New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Seriously...

I guess God has decided that He doesn't need to try and inspire me. Not sure which side that comes down on; am I a hopeless case or is it simply not necessary?

I think gigi posts things without thinking some times.....or else she is taking a viewpoint that is completely at odds with her Catholicism.

In fact, it sounds more like Calvinistic Predestination.
 
Here's my difficulty with you...You're as dishonest as the day is long. How can you possibly state there are 30,000 different sects etc...and then try to explain there is not a disparate outlook, that you didn't admit to such?

gigi wrote:


What church are you talking about, Craig? There are over 30,000 different religions, sects, and denominations in this country.

Do we both understand the definition of disparate in the same way? Disparate meaning different, separate, and apart from one another?
 
The contradiction is apparent. But naturally, poses a risk to someone like gigi.

The Schism over "faith, not deeds" or "faith PLUS deeds" is just one example. Now she can argue that's a point of "interpretation", but if it can be interpreted two DIFFERENT ways, then the Bible is NOT "clear and non-vague", is it?

She admits to difference sects and denominations....yet claims the Bible is "consistant or has NO vague elements to it".....then there shouldn't be denominations....in fact, there should ONLY be the Catholic Church (or one Protestant or Orthodox Church).....since no other division would have the ability to claim it is "Biblically based".

Kind of funny, isn't it? There was one church for centuries until some men decided they knew better how to interpret the Bible. And they've been starting over and starting over and starting over ever since. And they're STILL starting over. Can't blame God for that.
 
Do we both understand the definition of disparate in the same way? Disparate meaning different, separate, and apart from one another?

Without question, as exemplified by the vast amount of religions,sects and denominations.

Catholics are separate and different from Mennonites. Shakers are separate and different from Greek Orthodox. The Apostolic are different and separate from the 7th Day Adventists.
 
Kind of funny, isn't it? There was one church for centuries until some men decided they knew better how to interpret the Bible. And they've been starting over and starting over and starting over ever since. And they're STILL starting over. Can't blame God for that.

How can anyone claim to "interpret" something....that you claim is "clear and not vague at all"???

And what makes YOUR version the "right version"...and not theirs? Except opinion?
 
Without question, as exemplified by the vast amount of religions,sects and denominations.

Catholics are separate and different from Mennonites. Shakers are separate and different from Greek Orthodox. The Apostolic are different and separate from the 7th Day Adventists.

And this is what makes me dishonest? What do all these religions you mentioned have in common? One God, the same God. Not separate different Gods apart from one another. And this is how the conversation got started...
 
I admitted the Word of God has created a disparate outlook? I don't think so, Craig. Nor did I speak for all of Christianity. You tried to have me do that on the other thread. And I guess you're just manufacturing at this point.


Perhaps not in this thread, but I've seen you make the pronouncement that there are 30,000 different varieties of Christianity in at least two other threads. I don't know if that number is accurate, but I do know that you have said it more than once, when it was a convenient argument for you to offer. You use different arguments in different situations. You have no consistency in your own beliefs. Consistency is even more difficult to find in the beliefs of any given group of people who claim to be "Christian".
 
Kind of funny, isn't it? There was one church for centuries until some men decided they knew better how to interpret the Bible. And they've been starting over and starting over and starting over ever since. And they're STILL starting over. Can't blame God for that.


There was never one Christian Church, and if there was, it certainly wasn't the Roman Catholic Church.
 
And this is what makes me dishonest? What do all these religions you mentioned have in common? One God, the same God. Not separate different Gods apart from one another. And this is how the conversation got started...

I explained what I believe makes you dishonest.

The commonality doesn't alter the fact that the 30,000 plus religions, sects and denominations have different outlooks and different practices and different interpretations of the same book.

There are 4 major differing povs as to exactly who and what God is; whether Authoritarian, Critical, Benevolent or Distant. From these 4 groups, more splay out.

http://content.time.com/time/interactive/0,31813,1549628,00.html
 
I'd say that you're very far off-base in that assertion.

So you are saying that the Spiritual level of Christian Fundamentalism is other than the Spiritual Level of Islamic Fundamentalism?

Do either actually call themselves Fundamentalists?

My understanding has always been that Religious Fundamentalism is out side the inner Walls/sanctum - that it is of the material even if only in so far as becoming perhaps radically Political.
 
I explained what I believe makes you dishonest.

The commonality doesn't alter the fact that the 30,000 plus religions, sects and denominations have different outlooks and different practices and different interpretations of the same book.

There are 4 major differing povs as to exactly who and what God is; whether Authoritarian, Critical, Benevolent or Distant. From these 4 groups, more splay out.

http://content.time.com/time/interactive/0,31813,1549628,00.html

That's Time Magazine's conclusion that they came to from polling....how many people? And you happen to agree with it. I'm dishonest I guess because I don't agree with it.
 
So you are saying that the Spiritual level of Christian Fundamentalism is other than the Spiritual Level of Islamic Fundamentalism?

Do either actually call themselves Fundamentalists?

My understanding has always been that Religious Fundamentalism is out side the inner Walls/sanctum - that it is of the material even if only in so far as becoming perhaps radically Political.


Yes, Christian Fundamentalists called themselves Fundamentalists. The word eventually came to be seen as a pejorative, and they may have begun to avoid using it then, but they still held to certain fundamentals. Fundamentalists are true believers. They believe in the supernatural aspects of religion that the more mainstream congregations began to shy away from over time out of embarrassment.

It's difficult to assign an exact definition to Christian Fundamentalism, because there are variations in the beliefs of different groups who consider themselves Fundamentalists.
 
That's Time Magazine's conclusion that they came to from polling....how many people? And you happen to agree with it. I'm dishonest I guess because I don't agree with it.

I explained to you why I believe you to be dishonest. It's this game you play...Oh...did I admit??? When you clearly admitted.

Instead of attacking a methodology you have no idea of, why don't you explain where you disagree with the poll's finding?
 
Yes, Christian Fundamentalists called themselves Fundamentalists. The word eventually came to be seen as a pejorative, and they may have begun to avoid using it then, but they still held to certain fundamentals. Fundamentalists are true believers. They believe in the supernatural aspects of religion that the more mainstream congregations began to shy away from over time out of embarrassment.

It's difficult to assign an exact definition to Christian Fundamentalism, because there are variations in the beliefs of different groups who consider themselves Fundamentalists.

And somehow the meaning of the word in connection with Religion has changed with them?

So a Fundamentalist who is a Muslim is still an old fashioned Fundamentalist - who may say they are Spiritually led and all they do is in the name of God -but are actually deluded - but a Fundamentalist who is a Christian is now something different ?
 
I don't know nearly as much about Muslim Fundamentalism as I do about the Christian variety. I do know that the word has evolved into a pejorative and that most folks nowadays use it that way without even caring what it means. Sort of like when people use the word "liberal" as a slur against someone who votes differently from themselves. They don't know, or care, what "liberal" means. It's just another dirty word to them.
 
Fundamentalist Christians are like Libertarians. The former believe that The Bible is absolute. The latter are convinced that "less guvmint" is all good. But....the members of BOTH groups retain the right to make their own personal exceptions to their rules, as they see fit.
 
Back
Top