New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Sociaties reacton to rape

http://blogs.independent.co.uk/2012...ety-needs-to-drop-its-sexual-double-standard/

I know this article is of Britain but in many ways we progress along the same social lines.

I am not asking anyone what they think of women who have many partners nor what they them selves feel about rape but .................I feel that in someways we are slideing backwards here and I wonder why. Why does society behave so often as families with an abusive member, putting blame on the victim rather than the abuser ?

Part of it must be that now more rapes are being reported we have to face the problem which has been swept under the carpet for so long but ......................

The complete answer as to why we find it so hard to look at is I think somewhat complicated
 
Societies .....apologies for my spelling lately. Too much time on this contraption lately ...I go a bit cross eyed and so does my spelling.
 
http://blogs.independent.co.uk/2012...ety-needs-to-drop-its-sexual-double-standard/

I know this article is of Britain but in many ways we progress along the same social lines.

I am not asking anyone what they think of women who have many partners nor what they them selves feel about rape but .................I feel that in someways we are slideing backwards here and I wonder why. Why does society behave so often as families with an abusive member, putting blame on the victim rather than the abuser ?

Part of it must be that now more rapes are being reported we have to face the problem which has been swept under the carpet for so long but ......................

The complete answer as to why we find it so hard to look at is I think somewhat complicated

There is a persistent double standard; there's no doubt about that. It pops up all the time, sometimes in the most unexpected places. Ultimately, I think the psychology than underlies the stigma that attaches to rape victims also gives rise to the casual assumption that lesbians don't have real sex. It's all about associating women with being a vessel for the "seed of life", don't you think? No one wants to use a vessel that isn't clean, eh?

'Course, we could get into some of the notions that have been advanced by evolutionary psychologists, notions having to do with the tensions that arise from men "wanting" to control the reproductive activities of women in order to be sure of paternity, women "wanting" to mate with the fittest fathers, and so on. I suppose it's all connected, somehow or other.

Yet more evidence that we tend to feel first, and rationalize later, I reckon.

Cheers.
 
U.S. statistics on rape show that 'stranger rape' - the kind we automatically envision when we hear the word 'rape', e.g. a thug yanking a women down a dark alley, is not as common as we assume. Many rapes are committed by 'dates' or those the victim is familiar with (schoolmates, co-workers, etc). However, the reaction to victims tends to be generally sympathetic. The days of someone muttering "she asked for it" when told a woman has been raped are pretty much gone in most quarters, although, regretfully, there will always be misogynists among us. With many, many TV shows, theater and TV movies, books and magazine articles about the emotional devastation being raped has on a woman, few Americans consider it casually any more. I certainly don't. Anyone 'blaming the victim' (for being raped) is either stupid or simply a male misogynist and rightly shunned by decent folk.
 
There is a persistent double standard; there's no doubt about that. It pops up all the time, sometimes in the most unexpected places. Ultimately, I think the psychology than underlies the stigma that attaches to rape victims also gives rise to the casual assumption that lesbians don't have real sex. It's all about associating women with being a vessel for the "seed of life", don't you think? No one wants to use a vessel that isn't clean, eh?

'Course, we could get into some of the notions that have been advanced by evolutionary psychologists, notions having to do with the tensions that arise from men "wanting" to control the reproductive activities of women in order to be sure of paternity, women "wanting" to mate with the fittest fathers, and so on. I suppose it's all connected, somehow or other.

Yet more evidence that we tend to feel first, and rationalize later, I reckon.

Cheers.

Mmmm that it is so primeval that we are no longer in our sophistication to actually cope with our reaction to it ?
 
Mmmm that it is so primeval that we are no longer in our sophistication to actually cope with our reaction to it ?

Sure. There are a lot of primeval responses that, despite our supposed sophistication, we really don't cope with all that well, don't you think? Training is the key. Cultivating adaptive responses is like training a vine. It's no good trying to stop the flow, but with patience and effort it can be directed into something attractive and useful.

Cheers!
 
U.S. statistics on rape show that 'stranger rape' - the kind we automatically envision when we hear the word 'rape', e.g. a thug yanking a women down a dark alley, is not as common as we assume. Many rapes are committed by 'dates' or those the victim is familiar with (schoolmates, co-workers, etc). However, the reaction to victims tends to be generally sympathetic. The days of someone muttering "she asked for it" when told a woman has been raped are pretty much gone in most quarters, although, regretfully, there will always be misogynists among us. With many, many TV shows, theater and TV movies, books and magazine articles about the emotional devastation being raped has on a woman, few Americans consider it casually any more. I certainly don't. Anyone 'blaming the victim' (for being raped) is either stupid or simply a male misogynist and rightly shunned by decent folk.

