New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Rape Does Not Justify Abortion

IAmBrown

Council Member
You don’t respect my reason, my rape, my abortion, and I guarantee you there are other women who should stand up with me and be courageous enough to speak that voice. What you’re doing is so fundamentally inhuman, unconstitutional, and I’ve sat here too long. I dare any one of you to judge me, because there’s only one judge I’m going to face.

http://thefederalist.com/2015/04/15/rape-does-not-justify-abortion/

As the article says 'One crime does not require another'. I believe however the second crime in this case is not woman's desire to get rid of attacker's heritage, it is society's desire to decide for the woman what she has to do in this case. Look, a woman and her body has been violated. Barely she wants anybody advice on how to overcome psychological trauma. If she was stupid enough to impregnate herself during a drunk student party and now wants to get rid of the fetus it is one thing. Abortion after rape is absolutely another.
 
http://thefederalist.com/2015/04/15/rape-does-not-justify-abortion/

As the article says 'One crime does not require another'. I believe however the second crime in this case is not woman's desire to get rid of attacker's heritage, it is society's desire to decide for the woman what she has to do in this case. Look, a woman and her body has been violated. Barely she wants anybody advice on how to overcome psychological trauma. If she was stupid enough to impregnate herself during a drunk student party and now wants to get rid of the fetus it is one thing. Abortion after rape is absolutely another.

Your comments here are a little vague but if I'm reading that a woman's body is her own and society should stay out of her decisions, then I agree.

While abortion under any circumstances is not something that anybody would actually be for, the right to choose certainly should be.

Interestingly, vast numbers of the very people who rant and protest against an abortion are fine with us using drones in country after country or even attacking them outright, and when we kill multitudes of innocent people, including women and children, they simply chalk it up to 'collateral damage'. To me that is the ultimate in hypocrisy. It's then OK to kill 'babies'.

In the past, I've stated that when an unwanted zygote or fetus can be extracted from a woman and then allowed to develop under different means such as a petrie dish or some such, then those who want it to become a child should make it so. Until then it is not a child without a major contribution from a woman who may not choose to for her own reasons.
 
http://thefederalist.com/2015/04/15/rape-does-not-justify-abortion/

As the article says 'One crime does not require another'. I believe however the second crime in this case is not woman's desire to get rid of attacker's heritage, it is society's desire to decide for the woman what she has to do in this case. Look, a woman and her body has been violated. Barely she wants anybody advice on how to overcome psychological trauma. If she was stupid enough to impregnate herself during a drunk student party and now wants to get rid of the fetus it is one thing. Abortion after rape is absolutely another.

Neither are anybody's business but her own.
 
Your comments here are a little vague but if I'm reading that a woman's body is her own and society should stay out of her decisions, then I agree.

While abortion under any circumstances is not something that anybody would actually be for, the right to choose certainly should be.

Interestingly, vast numbers of the very people who rant and protest against an abortion are fine with us using drones in country after country or even attacking them outright, and when we kill multitudes of innocent people, including women and children, they simply chalk it up to 'collateral damage'. To me that is the ultimate in hypocrisy. It's then OK to kill 'babies'.

In the past, I've stated that when an unwanted zygote or fetus can be extracted from a woman and then allowed to develop under different means such as a petrie dish or some such, then those who want it to become a child should make it so. Until then it is not a child without a major contribution from a woman who may not choose to for her own reasons.


Can you be more specific when you say "vast numbers of the very people who rant and protest against an abortion are fine with us using drones in country after country or even attacking them outright, and when we kill multitudes of innocent people, including women and children, they simply chalk it up to 'collateral damage'. To me that is the ultimate in hypocrisy. It's then OK to kill 'babies'."

What is that vast number?
 
That is one wonderful article. I particularly like the address to congress where the woman mentions that other women who've been in her situation should be standing up with her. Actually, there is a coalition of women who've been in her situation and are sick and tired of the pro abortion lobby marching their cause across the backs of rape victims. They would love to stand up with her, but they are seldom invited to give their testimonies. And they are often ridiculed and marginalized when they express that no post-rape help was offered to them by the "prochoice" community other than access and encouragement to abortion. Some of these women have had abortions, some not.
Of the women who conceived children in rape and chose to have them, whether they gave them up for adoption or not, the ones who speak about it say that their pregnancy and their child actually helped them heal mentally and emotionally, and returned their feelings of self autonomy and empowerment to them more than anything else. Unfortunately, women who say these things are often met with accusations of lying about having been raped in the first place.

Then there are people walking around right now who were conceived by rape. They are very clear that those who use rape as justification for abortion are basically saying that they should not be alive right now. But they are alive. And they're talking.
 
