New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Catholics on facilitating Sin.

degsme

Council Member
So a while ago, Gigi and others were explaining to me how a good Catholic cannot abide in giving any $$ to someone who might use it in a sinful way... specifically in acquiring an abortificant

OK.

So then what about this? I

  1. s it OK for someone to actively court those engaged in such sinful promotion to help your personal goals?
  2. Is it OK to seek the profits generated from such sinful goals to further your personal goals, some of which contradict the sinful actions?


I ask this becasue many Catholics are supporting Mitt Romney's campaign. And yet Mitt Romney is
Meeting with Dr. Phillp Frost - Chairman of the Board for Teva Pharma who is a major manufacturer of contracption including Plan B One Step that Catholics consider an abortificant?

http://miamiherald.typepad.com/nake...-on-multi-city-florida-fundraising-swing.html

http://www.tevapharm.com/About/BoardOfDirectors/Pages/Dr_Phillip_Frost.aspx

http://www.tevapharm-na.com/Our-Products.aspx
 
Mitt Romney's Magic Underwear© give him the supernatural ability to dynamically "phase shift" his moral positions, based upon optimum ROI.
 
As a Catholic, I'll suggest that dollars are most certainly fungible, which suggests that we Catholics need an accounting degree to address this question! But, since all available science and accounting demonstrates that a dollar spent on contraception is a dollar saved, this one's pretty simple. Even IF I was of the Catholic minority that was obsessed with non-contraception, I'd know that MY dollar wasn't actually going TOWARDS promoting contraception.
 
I didn't tell you that a good Catholic can't give money to anyone who MIGHT use it in a sinful way. If that were the case, no Catholic would be allowed to give money to anyone, ever. They wouldnt' be allowed to employ people, make donations, give money as gifts. In fact we wouldn't be allowed to give any kind of gift because the recipient might trade it for something sinful. It's one thing to pay a salary or give a gift in good faith. It's quite another to provide a specific product that you believe is sinful as part of a salary or as a gift.


I really don't know what the Mormons believe about contraception. I don't care. Romney is as free as anyone to make his decisions about an issue. IT only becomes an issue of hypocrisy for Romney if two things are true. One of them would be that the Mormons forbid contraception. And the second would be if Romney were claiming to be a devout and obedient Mormon who intends to lead according to what his faith commands.

If Romney were promising to promote the company's contraceptive sales through legislation that would violate the right to faithful practice of a particular religion(a la Obama and Sebilius) , the two questions you pose would be questions you'd ask of Romney and of Catholic voters. But so far, I haven't seen Romney promising to promote anything of the kind.

Barry, Kathy and Nancy have managed to successfully sell nonsense to some of their supporters about a Catholic agenda to force everyone off of contraceptives, to the point where Catholic support for a candidate who isn't Catholic is incomprehensible to them.

IF you feel prolife Catholic and anyone who believes in religious liberty is going to stay home on election day because Romney fundraised with a pharmaceutical company, you're terribly mistaken.
 
Degs, do you really think that is the Catholic position, or are you just adopting for the sake of argument?
 
Degs, do you really think that is the Catholic position, or are you just adopting for the sake of argument?
Its the position Gigi (a strong Catholic apologist) has claimed is the basis for why the HRCC objected to the requirement that their SECULAR BUSINESSES that provide healthcare insurance, have to cover women's reproductive services including contraception like Plan B.

I'm just asking for how one with that position can support Romney who is actively using the "wages of sin" to run his campaign.
 
Its the position Gigi (a strong Catholic apologist) has claimed is the basis for why the HRCC objected to the requirement that their SECULAR BUSINESSES that provide healthcare insurance, have to cover women's reproductive services including contraception like Plan B.

I'm just asking for how one with that position can support Romney who is actively using the "wages of sin" to run his campaign.


And it was explained to you. If you didn't get it before, you won't get it now. Nutshell recap, Catholics don't have to convert candidates to Catholicism before they can vote for them. There's a difference between a candidate not acting as a Catholic(Romney) and a candidate trying to tell Catholics what to believe (Obama)
Romney is making a moral decision for himelf, not for me. And when are you going to ask our liberal Catholic friends here how they can support Obama despite what their church teaches? I notice you have not taken them to task
for claiming to be Catholic but yet doing the same thing you're trying to accuse me of doing.