You are talking about societies outward reaction to rape. We know that things have changed from those long off days when one never ever thought about going to the Police, blimey that would only get you raped again, in the cells. I know !!!! But though on levels of the emotionally and interlectually educated of society a rape victim is thought of and treated as the victim and yes on TV and in the magazines but is that so of most of society in fact ?
Listening to younger members of society sometimes I am not so sure. Not amongst my circle but just on the bus or the train and the few young people I do talk to now there seems to be a part of the youth culture that is going backwards which means that those already 'not so progessive thinkers' can stay comfy as they are.

I don't know, I have been raped and it is so deeply painful and shocking and such a theft, it truly is primeval, one just wants to curl up like a wounded beast. That is the first reaction to wash,hide and curl up ....... And is it something to do with not curling up and hiding as is the natural instinct but coming out and showing ones wounds that also on a primeval level sets off others reaction to attack the wounded one ?

I'm searching here for something deeper than just the normal PC answer btw :)

I just came across the article and whether it is true or not of most people, it set me to thinking why do people, any people, turn on the wounded especially such a profound wound as rape is, in a time of sexual freedom.
 
Societies .....apologies for my spelling lately. Too much time on this contraption lately ...I go a bit cross eyed and so does my spelling.

Ms. Queen,

Also, it's "societal" not societies, unless you are using the possessive, where it would be "society's." (Techincally, if you are talking about how different societies react to rape, "societies" would be correct, but the more appropriete word is still "societal")

By the by, isn't it wild, we are taught "i before e except after c" then societal influence comes in and throws that wall out?
 
Sure. There are a lot of primeval responses that, despite our supposed sophistication, we really don't cope with all that well, don't you think? Training is the key. Cultivating adaptive responses is like training a vine. It's no good trying to stop the flow, but with patience and effort it can be directed into something attractive and useful.

Cheers!

Yes :) We have fragmented and disconnected parts of ourselves from each other and so no we cannot be happy with our harsh kneejerk reactions to many of societies 'faults'. Cultivating vines would be far more pleasing especially if they were grape vines :) xxxx Lots of love gentle darling xxx I'm off 'up the wooden hill to bed'. I hope you are well and all of those you love too xxxx
 
Ms. Queen,

Also, it's "societal" not societies, unless you are using the possessive, where it would be "society's." (Techincally, if you are talking about how different societies react to rape, "societies" would be correct, but the more appropriete word is still "societal")

By the by, isn't it wild, we are taught "i before e except after c" then societal influence comes in and throws that wall out?

Thank you Mr Ya-ta-hey, I shall now go to bed with an 'unsocietal' smile on my face. Yes it is interesting xxxx

ps there was a fella on Slate who followed me around for a while just because my grammer and spelling so amused ...........:) I am improving though so not quite as much fun any more :(
 
On the one hand, we should never blame the victim; a rapist or abuser has only themselves to blame. On the other hand, we do need to place some responsibility on potential victims to make sure they don't end up with an abuser or rapist.

This means watching for the signs. A woman doesn't marry Prince Charming, only to have him suddenly develop six legs and a crunchy brown exoskeleton one day. What I'm saying is, there are signs that the guy you're dating is an abuser, and when these signs start showing themselves, it's your cue to break it off. Does he lose his temper easily? Is he abusive to animals? How does he treat the staff in a restaurant? His friends? Does he put you down a lot?

I would never suggest that victims should be blamed, but I would suggest that everyone should be acquainted with the signs of an abuser: http://www.helpguide.org/mental/domestic_violence_abuse_types_signs_causes_effects.htm

Because these signs show up, we need to be honest about what we're seeing. Not deny what's happening or making excuses for it. Or thinking that this abuser is about the best we're going to get so we're stuck with it.

And knowing the signs doesn't mean that we can blame the victim if something happens...but we know the signs so we have a better chance of avoiding these things.
 
Patrick,

Yes, we often say afterwards 'I should have known' .....and such like about many things and yes not all of us listen to our instincts or our intuitions as well as we might and yes in some circumstance there are tell tale signs but all that and more wasn't what I was asking :)

Nor what we ourselves thought or felt about it but Why it is that victims of rape are still sometimes turned on..........
 
If as a society we wish to improve attitudes towards the victims of rape – and in doing so improve the number of women who actually come forward to report rape – we should make a start by putting an end to our sexual hypocrisy. The number of men a woman chooses to have sex with is the business of nobody else but her, and is unrelated to morality. More importantly, it in no way compromises a woman’s right to say no – with a boyfriend, a husband or on a one night stand – at any point during any interaction.

It seems an obvious point to make, but rape isn’t caused by anything other than the perpetrator’s decision. Oh, and women like consensual sex too, so grow up and deal with it.

Sick, sad world, Anny.
 
