New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Romney Supporters

Judy1

Mayor
I've asked this of another poster, but I think it would be good to have an answer from all Romney Supporters.

Please explain how putting back in place the same economic and neocon warmongering policies that got us into this mess in the first place are going to suddenly turn things around. I accept the fact that our economy is still in a slow growth pattern, I don't think anyone argues that. But here is the question that I would want from the Romney camp. What do you really think would have happend to our economy if the whole banking system had been allowed to collapse? What do you suppose would have happened if Detroit had been allowed to fail? What would our deficit look like now if we hadn't left Iraq? Do you honestly believe that if we had allowed those things to happen that we'd really have a better economy four years later? Please explain how.

We live in an impatient society, we all want things instantly, but isn't it time to accept the fact that reality does not always mesh with our immediate wishes?
 
Are you expecting any coherent and cogent answers, Judy?

Because that would be about as likely as seeing Elvis and Sasquatch on the same day....in a UFO.
 
Well, I would hope that someone would at give it a try. I think its a reasonable question, unfortunately, no one really addressed these questions during any of the debates,which is a shame.
 
Romney is not a Bush clone.
He will not put us back where we were. For Romney (if you have been listening to him at all) war is the last possible resort and not to be taken until everything else is exhausted.

A Romney boat takes us forward.....not backward.
 
Jen, please explain how Romney's economic policies are not the same as Bush's? please be specific. Romneys foriegn policy advisors are the same neocons from the Bush administration. Please explain how Romney's policies would be different. Romney flip flopped on Afganistan troop withdrawal and how Iran should be dealt with, how can you trust someone who doesn't know where he stands on things?
 
Jen,

Do you think that there was any relationship between the tax-cutting and anti-regulatory policies followed by GWB and the financial catastrophe that the country ran into in 2008-2009? Bushes policies increased the deficit, led to tepid economic growth, and had terrible long term consequences. Why should I expect anything different from Romney's policies? Why should I believe that his policies would lead to economic growth and falling deficits? I am VERY, VERY skeptical.

I don't think that Obama policies are a quick fix either. It will be a long slog to full recovery. But I do think that Obama's policies are much more balanced and much less radical than the Romney/Ryan policies. One thing that I dislike about Romney is that he is making promises that I don't think that he will be able to deliver on. We are not going to have a "fast" recovery if Romney is elected and there is a good chance that we will have another economic downturn (whoever is elected.) The deficit will still be horrendous. And Romney is not going to get bi-partisan support for radical Republican policies. If that is all he will offer (and I suspect it is), he won't get Democratic support on principle.

That said, I know that nothing you or I say is going to change the other person's mind. I do think that Romney's plans are more likely to take the country backward than move them forward. Obviously, you feel differently.

Romney is not a Bush clone.
He will not put us back where we were. For Romney (if you have been listening to him at all) war is the last possible resort and not to be taken until everything else is exhausted.

A Romney boat takes us forward.....not backward.
 
Romney is not a Bush clone.
He will not put us back where we were. For Romney (if you have been listening to him at all) war is the last possible resort and not to be taken until everything else is exhausted.
That's what Bush said as well.

Tell us again what policies Romney differs from GWB on? Precisely please.
 
Republican fiscal policy is lower taxes and have government step out of the way to allow business (and job hiring) to flourish. Bush and Reagan both did that and tax revenue increased. If you "tax the rich" jobs go away, so all the money you gain by taxing the rich is offset by the lost revenue from the lost jobs and that equals no gained tax revenue.

Romney and Bush are not the same on foreign policy. My thought is that Bush had Cheney who was a hawk and cheney (along with Rumsfeld, also a hawk) drove foreign actions and policy. Romney has done his homework regarding foreign policy and he is strong enough (unlike Bush) not to be led around by any hawks he may have in his administration.

Romney is a proven leader, he has created jobs in real life, he showed in the last debate that he knows foreign policy. He knew enough to agree with some of obama's actions and policies when they were correct, and stand apart from them when they were wrong.

Obama came to this job too soon. I think he's a good man, but he has been in over his head. He just wasn't ready and still isn't ready judging by how he handled Libya. Romney IS ready and will be a better President than Obama was and certainly better than Bush was.
 
No. I do not think there was any relationship between the tax-cutting and anti-regulatory policies that we followed under Bush. If you will notice the time line, the financial fall came the last two years of his administration - when the Democrats took over Congress. Pelosi was determined to bring the Republicans down and she succeeded.

Jen,

Do you think that there was any relationship between the tax-cutting and anti-regulatory policies followed by GWB and the financial catastrophe that the country ran into in 2008-2009? Bushes policies increased the deficit, led to tepid economic growth, and had terrible long term consequences. Why should I expect anything different from Romney's policies? Why should I believe that his policies would lead to economic growth and falling deficits? I am VERY, VERY skeptical.

