New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Racial Double Standard

Arkady

President
A few days ago I objected to Salon columnist David Sirota's argument that Tagg Romney's comments about wanting to take a swing at Obama had something to do with "white privilege." I think that was over-reaching on Sirota's part -- "race-baiting." But he has a much stronger point here:

http://www.salon.com/2012/10/24/five_signs_racism_still_dominates_our_politics/

'If one of Obama’s teenage daughters was unmarried and pregnant, it wouldn’t be considered a “private” matter. When Sarah Palin was put on the Republican ticket in 2008, Bristol Palin’s pregnancy did not initiate a national discussion about the issue of teen pregnancy, unprotected sex, or promiscuous fornication outside of wedlock. Instead, conservative leaders insisted it was off-limits as a topic, with no less than the leader of the Christian Coalition telling reporters, “I think it’s a very private matter.” Now imagine if instead of Palin’s teenage daughter being pregnant, it was Obama’s teenage daughter. Can anyone seriously insist that such a situation wouldn’t prompt a wave of vitriolic attacks on African American “culture” and “irresponsible pathologies”?'


It's hard to prove Sirota's point, since Obama's daughters aren't, as far as we know, pregnant. However, I'm convinced that there would be a cultural double standard here. Nearly all of the right-wing figures who objected to any discussion of Palin's unwed teen motherhood, and a fair number of mainstream media personalities who also proclaimed that topic out-of-bounds, would have gladly jumped all over it if it had been Barack Obama with the unwed teen daughter who got knocked up. Some of that is just pure politics -- Democrats get judged by tougher standards. But, in this case, I think race plays an even bigger role. I think that Obama would have effectively been asked to answer for the social dysfunction of the black community in general.... white reporters would tell themselves the personal life of his daughter is fair game because it's symbolic of an important social problem within the black community.

To a lesser extent, I think you could make the same prediction about other stories the media shrugs at when it's a white Republican, but would dig into hard if it were a black Democrat. For example, both Mitt Romney and George W. Bush were arrested for criminal conduct earlier in their lives. If Obama had an arrest record like that, I'm convinced the media would be far more intent on discussing it, and there would be pressure to release his mug-shot. I think the standards for him would be higher not just because he's a Democrat, but because he's black, and thus effectively made to stand in for his whole race.
 
A similar dynamic exists, regarding religion. Obama's religion has been considered the fairest of game, whilst Mitt's has been virtually off limits. We'd have to go clear back to JFK - with perhaps a brief stop at Lieberman in 2000, to see anything remotely like it.

And, I would suggest the "guilt" isn't exlusively Fox/GOPian. With Obama, it was if we didn't just feel entitled, but we felt obligated to parse his faith perspective to the nth degree, in order to assure ourselves that he would be "acceptable" and that we'd not be buying some sort of scary pig in a poke.

I would suggest that Mitt's fundamentalist Mormonism, should be of actual and real concern. But again...the question has been virtually off our table. The only rational explanation I can think of, is that Mitt and Mormonism are whiter than white.
 
Mormons kept the faith on segregation up until 1978. They still get some credit for that amongst the KKK admirers on the right.
 
Racial double standard..A member of the Democrat party whose history shows the voted against civil rights bills since 1933 80 percent of the time...that 80 percent on 26 major civil rights bills , a person whose party had the State police out in front of my school not letting African Americans into scool is now goiimg to lecture us on what is racially incorrect.

I think the standards for him would be higher not just because he's a Democrat, but because he's black, and thus effectively made to stand in for his whole race

Since he was raised in a family that was White doe this really make sense? I am not sure that this is anything more than political foggery to accuse Romney of getting a fair deal for being white and Obama didnt for being black. As I understand this that the Democrat is about the underpriveledged..but they need those who are to stay underpriveledged because if everyone became successful then the whole idealogical program would not be needed.. indeed the rant is Bogus..Obama was an advataged person who is now a multimillionaire.
 
