New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for climate "skeptics."

Arkady

President
A key difference between faith and science is responsiveness to facts. If you can't think of any hypothetical real-world events that would cause you to change your beliefs on a question, there's a good chance your belief is a matter of faith, not science.

For example, I believe in Darwinian evolution, and don't believe in intelligent design, but that's a matter of science, not faith. I can easily come up with any number of real world events that would cause me to change both those beliefs -- discoveries that would cause me to reject Darwinism and/or to embrace intelligent design.

For example, picture if scientists discovered that when you look at DNA at the sub-atomic level, it turns out there's a system of quantum interactions guiding all mutations in a non-random way that can be deciphered and shown to be converging towards something, and that it was coded with certain non-functional information that when deciphered turns out to be a message describing how to use the coding system for further manipulation. That would convince me that DNA was designed by some intelligent agent for some purpose and that evolution was at least partly the outcome of that intelligent plan.

So, here's my question. Is there some real world set of events that would convince you that global warming is happening, that human activities are the primary cause, and that there will be disastrous results if we don't take major steps to reduce green house gas emissions? The vast majority of experts have been convinced by that enough to support 95% confidence findings. But, if you haven't been convinced, what could change that? Are there any discoveries or events that would move you into the other camp, or is your stance a matter of faith?
 
Kinda like your faith America is on the right track.
I think we're on the right track with sone stuff (the economic recovery, the fading of legal discrimination, and falling crime rates). On other things I think we're on the wrong track (erosion of due process and the right against unreasonable searches, worsening wealth inequality). In neither case is it a matter of faith. It's an analysis of real-world trends. And my mind could be changed on any of that by new facts.
 
If you define recovery as "having already gotten back to pre-recession employment-population ratio," there isn't a recovery. However, that's a definition that is inconsistent with how the term has always been used. Historically, we've referred to recoveries when the economy is expanding. The NBER says the economy has been growing since June 2009. We aren't yet fully recovered, but we've been recovering, and that's what people mean when they talk about the recovery.
 
A key difference between faith and science is responsiveness to facts. If you can't think of any hypothetical real-world events that would cause you to change your beliefs on a question, there's a good chance your belief is a matter of faith, not science.

For example, I believe in Darwinian evolution, and don't believe in intelligent design, but that's a matter of science, not faith. I can easily come up with any number of real world events that would cause me to change both those beliefs -- discoveries that would cause me to reject Darwinism and/or to embrace intelligent design.

For example, picture if scientists discovered that when you look at DNA at the sub-atomic level, it turns out there's a system of quantum interactions guiding all mutations in a non-random way that can be deciphered and shown to be converging towards something, and that it was coded with certain non-functional information that when deciphered turns out to be a message describing how to use the coding system for further manipulation. That would convince me that DNA was designed by some intelligent agent for some purpose and that evolution was at least partly the outcome of that intelligent plan.

So, here's my question. Is there some real world set of events that would convince you that global warming is happening, that human activities are the primary cause, and that there will be disastrous results if we don't take major steps to reduce green house gas emissions? The vast majority of experts have been convinced by that enough to support 95% confidence findings. But, if you haven't been convinced, what could change that? Are there any discoveries or events that would move you into the other camp, or is your stance a matter of faith?

two things would go a long way to restoring faith that the "experts" are right on this one (even though they were wrong on nuclear energy, the coming ice age, the origin of the universe, and what belongs at the top of the food pyramid)

first - i call on Dr Hansen to immediately release the "raw" global temperature data for objective analysis by the community. the fact that NASA has steadfastly refused, and only gives numbers that are adjusted by their secret formula is off the charts suspicous, no?

second - create a REAL climate change equation - not one that deals only with carbon. Use the relevant factors which have driven climate change in the past. Solar cycles. Oscillations in the earths orbit. Water vapor. Desertification/deforestation. Atmospheric particulates from volcanoes fires and other calamities. And maybe figure out whether urban "asphalt islands" should be in the mix too. Get back to us when you have an equation with more than one variable, that predicts we're all gonna die if we don't go back to the stone age.
 
Well, skepticism is one thing, and denial another. Over the last decade there has been a distinct flattening in temperatures according to the UN Council for Climate Change (which acknowledges it cannot explain the phenomena). Over the past 100 years there has been a slight increase in global temperatures.

No one rational denies that increase -- I remain somewhat skeptical that it is manmade. Vastly larger amounts of CO2 were released by burning soft coal throughout the 19th century, but there was no significant concomitant rise in global temperatures. The current models explain neither the Medieval Warm Period nor the Little Ice Age (and no, neither of these was a localized phenomenon -- ice cores taken in Antarctica reflect the impact of both climatalogical phenomena).

So a dose of skepticism is reasonable, given the alarmism being expressed on the topic by that portion of the left who are not scientists, and the extremity of the impact, economic and social, that would result from implementing some of the measures they've sought.

UNCC predicts, worst case, that global temperatures might increase by as much as 4 degrees C over the next century. That's based on the concept that we will do nothing to counter the trend, that no new technologies will arise, etc. The call to do this or that about atmospheric CO2, and that we must act right now, or else, seems highly overblown given that as a worst-case scenario.
 
two things would go a long way to restoring faith that the "experts" are right on this one (even though they were wrong on nuclear energy, the coming ice age, the origin of the universe, and what belongs at the top of the food pyramid)

first - i call on Dr Hansen to immediately release the "raw" global temperature data for objective analysis by the community. the fact that NASA has steadfastly refused, and only gives numbers that are adjusted by their secret formula is off the charts suspicous, no?

second - create a REAL climate change equation - not one that deals only with carbon. Use the relevant factors which have driven climate change in the past. Solar cycles. Oscillations in the earths orbit. Water vapor. Desertification/deforestation. Atmospheric particulates from volcanoes fires and other calamities. And maybe figure out whether urban "asphalt islands" should be in the mix too. Get back to us when you have an equation with more than one variable, that predicts we're all gonna die if we don't go back to the stone age.
I asked what would convince you the consensus was probably right. If I were to show Hansen released the data and that the models include the things you mentioned, would you be convinced?
 
Well, skepticism is one thing, and denial another. Over the last decade there has been a distinct flattening in temperatures according to the UN Council for Climate Change (which acknowledges it cannot explain the phenomena). Over the past 100 years there has been a slight increase in global temperatures.

No one rational denies that increase -- I remain somewhat skeptical that it is manmade. Vastly larger amounts of CO2 were released by burning soft coal throughout the 19th century, but there was no significant concomitant rise in global temperatures. The current models explain neither the Medieval Warm Period nor the Little Ice Age (and no, neither of these was a localized phenomenon -- ice cores taken in Antarctica reflect the impact of both climatalogical phenomena).

So a dose of skepticism is reasonable, given the alarmism being expressed on the topic by that portion of the left who are not scientists, and the extremity of the impact, economic and social, that would result from implementing some of the measures they've sought.

UNCC predicts, worst case, that global temperatures might increase by as much as 4 degrees C over the next century. That's based on the concept that we will do nothing to counter the trend, that no new technologies will arise, etc. The call to do this or that about atmospheric CO2, and that we must act right now, or else, seems highly overblown given that as a worst-case scenario.
I'm all for skepticism. I'm asking what it would take for you to think, with a reasonable degree of confidence (let's say 75% or higher) that those propositions are probably right.
 
I asked what would convince you the consensus was probably right. If I were to show Hansen released the data and that the models include the things you mentioned, would you be convinced?

100%. convinced, after community review. I have always agreed that carbon is "a factor". that's not in dispute. what i take issue with is that notion that having everyone drive a prius or put a windmill in his back yard is going to change the outcome in any way
 
I'm all for skepticism. I'm asking what it would take for you to think, with a reasonable degree of confidence (let's say 75% or higher) that those propositions are probably right.

Among other things, more transparency. When Mann was telling people to conceal things to avoid FOIA requests, it quit mattering whether the concealed information was accurate or not. It provided a basis for suspicion.

Also, it would take less sensationalism -- less linkage between current short-term weather and long-term climate trends. The sort of thing I'm talking about is Gore, et alia, predicting a series of bad hurricane seasons post-Katrina, when the next few years have been relatively mild hurricane seasons. The predicted violent weather that was supposed to have resulted from current (not future) global warming never materialized and is unlikely to materialize.

Two years ago, much of the North American continent experienced record low temperatures during the winter. I want to repeat the term "record" here -- a "record" is, by definition, statistically significant. If you bring this up to many who back the "global climate disaster" meme, they will tell you that the record low temperatures were driven by global warming -- this is a contradiction so obvious that it should shake the beliefs of all but the most lacking in skepticism.

Finally, quit telling us we have to give up our cars/boats/airplanes/power-that-isn't-solar to avoid a catastrophe in our own lifetimes. Even the worst case scenario isn't a catastrophe, and it is unlikely to occur in the lifetime of anyone who is an adult today. Try persuading and giving open and transparent evidence instead of labeling anyone who questions this or that fact as a "denier."
 
Last edited:
A key difference between faith and science is responsiveness to facts. If you can't think of any hypothetical real-world events that would cause you to change your beliefs on a question, there's a good chance your belief is a matter of faith, not science.

For example, I believe in Darwinian evolution, and don't believe in intelligent design, but that's a matter of science, not faith. I can easily come up with any number of real world events that would cause me to change both those beliefs -- discoveries that would cause me to reject Darwinism and/or to embrace intelligent design.

For example, picture if scientists discovered that when you look at DNA at the sub-atomic level, it turns out there's a system of quantum interactions guiding all mutations in a non-random way that can be deciphered and shown to be converging towards something, and that it was coded with certain non-functional information that when deciphered turns out to be a message describing how to use the coding system for further manipulation. That would convince me that DNA was designed by some intelligent agent for some purpose and that evolution was at least partly the outcome of that intelligent plan.

So, here's my question. Is there some real world set of events that would convince you that global warming is happening, that human activities are the primary cause, and that there will be disastrous results if we don't take major steps to reduce green house gas emissions? The vast majority of experts have been convinced by that enough to support 95% confidence findings. But, if you haven't been convinced, what could change that? Are there any discoveries or events that would move you into the other camp, or is your stance a matter of faith?
How about some actual warming? We haven't hit 90 yet this year. Usually we have at least a week
 
100%. convinced, after community review. I have always agreed that carbon is "a factor". that's not in dispute. what i take issue with is that notion that having everyone drive a prius or put a windmill in his back yard is going to change the outcome in any way
I don't think there is any scientific consensus about how to tackle this... That's more of a political question and an economic one than a question of geophysics. Carbon taxes, carbon sequestration, cap and trade, geoengineering, and a vast assortment of energy savings mandates and programs are on the table. But there is a very strong consensus about the warming, the majority role played by humans, and the idea that there will be severe negative repercussions for humans if we stay on the present course (though exactly how severe is a topic where the consensus hasn't narrowed down much).
 
For example, I believe in Darwinian evolution, and don't believe in intelligent design, but that's a matter of science, not faith.
If you had any faith, you wouldn't believe the way you do. That's a matter of fact.
 
How about some actual warming? We haven't hit 90 yet this year. Usually we have at least a week
If we hit 90, you'd be convinced?

I'm looking for some suggestion of what it would take to convince you. Here is just a quick summary of what's already out there that hasn't convinced you:

(1) Peer reviewed studies of surface temperature measures for decades, showing a clear long-term trend of warming.

(2) Studies of glaciers, tree rings, and other indirect measures of older climate trends, showing the current warming is happening at an unprecedented speed relative to anything we can see in the past.

(3). Experimental results confirming the theoretical ability of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere to trap infrared radiation, resulting in warming.

(4). Direct measures showing very rapid carbon dioxide increases in our atmosphere since the start of the industrial revolution.

(5) Massive measurable carbon dioxide contributions from things like combustion of fossil fuels.

(6) Every major national Academy for science joining the consensus position.

(7) Studies undermining every significant alternative explanation for rising temperatures, such as solar cycle changes.

(8). The intergovernmental panel on climate change doing a meta-analysis of all peer reviewed papers on the subject of climate change, resulting in a consensus expressed with 90% to 95% confidence.

That's enough for me. If it isn't enough for you, I'm wondering what we need to add to the list before it is.
 
If you had any faith, you wouldn't believe the way you do. That's a matter of fact.
I suppose that's intended to be some sort of attack, but I take it as a compliment for you to tell me I lack faith. Faith, in my opinion, is simply an error of the mind. It is belief without reason. I try not to believe without reason.
 
Back
Top