New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Sharia law

afella

Mayor
This is more of a hypothetical post, but also an address to religion (general term to all religions) being incorporated into the governance of a people. I chose sharia law because it is perhaps the most extreme example of religious law in the world right now.

I still haven't been able to come to absolute decision on the matter within a community, here in the US. I am an agnostic, but regard religious freedom as the MOST fundamental right of every US citizen. It is, arguably, the driving factor behind civilization over the past 2000 years or so. Science also ranks in the same category, it just drives different issues in our lives. However, religion has been at the forefront of virtually every major event.


Having spent 9 months in Iraq/Kuwait I had a glimpse of a world I couldn't understand, and left me thankful for the life we have here. That doesn't mean that I didn't appreciate what I saw. I respect islam in general, as I respect christianity. I have fundamental differences of opinions with the two, but respect them and their views as much as I can in regards to my own.


Sharia law as it has been practiced across the world, by western civilizations standards would be considered appauling. While culture certainly plays into the mix, sharia law can be excepted with relative ease in mid eastern societies. With an ever evolving and globalized world those ideas, and groups of people who hold those values will undoubtedly immigrate to the US. Our constitution does guarentee a right to religious freedom. If that freedom is guarenteed could it be acceptable for communitees to practice their own form of governance under a religious pretext?


Take for example Jeffs, I wouldn't argue that he commited crimes. However, would a poligamist sect be allowed to function as it pleases, barring the obvious child molestation? Should we restrict it? What do we restrict, to allow people to function as the seem fit within a religious community?


Quite frankly I have a hard time restricting anything, other than child molestation. Murder is also murder and should be treated as such. If a community would want to practice sharia law to some extent, say restict women to being wives and denying them an education, should we break up the community and deny them their religious right of practice? Should we do the same to christians, who preach the bible attend KKK rallies preach hate and act on it?


I ask these questions, because agnostics and athiests are gaining numbers daily and becoming a more dominant factor. I see no reason to disbar religious institutions or communities, or limit their rights to preach what they believe as they see fit. I hold my opinions in the same regard.
 
This is more of a hypothetical post, but also an address to religion (general term to all religions) being incorporated into the governance of a people. I chose sharia law because it is perhaps the most extreme example of religious law in the world right now.

I still haven't been able to come to absolute decision on the matter within a community, here in the US. I am an agnostic, but regard religious freedom as the MOST fundamental right of every US citizen. It is, arguably, the driving factor behind civilization over the past 2000 years or so. Science also ranks in the same category, it just drives different issues in our lives. However, religion has been at the forefront of virtually every major event.


Having spent 9 months in Iraq/Kuwait I had a glimpse of a world I couldn't understand, and left me thankful for the life we have here. That doesn't mean that I didn't appreciate what I saw. I respect islam in general, as I respect christianity. I have fundamental differences of opinions with the two, but respect them and their views as much as I can in regards to my own.


Sharia law as it has been practiced across the world, by western civilizations standards would be considered appauling. While culture certainly plays into the mix, sharia law can be excepted with relative ease in mid eastern societies. With an ever evolving and globalized world those ideas, and groups of people who hold those values will undoubtedly immigrate to the US. Our constitution does guarentee a right to religious freedom. If that freedom is guarenteed could it be acceptable for communitees to practice their own form of governance under a religious pretext?


Take for example Jeffs, I wouldn't argue that he commited crimes. However, would a poligamist sect be allowed to function as it pleases, barring the obvious child molestation? Should we restrict it? What do we restrict, to allow people to function as the seem fit within a religious community?


Quite frankly I have a hard time restricting anything, other than child molestation. Murder is also murder and should be treated as such. If a community would want to practice sharia law to some extent, say restict women to being wives and denying them an education, should we break up the community and deny them their religious right of practice? Should we do the same to christians, who preach the bible attend KKK rallies preach hate and act on it?


I ask these questions, because agnostics and athiests are gaining numbers daily and becoming a more dominant factor. I see no reason to disbar religious institutions or communities, or limit their rights to preach what they believe as they see fit. I hold my opinions in the same regard.

I think we should enforce our nation's laws to the best of our ability.
 
You hit on the reason for,"Freedom Of Religion," That is what our Country was founded on!

You have the choice to worship,or not to! No one can step on your freedom!

As one who does believe I stand by the firm separation of Church and State! Religion has no place in Government! Too many have abused it,and are still trying to do that today!

I do thank you for your sacrifice for our Country!
 
Agree, I wouldn't like to live under Sharia law. But to say that it is the most extreme of religious laws isn't true. What about the Noahide laws? There are 7 main Noahide laws, and 66 sub laws - the penalty for infringing any of those laws is decapitation.

I'd point out that, unlike Sharia law, Noahide law is legally stated as the bedrock of the US: "The Seven Laws of Noah were recognized by the United States Congress in the preamble to the 1991 bill that established Education Day in honor of the birthday of Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, the leader of the Chabad movement:


Whereas Congress recognizes the historical tradition of ethical values and principles which are the basis of civilized society and upon which our great Nation was founded; Whereas these ethical values and principles have been the bedrock of society from the dawn of civilization, when they were known as the Seven Noahide Laws" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noahide_laws#United_States_Congress
 
I do not even care if they take,'Under God," out of the Pledge. That was put in by Ike. Never in there before.

Now on another subject that will make the left angry. I do not want Gays as Scoutmasters. I wish I could say I am sorry,I am not. The Boy Scouts is a Christian Organization formed in 1912. The USSC has ruled they have the right to choose,and I agree!