Um cherry picking much? The GOP has been in opposition to Civil Rights since the passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The Dems have been in support. The GOP has openly embraced unrepentant racists like Strom Thurmond, Jesse Helms, Trent Lott and others. Folks the Dems kicked out of their party after seeing the light.

Now. as to racism and Obama, seeing him tells no-one who he was raised by. So he experienced racism just as any other minority in the USA does.

And racism occurs at every strata of US Society. So the comparison is not between a high status black man and a low status white man. But rather between each of their peers.

So your point is?

Other than trying to redefine racism into a non-existant pablum so that you and yours can continue to benefit from the unearned priviledges that you as a white person receive on a daily basis?
 
I disagree with you Ark.

Tagg's "permission" to himself to even entertain the notion of "wanting to take a swing at Obama" - is something he would not do to another high status WHITE Male. It is preisely because at a core level Tagg does not consider Obama a "legitimate President" - something that is inherently based in race - that he not only gave himself permission to THINK such a thought, but also to openly voice it.
 
Judeo-Christian houses of worship remain the most racially segregated institutions existing within our society. That tells me all that I need to know about racial attitudes among the religious.
 
Um cherry picking much? The GOP has been in opposition to Civil Rights since the passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The Dems have been in support. The GOP has openly embraced unrepentant racists like Strom Thurmond, Jesse Helms, Trent Lott and others. Folks the Dems kicked out of their party after seeing the light.

Wrong...care to point case and example...care to Explain why Only Democrats voted for Jim Crow laws...in the Supreme court Of the United States? ..didnt think so.

Now. as to racism and Obama, seeing him tells no-one who he was raised by. So he experienced racism just as any other minority in the USA does.

So you see a Person of color and assume that he is suffering from racism...Ok a leftist point of view...I just see another Human being, but then by vitue of having a mother who is Arabic and practices Islam , I guess I qualify just like Obama in your same statement.

So really Degs now that your President has had to suffer at the hands of the White man wo is bent on destroying his political bid for a 2nd term...Joe Biden....I do feel for you but you like , most lefty on the P.J. dont try to end racism...and laugh at those who do...so you can keep BullSh&ttinging yourself into believing that that this conversation is of some moral importance ...but is really is using racism as apolitical tool to re-elect Obam and That because of his race he should get extra credit the other guy shouldnt get based on skin tone...and as long as you believe that..you will never have equality..but then you never wanted equality..but you dont have the guts, because you are a coward to stand up to these people and say no it's wrong...we cant use skin tone to discriminate against anyone. Your not the Party of Lincoln...you dont have the guts to be nor the political will to have equality.
 
Drum, desperately tries to convince others that the GOP is the "real home for blacks in America".....


but ask her why it's not?....and she'll insult African-Americans as "stupid" or "brainwashed"....

and thus show why it's not, accidentially.
 
"When Sarah Palin was put on the Republican ticket in 2008, Bristol Palin’s pregnancy did not initiate a national discussion about the issue of teen pregnancy, unprotected sex, or promiscuous fornication outside of wedlock."

What has your author been smoking? It was an endless commentary by the leftist mainstream media for weeks / months and beyond, primarily focusing on how hypocritical God-fearing conservatives truly are. So this guy's premise is garbage.

As far as some sources playing up "the black problem" if one of Obama's teenage daughters got pregnant, well we are very sorry we cannot control every voice. But for him to imply this is how conservatives become so small minded and hypocritical is totally small minded on his part. I think the whole matter is a very weak ploy (if not desperate) to disparage the predominant conservative positions.
 
I disagree with you Ark.

Tagg's "permission" to himself to even entertain the notion of "wanting to take a swing at Obama" - is something he would not do to another high status WHITE Male. It is preisely because at a core level Tagg does not consider Obama a "legitimate President" - something that is inherently based in race - that he not only gave himself permission to THINK such a thought, but also to openly voice it.

