Arkady
President
David Brooks's most recent NYT op-ed is an argument against anti-immigration policy, and it makes some good points. But it also indulges in some dishonest conservative rhetoric about the nature of social dysfunction.
One of his arguments against the idea that immigration breeds dysfunction is to look through low-immigration areas, such as Appalachia, pointing out how those areas are suffering more from social dysfunction than high-immigration areas like the big cities. He hearkens to Charles Murray's book "Coming Apart" about the social breakdown among working-class whites, many of whom live in low-immigration areas.
Where I think Brooks steers wrong is in his list of the virtues that are breaking down, resulting in the dysfunction. He argues that it's a breakdown of " industriousness, honesty, marriage and religiosity," and he argues that immigrants show those virtues more than the native-born. I think he's correct that immigrants tend to display more industriousness, honesty, marriage, and religiosity than native born people. But I think it's a mistake to list religiosity as a socially beneficial virtue. I think immigrants thrive despite their higher rate of religiosity, not because of it.
To demonstrate the issue with Brooks's rhetoric, just use Brooks's own example. When you look at the parts of the US that are suffering the breakdown Brooks and Murray are referring to, they aren't the low-religiosity areas. They're places like the Bible Belt, where religion is one of the only standing pillars of culture.
Take a look at it in terms of a hard indicator of social dysfunction, like murder rates. Compare the murder rates of the most and least religious states, in terms of percent of people in the state who think religion is important:
Least religious:
Vermont 2.2
New Hampshire 1.3
Massachusetts 2.0
Maine 1.5
Washington 2.7
Most religious:
Louisiana 11.8
Alabama 8.4
Tennessee 7.3
Mississippi 8.0
Oklahoma 6.2
All the highly religious states have significantly higher murder rates than the national average (5.3),while all the low-religiosity states have less than half the national rate.
Or take incarceration rates as an indicator of broader criminality:
Least religious:
Vermont 335
New Hampshire 362
Massachusetts 318
Maine 285
Washington 425
Most religious:
Louisiana 1082
Alabama 951
Tennessee 740
Mississippi 962
Oklahoma 983
All the most religious states are worse than the national average and all the least religious states are better than the national average.
That's not just a quirk of crime rates, either. Take other indicators of social dysfunction like teen birth rates:
Least religious:
Vermont 14.2
New Hampshire 11.0
Massachusetts 10.6
Maine 16.5
Washington 19.1
Most religious:
Louisiana 35.8
Alabama 32.0
Tennessee 33.0
Mississippi 38.0
Oklahoma 38.5
Once again, all the low-religiosity states are better than the national average, and all the high-religiosity states are worse.
Brooks's mistake is in thinking of religiosity as a virtue, when in fact it's a vice. Faith is belief in the absence of evidence, which is a mental error, and stubborn insistence on sticking with a mental error is a moral weakness. It shouldn't be surprising that areas in the grips of that vice also are socially dysfunctional.
You can see the same thing on the international level. Take a look at the most and least religious countries in terms of percent of people who think religion is important, and let me know in which of those sets of countries you'd rather live.
Least religious:
Estonia
Sweden
Denmark
Czech Republic
Norway
Most religious:
Niger
Bangladesh
Indonesia
Democratic Republic of the Congo
Malawi
Is there any question which of those groups is suffering more from social dysfunction? You can also see it at the city level:
http://ava.prri.org/#religious/2015/MetroAreas/religion/16
In terms of percent of residents unaffiliated with any church, the least religious cities are:
The most religious
Other lists are a little different:
https://www.citylab.com/equity/2013/04/americas-most-and-least-religious-metro-areas/5180/
But the pattern is the same. Generally speaking, low-religiosity cities tend to be in good shape (Burlington, Boulder, and Manchester), while high-religiosity cities tend to be in rough shape, like Montgomery, Jackson, and Birmingham (Mormon cities being the big exception).