What you do in your bedroom is no problem with me. When you insist I have to accept,I disagree!
 


No disagreement. However, what if it is a strictly religious community? Take the amish for example, and those who live in the community are strict adherents to their religious law and accept it. Should the government intervene and impose our laws, and force them to retract their adherence to their own religious laws?
 
No disagreement. However, what if it is a strictly religious community? Take the amish for example, and those who live in the community are strict adherents to their religious law and accept it. Should the government intervene and impose our laws, and force them to retract their adherence to their own religious laws?

These religious communities remain under law. Some exceptions are made for religious considerations, but those are exemptions. Peyote rituals for example...

The Amish still have to follow "imposed" laws. We have a pretty good community of Amish here in Maryland and they are nowhere near as strict as folks tend to believe. The communities separate and compartmentalize their lives extremely well. We have a huge Amish Market nearby. The workers are all Amish and drive to work in cars. They use electric machines and telephones and sell meats subject to federal inspection. They drive their goods to market in modern vehicles that need to have license plates.

There was a recent argument regarding raw milk and the transportation of it across state lines. One can still drive to Pennsylvania and buy raw milk, but the dairy farmers in PA can't bring it into Maryland for sale.
 
Tend to agree, MA; putting a gay guy in charge of a troop of scouts is the same as putting a hetro guy in charge of a troop of girl guides.
 
No disagreement. However, what if it is a strictly religious community? Take the amish for example, and those who live in the community are strict adherents to their religious law and accept it. Should the government intervene and impose our laws, and force them to retract their adherence to their own religious laws?

What law are the Amish breaking? My small city was founded by German Baptist, a close relation,although they use Modern Equipment. My Landscaper belongs. He has even invited me to his Church. The Amish are over my state. I have seen no laws broken.I will say,they serve a great Buffet!

There is no law against Religion. THat is the separation.
 
I do not even care if they take,'Under God," out of the Pledge. That was put in by Ike. Never in there before.

Agreed.

MaryAnne said:
Now on another subject that will make the left angry. I do not want Gays as Scoutmasters. I wish I could say I am sorry,I am not. The Boy Scouts is a Christian Organization formed in 1912. The USSC has ruled they have the right to choose,and I agree!

What you do in your bedroom is no problem with me. When you insist I have to accept,I disagree!

Not sure how wanting to join the Scouts qualifies as insisting that you have to accept what anyone does in his or her bedroom... In any case, according to reports, the Boy Scouts of America are about to choose to admit gay members as both Scouts and troop leaders. If that does in fact happen, then there's no problem, right?

Cheers.
 
Tend to agree, MA; putting a gay guy in charge of a troop of scouts is the same as putting a hetro guy in charge of a troop of girl guides.

I'm not sure what the rules are in Scotland, but here in the U.S. men 18 and above are permitted to be Girl Scout troop leaders. They are required to have a female co-leader, as I understand it. I imagine that's more to allay possible concerns about access to a person who's in a position to understand issues that girls might have related to gender and sex rather than to allay fears about predators. Could be wrong...

In any case, these days most youth organizations understand that policies and procedures need to be in place to minimize the risk of abuse -- policies such as not allowing any adult unaccompanied access to a child and so on. These are the sorts of things that will help keep kids safe. Based on recently-released records, not allowing openly gay men to volunteer or openly gay kids to join certainly hasn't accomplished that goal for the Boy Scouts.

So, what's the problem?

Cheers.
 
Tend to agree, MA; putting a gay guy in charge of a troop of scouts is the same as putting a hetro guy in charge of a troop of girl guides.

Wulk, what is your take on putting women in charge of a troop of scouts, say 14 to 18 years old? It has been happening for years and it has caused some problems locally. Especially at summer camps and week long camping trips.
 
That is so wrong, it is what is wrong, science should not belong to the State.

My, my, strange things do happen. In this particular case I do agree with NS over your comment.

I do not believe that the picture was denoting 'ownership', only where the division should be.
 
I think that all religions, at their core center, are peaceful and pragmatic; it's the outer rims as in any state of mind, where the chaos erupts.

Look, every religion in the world holds the same credos; treat others as you would treat yourself, do kind acts, don't lie, don't steal, don't cheat, these are core values for almost every religion.

Even Hindis who believe in re-incarnation, therefore leave a bit of life to pre-destination, also have a code of conduct, without which you can never evolve to the highest level, Nirvana, and therefore break the cycle of life and death.

BUT, it's the outer edges, the extremes, where ALL religions clash;

There are Christians who believe that Jewish people are "imperfect", that's an outer edge belief

Anyone who is not Muslim is an infidel, that is an outer edge belief

Anyone who violates the inner sanctum of an Orthodox jew, touches a rebbi or a rabbi, is "soiling" judaism, that's an outer edge belief

And the manifestation of beliefs from one place to another is also the stuff of fantasy

Onan was struck dead by the Lord God for spilling his seed on the earth - Hebraic law, Onan was the second son who married his brother's widow, therefore keeping the first born legacy, wealth and property in the family, he spilled his seed on the ground on his wedding night, therefore angered Yahweh, who killed him on the spot

The Christians believe this is a story that promotes the ideal that masturabation is evil and against the law of God.

Simple transmorgification of a Hebraic law turned into a story of convenience

Religions, impose too much on the moderate sensibilities of the average human being, there are specific and simple credos, that can be lived by for all.

But when you start engaging those who take the religiousity to the extreme, you must throw out the religious discussion, and peel back to the core issue;

Extremism,

It's fatal, it's ugly, and it causes self destruction.


Regards
Pace
 
Back
Top