New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for atheists.........

I guess the follow up question then is where do you think the "rules" of how to live come from? Why do you feel you want to make the world a better place? Where do you believe your morality comes from? Something tells you that murdering another person is wrong, that stealing what isn't yours is wrong. Surely it isn't just the fear of going to jail that prevents you from doing that. So what is that something and where does it come from?

I think the answer to your questions is that the "rules" come from thousands of years of human experience. This is compatible by the way, with both a God perspective and a non-God perspective.
 
What is the purpose of life?

The presumption here seems to be that atheists will or should have a harder time answering this question than theists. But I don't see why that should necessarily be true at all.

The same sort of “problem of infinite regression” that gets applied to the question of the Universe's origin could be applied to this question as well. After all, how might a theist answer the question? Well, he or she might say something like, “The purpose of life is to discover and embrace the grace of God and thereby be granted the gift of eternal life and joy with Him in Heaven.” Or he or she might say, “The purpose of life is to purify one's soul and so attain a higher level of existence in the next life.” Or, “The purpose of life is to attain higher wisdom so that one may draw ever closer to oneness with the Divine.” And so on... But to any of those answers one might say, “Great, and what's the purpose of that?”

Ultimately the only answer to the “why” of any purpose one gives to existence is, “Because it seems right and fulfilling.” From an ontological perspective, I don't see why it matters whether we call that answer “living according to God's plan” or “seeking union with the divine” or “living in harmony with the ethical/moral impulses imbued in us by millions of years of evolution as social animals.”

Now from a political perspective, on the other hand, the nature of one's answer may matter a great deal. After all, if one believes that one's purpose in life is defined and sanctioned by the Almighty, then it's a bit easier to brush away challenges as blasphemy and to seek to crush any opposition as the enemy of Truth.

As for my answer, well, I've given it before. The purpose of life is to learn and love, to do your best with what time you have for yourself and those you care for and about, and to try to do what you can to make things better as best you understand that for those here now and for those to come. For all of us who share this existence... Or something like that.

That seems like a lot to live for to me – and an awesome reward and responsibility in itself. And if there's something more after this life is done, well, great. And if there's not, then we're all in the same boat and there's really no point worrying about it.

Cheers.
 
The presumption here seems to be that atheists will or should have a harder time answering this question than theists. But I don't see why that should necessarily be true at all.

The same sort of “problem of infinite regression” that gets applied to the question of the Universe's origin could be applied to this question as well. After all, how might a theist answer the question? Well, he or she might say something like, “The purpose of life is to discover and embrace the grace of God and thereby be granted the gift of eternal life and joy with Him in Heaven.” Or he or she might say, “The purpose of life is to purify one's soul and so attain a higher level of existence in the next life.” Or, “The purpose of life is to attain higher wisdom so that one may draw ever closer to oneness with the Divine.” And so on... But to any of those answers one might say, “Great, and what's the purpose of that?”

Ultimately the only answer to the “why” of any purpose one gives to existence is, “Because it seems right and fulfilling.” From an ontological perspective, I don't see why it matters whether we call that answer “living according to God's plan” or “seeking union with the divine” or “living in harmony with the ethical/moral impulses imbued in us by millions of years of evolution as social animals.”

Now from a political perspective, on the other hand, the nature of one's answer may matter a great deal. After all, if one believes that one's purpose in life is defined and sanctioned by the Almighty, then it's a bit easier to brush away challenges as blasphemy and to seek to crush any opposition as the enemy of Truth.

As for my answer, well, I've given it before. The purpose of life is to learn and love, to do your best with what time you have for yourself and those you care for and about, and to try to do what you can to make things better as best you understand that for those here now and for those to come. For all of us who share this existence... Or something like that.

That seems like a lot to live for to me – and an awesome reward and responsibility in itself. And if there's something more after this life is done, well, great. And if there's not, then we're all in the same boat and there's really no point worrying about it.

