Arkady
President
Some of you are not convinced as to the view of climate change that has been embraced by the majority of experts (that human activities are predominantly responsible for the current global warming trend, and that if we don't curb greenhouse gas emissions significantly, there will be climate changes that will cause mankind severe problems). What would it take to convince you?
Presumably you can at least agree that if the majority of experts were right, it would be a very big deal, and we'd be wise to do something about it. So, presumably you can also agree that we should be making an effort to figure out if what the majority of experts say is happening is actually happening. So, what form should that effort take? How should we be looking into the question, and when will we know we have enough confidence in the findings to justify actions such as laws designed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions?
Governments addressed those very questions back in the 1980s. At the time, there were a lot of signs as to what was going on with global warming and how serious it might be, but governments had to figure out a way to pull that science together so they'd know whether various policy proposals made sense. Their solution was to set up the IPCC -- an international panel staffed by top climate scientists from all over the world. They would form various working teams of subject-matter experts, to examine all the component issues about the climate change question. The working groups would review all the published scientific research in each of those subject areas. Then their job would be to bring it together into a single clear picture that the public and policy-makers could use in deciding how to proceed. The idea was to make it a conservative panel, by requiring universal consent by all member countries before something could make it into an IPCC report, so that unsupported alarmist beliefs of a minority wouldn't make the cut.
That was a quarter century ago, and much has passed since then. The IPCC has released five major reports, each updating and fine-tuning the information based on the latest research. At each stage, a larger share of scientists became convinced of the majority position, and at each stage the IPCC upped the probability they ascribed to the findings, in light of ever-greater evidence. When we speak of a consenus view on climate change, it's the IPCC summary we're talking about, and nearly every major scientific body in the world has either echoed that view, or has expressly deferred to the IPCC on it. For example, the governing bodies of the national academy of science for each of the 34 leading nations of the world have all endorsed the consensus position, and the academies of the 13 top nations (including the US) issued a joint statement saying:
"It is unequivocal that the climate is changing, and it is very likely that this is predominantly caused by the increasing human interference with the atmosphere. These changes will transform the environmental conditions on Earth unless counter-measures are taken."
To me, the idea of a panel like the IPCC (to pull together the research and provide clear guidance to lay people and politicians) seemed like a perfectly sensible approach to the problem of deciding whether various policies made sense in light of the supposed threat. I can't come up with a better way to approach the problem. And given the fact that there's been such overwhelming concurrence among all the major science foundations, national academies, and relevant professional bodies, it seems that those who understand the issue better than me have generally been convinced, too. But for those of you who haven't been convinced, what would do it?
How would you propose that the science be brought together in order to inform policy-making, if the IPCC approach didn't do it for you? Politicians and lay people are never going to read the hundreds of thousands of pages of primary research being published every year, and even if they did, they couldn't follow it. So, you need some sort of mechanism for creating a synthesis of that work that policymakers and lay people can understand. If the IPCC wasn't a good mechanism for that, what do you propose? And what would it take for you to be convinced that serious efforts to limit greenhouse gas emissions were called for?
Presumably you can at least agree that if the majority of experts were right, it would be a very big deal, and we'd be wise to do something about it. So, presumably you can also agree that we should be making an effort to figure out if what the majority of experts say is happening is actually happening. So, what form should that effort take? How should we be looking into the question, and when will we know we have enough confidence in the findings to justify actions such as laws designed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions?
Governments addressed those very questions back in the 1980s. At the time, there were a lot of signs as to what was going on with global warming and how serious it might be, but governments had to figure out a way to pull that science together so they'd know whether various policy proposals made sense. Their solution was to set up the IPCC -- an international panel staffed by top climate scientists from all over the world. They would form various working teams of subject-matter experts, to examine all the component issues about the climate change question. The working groups would review all the published scientific research in each of those subject areas. Then their job would be to bring it together into a single clear picture that the public and policy-makers could use in deciding how to proceed. The idea was to make it a conservative panel, by requiring universal consent by all member countries before something could make it into an IPCC report, so that unsupported alarmist beliefs of a minority wouldn't make the cut.
That was a quarter century ago, and much has passed since then. The IPCC has released five major reports, each updating and fine-tuning the information based on the latest research. At each stage, a larger share of scientists became convinced of the majority position, and at each stage the IPCC upped the probability they ascribed to the findings, in light of ever-greater evidence. When we speak of a consenus view on climate change, it's the IPCC summary we're talking about, and nearly every major scientific body in the world has either echoed that view, or has expressly deferred to the IPCC on it. For example, the governing bodies of the national academy of science for each of the 34 leading nations of the world have all endorsed the consensus position, and the academies of the 13 top nations (including the US) issued a joint statement saying:
"It is unequivocal that the climate is changing, and it is very likely that this is predominantly caused by the increasing human interference with the atmosphere. These changes will transform the environmental conditions on Earth unless counter-measures are taken."
To me, the idea of a panel like the IPCC (to pull together the research and provide clear guidance to lay people and politicians) seemed like a perfectly sensible approach to the problem of deciding whether various policies made sense in light of the supposed threat. I can't come up with a better way to approach the problem. And given the fact that there's been such overwhelming concurrence among all the major science foundations, national academies, and relevant professional bodies, it seems that those who understand the issue better than me have generally been convinced, too. But for those of you who haven't been convinced, what would do it?
How would you propose that the science be brought together in order to inform policy-making, if the IPCC approach didn't do it for you? Politicians and lay people are never going to read the hundreds of thousands of pages of primary research being published every year, and even if they did, they couldn't follow it. So, you need some sort of mechanism for creating a synthesis of that work that policymakers and lay people can understand. If the IPCC wasn't a good mechanism for that, what do you propose? And what would it take for you to be convinced that serious efforts to limit greenhouse gas emissions were called for?