New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Rand Paul's Droning Rant

A fine and harshly worded editorial in The Wall Street Journal yesterday:

Give Rand Paul credit for theatrical timing. As a snow storm descended on Washington, the Kentucky Republican's old-fashioned filibuster Wednesday filled the attention void on Twitter and cable TV. If only his reasoning matched the showmanship.

Shortly before noon, Senator Paul began a talking filibuster against John Brennan's nomination to lead the CIA. The tactic is rarely used in the Senate and was last seen in 2010. But Senator Paul said an "alarm" had to be sounded about the threat to Americans from their own government. He promised to speak "until the President says, no, he will not kill you at a café." He meant by a military drone. He's apparently serious, though his argument isn't.

Senator Paul had written the White House to inquire about the possibility of a drone strike against a U.S. citizen on American soil. Attorney General Eric Holder replied that the U.S. hasn't and "has no intention" to bomb any specific territory. Drones are limited to the remotest areas of conflict zones like Pakistan and Yemen. But as a hypothetical Constitutional matter, Mr. Holder acknowledged the President can authorize the use of lethal military force within U.S. territory.

This shocked Senator Paul, who invoked the Constitution and Miranda rights. Under current U.S. policy, Mr. Paul mused on the floor, Jane Fonda could have been legally killed by a Hellfire missile during her tour of Communist Hanoi in 1972. A group of noncombatants sitting in public view in Houston may soon be pulverized, he declared.

Calm down, Senator. Mr. Holder is right, even if he doesn't explain the law very well. The U.S. government cannot randomly target American citizens on U.S. soil or anywhere else. What it can do under the laws of war is target an "enemy combatant" anywhere at anytime, including on U.S. soil. This includes a U.S. citizen who is also an enemy combatant. The President can designate such a combatant if he belongs to an entity—a government, say, or a terrorist network like al Qaeda—that has taken up arms against the United States as part of an internationally recognized armed conflict. That does not include Hanoi Jane.

Such a conflict exists between the U.S. and al Qaeda, so Mr. Holder is right that the U.S. could have targeted (say) U.S. citizen Anwar al-Awlaki had he continued to live in Virginia. The U.S. killed him in Yemen before he could kill more Americans. But under the law Awlaki was no different than the Nazis who came ashore on Long Island in World War II, were captured and executed.

The country needs more Senators who care about liberty, but if Mr. Paul wants to be taken seriously he needs to do more than pull political stunts that fire up impressionable libertarian kids in their college dorms. He needs to know what he's talking about.
 
they didn't mention Rand's (son of Ron) references to Hitler. I thought that was particularly astute of him as he stoked the paranoia of the black helicopter militia crowds who are stockpiling guns to take out local law enforcement.

a few years ago, the Christian Hutari plan in MI was to shoot police as they attended the funeral of one of their own. 2 of the leaders served time, the rest had mug shots that looked like they came right out of an abnormal psych textbook.
 
they didn't mention Rand's (son of Ron) references to Hitler. I thought that was particularly astute of him as he stoked the paranoia of the black helicopter militia crowds who are stockpiling guns to take out local law enforcement.

a few years ago, the Christian Hutari plan in MI was to shoot police as they attended the funeral of one of their own. 2 of the leaders served time, the rest had mug shots that looked like they came right out of an abnormal psych textbook.

So you don't classify them as American patriots, Julie? ;)
 
Good stuff LR.. especially the "impressionable libertarian kids in college dorms" part.

Those are probably the ones who kidnap and blindfold sorority girls and force them to worship Aqua-Buddha. :D
 
LeRoy wrote: ...The U.S. government cannot randomly target American citizens on U.S. soil or anywhere else. What it can do under the laws of war is target an "enemy combatant" anywhere at anytime, including on U.S. soil. This includes a U.S. citizen who is also an enemy combatant. The President can designate such a combatant if he belongs to an entity—a government, say, or a terrorist network like al Qaeda—that has taken up arms against the United States as part of an internationally recognized armed conflict....

The WSJ op ed makes the valid point that Paul's filibuster was theatrical and that Paul's argument wasn't serious.

But then the piece goes on to endorse the enemy combatant doctrine articulated above. That is actually the heart of the dispute -- can the president designate an individual an enemy combatant and kill that individual anytime and anywhere without due process, and in lands that are not battlefields or the US is not at war with?

Inexplicably, the op ed circles back and supports the idea that the president can kill US citizens on US soil by drone:
Mr. Holder is right that the U.S. could have targeted (say) U.S. citizen Anwar al-Awlaki had he continued to live in Virginia.

OK, so the WSJ believes a president can zap a US citizen on US soil under the constitution.

The op ed highlights the dilemma faced by many conservatives: support for Obama's droning policy and political opposition to Obama -- leading many cons to adopt a position they don't actually agree with.
 
First speech of the 2016 Republican Primaries. (Well...first successful one....Rand wasn't grasping around for a water bottle. :) )

Even some Rand fans know the truth of what that little show was about.
 
The WSJ op ed makes the valid point that Paul's filibuster was theatrical and that Paul's argument wasn't serious.

But then the piece goes on to endorse the enemy combatant doctrine articulated above. That is actually the heart of the dispute -- can the president designate an individual an enemy combatant and kill that individual anytime and anywhere without due process, and in lands that are not battlefields or the US is not at war with?

Inexplicably, the op ed circles back and supports the idea that the president can kill US citizens on US soil by drone:

OK, so the WSJ believes a president can zap a US citizen on US soil under the constitution.

The op ed highlights the dilemma faced by many conservatives: support for Obama's droning policy and political opposition to Obama -- leading many cons to adopt a position they don't actually agree with.

From the editorial: But under the law Awlaki was no different than the Nazis who came ashore on Long Island in World War II, were captured and executed.