You are talking about societies outward reaction to rape. We know that things have changed from those long off days when one never ever thought about going to the Police, blimey that would only get you raped again, in the cells. I know !!!! But though on levels of the emotionally and interlectually educated of society a rape victim is thought of and treated as the victim and yes on TV and in the magazines but is that so of most of society in fact ?
Listening to younger members of society sometimes I am not so sure. Not amongst my circle but just on the bus or the train and the few young people I do talk to now there seems to be a part of the youth culture that is going backwards which means that those already 'not so progessive thinkers' can stay comfy as they are.

I don't know, I have been raped and it is so deeply painful and shocking and such a theft, it truly is primeval, one just wants to curl up like a wounded beast. That is the first reaction to wash,hide and curl up ....... And is it something to do with not curling up and hiding as is the natural instinct but coming out and showing ones wounds that also on a primeval level sets off others reaction to attack the wounded one ?

I'm searching here for something deeper than just the normal PC answer btw :)

I just came across the article and whether it is true or not of most people, it set me to thinking why do people, any people, turn on the wounded especially such a profound wound as rape is, in a time of sexual freedom.

Queen - First, I am sorry for what you endured, that is truly a horrible thing. Second, I think that people may want to 'blame the victim' or see women who have been raped as 'victims' as a way to protect themselves from being vulnerable. This goes too to Patrick's ideas about how people should react to the first instance of 'off behavior' that fits a 'profile' of an abuser or rapist, and should just get out. This is a common belief, that women should have somehow seen it coming in time to get out. It goes against the very personal experiences of each individual who is in that situation - sure, an outsider may have been able to see the signs, but when one is living it, those signs are mitigated to a greater or lesser degree by the context surrounding the entire relationship, not just the obvious (to an oursider) signs. Nevertheless, the whole 'if she wasn't wearing a short skirt / didn't walk in that neighborhood / hadn't divorced / didn't drink / whatever reason the woman is at least partly to blame for her attack are all motivated by a need to see oneself as not a potential victim because one has not engaged in said behavior.

The fact is that rape is never a victimless (or even a blame-sharing) crime. The taking of another, through violence, is never excused by anything no matter what the woman wore, said, or did. Unless a man considers himself an animal, he always has the choice whether to rape or not. If he chooses to rape, it's ALL on him.
 
Queen - First, I am sorry for what you endured, that is truly a horrible thing. Second, I think that people may want to 'blame the victim' or see women who have been raped as 'victims' as a way to protect themselves from being vulnerable. This goes too to Patrick's ideas about how people should react to the first instance of 'off behavior' that fits a 'profile' of an abuser or rapist, and should just get out. This is a common belief, that women should have somehow seen it coming in time to get out. It goes against the very personal experiences of each individual who is in that situation - sure, an outsider may have been able to see the signs, but when one is living it, those signs are mitigated to a greater or lesser degree by the context surrounding the entire relationship, not just the obvious (to an oursider) signs. Nevertheless, the whole 'if she wasn't wearing a short skirt / didn't walk in that neighborhood / hadn't divorced / didn't drink / whatever reason the woman is at least partly to blame for her attack are all motivated by a need to see oneself as not a potential victim because one has not engaged in said behavior.

The fact is that rape is never a victimless (or even a blame-sharing) crime. The taking of another, through violence, is never excused by anything no matter what the woman wore, said, or did. Unless a man considers himself an animal, he always has the choice whether to rape or not. If he chooses to rape, it's ALL on him.

Bobby, darling I have no problems with the 'the harder times' of my life, it is all a part of the tapestry and I have found many understandings/wisdoms come out of seeing, feeling and even being the 'devils' hand in the great scheme. So I honestly don't tell snippets of my own particular melodrama for sympathy for myself :) Thank you though xxxx But out of trying to find some deeper understanding of us all. My fear is always that as we go two steps forward on one level some on another level are going five steps back. We only have to listen to some of the Rap that young kids are listening too and are a part of their culture to start shaking in our beautiful high heels and short skirts.

I don't actually like this kneejerk of sending so many 'rapists' to prison for a few years putting them on a ridiculous list, that isn't really a list and thats that, hidden from sight. I mean in the 'lesser' degrees of abuse ( one MP nearly lost his job here recently for saying there were degrees of rape but there are ) and then on the other hand those who are preditory and violent and truly dangerous cop a plea and are out in society again within a few years. I mean that society, now that we accept rape openly enough for men and women who are victims of dare to come forward we still don't actually look at it other than to say 'bastard' throw away the key, have a set punishment, and so then we can forget about it. I have problems with dealing with 'ciminals' so anyway, it heals none of our ails.

But that apart, thank you and yes you are right, we do wish 'it haddent happened' and that we don't have to face anothers misery or unhappiness, as with illnesses we don't really want to have to cope with another persons pain, '...the world smiles with us but doesn't cry with us sortta thing' ..... it is just so odd that we so often turn on the victim 'it must have been their fault' in so many circumstances. And that goes for all of our first reactions more often than we care to admit, I think.

