New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ridiculing the Prophet

Arkady

President
I just read a piece from a few years ago, following an earlier extremist Muslim attack on the same Paris newspaper, in which the author engages in some "victim blaming." Although he goes out of his way to make it clear that nothing justifies the violence, he does use the violence as an occasion to chastise the satirists for pointlessly provoking Muslims. Although I get where he's coming from, I think it sends a terrible message to level such a criticism directly following an attack like that.

Sure, I can see a strong argument to be made that people should lay off these attempts to get a rise out of extremist Muslims. Their whole movement is fueled by a sense of outrage and martyrdom, so handing them a way to feel put-upon by society is just going to feed their worst impulses. You kill religious extremism by boring it to death, not by inviting it to a no-holds-barred culture clash. But that's an argument for another time. In the wake of an actual violent attack, blaming the victim is absurd. The victim of the attack deserves sympathy unpolluted by any reproach, and the perpetrators deserve condemnation without even the slightest hint of mutual wrong.
 
I just read a piece from a few years ago, following an earlier extremist Muslim attack on the same Paris newspaper, in which the author engages in some "victim blaming." Although he goes out of his way to make it clear that nothing justifies the violence, he does use the violence as an occasion to chastise the satirists for pointlessly provoking Muslims. Although I get where he's coming from, I think it sends a terrible message to level such a criticism directly following an attack like that.

Sure, I can see a strong argument to be made that people should lay off these attempts to get a rise out of extremist Muslims. Their whole movement is fueled by a sense of outrage and martyrdom, so handing them a way to feel put-upon by society is just going to feed their worst impulses. You kill religious extremism by boring it to death, not by inviting it to a no-holds-barred culture clash. But that's an argument for another time. In the wake of an actual violent attack, blaming the victim is absurd. The victim of the attack deserves sympathy unpolluted by any reproach, and the perpetrators deserve condemnation without even the slightest hint of mutual wrong.

Well said, but once again it must sadden you to see so many of your fellow progreSSives disagreeing with you.
 
I just read a piece from a few years ago, following an earlier extremist Muslim attack on the same Paris newspaper, in which the author engages in some "victim blaming." Although he goes out of his way to make it clear that nothing justifies the violence, he does use the violence as an occasion to chastise the satirists for pointlessly provoking Muslims. Although I get where he's coming from, I think it sends a terrible message to level such a criticism directly following an attack like that.

Sure, I can see a strong argument to be made that people should lay off these attempts to get a rise out of extremist Muslims. Their whole movement is fueled by a sense of outrage and martyrdom, so handing them a way to feel put-upon by society is just going to feed their worst impulses. You kill religious extremism by boring it to death, not by inviting it to a no-holds-barred culture clash. But that's an argument for another time. In the wake of an actual violent attack, blaming the victim is absurd. The victim of the attack deserves sympathy unpolluted by any reproach, and the perpetrators deserve condemnation without even the slightest hint of mutual wrong.

If people back down a little, more will be demanded.
This is not about them being offended by some non-offensive cartoon. It's about them moving in a certain direction. If they try to take a step (as they did today) and that step is ceded to them, they will assume that ground and take another step until they control everything.
 
If people back down a little, more will be demanded.
This is not about them being offended by some non-offensive cartoon. It's about them moving in a certain direction. If they try to take a step (as they did today) and that step is ceded to them, they will assume that ground and take another step until they control everything.
Many feel that way about religious extremists in this country, too. For example, if you try to placate them by agreeing to a ban on the intact dilation and extraction abortion procedure, they'll assume that ground and take another step until they're controlling everyone's complete sex life.
 
Many feel that way about religious extremists in this country, too. For example, if you try to placate them by agreeing to a ban on the intact dilation and extraction abortion procedure, they'll assume that ground and take another step until they're controlling everyone's complete sex life.

Yes. I can see that some people in this country feel that way.
Sometimes it is warranted, most times, not so much.
My post was specifically pointed toward the threat of violence if people aren't given that step they want to take. That is never done by religious groups in this country. If it is done by fringe groups that claim some religion, even religious people stand up and condemn it.

So your comparison here is invalid - despite Leftists' constant attempts to convince us that they are true and valid.
 
Many feel that way about religious extremists in this country, too. For example, if you try to placate them by agreeing to a ban on the intact dilation and extraction abortion procedure, they'll assume that ground and take another step until they're controlling everyone's complete sex life.

I know you're into moral equivalencies, but I'd be much more concerned about getting shot, blown up or beheaded than about what kind of birth control is available...
Yes. I can see that some people in this country feel that way.
Sometimes it is warranted, most times, not so much.
My post was specifically pointed toward the threat of violence if people aren't given that step they want to take. That is never done by religious groups in this country. If it is done by fringe groups that claim some religion, even religious people stand up and condemn it.

So your comparison here is invalid - despite Leftists' constant attempts to convince us that they are true and valid.

Moral equivalencies like the ones Arkady tries to pull are rarely very convincing, at least among intelligent people...
 
I know you're into moral equivalencies, but I'd be much more concerned about getting shot, blown up or beheaded than about what kind of birth control is available...


Moral equivalencies like the ones Arkady tries to pull are rarely very convincing, at least among intelligent people...

It takes a certain kind of stupid to believe in that sort of moral equivalency. Your post here is spot on, marvin.
 
