Arkady
President
A few days ago I objected to Salon columnist David Sirota's argument that Tagg Romney's comments about wanting to take a swing at Obama had something to do with "white privilege." I think that was over-reaching on Sirota's part -- "race-baiting." But he has a much stronger point here:
http://www.salon.com/2012/10/24/five_signs_racism_still_dominates_our_politics/
'If one of Obama’s teenage daughters was unmarried and pregnant, it wouldn’t be considered a “private” matter. When Sarah Palin was put on the Republican ticket in 2008, Bristol Palin’s pregnancy did not initiate a national discussion about the issue of teen pregnancy, unprotected sex, or promiscuous fornication outside of wedlock. Instead, conservative leaders insisted it was off-limits as a topic, with no less than the leader of the Christian Coalition telling reporters, “I think it’s a very private matter.” Now imagine if instead of Palin’s teenage daughter being pregnant, it was Obama’s teenage daughter. Can anyone seriously insist that such a situation wouldn’t prompt a wave of vitriolic attacks on African American “culture” and “irresponsible pathologies”?'
It's hard to prove Sirota's point, since Obama's daughters aren't, as far as we know, pregnant. However, I'm convinced that there would be a cultural double standard here. Nearly all of the right-wing figures who objected to any discussion of Palin's unwed teen motherhood, and a fair number of mainstream media personalities who also proclaimed that topic out-of-bounds, would have gladly jumped all over it if it had been Barack Obama with the unwed teen daughter who got knocked up. Some of that is just pure politics -- Democrats get judged by tougher standards. But, in this case, I think race plays an even bigger role. I think that Obama would have effectively been asked to answer for the social dysfunction of the black community in general.... white reporters would tell themselves the personal life of his daughter is fair game because it's symbolic of an important social problem within the black community.
To a lesser extent, I think you could make the same prediction about other stories the media shrugs at when it's a white Republican, but would dig into hard if it were a black Democrat. For example, both Mitt Romney and George W. Bush were arrested for criminal conduct earlier in their lives. If Obama had an arrest record like that, I'm convinced the media would be far more intent on discussing it, and there would be pressure to release his mug-shot. I think the standards for him would be higher not just because he's a Democrat, but because he's black, and thus effectively made to stand in for his whole race.
http://www.salon.com/2012/10/24/five_signs_racism_still_dominates_our_politics/
'If one of Obama’s teenage daughters was unmarried and pregnant, it wouldn’t be considered a “private” matter. When Sarah Palin was put on the Republican ticket in 2008, Bristol Palin’s pregnancy did not initiate a national discussion about the issue of teen pregnancy, unprotected sex, or promiscuous fornication outside of wedlock. Instead, conservative leaders insisted it was off-limits as a topic, with no less than the leader of the Christian Coalition telling reporters, “I think it’s a very private matter.” Now imagine if instead of Palin’s teenage daughter being pregnant, it was Obama’s teenage daughter. Can anyone seriously insist that such a situation wouldn’t prompt a wave of vitriolic attacks on African American “culture” and “irresponsible pathologies”?'
It's hard to prove Sirota's point, since Obama's daughters aren't, as far as we know, pregnant. However, I'm convinced that there would be a cultural double standard here. Nearly all of the right-wing figures who objected to any discussion of Palin's unwed teen motherhood, and a fair number of mainstream media personalities who also proclaimed that topic out-of-bounds, would have gladly jumped all over it if it had been Barack Obama with the unwed teen daughter who got knocked up. Some of that is just pure politics -- Democrats get judged by tougher standards. But, in this case, I think race plays an even bigger role. I think that Obama would have effectively been asked to answer for the social dysfunction of the black community in general.... white reporters would tell themselves the personal life of his daughter is fair game because it's symbolic of an important social problem within the black community.
To a lesser extent, I think you could make the same prediction about other stories the media shrugs at when it's a white Republican, but would dig into hard if it were a black Democrat. For example, both Mitt Romney and George W. Bush were arrested for criminal conduct earlier in their lives. If Obama had an arrest record like that, I'm convinced the media would be far more intent on discussing it, and there would be pressure to release his mug-shot. I think the standards for him would be higher not just because he's a Democrat, but because he's black, and thus effectively made to stand in for his whole race.