New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Sandra Fluke's Flakey Math

Lapcat

Governor
Sandra Fluke and contraception

In February, Georgetown law student Sandra Fluke was banned from testifying at a congressional panel on birth control; she had been deemed unqualified to testify ona panel that had doctors and nurses. However, last month, she had been the one rebuttal witness allowed to the minority party.

When she was allowed to testify, she tried to make a case that birth control pills will cost $3,000 over the course of a law school career.

Let us for a moment think that over. Where does the $3,000 number come from? Wal-Mart will sell birth control pills for $5 for a month's supply, which equals $60 a year, which equals $240 for four years.

Not to mention: Georgetown Law school is $60,000 a year. Even using Ms. Fluke's numbers, $3,000 a year for three years comes out to $1000 a year -- rather paltry when measured against the tuition rate.

One of the strange things about this affair is that Sandra Fluke researched the uninsurance policy of Georgetown when she first applied, and knew that it was a Catholic institution that does not pay for birth control pills.

“I decided I was absolutely not willing to compromise the quality of my education in exchange for my health care,” Fluke told the Washington Post. Since Fluke arrived, she has spent the past three years lobbying the administration to change its policy.

The majority of Fluke's arguments stated that worried about "health benefits." However, only 14% of users of The Pill use it for non-contraceptive purposes, so saying that over 40% of the students use birth control means that 4%, maybe 5% of the Georgetown campus need it for any actual medical purpose. Assuming her numbers are accurate.

So, easily 35%-40% of these women are using birth control for non-medical purposes (ie: sex). So, why should a Catholic institution pay for that?


More here:

http://www.examiner.com/catholic-in-new-york/sandra-fluke-and-contraception

Full testimony here:

[video]http://cnsnews.com/sites/all/modules/contrib/flowplayer/flowplayer/flowplayer.swf[/video]
 
Sandra Fluke and contraception

In February, Georgetown law student Sandra Fluke was banned from testifying at a congressional panel on birth control; she had been deemed unqualified to testify ona panel that had doctors and nurses. However, last month, she had been the one rebuttal witness allowed to the minority party.

When she was allowed to testify, she tried to make a case that birth control pills will cost $3,000 over the course of a law school career.

Let us for a moment think that over. Where does the $3,000 number come from? Wal-Mart will sell birth control pills for $5 for a month's supply, which equals $60 a year, which equals $240 for four years.

Not to mention: Georgetown Law school is $60,000 a year. Even using Ms. Fluke's numbers, $3,000 a year for three years comes out to $1000 a year -- rather paltry when measured against the tuition rate.

One of the strange things about this affair is that Sandra Fluke researched the uninsurance policy of Georgetown when she first applied, and knew that it was a Catholic institution that does not pay for birth control pills.

“I decided I was absolutely not willing to compromise the quality of my education in exchange for my health care,” Fluke told the Washington Post. Since Fluke arrived, she has spent the past three years lobbying the administration to change its policy.

The majority of Fluke's arguments stated that worried about "health benefits." However, only 14% of users of The Pill use it for non-contraceptive purposes, so saying that over 40% of the students use birth control means that 4%, maybe 5% of the Georgetown campus need it for any actual medical purpose. Assuming her numbers are accurate.

So, easily 35%-40% of these women are using birth control for non-medical purposes (ie: sex). So, why should a Catholic institution pay for that?


More here:

http://www.examiner.com/catholic-in-new-york/sandra-fluke-and-contraception

Full testimony here:

[video]http://cnsnews.com/sites/all/modules/contrib/flowplayer/flowplayer/flowplayer.swf[/video]

I think perhaps your math is flukey LC.

1.in order to get a law school degree, its four years undergraduate plus the three years, so you're talking seven years.

2. the $ 5 dollar per month would be the insurance co pay. The cost of birth control pills would be considerably more if one's insurance didn't cover it, which is what the issue was. I'm guessing it would likely be in the $35-$50 per month range, maybe more. I know that when I was on the pill the cost if I didn't have insurance was $28 per month, and that was several years ago. Prescription costs keep going up, so I don't think $50 is an exaggeration.

3. In order for a doctor to keep prescribing birth control pills, a woman must have a once a gyn exam which also includes a pap. So add another $200, per year, and I think you get close to the $3,000 over a 7 year course of time
 
Back
Top