Should we practicing Catholics vote for Obama, the man who has never been Catholic but now considers himself to be one of the "voices of enlightenment" in the Catholic religion?

He's also the guy who takes time and taxpayer money to create vocal and viral support of PP, an agency that uses our money to create videos aimed at children that openly mock deliberately misprepresent opposition to what they do.
http://www.lifesitenews.com/blog/th...parenthood-wishes-everybody-would-just-forget

He's also the guy who promised to sign FOCA, a bill that in its original form, would have abolished the Hyde protections. He is now using the healthcare bill to do that.

He's also the guy that directed his justice dept and his attorney general to prosecute protesters outside of clinics, failed miserably, and exposed his agenda in the process.

Oh, and he's also the guy who thinks unplanned children are a punishment, even when those children mght be his own grandchildren.

So who do you think a devout Catholic should support out of the two? OR do you think we should just all stay home on election day because Romney had a fundraiser at a pharmaceutical company?


What this really comes down to is that libs are rankled because the conservative ("war on women")candidate is betraying your propaganda with his actions. And like libs often do, you're trying to us a group-in this case Catholics- to beat up a candidate. You just know that the next time you start that business, we'll remind you of Romney's association with Teva.
 
And it was explained to you. If you didn't get it before, you won't get it now. Nutshell recap, Catholics don't have to convert candidates to Catholicism before they can vote for them. There's a difference between a candidate not acting as a Catholic(Romney) and a candidate trying to tell Catholics what to believe (Obama)
Romney is making a moral decision for himelf, not for me.

But in supporting Romney, you are supporting someone who is not only taking the wages of sin and profiting from them but in return promising benefits to that donor - even if they are only benefits of "access". So by supporting Romney you are supporting a company that promotes what you consider sinful every bit as much as the insurnace company that you pay benefits into promoting THE SAME sins.

And when are you going to ask our liberal Catholic friends here how they can support Obama despite what their church teaches? I notice you have not taken them to task
for claiming to be Catholic but yet doing the same thing you're trying to accuse me of doing.
Because most of my liberal Catholic Friends are either lapsed, BCED Catholics or self-admitted Cafeteria Catholics.
 
But in supporting Romney, you are supporting someone who is not only taking the wages of sin and profiting from them but in return promising benefits to that donor - even if they are only benefits of "access". So by supporting Romney you are supporting a company that promotes what you consider sinful every bit as much as the insurnace company that you pay benefits into promoting THE SAME sins.


Because most of my liberal Catholic Friends are either lapsed, BCED Catholics or self-admitted Cafeteria Catholics.

degs this is where the brainwashing by leftist media becomes apparent. The Church doesn't teach us to ban access, nor to cast off anyone who uses or beileves in contraceptives. The Church teaches us not to use them or buy them for someone else. Of course the talking heads and Pelosi and that group have successfully sold you a lie that you now are trying to reconcile to something that hasn't even happened..If you had listened to the people in the center of this debacle of Obama's instead of listening to the spin, you wouldn't be confused now.

I almost had to laugh when I got to the line in your post about promising access. First, promising access to what, degs? Are contraceptives the only product this company makes? How do you know that Romney has promised them anything in return for their support? Maybe this man throwing the fundraiser just doesn't like Obama as our president.
And second, when we looked at Obama's positions before he was elected and we said that he would pull the crap he's pulling now, your side said we were crazy conspiracy theory racists.
But now you take a guy who had a fundraiser with a huge pharmaceutical company that manufactures many products, and you're deciding he'll do exactly what Obama did.

You're straining yourself trying to make this into something it isn't. All you've got is a lib blog talking point. I say let them continue to talk because the more they spread this nonsense, the harder it becomes for the hard left to gin up fear about a war on women from the right. When that stuff comes up, and it will as we get closer to November, all we have to do is use your own talking points to remind you of what you really believe.....That Mitt Romney is going to increase access to contraceptives.
 
degs this is where the brainwashing by leftist media becomes apparent. The Church doesn't teach us to ban access, nor to cast off anyone who uses or beileves in contraceptives.