I don't think that Obama policies are a quick fix either. It will be a long slog to full recovery. But I do think that Obama's policies are much more balanced and much less radical than the Romney/Ryan policies. One thing that I dislike about Romney is that he is making promises that I don't think that he will be able to deliver on. We are not going to have a "fast" recovery if Romney is elected and there is a good chance that we will have another economic downturn (whoever is elected.) The deficit will still be horrendous. And Romney is not going to get bi-partisan support for radical Republican policies. If that is all he will offer (and I suspect it is), he won't get Democratic support on principle.

That said, I know that nothing you or I say is going to change the other person's mind. I do think that Romney's plans are more likely to take the country backward than move them forward. Obviously, you feel differently.
 
No. I do not think there was any relationship between the tax-cutting and anti-regulatory policies that we followed under Bush. If you will notice the time line, the financial fall came the last two years of his administration - when the Democrats took over Congress. Pelosi was determined to bring the Republicans down and she succeeded.

pelosi caused the teaser interest rates to come up for renewal?? lol
 
so, in other words, same economic policies as Bush. Got it. Thanks.

and how can you say that Romney is strong enough to fight off neocons when they are currently advising him:

http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politics/2012/09/whos-advising-mitt-romney-on-foreign-policy/

With eight advisors from PNAC, how can you possibly believe that he is going to all of a sudden reject their advice, when they've been advising him from the beginning?
Romney couldn't stand up to the Tea Party, what makes you think he's going to stand up to PNAC? Seriously? open your eyes Jen.
 
Please explain how putting back in place the same economic and neocon warmongering policies that got us into this mess in the first place are going to suddenly turn things around.

What policies? The current tax rates? How did the current tax rates cause the financial collapse? Answer, the didn't. The sub prime market caused the financial collapse.

And if you are talking about the current tax rates and the wars; we had the same two wars going on in 2006 and we had the same tax rates. The deficit in 2006 was less that 200 billion.

Today we have one less war, the same tax rates, and the deficit is 6 times larger, 1.2 trillion. Why, two reasons. massive spending increases ( a trillion on non ss and medicare welfare alone) and anti business policies and statements that have increased unemployment when it should have come down by now, and by a reduction in revenues from a shrinking of the workforce, again caused by anti business policy and an anti economical fossil fuel agenda. and threats to tax everyone that produces anything and suing any company that tries to locate in friendly right to work states to create jobs.
Pretty simple really and real easy to fix.

Just get rid of Obama.
 
Your answer is another reason why I would never vote for Romney and would be disinclined to take any radical Republican economic strategy seriously. If anything goes wrong, Republicans will find a way to pin the problem on Democrats and leave Republicans blameless. So it goes.

No. I do not think there was any relationship between the tax-cutting and anti-regulatory policies that we followed under Bush. If you will notice the time line, the financial fall came the last two years of his administration - when the Democrats took over Congress. Pelosi was determined to bring the Republicans down and she succeeded.
 
Bush was wrong to take us into Iraq. Cheney and Rumsfeld led him into taking a wrong direction. The Bush economics could have given Obama another Clinton-like era (as Reagan gave Clinton that) but Nancy Pelosi and a Democratic House in the last 2 years of the Bush Presidency felt it was important to take the Republican down and they hit it hard. Then Obama decided that rather than make the economy better in the first two years he would push through health care reform. That was needed, but the economy should have taken precedence (as it did for Bush when economy was starting to slump at the end of Clinton's second term). Pelosi taking down the Republicans and obama having an agenda that didn't support bringing the economy back is what put us into this mess.

There is nothing wrong with Republican fiscal policy.


so, in other words, same economic policies as Bush. Got it. Thanks.

and how can you say that Romney is strong enough to fight off neocons when they are currently advising him:

http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politics/2012/09/whos-advising-mitt-romney-on-foreign-policy/

With eight advisors from PNAC, how can you possibly believe that he is going to all of a sudden reject their advice, when they've been advising him from the beginning?
Romney couldn't stand up to the Tea Party, what makes you think he's going to stand up to PNAC? Seriously? open your eyes Jen.
 
Bush was wrong to take us into Iraq. Cheney and Rumsfeld led him into taking a wrong direction. The Bush economics could have given Obama another Clinton-like era (as Reagan gave Clinton that) but Nancy Pelosi and a Democratic House in the last 2 years of the Bush Presidency felt it was important to take the Republican down and they hit it hard. Then Obama decided that rather than make the economy better in the first two years he would push through health care reform. That was needed, but the economy should have taken precedence (as it did for Bush when economy was starting to slump at the end of Clinton's second term). Pelosi taking down the Republicans and obama having an agenda that didn't support bringing the economy back is what put us into this mess.

There is nothing wrong with Republican fiscal policy.

Putting raging lunacy total ignorance and shameless FOXPRavdian cluelessness aside, which policies of Democratic congress in 2007-2008 caused the economy to get into recession in 2007 ?
Let's assume that all economic events take place immediately and do not take sometimes years of reckless development.
So, question for kindergarten kid with slow developmental problems.
Name those actions of Dem congress in 2007 which veto-less powerless executive approved of and that caused the recession.
 
Back
Top