it is and will continue to be a train wreck until it does happen.
 
Are we sure the positives aren’t hitting on antibodies? Are the tests standard across the country? How long can people carry it and not know? Or develop symptoms? How do we know?
An antibody test is a different kind of test.

As for the rest you go look that stuff up and then come back and tell me.
 
Back
Top