One of his arguments against the idea that immigration breeds dysfunction is to look through low-immigration areas, such as Appalachia, pointing out how those areas are suffering more from social dysfunction than high-immigration areas like the big cities. He hearkens to Charles Murray's book "Coming Apart" about the social breakdown among working-class whites, many of whom live in low-immigration areas.
Where I think Brooks steers wrong is in his list of the virtues that are breaking down, resulting in the dysfunction. He argues that it's a breakdown of " industriousness, honesty, marriage and religiosity," and he argues that immigrants show those virtues more than the native-born. I think he's correct that immigrants tend to display more industriousness, honesty, marriage, and religiosity than native born people. But I think it's a mistake to list religiosity as a socially beneficial virtue. I think immigrants thrive despite their higher rate of religiosity, not because of it.
To demonstrate the issue with Brooks's rhetoric, just use Brooks's own example. When you look at the parts of the US that are suffering the breakdown Brooks and Murray are referring to, they aren't the low-religiosity areas. They're places like the Bible Belt, where religion is one of the only standing pillars of culture.
Take a look at it in terms of a hard indicator of social dysfunction, like murder rates. Compare the murder rates of the most and least religious states, in terms of percent of people in the state who think religion is important:
Least religious:
Vermont 2.2
New Hampshire 1.3
Massachusetts 2.0
Maine 1.5
Washington 2.7
Most religious:
Louisiana 11.8
Alabama 8.4
Tennessee 7.3
Mississippi 8.0
Oklahoma 6.2
All the highly religious states have significantly higher murder rates than the national average (5.3),while all the low-religiosity states have less than half the national rate.
Or take incarceration rates as an indicator of broader criminality:
Least religious:
Vermont 335
New Hampshire 362
Massachusetts 318
Maine 285
Washington 425
Most religious:
Louisiana 1082
Alabama 951
Tennessee 740
Mississippi 962
Oklahoma 983
All the most religious states are worse than the national average and all the least religious states are better than the national average.
That's not just a quirk of crime rates, either. Take other indicators of social dysfunction like teen birth rates:
Least religious:
Vermont 14.2
New Hampshire 11.0
Massachusetts 10.6
Maine 16.5
Washington 19.1
Most religious:
Louisiana 35.8
Alabama 32.0
Tennessee 33.0
Mississippi 38.0
Oklahoma 38.5
Once again, all the low-religiosity states are better than the national average, and all the high-religiosity states are worse.
Brooks's mistake is in thinking of religiosity as a virtue, when in fact it's a vice. Faith is belief in the absence of evidence, which is a mental error, and stubborn insistence on sticking with a mental error is a moral weakness. It shouldn't be surprising that areas in the grips of that vice also are socially dysfunctional.
You can see the same thing on the international level. Take a look at the most and least religious countries in terms of percent of people who think religion is important, and let me know in which of those sets of countries you'd rather live.
Least religious:
Estonia
Sweden
Denmark
Czech Republic
Norway
Most religious:
Niger
Bangladesh
Indonesia
Democratic Republic of the Congo
Malawi
Is there any question which of those groups is suffering more from social dysfunction? You can also see it at the city level:
http://ava.prri.org/#religious/2015/MetroAreas/religion/16
In terms of percent of residents unaffiliated with any church, the least religious cities are:
- Seattle 3.4
- San Francisco 6.1
- Portland 4.2
- Las Vegas 8.1
- Denver 7.8
The most religious
- Kansas City 23.0
- Houston 13.3
- Milwaukee 24.2
- Dallas 10.4
- Charlotte 6.9
Other lists are a little different:
https://www.citylab.com/equity/2013/04/americas-most-and-least-religious-metro-areas/5180/
But the pattern is the same. Generally speaking, low-religiosity cities tend to be in good shape (Burlington, Boulder, and Manchester), while high-religiosity cities tend to be in rough shape, like Montgomery, Jackson, and Birmingham (Mormon cities being the big exception).
Last edited: