New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Conservatives/Republicans

Arkady

President
With regard to the Trump/Russia story, where is the line for you, in terms of the kind of action by Trump or members of his team that would be sufficient for you to call for impeachment or criminal prosecution?

As this story has played out, each new revelation has made the picture a little uglier. At first all we had were unofficial reports suggesting Russian interference in the election. Then the US intelligence agencies came out and confirmed that interference. One by one, several members of Trump's inner circle have been implicated in contacts with Russian agents during the crucial period, either of an illegal nature, or at least of a questionable enough nature that they felt the need to lie about those contacts, sometimes in official inquiries/documents (Page, Manafort, Flynn, Session, Jr.) There's also the slam-dunk case of obstruction of justice against the president, related to the Comey pressure and firing. The latest news, if true, would indicate knowing collusion between Trump's own son and the Russians -- that Trump met with a Russian agent in the hopes of getting compromising information about Hillary Clinton that he knew to be part of a Russian government effort to help the Trump campaign.

Clearly none of this has been enough to get Trump backers to turn on him -- and even among Trump-skeptical conservatives, there remains little outrage. So, I'm curious what it will take. At what point would the cooperation with Russia be clear enough or egregious enough to cross a line with you? Is it going to take a smoking-gun of quid-pro-quo (i.e., a clear promise that the Trump administration would do certain favors for the Putin regime in exchange for assistance in the election)? Would even that do it?
 
I would nee to see the evidence. Take for example this email being reported by the NYT today. They're saying that their sources are '3 people with knowledge of the email'. Not the email itself, as the reporter nor anyone else at the Times has seen said email.

It's going to take a lot more than that. I would require actual EVIDENCE.

Oh, and one more thing, Trump Sr. never met with a Russian agent. The facts, as they sit now, tells us that someone on his team met with her and nothing came of it.

I wouldn't start planning an impeachment party just yet.

What I would like to see is a complete and thorough investigation that comes to a head in a timely manner. Say, before Christmas.
 
With regard to the Trump/Russia story, where is the line for you, in terms of the kind of action by Trump or members of his team that would be sufficient for you to call for impeachment or criminal prosecution?

As this story has played out, each new revelation has made the picture a little uglier. At first all we had were unofficial reports suggesting Russian interference in the election. Then the US intelligence agencies came out and confirmed that interference. One by one, several members of Trump's inner circle have been implicated in contacts with Russian agents during the crucial period, either of an illegal nature, or at least of a questionable enough nature that they felt the need to lie about those contacts, sometimes in official inquiries/documents (Page, Manafort, Flynn, Session, Jr.) There's also the slam-dunk case of obstruction of justice against the president, related to the Comey pressure and firing. The latest news, if true, would indicate knowing collusion between Trump's own son and the Russians -- that Trump met with a Russian agent in the hopes of getting compromising information about Hillary Clinton that he knew to be part of a Russian government effort to help the Trump campaign.

Clearly none of this has been enough to get Trump backers to turn on him -- and even among Trump-skeptical conservatives, there remains little outrage. So, I'm curious what it will take. At what point would the cooperation with Russia be clear enough or egregious enough to cross a line with you? Is it going to take a smoking-gun of quid-pro-quo (i.e., a clear promise that the Trump administration would do certain favors for the Putin regime in exchange for assistance in the election)? Would even that do it?

I have always thought that, even when provided with clear evidence of collusion between Team Trump and the Kremlin, Trump's toadies would just blow it off.

We see that happening. With rare exceptions, Trump toadies' basic reaction is "OK, so the Trump team and the Kremlin colluded to beat Hillary? So what?"

The facts just don't matter to them. Nothing matters to them except preserving the positions of power of their cult leaders. It's sad, but true.
 
I would nee to see the evidence. Take for example this email being reported by the NYT today. They're saying that their sources are '3 people with knowledge of the email'. Not the email itself, as the reporter nor anyone else at the Times has seen said email.

It's going to take a lot more than that. I would require actual EVIDENCE.

Oh, and one more thing, Trump Sr. never met with a Russian agent. The facts, as they sit now, tells us that someone on his team met with her and nothing came of it.