Again with the false claims. You cannot demonstrate anything "leftist" in the media. Nor any tie between what I am asking you here and the media itself. I'm taking WHAT YOU SAID ABOUT ENABLING OF SIN in a previous conversation, and simply holding you to the logical consequence of that same position. I'm not operating off of any "lib blog talking point" but rather YOUR WORDS and basic logic

I almost had to laugh when I got to the line in your post about promising access. First, promising access to what, degs? Are contraceptives the only product this company makes? How do you know that Romney has promised them anything in return for their support?

People don't donate tens of thousands of dollars for nothing. And Contraceptive are one of the big profit makers for the company in that they focus on hormone driven therapies http://finance.yahoo.com/q/pr?s=TEVA+Profile

And second, when we looked at Obama's positions before he was elected and we said that he would pull the crap he's pulling now, your side said we were crazy conspiracy theory racists.
You still are conspiracy theory racists. Becaues there is no "crap" that he is "pulling now"..
 
Again with the false claims. You cannot demonstrate anything "leftist" in the media. Nor any tie between what I am asking you here and the media itself. I'm taking WHAT YOU SAID ABOUT ENABLING OF SIN in a previous conversation, and simply holding you to the logical consequence of that same position. I'm not operating off of any "lib blog talking point" but rather YOUR WORDS and basic logic



People don't donate tens of thousands of dollars for nothing. And Contraceptive are one of the big profit makers for the company in that they focus on hormone driven therapies http://finance.yahoo.com/q/pr?s=TEVA+Profile


You still are conspiracy theory racists. Becaues there is no "crap" that he is "pulling now"..


I'm not making any false claims. There's two threads by two different posters about this issue just on this board. Ya'll read it somewhere. I bet if I go looking for it, I'll find it in the blogosphere. I know Romney didn't call you all and tell you about this fundraiser himself. I also know that the lib blogs made a point of spreading the lie that the Catholic Church was trying to take access away. You fell for it.

And no, you didn't address what I said about enabling sin. You demonstrated in your top post that either you didn't understand what I said, or you chose to twist it up to serve the point you're trying so desperately to make. I corrected you(on what you claimed I said) and you refused to go on from there. You need me to have said something I didn't in order for your "logical conclusion" to work. You need the Church to teach something she doesn't for the same reason. And then you ask questions about Catholic faith point of view. I answer you. And you continue to ask the same questions. Maybe you just figure that if you keep asking, you'll get a different answer.Other Catholics have even answered you, yet you hold on with both hands to this idea you have. Meanwhile, you didn't answer my question at all.

And yeah, Obama is pulling crap. He's attempting to make the Catholic Church pay for contraceptives and sterilizations when they're forbidden from doing so. Nobody, not even Obama's most devoted fan is dumb enough to believe that the "accomodation" he provided does anything more than put a different signature on the check. The money still comes from the same place. When the bishops went back to him to explain that, he told them, "Why don't you just listen to the voices of enlightenment?" What a head this guy has. He's the voice of enlightenment now?


At least we had Obama's stated point of view on certain issues to go on when we suspected he'd do something like this. You have absolutely nothing to support your theory and yet you're devoted to it. Shiny side out, degs.
 
thhe church is an employer, and as such is no different from any employer. if they dont like the employment standards, get out of the business of emplying people! you are NOT special.
 
How about all the profit from those Bingo Games? And the pedophile Priests? No sin there, but Lord have mercy the people in the pews use birth control! What about all the wealth in the Vatican? Pompous little men in gold robes. There is nothing about Religion there. It is all self importance.

This is as hypocritical as some of the Ministers in my own Church. But,I call them on it! Do not pretend they are right.
 
How about all the profit from those Bingo Games? And the pedophile Priests? No sin there, but Lord have mercy the people in the pews use birth control! What about all the wealth in the Vatican? Pompous little men in gold robes. There is nothing about Religion there. It is all self importance.

This is as hypocritical as some of the Ministers in my own Church. But,I call them on it! Do not pretend they are right.

Bingo is a sin now? All the priests are pedophiles? Is what your church teaches all a lie because of the sins of some of the people in the pews or some of those ministers? Should your church STOP preaching what they believe is true for that reason?
Not that we were really discussing any of this, but you'll create your opportunities to put down the Catholic Church whenever you get the urge. I've read what your church has to say. You fit right in. But what I want to know is.....who calls YOU on your schtick?
 
Curious, gigi, would you frequent a business that provided contraception as part of its health care insurance to its employees?
 
Back
Top