New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question regarding climate.

Arkady

President
I believe the climate change consensus (a consensus saying global temps are rising largely due to human greenhouse gas emissions, and that this will wind up being a serious problem). One of things that won me over is the track record of the experts. Their consensus started out tentatively in the early 1970s, with only slightly more experts expecting warming than were expecting cooling, and the majority not making any predictions. But by the late 1980s, there was a pretty clear consensus on the topic, and they were making bold predictions. Not only did they predict there would be more warming in the coming years, but they predicted it would be occurring at far above historical averages. In fact, they were predicting a rate of warming many times the rate seen for tens of thousands of years, at least. Going way out on the limb, like that, was daring, because that limb could have collapsed underneath them. But it didn't. Over the next three decades, global average temperatures did what they predicted: they rose much faster than we have any evidence of them rising for tens of thousands of years, at least.

What made that prediction so bold was that there wasn't some other reason we'd expect any warming, much less warming at that rate. Other things being equal, we'd have expected regression to the mean. To make such a counter-intuitive prediction, and then have events play out as predicted, gives them credibility.

As of the end of the 1980s, here's what 110 years of recent temperature data looked like:

upload_2018-4-23_12-3-22.png

Although that looked, even then, like a warming trend, it wasn't a very impressive one. In fact, the best- fit trend line shows just 0.44 degrees Celsius of warming per century. Yet, the large majority of climate scientists predicted far more rapid warming than that in the future. And here's what the subsequent era looks like, through 2017:

upload_2018-4-23_12-2-30.png

As you can see, the rate of warming has been over four times as fast as in the prior era (which, itself, was unusually fast relative to any known average pace in the pre-instrument-record past).

The test of a scientific theory is in its explanatory and predictive power, and the theory supported by the majority of climate experts passed that test with flying colors. Not only does the theory explain why there was warming throughout the modern era, but it correctly predicted that the warming would greatly accelerate.

As far as I know, the "denialist" community never made any accurate predictions. They didn't foresee the warming continuing, much less vastly accelerating. So, their competing theory failed the test of having predictive power. But it also seems to fail when it comes to explanatory power. I have yet to hear any sensible competing explanation for the rapid warming and accelerating warming. There's no change in total solar irradiance that would explain it. There's been no seismological or atmospheric chemistry changes consistent with the extra heat coming from an increase in heat output from the core. So, if the global warming is not being caused by more heat being put out from the sun or the core, what's doing it? The only plausible explanation seems to be based on how quickly the heat can escape into space. The mainstream theory has a mechanism to explain why heat would be escaping less and less quickly in recent decades. But do the denialists have any competing explanation for that?
 
I believe the climate change consensus (a consensus saying global temps are rising largely due to human greenhouse gas emissions, and that this will wind up being a serious problem). One of things that won me over is the track record of the experts. Their consensus started out tentatively in the early 1970s, with only slightly more experts expecting warming than were expecting cooling, and the majority not making any predictions. But by the late 1980s, there was a pretty clear consensus on the topic, and they were making bold predictions. Not only did they predict there would be more warming in the coming years, but they predicted it would be occurring at far above historical averages. In fact, they were predicting a rate of warming many times the rate seen for tens of thousands of years, at least. Going way out on the limb, like that, was daring, because that limb could have collapsed underneath them. But it didn't. Over the next three decades, global average temperatures did what they predicted: they rose much faster than we have any evidence of them rising for tens of thousands of years, at least.

What made that prediction so bold was that there wasn't some other reason we'd expect any warming, much less warming at that rate. Other things being equal, we'd have expected regression to the mean. To make such a counter-intuitive prediction, and then have events play out as predicted, gives them credibility.

As of the end of the 1980s, here's what 110 years of recent temperature data looked like:

View attachment 39007

Although that looked, even then, like a warming trend, it wasn't a very impressive one. In fact, the best- fit trend line shows just 0.44 degrees Celsius of warming per century. Yet, the large majority of climate scientists predicted far more rapid warming than that in the future. And here's what the subsequent era looks like, through 2017:

View attachment 39006

As you can see, the rate of warming has been over four times as fast as in the prior era (which, itself, was unusually fast relative to any known average pace in the pre-instrument-record past).

The test of a scientific theory is in its explanatory and predictive power, and the theory supported by the majority of climate experts passed that test with flying colors. Not only does the theory explain why there was warming throughout the modern era, but it correctly predicted that the warming would greatly accelerate.

As far as I know, the "denialist" community never made any accurate predictions. They didn't foresee the warming continuing, much less vastly accelerating. So, their competing theory failed the test of having predictive power. But it also seems to fail when it comes to explanatory power. I have yet to hear any sensible competing explanation for the rapid warming and accelerating warming. There's no change in total solar irradiance that would explain it. There's been no seismological or atmospheric chemistry changes consistent with the extra heat coming from an increase in heat output from the core. So, if the global warming is not being caused by more heat being put out from the sun or the core, what's doing it? The only plausible explanation seems to be based on how quickly the heat can escape into space. The mainstream theory has a mechanism to explain why heat would be escaping less and less quickly in recent decades. But do the denialists have any competing explanation for that?
So, do the denialists have some plausible competing theory for the warming? And are there any denialists who used that theory to correctly predict the kind of warming we've seen, decades ago, the way the mainstream scientists used their theory?
 
Back
Top