New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Rules suggestion.

I'm not fond of most rules on forums like this. I don't care if I get called a "racist," etc. It's not my forum, but if it were, my rules would focus on usability. Having someone call me even the most vicious of names doesn't make the forum less usable for me, so I don't care about it. What I care about are things that make the forum harder to use, or which otherwise waste time or make it hard to track substantive discussions.

For example, people should not over-indulge in top posts, since it sometimes scrolls other posts away before discussion can develop. Another example of something hurting usability was a poster who would mechanically go through and "rate" my posts negatively without reading them: sometimes dozens in the course of a few minutes. That makes the rating system useless, since it no longer reflects actual opinions about the posts, and is instead just a way to vent emotions about the posters. Yet another example is a poster who regularly calls me out in threads where I'm not even participating, and which have nothing to do with me (e.g., insulting another poster's intelligence and referencing me in passing, with an "at-Arkady" coding that makes sure it shows up in my alerts). That makes the forum less usable, since the alerts no longer are a good way to spot instances where one's views are genuinely being discussed or solicited.

Most forum censorship just strikes me as a way to shelter overly delicate feelings, and I have no use for it. But if we're going to have censorship, wouldn't it be better to focus is on behaviors that actually hurt the function of the forum?
Here's a rule suggestion everytime you lie go fvck yourself. hows that for a rule?
 
Check this out...Those here who hate my guts (boo hoo) tell me that I am full of hate, etc. etc. YET...check out these stats as of awhile ago. @Dawg claims there are no "negative" ratings. That's bull...the Dislike and Disagree are both considered (-) Negative. They give themselves the plus' ratings.
I hold the record for over 10,000 negative ratings given to me. That's how I earned my banner. BUT...look how many I've given out. Odd for someone so negative and full of hate to give out so few compared to the ankle biters, rate and run posters.

clear.png
Dislikes received.... 8,049 37

Disagree's received 2,633 2

But I've only given out 37 Dislikes and 2 Disagrees TOTAL in all these years.

But I sure as hell dislike or disagree with them more than that, but not enough to bother. I guess that shows I'm hated more than I hate them. Odd, it sure as hell doesn't keep me awake at night. I could do the same thing...slither through the threads without reading the posts and rate them. I guess I don't hate them enough to waste my time like they do. I just don't care. In fact I LOVE them hating me. I want all vermin to hate me.

Instead of MORE hate infested rating buttons, we need a "Report" button. Every time you report someone you should have to state why and it should show up. What do you bet, that would stop a lot of the incessant reporting. But we wouldn't want to "embarrass" them. When I saw that they wanted a "Dumb" button again, I had to laugh. Who cares if they think our posts are dumb? I'm surprised at least one of them doesn't call for "Beautiful" or "Ugly" buttons so they could mark us all Ugly. We'd have to post our ugly faces to make them feel better about themselves, they're so damn needy. They sound so insecure and "Trumpish".

There is NO rating any longer that gives you a negative rating. NONE. They are all positive except 3 of them, which are all neutral. Look on your own profile page, then tell us which ones you've received that are negative! This was changed a long time ago and already discussed. Doesn't it suck to be wrong, again?
 
Been there, done that, and got banned for my efforts.

Good Luck !

You should banned. You are the only poster I have ever reported because you did the scummiest thing anyone can do, you quoted me and then completely rewrote what I said.

I can only hope the rest of the board is aware of you doing this.
 
Another example of something hurting usability was a poster who would mechanically go through and "rate" my posts negatively without reading them: sometimes dozens in the course of a few minutes.
Maybe you could try writing better posts. Then people might not feel the need to rate you negatively.

You're welcome. :)
 
How do you know anyone "mechanically" goes through posts and rates them without reading them?

