New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Remember this Feeling

You seem to be missing the essential gist. Since the media is our "eyes and ears", the fact of the media being involved is a constant and a useless diversion on your part. Exactly what the Sanford Police did or didn't do, isn't the point. The point is that what they did do, didn't satisfy "the people". It was their obligation to satisfy the people.
No, it is their obligation to enforce the law....
 
This is probably my only first-tier post on the Zimmerman/Martin killing and trial since the story first broke. I'm generally not entertained by news coverage of crimes, so I didn't follow it actively enough to have any strong feelings about it. This post is more of a meta post.

Regardless of what you think really went down and how you feel about the the trial outcome, it's probably worth remembering this feeling, since it most likely puts you in the opposite camp as you're generally in when it comes to the outcomes of criminal trials. More often than not, when someone is fuming about a "clearly guilty" defendant getting off because the rules of our criminal law system are tilted heavily towards the defense, the person fuming is a conservative. I've heard a whole lot of rants, over the years, from right-wingers who despise lawyers who get their clients off on technicalities, or juries that let guilty men walk for cultural reasons (e.g., the OJ Simpson jury). And usually it's liberals, and especially black liberals, who are concerned about the system railroading innocent men to conviction in the absence of proof beyond a reasonable doubt.

In this case, those accustomed positions are reversed for cultural reasons. Most conservatives have felt emotionally attracted to George Zimmerman, who acts as a cultural stand-in for them. And for the same reason, most liberals, and especially blacks, have felt emotionally attracted to Trayvon Martin, in whom they see a proxy for themselves or their children. And so each side finds itself in an usual position, and that could have some value, if we could make ourselves think openly about it. The value I see is not so much for this case, where people are so emotionally entrenched in their positions that reason has shut down, but rather for the next case, where people find themselves back in their more accustomed stance. Maybe the next time some black man stands accused of a crime based on strong circumstantial evidence, "law and order" conservatives will be just a bit more willing to allow the "reasonable doubt" standard to have the very wide breadth it's intended to have. And maybe the next time liberals will be more sensitive to how it feels to others when it seems our system is letting someone get away with murder.

Overall, this incident has been too ugly for much positive to come out of it. But, maybe there will at least be that.





I didn't feel "emotionally attracted to George Zimmerman", who, after all, is a Democrat and Obama supporter. My major objection was to those who claimed to know what they couldn't possibly know: the state of his mind, and Trayvon Martin's mind, on the night in question. Anyone who wasn't there is never going to know for certainty what transpired on that dreadful night. Early in this process, when posters here were pontificating profusely about the certainty of Zimmerman's guilt or innocence, I said I would be content to let a jury decide. Now they have. That part of it is over. Whether you or I like it or not, it's done.

Next will likely come the wrongful death civil suit, where the burden of proof is less than in the criminal case. very good chance the Martin family will prevail there, and be awarded some damages. How much money can compensate for the loss of a son? There is no such amount, but lawyers being lawyers they will arrive at some number, and keep a good chunk of it for themselves. Quite unlikely Zimmerman has enough wealth to pay that bill.

I see you have decided Zimmerman is a murderer. He may be, but I don't know that. If you're honest with yourself, you'll realize you don't know either, and likely never will. Unsettling to be sure, but nonetheless true.
 
I'm not saying I think he's a murderer. I'm just saying that those who do think that should keep that in mind the next time they find themselves on the opposite side of an issue like this.
 
I'm not saying I think he's a murderer. I'm just saying that those who do think that should keep that in mind the next time they find themselves on the opposite side of an issue like this.


Ah. In that case, I take it back.
 
This is probably my only first-tier post on the Zimmerman/Martin killing and trial since the story first broke. I'm generally not entertained by news coverage of crimes, so I didn't follow it actively enough to have any strong feelings about it. This post is more of a meta post.

Regardless of what you think really went down and how you feel about the the trial outcome, it's probably worth remembering this feeling, since it most likely puts you in the opposite camp as you're generally in when it comes to the outcomes of criminal trials. More often than not, when someone is fuming about a "clearly guilty" defendant getting off because the rules of our criminal law system are tilted heavily towards the defense, the person fuming is a conservative. I've heard a whole lot of rants, over the years, from right-wingers who despise lawyers who get their clients off on technicalities, or juries that let guilty men walk for cultural reasons (e.g., the OJ Simpson jury). And usually it's liberals, and especially black liberals, who are concerned about the system railroading innocent men to conviction in the absence of proof beyond a reasonable doubt.

In this case, those accustomed positions are reversed for cultural reasons. Most conservatives have felt emotionally attracted to George Zimmerman, who acts as a cultural stand-in for them. And for the same reason, most liberals, and especially blacks, have felt emotionally attracted to Trayvon Martin, in whom they see a proxy for themselves or their children. And so each side finds itself in an usual position, and that could have some value, if we could make ourselves think openly about it. The value I see is not so much for this case, where people are so emotionally entrenched in their positions that reason has shut down, but rather for the next case, where people find themselves back in their more accustomed stance. Maybe the next time some black man stands accused of a crime based on strong circumstantial evidence, "law and order" conservatives will be just a bit more willing to allow the "reasonable doubt" standard to have the very wide breadth it's intended to have. And maybe the next time liberals will be more sensitive to how it feels to others when it seems our system is letting someone get away with murder.

Overall, this incident has been too ugly for much positive to come out of it. But, maybe there will at least be that.


As I see it, it wouldn't matter to me if the skin colors/roles were reversed, it was white on white, black on black, etc, the underlying problem is the SYG laws that make it too damn easy to kill someone and get away with it these days -- if you're white anyway. That was one of the primary reasons the case achieved the attention it did to begin with.

That it was a grown man and wouldbe "toughguy" that allegedly practiced MMA a few nights a week, had a history of racism, etc, that killed a kid, makes it all the harder to swallow.
 
Back
Top