Cheers.

As far as I am concerned we are all in the same boat (struggling through life as best we can) and "Love" (to find, to experience, to show) is my personal primary purpose for life. Sounds easy. Isn't necessarily easy.

I was curious as to whether someone who does not feel Soul within their being has the same feeling of purpose as I do.
I got some good answers.
 
As far as I am concerned we are all in the same boat (struggling through life as best we can) and "Love" (to find, to experience, to show) is my personal primary purpose for life. Sounds easy. Isn't necessarily easy.

I was curious as to whether someone who does not feel Soul within their being has the same feeling of purpose as I do.
I got some good answers.

A lot of the differences between “us” and “others” that we take to be significant when we think about them in the abstract tend to fall away when we dig below the surface. It's no coincidence that acceptance and respect are tied to understanding and familiarity. Most of the time, we have more in common with “the other” than we have truly profound differences. Most of the time...

And God knows I agree that "love" (to find, to experience, to show) is, in so many ways, so much easier said than accomplished. ;)

Cheers.
 
I did a workshop the other night and one of the "agree/disagree questions was "there should be prayer in public schools". It led to an interesting discussion and one man who was an atheist said, "I am a free thinker and I take responsibility for my actions" . I thought the term 'free thinker" expressed how I feel. Only two people thought there should be prayer in public school and blamed all the ills of society on the lack of prayer.
 
I did a workshop the other night and one of the "agree/disagree questions was "there should be prayer in public schools". It led to an interesting discussion and one man who was an atheist said, "I am a free thinker and I take responsibility for my actions" . I thought the term 'free thinker" expressed how I feel. Only two people thought there should be prayer in public school and blamed all the ills of society on the lack of prayer.
And those two people had as much right to have their opinions without having those opinions mocked as the ones who believed that prayer does not belong in school. I hope you were somehow able to give them the respect they deserved.

Had the group had all but two people who thought prayer did belong in school and that all the ills of society were brought to us by our removing prayer from school, those two loners, atheists who somehow saw other atheists as "free thinkers"............should have been given respect for their thoughts too.
 
And those two people had as much right to have their opinions without having those opinions mocked as the ones who believed that prayer does not belong in school. I hope you were somehow able to give them the respect they deserved.

Had the group had all but two people who thought prayer did belong in school and that all the ills of society were brought to us by our removing prayer from school, those two loners, atheists who somehow saw other atheists as "free thinkers"............should have been given respect for their thoughts too.

No I have everybody gang up and throw stones at them.... Seriously the very first thing I say in my groups is we must show respect to differing viewpoints. Without a safe environment people will not feel free to speak. What always impresses me is that most Catholic school teachers do not believe prayer should be in public schools. I never fail to be surprised.
 
No I have everybody gang up and throw stones at them.... Seriously the very first thing I say in my groups is we must show respect to differing viewpoints. Without a safe environment people will not feel free to speak. What always impresses me is that most Catholic school teachers do not believe prayer should be in public schools. I never fail to be surprised.

I am glad to know that.
I am a religious person and I do not believe that formal prayer or even a moment of silence should be in public schools, but if a kid bows his head in thought and someone thinks he is praying, he should be left alone and allowed to do that (unless he's sleeping during class, of course).
 
I am glad to know that.
I am a religious person and I do not believe that formal prayer or even a moment of silence should be in public schools, but if a kid bows his head in thought and someone thinks he is praying, he should be left alone and allowed to do that (unless he's sleeping during class, of course).

I agree...it's like the old joke, all kids pray when you out the test paper in front of them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
No I have everybody gang up and throw stones at them.... Seriously the very first thing I say in my groups is we must show respect to differing viewpoints. Without a safe environment people will not feel free to speak. What always impresses me is that most Catholic school teachers do not believe prayer should be in public schools. I never fail to be surprised.

Do you talk about your racist, bigoted statements about white people, Southerners, Christians and Jews? Or do you save that for the final?
 