The time signatures made it clear. We weren't talking about a situation where three or four posts in a given thread were negatively rated in a short period. If that's all it was, it would be possible the person read through the thread then quickly went back and rated its posts. Instead, it was more like sixty posts across dozens of threads being negatively rated in the course of just a few minutes -- basically, just the amount of time it would take to open them and hit the rating button, one after another.

Even if the person had actually read them all, which I'm sure didn't happen, remembering the contents of all of them to know whether or not it was a genuine "disagree," without at least taking a while for a memory refresh would have been impossible. And many of the posts weren't things a person could reasonably have disagreed with, as they simply stated a verifiable fact, provided some personal information, or expressed a non-controversial certainty. The poster wasn't attempting to express disagreement with the contents of the posts, but instead to express personal dislike, regardless of what I said in a given post.

Is tagging you in a thread really "calling" you out?

The semantics of it don't interesting me. Call it what you will.

I see it as they want your attention to respond to what's being talked about.

I'm fine with people who use tags that way. If someone genuinely wants to know what I think about something, or to draw my attention to a matter I might find interesting, that's great. Here's an example of a good use of a tag:

https://www.politicaljack.com/threa...power-has-been-political.107094/#post-2029552

Resident Evil clearly wanted to engage me in a debate about the feasability of sequestering ambient carbon, and tagged me in a thread I wasn't involved in. Whether he really wanted to know my thoughts or just wanted to yank my chain, I don't know, but either way it's an appropriate way to use the tagging system.... it helped to stimulate good political debate, which is the whole point of this forum.

And that good use of tags is exactly why the bad use is problematic -- it often makes me ignore tags altogether, thereby overlooking the good ones. The bad uses I'm talking about are instances where the tag is simply meant to annoy, with no expectation that it will foster substantive debate. For example, Marvin has a tendency, whenever a liberal posts something he thinks is dumb, to tag me with a comment like "maybe you should talk to @Arkady about putting you on his smart-poster list." For example:

https://www.politicaljack.com/threa...-beaten-by-justin-bieber.107210/#post-2033093
https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/donald-trump-says-they-like-me.107111/#post-2030416
https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/donald-trump-want-sexy-nurses.107054/#post-2028424

That's not meant to foster debate with me, nor is it a genuine belief on his part that the matter being discussed would interest me. Or he'll tag me will a lie about something I've said, just to troll me. For example, here he claims I pulled all my money out of the markets right before the election, when he knows perfectly well that I didn't (and, in fact, has criticized me for not doing so):

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/so-lets-recap-trumps-first-year.107049/#post-2028262

That's designed to troll a reaction from me if I don't want his deliberate lie to be mistaken for true information by whoever he's communicating with.

Some posters also use "quoting" that way, too -- quoting me as saying something, when the statement is months old and has no relevance to the thread, merely to troll a reaction.

You worry too much about others.....

What I care about is making this forum conducive to substantive debate. As I said in the top post, I don't care if people want to call me the most vicious names they can think of, because that does nothing to diminish the usability of the forum, and I don't care what such people think. But what I do care about are patterns of behavior that make the forum less useful for political debates, such as behaviors that largely negate the usefulness of the ratings and tagging features. I've already turned off the rating notifications entirely, because they were just crowded with mechanical ratings. And that's too bad, because if they were used only for genuine ratings, it would be useful to look at them and see what various posters honestly thought about something I posted. The abuse of the feature has effectively eliminated the feature entirely for me.
 
"For example, people should not over-indulge in top posts, since it sometimes scrolls other posts away before discussion can develop"

I think you've concisely demonstrated why we're all happy you don't make the rules.

your immediate impulse always seems to be censorship and suppression.
 
Maybe you could try writing better posts. Then people might not feel the need to rate you negatively.
I don't mind genuine negative posts. In fact, I encourage them, if people genuinely disagree with what I posted. I find them particularly useful when someone I respect disagrees with something I posted, because it gives me cause to reconsider what I wrote and see if it really holds up.

My issue is with those who use the posting system mechanically -- hitting "agree" or "disagree" not based on the contents of a given post, but instead simply on the identity of the poster.