Yes. I can see that some people in this country feel that way.
Sometimes it is warranted, most times, not so much.
My post was specifically pointed toward the threat of violence if people aren't given that step they want to take. That is never done by religious groups in this country. If it is done by fringe groups that claim some religion, even religious people stand up and condemn it.

So your comparison here is invalid - despite Leftists' constant attempts to convince us that they are true and valid.
In that sense, it's similar to Islam -- Muslim leaders have stood up and condemned this attack by a fringe group that claims their religion.
 
which ones?


Here:

The head of the French Muslim Council (CFCM) has condemned the deadly shooting on a popular satirical newspaper by three suspected Islamic extremists, calling it a "declaration of war". - See more at: http://www.straitstimes.com/news/wo...declaration-war-20150107#sthash.cMz1dQz3.dpuf

http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/01/07/us-france-shooting-idUSKBN0KG0Y120150107

There's plenty across the US who have done the same, and the whole of Europe. With the exception of the fringe Islamic radicals, most have or will condemn the attack. Vice versa the national front in Germany has taken a hold of it to further "strengthen" their views of hatred, and fascists society mentality.
 
Here:

The head of the French Muslim Council (CFCM) has condemned the deadly shooting on a popular satirical newspaper by three suspected Islamic extremists, calling it a "declaration of war". - See more at: http://www.straitstimes.com/news/wo...declaration-war-20150107#sthash.cMz1dQz3.dpuf

http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/01/07/us-france-shooting-idUSKBN0KG0Y120150107

There's plenty across the US who have done the same, and the whole of Europe. With the exception of the fringe Islamic radicals, most have or will condemn the attack. Vice versa the national front in Germany has taken a hold of it to further "strengthen" their views of hatred, and fascists society mentality.

How about Non-European and Non-American leaders?

Like, ones from actual Muslim countries?
 
I heard some discussion on this today, and I wonder what would happen if every small town, middle-sized town and large city in the WORLD published the same Mohammed cartoon in ALL of their media--including newspapers, TV, etc.--just to prove that terrorism would NOT stop freedom of speech. The results could be interesting to say the least.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
after watching the video, im pretty sure if the guy with the camera had been looking down the barrel of a ar-15 with a 30 rd. clip instead,,,, dead bang one,,,, and the two down the street,,oh yea,,,cut em up...but france has pretty strict gun ontrol laws,,,just so something like this couldnt happen...
 
Iran:

http://en.shafaqna.com/topnews/item/39471-iran-condemned-paris-attack.html

Saudi Arabia:

http://en.shafaqna.com/topnews/item/39472-saudi-arabia-paris-attack-is-incompatible-with-islam.html

Egypt, Turkey, and Palestine:

http://www.wsj.com/articles/muslim-...n-anti-islamic-sentiment-in-europe-1420654885


Iraq and Yemen also did so to my knowledge, I can see if I can find the articles. I am sure Kuwait, Jordan, and Pakistan did also, as they rely on western aid, and realize the futility of religious extremism.
 
after watching the video, im pretty sure if the guy with the camera had been looking down the barrel of a ar-15 with a 30 rd. clip instead,,,, dead bang one,,,, and the two down the street,,oh yea,,,cut em up...but france has pretty strict gun ontrol laws,,,just so something like this couldnt happen...
And, as you know, gun deaths are vastly less common in France than the US. Hard to argue with success.
 
Iran:

http://en.shafaqna.com/topnews/item/39471-iran-condemned-paris-attack.html

Saudi Arabia:

http://en.shafaqna.com/topnews/item/39472-saudi-arabia-paris-attack-is-incompatible-with-islam.html

Egypt, Turkey, and Palestine:

http://www.wsj.com/articles/muslim-...n-anti-islamic-sentiment-in-europe-1420654885


Iraq and Yemen also did so to my knowledge, I can see if I can find the articles. I am sure Kuwait, Jordan, and Pakistan did also, as they rely on western aid, and realize the futility of religious extremism.
The conservatives here get their news from the Murdoch tabloid empire, and the right wing websites, so they are sheltered from any news that doesn't fit the conservative narrative. Stories of Muslim leaders all around the world condemning an attack like this doesn't fit the narrative, which prefers to lump all Muslims into one extremist camp, so it isn't covered.
 
I just read a piece from a few years ago, following an earlier extremist Muslim attack on the same Paris newspaper, in which the author engages in some "victim blaming." Although he goes out of his way to make it clear that nothing justifies the violence, he does use the violence as an occasion to chastise the satirists for pointlessly provoking Muslims. Although I get where he's coming from, I think it sends a terrible message to level such a criticism directly following an attack like that.

Sure, I can see a strong argument to be made that people should lay off these attempts to get a rise out of extremist Muslims. Their whole movement is fueled by a sense of outrage and martyrdom, so handing them a way to feel put-upon by society is just going to feed their worst impulses. You kill religious extremism by boring it to death, not by inviting it to a no-holds-barred culture clash. But that's an argument for another time. In the wake of an actual violent attack, blaming the victim is absurd. The victim of the attack deserves sympathy unpolluted by any reproach, and the perpetrators deserve condemnation without even the slightest hint of mutual wrong.

yeah we get it shut up and don't invite them to wanna attack a liberal rag mag like charlie...Maybe your right...lefty oughtta keep his mouth shut...But I say screw' em. lefty's big mouth won us the House and Senate...and if they wanna come get me...let em..." I know you and lefty liberal aint gonna stop them.
 
Back
Top