afella
Mayor
This is more of a hypothetical post, but also an address to religion (general term to all religions) being incorporated into the governance of a people. I chose sharia law because it is perhaps the most extreme example of religious law in the world right now.
I still haven't been able to come to absolute decision on the matter within a community, here in the US. I am an agnostic, but regard religious freedom as the MOST fundamental right of every US citizen. It is, arguably, the driving factor behind civilization over the past 2000 years or so. Science also ranks in the same category, it just drives different issues in our lives. However, religion has been at the forefront of virtually every major event.
Having spent 9 months in Iraq/Kuwait I had a glimpse of a world I couldn't understand, and left me thankful for the life we have here. That doesn't mean that I didn't appreciate what I saw. I respect islam in general, as I respect christianity. I have fundamental differences of opinions with the two, but respect them and their views as much as I can in regards to my own.
Sharia law as it has been practiced across the world, by western civilizations standards would be considered appauling. While culture certainly plays into the mix, sharia law can be excepted with relative ease in mid eastern societies. With an ever evolving and globalized world those ideas, and groups of people who hold those values will undoubtedly immigrate to the US. Our constitution does guarentee a right to religious freedom. If that freedom is guarenteed could it be acceptable for communitees to practice their own form of governance under a religious pretext?
Take for example Jeffs, I wouldn't argue that he commited crimes. However, would a poligamist sect be allowed to function as it pleases, barring the obvious child molestation? Should we restrict it? What do we restrict, to allow people to function as the seem fit within a religious community?
Quite frankly I have a hard time restricting anything, other than child molestation. Murder is also murder and should be treated as such. If a community would want to practice sharia law to some extent, say restict women to being wives and denying them an education, should we break up the community and deny them their religious right of practice? Should we do the same to christians, who preach the bible attend KKK rallies preach hate and act on it?
I ask these questions, because agnostics and athiests are gaining numbers daily and becoming a more dominant factor. I see no reason to disbar religious institutions or communities, or limit their rights to preach what they believe as they see fit. I hold my opinions in the same regard.
I still haven't been able to come to absolute decision on the matter within a community, here in the US. I am an agnostic, but regard religious freedom as the MOST fundamental right of every US citizen. It is, arguably, the driving factor behind civilization over the past 2000 years or so. Science also ranks in the same category, it just drives different issues in our lives. However, religion has been at the forefront of virtually every major event.
Having spent 9 months in Iraq/Kuwait I had a glimpse of a world I couldn't understand, and left me thankful for the life we have here. That doesn't mean that I didn't appreciate what I saw. I respect islam in general, as I respect christianity. I have fundamental differences of opinions with the two, but respect them and their views as much as I can in regards to my own.
Sharia law as it has been practiced across the world, by western civilizations standards would be considered appauling. While culture certainly plays into the mix, sharia law can be excepted with relative ease in mid eastern societies. With an ever evolving and globalized world those ideas, and groups of people who hold those values will undoubtedly immigrate to the US. Our constitution does guarentee a right to religious freedom. If that freedom is guarenteed could it be acceptable for communitees to practice their own form of governance under a religious pretext?
Take for example Jeffs, I wouldn't argue that he commited crimes. However, would a poligamist sect be allowed to function as it pleases, barring the obvious child molestation? Should we restrict it? What do we restrict, to allow people to function as the seem fit within a religious community?
Quite frankly I have a hard time restricting anything, other than child molestation. Murder is also murder and should be treated as such. If a community would want to practice sharia law to some extent, say restict women to being wives and denying them an education, should we break up the community and deny them their religious right of practice? Should we do the same to christians, who preach the bible attend KKK rallies preach hate and act on it?
I ask these questions, because agnostics and athiests are gaining numbers daily and becoming a more dominant factor. I see no reason to disbar religious institutions or communities, or limit their rights to preach what they believe as they see fit. I hold my opinions in the same regard.