In addition to the kinds of "carpet bombing" of disagrees that I discussed above (60 disagrees in just a couple minutes, such that there's no way the material was read before rating), there are also all the times I see something "disagreed" with where there's simply no rational way the person actually disagrees with what was written, because it consists of nothing but non-controversial statement of fact. For example, I might reply with something like "Robert Mueller was appointed in May of this year." Yet I'll find several "disagrees" all from conservatives, even though the only statement in my post was that simple fact, which presumably none of them are actually disputing. Here's a recent example (see post 11 in the thread):

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/mueller-crosses-trumps-red-line.106565/page-2#post-2013222

Tore-Pete-O had asked what Mueller was hired to do. I gave him a very nearly verbatim quotation of Mueller's assignment, taken directly from the letter appointing him to the job, and yet Tore-Pete-O hit "disagree." Did he really "disagree," with the simple factual statement, or did he just mechanically hit "disagree" because of the partisan politics?

Many posters are clearly not using the system the way it's intended, to express agreement or disagreement with a given post, but rather simply to express like or dislike for a given poster, which is useless.
 
I'm not fond of most rules on forums like this. I don't care if I get called a "racist," etc. It's not my forum, but if it were, my rules would focus on usability. Having someone call me even the most vicious of names doesn't make the forum less usable for me, so I don't care about it. What I care about are things that make the forum harder to use, or which otherwise waste time or make it hard to track substantive discussions.

For example, people should not over-indulge in top posts, since it sometimes scrolls other posts away before discussion can develop. Another example of something hurting usability was a poster who would mechanically go through and "rate" my posts negatively without reading them: sometimes dozens in the course of a few minutes. That makes the rating system useless, since it no longer reflects actual opinions about the posts, and is instead just a way to vent emotions about the posters. Yet another example is a poster who regularly calls me out in threads where I'm not even participating, and which have nothing to do with me (e.g., insulting another poster's intelligence and referencing me in passing, with an "at-Arkady" coding that makes sure it shows up in my alerts). That makes the forum less usable, since the alerts no longer are a good way to spot instances where one's views are genuinely being discussed or solicited.

Most forum censorship just strikes me as a way to shelter overly delicate feelings, and I have no use for it. But if we're going to have censorship, wouldn't it be better to focus is on behaviors that actually hurt the function of the forum?

I think that racist is a free speech term and should not be banned.....I also love a good knock down dragout posting war...though it might be a bit much for the eyes of minors I suppose.

And for rating.....I don't think it would be that difficult to require some kind of participation lock out...like a reply....before being allowed to rate something. Not a bad Idea really....it's probably impossible to require a full read first...how could one possibly determine that?

All in all...not a bad post....pretty good suggestions IMO.

JO
 
"For example, people should not over-indulge in top posts, since it sometimes scrolls other posts away before discussion can develop"

I think you've concisely demonstrated why we're all happy you don't make the rules.

your immediate impulse always seems to be censorship and suppression.

Well to be honest I think that fifty percent of the Top posts are made by a sock puppet Trio and to keep the rules honorably I shall not list the monikers. I do think that there's one author that uses those monikers like a forum bulldozer and should be limited to one or two top posts a day where in my estimation this particular poster makes 10-12 a day and does indeed push the page out of sight quite on purpose.

JO
 
Well to be honest I think that fifty percent of the Top posts are made by a sock puppet Trio and to keep the rules honorably I shall not list the monikers. I do think that there's one author that uses those monikers like a forum bulldozer and should be limited to one or two top posts a day where in my estimation this particular poster makes 10-12 a day and does indeed push the page out of sight quite on purpose.

JO
I don't disagree. last month I spent a minute responding to all of bugsy's posts that day, to ensure (however briefly) they would all be sequentially displayed at the top.

he skirts the no man's land between "naked links" on the one hand, and outright lies/defamation on the other. this is a person with no life.
 