That is one wonderful article. I particularly like the address to congress where the woman mentions that other women who've been in her situation should be standing up with her. Actually, there is a coalition of women who've been in her situation and are sick and tired of the pro abortion lobby marching their cause across the backs of rape victims. They would love to stand up with her, but they are seldom invited to give their testimonies. And they are often ridiculed and marginalized when they express that no post-rape help was offered to them by the "prochoice" community other than access and encouragement to abortion. Some of these women have had abortions, some not.
Of the women who conceived children in rape and chose to have them, whether they gave them up for adoption or not, the ones who speak about it say that their pregnancy and their child actually helped them heal mentally and emotionally, and returned their feelings of self autonomy and empowerment to them more than anything else. Unfortunately, women who say these things are often met with accusations of lying about having been raped in the first place.

Then there are people walking around right now who were conceived by rape. They are very clear that those who use rape as justification for abortion are basically saying that they should not be alive right now. But they are alive. And they're talking.

I believe that whether a baby is conceived by rape, or it is malformed, or it is just an inconvenience, it should hurt a woman's heart and soul more to choose to abort it than it would hurt her to have the child. That women can abort their children at any point for any reason at all, says things about our society that are just too sad for words.
 
As a nation ruled by seculsr law- not the bible or koran - abortion is legal and has been for decades. The entire premise of your post is an insult to the rule of law and our constitution.
 
As a nation ruled by seculsr law- not the bible or koran - abortion is legal and has been for decades. The entire premise of your post is an insult to the rule of law and our constitution.

It is still possible to outlaw something that has nothing to do the Bible.
 
Yeah, killing your child is nobody's business but if you circumcise him, you're not even a woman, right?
Wrong.

A fetus is not a child - a child though has rights, so they say, until it comes to the skinning of and ripping off the top layer of half the skin, which is still adhered to the main body of --- his tiny penis, without the babe or childs consent.

Circumcision is, at the very least, an abuse of young human beings rights making a mockery of any protective legislation.

Forcing a woman to bring a fetus to term against her will is an abuse of womans human rights.

Circumcision has been foisted on America - you should really take a second look at the whole question ---

If we want to see less abortions we need to work on making this world a safer and more friendly place so that women feel they can bring babes into it ---- and better forms of contraception --- I have no problem with the programs which encourage serious druggies to have reversible 'snips'.

I did not say 'she is not a woman' I questioned Jewish mothers who knowingly give their 8 day old babes into the arms of a man who will cause that babe excruciating pain and harm --- and I question mothers who have allowed themselves be persuaded to have their babes circumcised since the advent of the internet ---
 
Last edited:
A fetus is not a child - a child though has rights, so they say, until it comes to the skinning of and ripping off the top layer of half the skin, which is still adhered to the main body of --- his tiny penis, without the babe or childs consent.

Circumcision is, at the very least, an abuse of young human beings rights making a mockery of any protective legislation.

Forcing a woman to bring a fetus to term against her will is an abuse of womans human rights.

Circumcision has been foisted on America - you should really take a second look at the whole question ---

If we want to see less abortions we need to work on making this world a safer and more friendly place so that women feel they can bring babes into it ---- and better forms of contraception --- I have no problem with the programs which encourage serious druggies to have reversible 'snips'.

I did not say 'she is not a woman' I questioned Jewish mothers who knowingly give their 8 day old babes into the arms of a man who will cause that babe excruciating pain and harm --- and I question mothers who have allowed themselves be persuaded to have their babes circumcised since the advent of the internet ---

Yes, you did say that women who have their kids circumcised are not women.
"No answers though jen! - It is no ones fault that they were mutilated as babes as nor is it older mothers fault if they were persuaded into the 70s mmmm even the 80s to have their babes mutilated - but - there after, any mother who allowed their babe to be circumcised is not woman nor mother but an abomination -

truth
-"

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/are-there-any-men-on-pj-who-are-not-circumcised.74682/

You're being hypocritical. You want to talk about how awful it is to mutilate children, but you want to hide behind legal rights and semantics when it comes to mutilating them to death for the sake of a choice you might want to make.

You can talk about the law all day long. But I notice that you don't take the "mothers have the right to circumcise so it's not my business" approach when discussing circumcision. Only abortion.
 
Yes, you did say that women who have their kids circumcised are not women.
"No answers though jen! - It is no ones fault that they were mutilated as babes as nor is it older mothers fault if they were persuaded into the 70s mmmm even the 80s to have their babes mutilated - but - there after, any mother who allowed their babe to be circumcised is not woman nor mother but an abomination -

truth
-"

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/are-there-any-men-on-pj-who-are-not-circumcised.74682/

You're being hypocritical. You want to talk about how awful it is to mutilate children, but you want to hide behind legal rights and semantics when it comes to mutilating them to death for the sake of a choice you might want to make.

You can talk about the law all day long. But I notice that you don't take the "mothers have the right to circumcise so it's not my business" approach when discussing circumcision. Only abortion.



''It is no ones fault that they were mutilated as babes as nor is it older mothers fault if they were persuaded into the 70s mmmm even the 80s to have their babes mutilated - but - there after, any mother who allowed their babe to be circumcised is not woman nor mother but an abomination ''

My meaning is clear, that once the information was easily available (via the internet) there was/is no excuse, there is only weakness, that a mothers wish to comply with the status quo is stronger than her maternal instincts. Of Jewish mothers there is no excuse what so ever, because they know 'the ropes'.