Do you talk about your racist, bigoted statements about white people, Southerners, Christians and Jews? Or do you save that for the final?

No kidding.....I read that sentence and wondered the same thing. How can someone that doesn't know how to show respect to people with differing viewpoints teach a class to respect them?
 
Question for atheists.........What is the purpose of life?

I'm always suspicious of people who ask this question. it hints to me that they're not feeling secure in their beliefs or are afraid of dying. let's face it, the primary existential threat to humans is death. yet when you talk seriously about death with old people, you find almost a contentment that the end is right around the corner and that's okay.
I figure we float around for a bit after death.......too many psychics communicate messages from the dead back to the living (ha ha).....then after a bit, the lights are turned off.
 
I'm always suspicious of people who ask this question. it hints to me that they're not feeling secure in their beliefs or are afraid of dying. let's face it, the primary existential threat to humans is death. yet when you talk seriously about death with old people, you find almost a contentment that the end is right around the corner and that's okay.
I figure we float around for a bit after death.......too many psychics communicate messages from the dead back to the living (ha ha).....then after a bit, the lights are turned off.

If you float around a bit...wouldn't that indicate that there's a soul involved? What would be floating?

Asking this question doesn't mean anyone is insecure....it's just interesting to know what others really think about it. I don't feel insecure at all, and I'm also not afraid of dying. I will admit though.....I'm afraid of HOW I will die (I'm not into pain!)
 
I supposed you can prove that? Or are you just talking out your ass again?

And I guess you think they're atheists.....since most poor people are more religious. The poorer the people, the needier they are and the more they need Daddy in the sky. So commonsense dictates. Since most atheists are young and educated, I believe my statement to be true. I didn't "talk out of my ass." What a classy woman you are.
 
If you float around a bit...wouldn't that indicate that there's a soul involved? What would be floating?

Asking this question doesn't mean anyone is insecure....it's just interesting to know what others really think about it. I don't feel insecure at all, and I'm also not afraid of dying. I will admit though.....I'm afraid of HOW I will die (I'm not into pain!)

That's why morphine is the way to go!
 
Do you talk about your racist, bigoted statements about white people, Southerners, Christians and Jews? Or do you save that for the final?

As a matter of fact I have told mySouthern groups about my prejudice of the Deep South....and they shared their prejudices about the Yankees. Didn't know I hated Christians and jews.....I think you might be projecting, oh wait , I forgot..you're an extremist....so if you don't t like religion therefore you,must hate the people who believe...extremism, nothing gray...either/or
 
And I guess you think they're atheists.....since most poor people are more religious. The poorer the people, the needier they are and the more they need Daddy in the sky. So commonsense dictates. Since most atheists are young and educated, I believe my statement to be true. I didn't "talk out of my ass." What a classy woman you are.

What are you talking about? This is what you said and what I asked for proof of....

Those playing video games , collecting welfare and committing crimes are mostly believers
 
If you float around a bit...wouldn't that indicate that there's a soul involved? What would be floating?

Asking this question doesn't mean anyone is insecure....it's just interesting to know what others really think about it. I don't feel insecure at all, and I'm also not afraid of dying. I will admit though.....I'm afraid of HOW I will die (I'm not into pain!)

you call it a soul. I don't.
 
I'm always suspicious of people who ask this question. it hints to me that they're not feeling secure in their beliefs or are afraid of dying. let's face it, the primary existential threat to humans is death. yet when you talk seriously about death with old people, you find almost a contentment that the end is right around the corner and that's okay.
I figure we float around for a bit after death.......too many psychics communicate messages from the dead back to the living (ha ha).....then after a bit, the lights are turned off.

I am at peace with death.
I feel I'm a spirit dwelling in this body and I'll just pop out and see what comes next. I don't believe the death of my body will be the end for my spirit, but if it is, I won't know, so whatever happens it will be okay.
 
Back
Top