"For example, people should not over-indulge in top posts, since it sometimes scrolls other posts away before discussion can develop"

I think you've concisely demonstrated why we're all happy you don't make the rules.

your immediate impulse always seems to be censorship and suppression.
I don't want to see censorship. I'd like to see some self control. And I try to live by the rules I believe in myself. Occasionally I'll post three or four top posts on a given day, if I have three or four things I want to discuss, but that's very rare, because I realize that over-use of the top post slot crowds out other posts, especially on busy days. In the last two weeks, I have posted seven top posts -- one every other day.

You can also check and see that I use the rating system the way I've suggested I'd like to see it used: I use it fairly sparingly to express actual agreement or like of a post (I nearly always avoid negative ratings). That way my ratings don't crowd people's notices, and they can see only the times something really elicited a response from me.
 
I think that racist is a free speech term and should not be banned.....I also love a good knock down dragout posting war...though it might be a bit much for the eyes of minors I suppose.

And for rating.....I don't think it would be that difficult to require some kind of participation lock out...like a reply....before being allowed to rate something. Not a bad Idea really....it's probably impossible to require a full read first...how could one possibly determine that?

All in all...not a bad post....pretty good suggestions IMO.

JO
If the programming difficulty weren't an issue, one possibility would be a timed "income" of ratings -- you'd get an allowance for ratings based on the amount of time the browser was open to one of these pages. If you're here for thirty minutes, an allowance of ten ratings is reasonable, since three minutes per post is a reasonable average for reading them and forming an opinion. If you're here for thirty minutes and want to give sixty ratings, you're not really using the system in a useful way. Putting that kind of speed limit on the process would make people use their ratings more judiciously.
 
I think that racist is a free speech term and should not be banned.....I also love a good knock down dragout posting war...though it might be a bit much for the eyes of minors I suppose.

And for rating.....I don't think it would be that difficult to require some kind of participation lock out...like a reply....before being allowed to rate something. Not a bad Idea really....it's probably impossible to require a full read first...how could one possibly determine that?

All in all...not a bad post....pretty good suggestions IMO.

JO
Best idea ever. Would stop the slinking through the threads and rating posts but not participating in the dialogue. There's one in particular who has done that for a long time. But then I wouldn't have my banner for my over 10,000 negative ratings by the trolls.
 
There is NO rating any longer that gives you a negative rating. NONE. They are all positive except 3 of them, which are all neutral. Look on your own profile page, then tell us which ones you've received that are negative! This was changed a long time ago and already discussed. Doesn't it suck to be wrong, again?
I'm talking about the Dislike and Disagree ratings. If you want to call them Neutral...BREAK A LEG. But when you view this page... https://www.politicaljack.com/members/ you can see that there are numbers (marked in red) ..Not only is the number marked in
RED, it has a - before it. That symbol...- is a MINUS sign. Minus...means negative.
I guess if you and your friends were bitching about not getting ratings like DUMB or F*CK OFF or something else one of the Mods or SW might have told you that none of the others were negative. I don't consider either Dislike or Disagree (neutral) myself. BUT you might tell them that the red negative numbers shown on the "members" page certainly do show show negativity. Maybe they can make it like "racism". You can post all the posts you want that shows racism, but nobody is allowed to call you what you are. Have fun trying to understand that. I could put parenthesis around it so you'll think it's a quote, but don't want to take the time. Others would realize quotation marks aren't parenthesis.

Doesn't it make you feel good to stalk someone continuously, trying to cause a cat fight or give you some reason to get them banned again?
maxresdefault.jpg
 
"For example, people should not over-indulge in top posts, since it sometimes scrolls other posts away before discussion can develop"

I think you've concisely demonstrated why we're all happy you don't make the rules.

your immediate impulse always seems to be censorship and suppression.

Always and eternally. It's the lefty religion.
 
Back
Top