I wouldn't start planning an impeachment party just yet.

What I would like to see is a complete and thorough investigation that comes to a head in a timely manner. Say, before Christmas.


In the history of the United States, two Presidents have been impeached - Andrew Johnson and Bill Clinton. Neither was removed from office as a result. No U.S. President has ever been forcibly removed from office, although one (Nixon) did resign under pressure. Obviously, the odds of Trump being forcibly removed are long, despite fervent claims to the contrary.

How many U.S. Presidents have been accused of treason? My guess would be all of them, at
one time or another, by someone who didn't care for their brand of politics. So, is this time going to be different? Possibly, of course, but not terribly likely. I'm not going to lose any sleep over it one way or the other.
 
I have always thought that, even when provided with clear evidence of collusion between Team Trump and the Kremlin, Trump's toadies would just blow it off.

We see that happening. With rare exceptions, Trump toadies' basic reaction is "OK, so the Trump team and the Kremlin colluded to beat Hillary? So what?"

The facts just don't matter to them. Nothing matters to them except preserving the positions of power of their cult leaders. It's sad, but true.

That's where you're wrong. The facts do matter. It'as just that there is such a dearth of them in this case.

Presents some facts and I'll be more than happy to consider them.
 
The line(s) for me have to include that the Trump team was directed, by Trump, to work with the Russians; and proof, ANY proof, that as much as one vote was affected.

If any one thing cost Hillary Clinton the election, it was Comey's letter regarding the emails. No one is investigating if Trump colluded with Comey on that.
 
Useful Idiocy becomes you.

So anytime any political campaign meets with anyone who may or may not have some kind of opposition research on your opponent is guilty of colluding according to you?

Is that actually your contention?

Unless the Trump Campaign helped the Russians hack the DNC etc. there is no crime here. Even if (ZERO EVIDENCE OF THIS) it was proved that the Trump campaign coordinated with the Russians, it still is not a crime.

Again, unless the Trump campaign helped in obtaining the information illegally you are out of luck.

You did not lose the election because of the Russians, you lost the election because despite what the MSM is constantly telling the country, President Obama was [Unwelcome language removed] terrible. You ran a terrible candidate who promised four more years of just shit......

the country said no. Get over it.
 
With regard to the Trump/Russia story, where is the line for you, in terms of the kind of action by Trump or members of his team that would be sufficient for you to call for impeachment or criminal prosecution?

As this story has played out, each new revelation has made the picture a little uglier. At first all we had were unofficial reports suggesting Russian interference in the election. Then the US intelligence agencies came out and confirmed that interference. One by one, several members of Trump's inner circle have been implicated in contacts with Russian agents during the crucial period, either of an illegal nature, or at least of a questionable enough nature that they felt the need to lie about those contacts, sometimes in official inquiries/documents (Page, Manafort, Flynn, Session, Jr.) There's also the slam-dunk case of obstruction of justice against the president, related to the Comey pressure and firing. The latest news, if true, would indicate knowing collusion between Trump's own son and the Russians -- that Trump met with a Russian agent in the hopes of getting compromising information about Hillary Clinton that he knew to be part of a Russian government effort to help the Trump campaign.

Clearly none of this has been enough to get Trump backers to turn on him -- and even among Trump-skeptical conservatives, there remains little outrage. So, I'm curious what it will take. At what point would the cooperation with Russia be clear enough or egregious enough to cross a line with you? Is it going to take a smoking-gun of quid-pro-quo (i.e., a clear promise that the Trump administration would do certain favors for the Putin regime in exchange for assistance in the election)? Would even that do it?
Trump could murder Mike Pence on stage, and Republicans wouldn't care. They are believing the ends justifies the means. They just want to feel like winners. So did Barry Bonds.
 
In the history of the United States, two Presidents have been impeached - Andrew Johnson and Bill Clinton. Neither was removed from office as a result. No U.S. President has ever been forcibly removed from office, although one (Nixon) did resign under pressure. Obviously, the odds of Trump being forcibly removed are long, despite fervent claims to the contrary.

How many U.S. Presidents have been accused of treason? My guess would be all of them, at
one time or another, by someone who didn't care for their brand of politics. So, is this time going to be different? Possibly, of course, but not terribly likely. I'm not going to lose any sleep over it one way or the other.
What would it take for you?
 
