Arkady
President
I just read a piece from a few years ago, following an earlier extremist Muslim attack on the same Paris newspaper, in which the author engages in some "victim blaming." Although he goes out of his way to make it clear that nothing justifies the violence, he does use the violence as an occasion to chastise the satirists for pointlessly provoking Muslims. Although I get where he's coming from, I think it sends a terrible message to level such a criticism directly following an attack like that.
Sure, I can see a strong argument to be made that people should lay off these attempts to get a rise out of extremist Muslims. Their whole movement is fueled by a sense of outrage and martyrdom, so handing them a way to feel put-upon by society is just going to feed their worst impulses. You kill religious extremism by boring it to death, not by inviting it to a no-holds-barred culture clash. But that's an argument for another time. In the wake of an actual violent attack, blaming the victim is absurd. The victim of the attack deserves sympathy unpolluted by any reproach, and the perpetrators deserve condemnation without even the slightest hint of mutual wrong.
Sure, I can see a strong argument to be made that people should lay off these attempts to get a rise out of extremist Muslims. Their whole movement is fueled by a sense of outrage and martyrdom, so handing them a way to feel put-upon by society is just going to feed their worst impulses. You kill religious extremism by boring it to death, not by inviting it to a no-holds-barred culture clash. But that's an argument for another time. In the wake of an actual violent attack, blaming the victim is absurd. The victim of the attack deserves sympathy unpolluted by any reproach, and the perpetrators deserve condemnation without even the slightest hint of mutual wrong.