Until any being has taken breath it is not an independent being --- once a human is an independent living being it has Inherent Free Born Rights and soon after that, depending on where it is born, it may have Civil Rights as well. Before birth it is dependent on its 'incubator'. As birds may abandon their nests mammals to may abort their unborn. It has been so back to the Ancients -

The moral questions and emotive questions are sometimes another matter in such matters but you argue that women should be baby making machines/slaves - even though you will deny that, that is precisely what you are arguing. Well, we have been there for the last 2000 years and some of us are still performing blood rites on our boy babes too boot --- it is 2015 for heaven sake! These discussions are like something out of the Dark-Midde Ages. Sensible discussion is needed on how to curb the modern demand for an abortion industry but prohibition is a backward step. And as for circumcision, it is a violation of a babes or childs body anyway one wishes to look at it and should not be performed until that human being is able to give consent or at the very least that the foreskin has detached and can be pulled away from the main body of the penis........... and with anesthetic, which most are performed without. .
 
Last edited:
''It is no ones fault that they were mutilated as babes as nor is it older mothers fault if they were persuaded into the 70s mmmm even the 80s to have their babes mutilated - but - there after, any mother who allowed their babe to be circumcised is not woman nor mother but an abomination ''

My meaning is clear, that once the information was easily available (via the internet) there was/is no excuse, there is only weakness, that a mothers wish to comply with the status quo is stronger than her maternal instincts. Of Jewish mothers there is no excuse what so ever, because they know 'the ropes'.

Until any being has taken breath it is not an independent being --- once a human is an independent living being it has Inherent Free Born Rights and soon after that, depending on where it is born, it may have Civil Rights as well. Before birth it is dependent on its 'incubator'. As birds may abandon their nests mammals to may abort their unborn. It has been so back to the Ancients -

The moral questions and emotive questions are sometimes another matter in such matters.

Yes, we all understood your meaning. Women who had their sons circumcised before the seventies were blameless
and women who had their sons circumcised after the eighties....women like me and millions of others....are not women and not mothers. Got it.

But that doesn't change the fact that you one minute condemn what you believe is mutilation of an infant by the removal of a foreskin, but the next you support the mutilation UNTO. THE. DEATH. of an unborn child.
One minute you claim that women who have their sons circumcised aren't women or mothers, and the next, you're just calling us all "incubators" anyway.

And this argument about having the right to kill someone who is completely dependent on you for survival is probably the lamest argument "prochoice" has come up with. Your spin just makes it more bizarre: "He can't live without me so I can kill him. They'll suction him to smithereens or they'll pull him apart with instruments and that's okay. But if I let him live, I"m a monster if I circumcise."

You go on about defenseless vulnerable "babes". The fact that they haven't drawn breath on their own makes them not defenseless? Not vulnerable?
 
Yes, we all understood your meaning. Women who had their sons circumcised before the seventies were blameless
and women who had their sons circumcised after the eighties....women like me and millions of others....are not women and not mothers. Got it.

But that doesn't change the fact that you one minute condemn what you believe is mutilation of an infant by the removal of a foreskin, but the next you support the mutilation UNTO. THE. DEATH. of an unborn child.
One minute you claim that women who have their sons circumcised aren't women or mothers, and the next, you're just calling us all "incubators" anyway.

And this argument about having the right to kill someone who is completely dependent on you for survival is probably the lamest argument "prochoice" has come up with. Your spin just makes it more bizarre: "He can't live without me so I can kill him. They'll suction him to smithereens or they'll pull him apart with instruments and that's okay. But if I let him live, I"m a monster if I circumcise."

You go on about defenseless vulnerable "babes". The fact that they haven't drawn breath on their own makes them not defenseless? Not vulnerable?


I do not support abortion, I, myself, personally, wish there were none.

1) You have the argument the wrong way round. By arguing that a woman has not the right to abort, you are arguing that she has no rights over her body. Women abort because the environment is 'unfit' or she is, as animal will kill its young when the environment is 'unfit' or she is. That a woman has an inherent right over her own body puts the choice to abortion into her hands and so 'we' have nothing to say about it, no matter how we feel about it ---- unless we are to say she, her body, belongs to an out side power = The State.

2) Once the unborn is breathing, society has much more to say about it, if we are to live within the bounds of it/Civilization.

3) By arguing emotively over abortion or not abortion we are not finding any answers as to why there are so many and what we can do about the why.

4) American society has been duped into circumcising its boy children. American are naive and gullible - grow up, take responsibility, just because one has been doing a thing for 100 years does not make it right.

5) I had two abortions which I regret but I have to live with it --- you had your boys circumcised you have to live with that --- and that is life gigi.

In both cases I am talking about inherent rights, you are talking emotionally.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top