The line(s) for me have to include that the Trump team was directed, by Trump, to work with the Russians; and proof, ANY proof, that as much as one vote was affected.

As to the first half of that, if Congress eventually gets access to Trump's campaign emails and there's one where he tells his son to go forward with the meeting with the agent who offered to share Russian-government-sourced Clinton smears, would that be sufficient?

As to the second half -- the proof of a vote being affected, that sounds like an attempt to set yourself up for always being able to hold your current ground, since that kind of proof could always be denied. For example, I'm sure we could find voters who would admit that they were turned against Clinton as a result of some Russia-sourced information (e.g., a Sanders supporter who swapped to voting third-party once he heard about the hacked info suggesting DNC thumbs on the scale for Clinton during the primary). But would that do it? Or would you then just argue that although the person cited that information as switching his vote, we can't be sure it did? Or, alternately, would you argue that the information would have come out even if the Trump team hadn't been cooperating with Russia (thereby giving Russia extra incentive to interfere)?

If any one thing cost Hillary Clinton the election, it was Comey's letter regarding the emails. No one is investigating if Trump colluded with Comey on that.

That's a fair point. The Comey letter was a clear game-changer according to the polling history, given the rapid Clinton decline directly after that letter, which never fully bounced back. But, unlike with Russia, there's no sign of any collusion there . If members of Team Trump had been lying under oath about pre-election meetings with Comey, or the NYT were reporting on a supposed email between a Comey associate and a Trump family member asking for a meeting to discuss such a letter, or something like that, we'd be in the same situation as with the Russia story, where suspicions of collusion were reasonable. At this point, though, they're just idle speculation.
 
Useful Idiocy becomes you.

No clue who you were replying to. However, if it was me, I'd note you didn't answer the question. With regard to the Trump/Russia story, where is the line for you, in terms of the kind of action by Trump or members of his team that would be sufficient for you to call for impeachment or criminal prosecution?
 
No clue who you were replying to. However, if it was me, I'd note you didn't answer the question. With regard to the Trump/Russia story, where is the line for you, in terms of the kind of action by Trump or members of his team that would be sufficient for you to call for impeachment or criminal prosecution?

You would appear to be clueless about a lot of things. For instance the fact I did answer the question. Where is the crime?

Again, unless the Trump campaign helped in obtaining the information illegally you are out of luck.

You have to have a crime to be impeached. Prove criminality in any of this, that is always the line.

Truth is, the left has bupkus on this Russian Collusion theory.....
 
As to the first half of that, if Congress eventually gets access to Trump's campaign emails and there's one where he tells his son to go forward with the meeting with the agent who offered to share Russian-government-sourced Clinton smears, would that be sufficient?

Only if there is also proof that the meeting occurred and that the Trump campaign received information it otherwise would not have had.

As to the second half -- the proof of a vote being affected, that sounds like an attempt to set yourself up for always being able to hold your current ground, since that kind of proof could always be denied. For example, I'm sure we could find voters who would admit that they were turned against Clinton as a result of some Russia-sourced information (e.g., a Sanders supporter who swapped to voting third-party once he heard about the hacked info suggesting DNC thumbs on the scale for Clinton during the primary). But would that do it? Or would you then just argue that although the person cited that information as switching his vote, we can't be sure it did? Or, alternately, would you argue that the information would have come out even if the Trump team hadn't been cooperating with Russia (thereby giving Russia extra incentive to interfere)?

I honestly don't know how to answer. the bottom line is I don't think that there is any state that "went Trump" based on fake news provided by the Russians. I doubt there are any based on REAL news provided by the Russians, but if their are, such as the Russians hacking the Clinton emails -- isn't that the role of a free press, to bring the truth to light? If Clinton lost because the truth about her emails was exposed, it doesn't much matter who exposed the truth. That isn't hacking democracy, it's hacking a server. If Trump sought information, from anyone, that his opponent was doing something wrong -- isn't that what he was supposed to do?