I can't prove it, but it wouldn't shock me in the least to find examples of Tagg or other prominent Republican family members making similar comments about white Democrats. I can't remember which Republican it was, but one in the 90s effectively warned Clinton to stay out of his state if he didn't want to get hurt. I recall a flood of violent rhetoric about Ted Kennedy, in particular. I don't know if Tagg's on record wanting to take a swing at him, but would it really surprise you to find he was?
 
No the commentary was about Palin's hypocrisy - advocating Abstinence Only and forcing her daughter to carry to term by not giving her a choice. THAT was the difference.

There was no castigation about "promiscuous fornication"

And the issue is not about "not controlling every voice"... the reality is that AS A PARTY you conservatives have openly and happilly embraced unrepentant racists like Strom Thurmond as though nothing had happened.
 
I disagree with you Ark.

Tagg's "permission" to himself to even entertain the notion of "wanting to take a swing at Obama" - is something he would not do to another high status WHITE Male. It is preisely because at a core level Tagg does not consider Obama a "legitimate President" - something that is inherently based in race - that he not only gave himself permission to THINK such a thought, but also to openly voice it.

Degs -- did you ever think that Tagg's desire had nothing to do with the legitimacy of Obama's presidency and was more driven by personal umbrage at what Obama said about his father? Even if his father is outright lying, Tagg would be only human if he objected to someone calling his father a liar on national TV, and only typical if he wanted to take a swing at the person who (regardless of position or race) had done so.

You seem to always seek a racist motivation for any action taken by a non-minority person in the public sphere.
 
No the commentary was about Palin's hypocrisy - advocating Abstinence Only and forcing her daughter to carry to term by not giving her a choice. THAT was the difference.

There was no castigation about "promiscuous fornication"

And the issue is not about "not controlling every voice"... the reality is that AS A PARTY you conservatives have openly and happilly embraced unrepentant racists like Strom Thurmond as though nothing had happened.

As a party, the Democrats happily embraced "repentant" racists such as as Robert Byrd, the last elected person who had been an open member of the Ku Klux Klan, and who was still using racial epithets such as "[Unwelcome language removed]" in his old age.

The idea that somehow the last 40 years have erased the Democrats history of embracing racism, while the same period has somehow erased Republican opposition to racism is ludicrous. Sometimes I think if I hear the words "southern strategy" come out of a Democrat's mouth one more time I'll scream. Of course blue-collar whites abandoned the Democratic party. You can call this racism if you like, but what did the party, as it has existed since 1968, offer them? Mostly, it offered them the opportunity to pay higher taxes to support programs from which they could not benefit (and for realizing this, they are criticized for "not voting in their own best interests.")
 
Um cherry picking much? The GOP has been in opposition to Civil Rights since the passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The Dems have been in support. The GOP has openly embraced unrepentant racists like Strom Thurmond, Jesse Helms, Trent Lott and others. Folks the Dems kicked out of their party after seeing the light.
Wrong...care to point case and example.
Sure no problem. Trent Lott within the last 10 years saying that the nation would have been better off if Strom Thrumond had won the presidency. Strom Thrumond ran on an unrepentant segregationism ticket and never repudiated that stance.

that is simply factual record. so I'm not wrong. you are. Trent Lott at the time was the Senate Leader of the GOP. and the GOP objected to calls from Dems that Lott step down.

..care to Explain why Only Democrats voted for Jim Crow laws
Sure no problem.
1) it wasn't Dems only. Southern Republicans did as well.

2) After 1964, those Dems, like Lott, Zell Miller, Jesse Helms, Strom Thurmond CHANGED THEIR PARTY AFFILIATION AND BECAME REPUBLICANS

That too is historic recored.


So you see a Person of color and assume that he is suffering from racism.
Nothing leftist about it, nothing about "assuming"... the RESEARCH DATA is there as recently as within the last 2 years.

..Ok a leftist point of view...I just see another Human being,
Bullsh!t. Because your own words belie you on this subject. Furthermore if you don't see the racism in society that is well documented, then by defnition you are actually NOT seeing the other "human being" but rather your self-involved projection of what you ASSUME to be so but is not. And of course that serves to CONTINUE TO BENEFIT YOU DAILY.