LeRoy: Some of those people who came ashore on Long Island during WWII were American citizens who had joined the Nazis. Were they deprived of due process, in your opinion?

Personally, I think that if a member of Al Qaeda is on U.S. soil, they can almost certainly be apprehended, without the use of a drone, and given a proper trial.

But, you know, I find myself wishing that the Union army in the Civil War had had drones available. The Civil War might have been over much sooner, with much less loss of life. Here's the analogy: Suppose, at some point in the future, there is another serious armed rebellion in this country. Let's say some large right-wing militias decide that they are going to overthrow the lawfully elected government of this country. Let's say they start their 'campaign' by murdering U.S. judges, police officers, members of our military, elected officials. Then let's say we happen to observe a large contingent of these rebels in the field, heavily armed. If I were the President, I would be perfectly happy to order a drone strike against them. On U.S. soil. Imagine that!
 
I'm trying to understand all this angst about the potential use of drones to kill American citizens without due process.

Take for example a situation where hostages are taken: don't the police have a right to kill the hostage taker via sniper rifle if they feel the lives of the hostages are in danger, due process be damned? What difference would it make if a drone was used instead of sniper rifle?

My point being, in certain circumstances Federal / State / Local law enforcement officials can kill American citizens without the due process of law. What difference does it make how they do it?

Don't get me wrong, I'd like to think the use of armed drones would be extremely rare and that their use should be closely monitored.
 
I'm trying to understand all this angst about the potential use of drones to kill American citizens without due process.

Take for example a situation where hostages are taken: don't the police have a right to kill the hostage taker via sniper rifle if they feel the lives of the hostages are in danger, due process be damned? What difference would it make if a drone was used instead of sniper rifle?

My point being, in certain circumstances Federal / State / Local law enforcement officials can kill American citizens without the due process of law. What difference does it make how they do it?

Don't get me wrong, I'd like to think the use of armed drones would be extremely rare and that their use should be closely monitored.

Exactly.
 
I'm trying to understand all this angst about the potential use of drones to kill American citizens without due process.

Take for example a situation where hostages are taken: don't the police have a right to kill the hostage taker via sniper rifle if they feel the lives of the hostages are in danger, due process be damned? What difference would it make if a drone was used instead of sniper rifle?

My point being, in certain circumstances Federal / State / Local law enforcement officials can kill American citizens without the due process of law. What difference does it make how they do it?

Don't get me wrong, I'd like to think the use of armed drones would be extremely rare and that their use should be closely monitored.

Supposedly the idea is that some "good decent patriotic rightwingers" will be blasted off the face of the Earth by some "evil liberal President".....or even the political reverse and some "good decent patriotic leftwingers" will be blasted off the face of the Earth by some "evil rightwing President".....

and "somehow" there will be no public outrage over a horrific abuse of power or such outrage will be squelched under a "brutal dictatorship".

Mind you, none of these folks can explain why such things couldn't have been done just as easily in the past 30 years with an F-117 stealth fighter with a JDAM.....or hell, 70 years, with a P-47 Thunderbolt prop plane from World War-II and an archaic 1000 lbs iron bomb. But because it's a "drone"....somehow it ratchets up the paranoia.
 
I don't consider the Nazis who came to Long Island to engage in sabotage and were captured and executed to have been deprived of due process. They were tried by a military tribunal after the SCOTUS refused a defense plea to have a civilian trial. These guys did something interesting that ties into the enemy combatant doctrine. They came ashore in German military uniforms so they couldn't be designated spies and, if captured, would be POWs and protected. Hello sore thumbs(!) and alas, to no avail.

I share your opinion that members of al-Qaeda living in the US can and should be apprehended. We have done a pretty good job in that regard and the cases have been resolved in US courts without hopping a taxi to the dark side.
 
Cerulean Mutt wrote: ...My point being, in certain circumstances Federal / State / Local law enforcement officials can kill American citizens without the due process of law....

Yes. You hit the nail right on the head. We have the right to use lethal force in many emergency situations. The use of lethal force invokes a post-incident public examination of the appropriateness of the use. The analogy isn't a perfect fit since the drone strikes are not publicly reviewed.
 
Drone strikes are not publicly reviewed?

Balderdash. If and when a drone strike is used on American soil the press scrutiny would be enormous, and regardless of the political stripe of the President who ordered the strike, I guarantee Congress would be all over it like white on rice.
 
Rand Paul didn't say ""I will speak until I can no longer speak or I have to potty. Which ever comes first." It was a poor attempt on his part to make himself appear to be relevant in the world of rightwing politics. He failed miserably, only succeeding in making himself seem more of a nutjob than his old man. Now he can sit down and shut up while the adults in the room get on with trying to improve our nation.
 
The deliberations to kill American citizens are secret. The aftermath is also not publicly reviewed even if news coverage is extensive. Or do you know of a case in which the before/after drone deliberations have been made publicly available?
 
Rand Paul didn't say ""I will speak until I can no longer speak or I have to potty. Which ever comes first." It was a poor attempt on his part to make himself appear to be relevant in the world of rightwing politics. He failed miserably, only succeeding in making himself seem more of a nutjob than his old man. Not he can sit down and shut up while the adults in the room get on with trying to improve our nation.

If someone has that entire thing on tape, the CIA can use it for "enhanced interrogation" at Gitmo. Personally after about an hour of that, i'd spill the beans! ;-)
 
Drone strikes are not publicly reviewed?

Balderdash. If and when a drone strike is used on American soil the press scrutiny would be enormous, and regardless of the political stripe of the President who ordered the strike, I guarantee Congress would be all over it like white on rice.

Indeed. There have been few American military actions which have received MORE public review than the drone strike which killed Anwar Al-Awlaki. And that was on Yemeni soil.
 
Back
Top