That's a fair point. The Comey letter was a clear game-changer according to the polling history, given the rapid Clinton decline directly after that letter, which never fully bounced back. But, unlike with Russia, there's no sign of any collusion there . If members of Team Trump had been lying under oath about pre-election meetings with Comey, or the NYT were reporting on a supposed email between a Comey associate and a Trump family member asking for a meeting to discuss such a letter, or something like that, we'd be in the same situation as with the Russia story, where suspicions of collusion were reasonable. At this point, though, they're just idle speculation.

In other words, even if the Trumps colluded wiht Russia, it didn't affect the outcome of the election. Comey's actions apparently did. But even that isn't as important as what Hillary herseld failed to do. She failed to visit states in teh so-called "blue Wall." She utterly ignored the concerns of long-term Democratic voters, meany of whom voted for Obama, and then went on to vote for Trump. Hillary started teh campaign with advantages so extreme taht it seemed impossible to me that she could lose -- but lose she did, based not on Russia, or Trump, but on her own fecklessness and poor campaigning.
 
With regard to the Trump/Russia story, where is the line for you, in terms of the kind of action by Trump or members of his team that would be sufficient for you to call for impeachment or criminal prosecution?

As this story has played out, each new revelation has made the picture a little uglier. At first all we had were unofficial reports suggesting Russian interference in the election. Then the US intelligence agencies came out and confirmed that interference. One by one, several members of Trump's inner circle have been implicated in contacts with Russian agents during the crucial period, either of an illegal nature, or at least of a questionable enough nature that they felt the need to lie about those contacts, sometimes in official inquiries/documents (Page, Manafort, Flynn, Session, Jr.) There's also the slam-dunk case of obstruction of justice against the president, related to the Comey pressure and firing. The latest news, if true, would indicate knowing collusion between Trump's own son and the Russians -- that Trump met with a Russian agent in the hopes of getting compromising information about Hillary Clinton that he knew to be part of a Russian government effort to help the Trump campaign.

Clearly none of this has been enough to get Trump backers to turn on him -- and even among Trump-skeptical conservatives, there remains little outrage. So, I'm curious what it will take. At what point would the cooperation with Russia be clear enough or egregious enough to cross a line with you? Is it going to take a smoking-gun of quid-pro-quo (i.e., a clear promise that the Trump administration would do certain favors for the Putin regime in exchange for assistance in the election)? Would even that do it?

Do you have actual proof, or just more assertions from the people who keep claiming Trump is Hitler and posing for pictures, ISIS-like, with his bloody, severed head? You have a serious credibility problem, and passing more schoolgirl gossip, which is apparently all you have at this point, isn't helping it. This is why nearly everyone here is laughing at you.
 
I have always thought that, even when provided with clear evidence of collusion between Team Trump and the Kremlin, Trump's toadies would just blow it off.

We see that happening. With rare exceptions, Trump toadies' basic reaction is "OK, so the Trump team and the Kremlin colluded to beat Hillary? So what?"

The facts just don't matter to them. Nothing matters to them except preserving the positions of power of their cult leaders. It's sad, but true.

You need to learn the difference between evidence and proof. It's and especially important distinction when the "evidence" in question is coming from anonymous sources and being reported by outlets that spend much of their time crying on the air, referring to the president as Hitler, and posing for pictures, ISIS-like, with his bloody, severed head.
 
With regard to the Trump/Russia story, where is the line for you, in terms of the kind of action by Trump or members of his team that would be sufficient for you to call for impeachment or criminal prosecution?

What would be sufficient?

That answers the question right there because up to now there has been nothing sufficient and any accusation of Trump which so far is just fake could be said the same about Obama and his "after the election I will have more flexibility" Russian quote and Hillary's Uranium One and "Peregruzka" eff up and Podesta.

There is nothing sufficient about holding one person accountable and not others.

1950's Mississippi Democratic Judge re-enactment.

You killed that white girl and we know it. You are black aint ya...so we gonna string your but up.

Same Democratic Judge:

So you killed a negro, well even white people makes mistakes, just pay 10 dollar court cost and promise no killing negroes for sixty days.

It's no different today as it was in 1950. You are still letting" your people" off the hook. And holding others accountable with no real evidence.
 
Back
Top