So really Degs now that your President has had to suffer at the hands of the White man wo is bent on destroying his political bid for a 2nd term...Joe Biden.
Um Biden did make a racist comment. And apologized for it. OTOH you continue in your racism. And in your persistent attempt to maintain the racist privileges you receive by pretending they don't exist.

The facts show us that Obama did indeed suffer from racial prejudice in the 2008 election
http://www.ted.com/talks/nate_silver_on_race_and_politics.html
http://www.people.fas.harvard.edu/~sstephen/papers/RacialAnimusAndVotingSethStephensDavidowitz.pdf

So your attempts to play word games only shows you to be the racist you are.

No I'm not the Party of Lincoln (a man who himself was deeply racially prejudiced http://markii.wordpress.com/2007/02/19/racist-quote-by-abe-lincoln-happy-black-history-month/ ) and proud of that. I work to actually reduce racism by calling out those - like you - who seek to ossify racist privildge for themselves.

Perhaps this IS the problem with the GOP.. that it is the "Party Of Lincoln"... still today. Because here is what Lincoln had to say abotu blacks"
“I will say then that I am not, nor ever have been in favor of bringing about in anyway the social and political equality of the white and black races – that I am not nor ever have been in favor of making voters or jurors of negroes, nor of qualifying them to hold office, nor to intermarry with white people; and I will say in addition to this that there is a physical difference between the white and black races which I believe will forever forbid the two races living together on terms of social and political equality.
 
Drum, desperately tries to convince others that the GOP is the "real home for blacks in America".....


but ask her why it's not?....and she'll insult African-Americans as "stupid" or "brainwashed"....

and thus show why it's not, accidentially.

Yep Gecko..ya didnt ask people to end racism tho did ya... see everytime lefty wants to call you out for racism...he doesnt ask you to end racism and thus the cycle continues...Gecko your full of it and we know it...we share what you say to teach...look just out a stop to racism Gecko...it's that important.
 
Degs -- did you ever think that Tagg's desire had nothing to do with the legitimacy of Obama's presidency and was more driven by personal umbrage at what Obama said about his father?

Its both. Tagg is human in his objection and being pissed off about his father being called a liar on national TV. But his WILLINGNESS TO PERMIT HIMSELF to entertain "taking a swing at" the PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES... and his further WILLINGNESS to publically express that... THAT is the part where his views of Obama's illegitimacy simply cannot be disentangled from the racism he grew up with.
 
As a party, the Democrats happily embraced "repentant" racists such as as Robert Byrd,
And that's the operative Word... repentent.

The idea that somehow the last 40 years have erased the Democrats history of embracing racism, while the same period has somehow erased Republican opposition to racism is ludicrous.
Um depends on what you mean. If you mean Has the Dem Party eviscerated all of the manifestations of racism and racial bigotry within its own party? No - and that's not possible precisely because of the continued pervasiveness of racism in the society at large.

But if you mean "Has the Democratic Party removed all manifestations of racist political, and fiscal policies from its operations and platform"? Does it vigilently oppose racism?" then the answer is clearly yes.

And scream all you like about the "Southern Strategy" but the gerrymandering around race, the proven racism in Arizona's immigration laws etc. are all real and ongoing.

And if abandoning racism means abandoning white blue collar men... then so be it. That's the choice of those to not abandon THEIR OWN racism.

And no, the Dems have not raised taxes on the Blue Collar workers to support programs they could not benefit from. But the racism of those Blue Collar whites made them PERCEIVE that to be the case, just as you blame Affirmative Action for your failure to complete a college degree, when in reality it was Reagans 66% cuts in College Aid - something you VOTED TO SUPPORT - that prevented you from success.

Have the Dems been perhaps less than brilliant in explaining the details of this to blue collar white men? Perhaps. But considering that the GOP was ACTIVELY AMPLIFYING the racist tendecies in this demographic, the blame lies as much with those voters and their own racism as anyone else.
 
Back
Top