New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Religious discrimination?

NightSwimmer

Senator
Do Seers have an inalienable right to practice their craft?


Psychics say soothsaying laws unfair to believers

By JENNIFER PELTZ
Associated Press


NEW YORK (AP) -- They're in a mystical business with few guarantees, so perhaps anyone could foresee tension between psychics and the law.

In two prominent examples, self-declared clairvoyants were recently convicted of big-money scams in New York and Florida, where one trial featured a romance-writing titan as a victim. But beyond those cases is a history of legal wrestling over fortunetelling, free speech and fraud.

While the recent trials involved general fraud charges, numerous cities and states have laws banning or restricting soothsaying itself.

Authorities say they aim to distinguish between catering to people's interest in the supernatural and conning them. Still, some psychics feel anti-fortunetelling laws are unfair to them and to people who believe seers have something to offer.
 
Isn't it ESP?


ESP?

I'm not familiar with that faith tradition.

If you are asking whether extra-sensory perception is what is being claimed by the various Soothsayers to which these anti-fraud laws apply, then I'd say no. They typically claim to be visited by spirits, rather than claiming that they are reading the thoughts of another person.
 
ESP?

I'm not familiar with that faith tradition.

If you are asking whether extra-sensory perception is what is being claimed by the various Soothsayers to which these anti-fraud laws apply, then I'd say no. They typically claim to be visited by spirits, rather than claiming that they are reading the thoughts of another person.

What religion is "being visited by spirits"?
 
What religion is "being visited by spirits"?

I suspect that many of them are Theosophists. Regardless of their chosen denomination (or lack thereof), I don't see how one could separate spiritual readings from religion.

Christians claim to be possessed by the Holy Spirit. Is that claimed phenomenon one that you would write off as ESP?
 
Do Seers have an inalienable right to practice their craft?


Psychics say soothsaying laws unfair to believers

By JENNIFER PELTZ
Associated Press


NEW YORK (AP) -- They're in a mystical business with few guarantees, so perhaps anyone could foresee tension between psychics and the law.

In two prominent examples, self-declared clairvoyants were recently convicted of big-money scams in New York and Florida, where one trial featured a romance-writing titan as a victim. But beyond those cases is a history of legal wrestling over fortunetelling, free speech and fraud.

While the recent trials involved general fraud charges, numerous cities and states have laws banning or restricting soothsaying itself.

Authorities say they aim to distinguish between catering to people's interest in the supernatural and conning them. Still, some psychics feel anti-fortunetelling laws are unfair to them and to people who believe seers have something to offer.

I say yes, seers have a right to practice their 'craft.' They have as much right to convince people they can speak to the dead (or whatever they're claiming) as practitioners of Scientology have to convince people they have Thetans in them (or whatever it is they really say), since you have to pay for that 'service' just like you do for a seer. People seeking spiritual help, in whatever form they can make themselves believe, have the right to be fleeced of their money as far as I'm concerned. For both seers and Scientologists, the payees get what they pay for (I extend that to all purveyors of a religious/spiritual view, but recognize there's not necessarily as blatant a fee-for-service involved). I reserve the right change my mind if extortion or threats are involved.
 
Laws against allowing psychics to practice their craft is definitely religious discrimination. For both the psychic and the client.
 
Laws against allowing psychics to practice their craft is definitely religious discrimination. For both the psychic and the client.

I put psychics in the same group as faith healers....mostly charlatans
 
I suspect that many of them are Theosophists. Regardless of their chosen denomination (or lack thereof), I don't see how one could separate spiritual readings from religion.

Christians claim to be possessed by the Holy Spirit. Is that claimed phenomenon one that you would write off as ESP?
Isn't theosophy a belief in god? The spirit of my uncle Louie isn't god
 
Isn't theosophy a belief in god? The spirit of my uncle Louie isn't god

According to some religious beliefs, humans may aspire to become Gods. Mormons certainly believe this, and yet they are not required by law to place a sign upon the doors of their temples warning the public that their religious rituals are "for entertainment purposes only".
 
Back
Top