Arkady
President
A key difference between faith and science is responsiveness to facts. If you can't think of any hypothetical real-world events that would cause you to change your beliefs on a question, there's a good chance your belief is a matter of faith, not science.
For example, I believe in Darwinian evolution, and don't believe in intelligent design, but that's a matter of science, not faith. I can easily come up with any number of real world events that would cause me to change both those beliefs -- discoveries that would cause me to reject Darwinism and/or to embrace intelligent design.
For example, picture if scientists discovered that when you look at DNA at the sub-atomic level, it turns out there's a system of quantum interactions guiding all mutations in a non-random way that can be deciphered and shown to be converging towards something, and that it was coded with certain non-functional information that when deciphered turns out to be a message describing how to use the coding system for further manipulation. That would convince me that DNA was designed by some intelligent agent for some purpose and that evolution was at least partly the outcome of that intelligent plan.
So, here's my question. Is there some real world set of events that would convince you that global warming is happening, that human activities are the primary cause, and that there will be disastrous results if we don't take major steps to reduce green house gas emissions? The vast majority of experts have been convinced by that enough to support 95% confidence findings. But, if you haven't been convinced, what could change that? Are there any discoveries or events that would move you into the other camp, or is your stance a matter of faith?
For example, I believe in Darwinian evolution, and don't believe in intelligent design, but that's a matter of science, not faith. I can easily come up with any number of real world events that would cause me to change both those beliefs -- discoveries that would cause me to reject Darwinism and/or to embrace intelligent design.
For example, picture if scientists discovered that when you look at DNA at the sub-atomic level, it turns out there's a system of quantum interactions guiding all mutations in a non-random way that can be deciphered and shown to be converging towards something, and that it was coded with certain non-functional information that when deciphered turns out to be a message describing how to use the coding system for further manipulation. That would convince me that DNA was designed by some intelligent agent for some purpose and that evolution was at least partly the outcome of that intelligent plan.
So, here's my question. Is there some real world set of events that would convince you that global warming is happening, that human activities are the primary cause, and that there will be disastrous results if we don't take major steps to reduce green house gas emissions? The vast majority of experts have been convinced by that enough to support 95% confidence findings. But, if you haven't been convinced, what could change that? Are there any discoveries or events that would move you into the other camp, or is your stance a matter of faith?