Sorry I am babbling on here whilst trying to get to the place where .......we are doing what we have decided to be the right thing before we have come to that place were our feelings or even our philosophies have caught up so whilst we still have those ,even though in most of us on here perhaps fleeting, primeval reactions we don't really question or look at them and so are we doing the right thing ? We say that is bad and so he/she is bad, punish them, even though our culture has not really bought them up to believe that what they did/are was wrong. They are the victim and so we must be kind to them even though a part of us has still a suppressed animal urge not too be. Just questions ....

Enough wanderings of the mind ...good morning :) xxxx
As for blame sharing applied to rape, mmmmm maybe it is also that we find it uncomfortable that 'it' does happen within our 'tribe' and we do ourselves feel either some blame or helplessness or all a little bit of all of the above.
 
Sick, sad world, Anny.

Not all of it my darling friday, not all of it. Perhaps we concentrate more on the sad than we should but is that too 'our fault' ? Is it perhaps because we don't deal with the sad correctly and so it persists. Perhaps if we looked at the sad on a deeper level, strove to understand it more completly that we would be rid of it sooner ? :)

Lots of love xxxx I'm off out into the garden whilst there is a break in the rain falling out of the skies xxxxx
 
You are talking about societies outward reaction to rape. We know that things have changed from those long off days when one never ever thought about going to the Police, blimey that would only get you raped again, in the cells. I know !!!! But though on levels of the emotionally and interlectually educated of society a rape victim is thought of and treated as the victim and yes on TV and in the magazines but is that so of most of society in fact ?
Listening to younger members of society sometimes I am not so sure. Not amongst my circle but just on the bus or the train and the few young people I do talk to now there seems to be a part of the youth culture that is going backwards which means that those already 'not so progessive thinkers' can stay comfy as they are.

I don't know, I have been raped and it is so deeply painful and shocking and such a theft, it truly is primeval, one just wants to curl up like a wounded beast. That is the first reaction to wash,hide and curl up ....... And is it something to do with not curling up and hiding as is the natural instinct but coming out and showing ones wounds that also on a primeval level sets off others reaction to attack the wounded one ?

I'm searching here for something deeper than just the normal PC answer btw :)

I just came across the article and whether it is true or not of most people, it set me to thinking why do people, any people, turn on the wounded especially such a profound wound as rape is, in a time of sexual freedom.

Your interest in this subject is understandable. No one should have to endure that experience (rape) and I'm sorry you did.

Like you, the people I hang out with - responsible adults - do not condone rape or find excuses for it, much less 'blame the victim'.

It's undeniable that our 'culture' has been devolving for years and one result of that is exemplified in your account of hearing young people treat rape all-too casually. Although almost a cliché to mention - and hardly 'PC' - today, all one needs to do is listen to some of the 'harder' forms of hip-hop/rap music to find quite blatant references to rape - and they are not cautionary. Unfortunately, the majority of feminists have not collectively protested this kind of music, although to their credit, individually, some have.

The psychological reasons some people blame the victims of rape are definitely complex with no simple answer. From guilt to misogyny, the reasons are many and sometime illogical. However, when a culture devolves from the staid social mores of the 1950's to the hedonist attitudes of today, when 'hooking up' (casual, meaningless sex) is considered perfectly normal by many people and a girl who is still a virgin at 18 is considered 'uncool' by her peers, that rape is sometimes taken casually by some segments of society and in those precincts the victim considered morally equal to the perpetrator - an illogical equation on it's face - reflects the moral ambiguity our society faces, and, to me, the saddest part of this new reality is that it took less than 50 years to get here.
 
Your interest in this subject is understandable. No one should have to endure that experience (rape) and I'm sorry you did.

Like you, the people I hang out with - responsible adults - do not condone rape or find excuses for it, much less 'blame the victim'.

It's undeniable that our 'culture' has been devolving for years and one result of that is exemplified in your account of hearing young people treat rape all-too casually. Although almost a cliché to mention - and hardly 'PC' - today, all one needs to do is listen to some of the 'harder' forms of hip-hop/rap music to find quite blatant references to rape - and they are not cautionary. Unfortunately, the majority of feminists have not collectively protested this kind of music, although to their credit, individually, some have.

The psychological reasons some people blame the victims of rape are definitely complex with no simple answer. From guilt to misogyny, the reasons are many and sometime illogical. However, when a culture devolves from the staid social mores of the 1950's to the hedonist attitudes of today, when 'hooking up' (casual, meaningless sex) is considered perfectly normal by many people and a girl who is still a virgin at 18 is considered 'uncool' by her peers, that rape is sometimes taken casually by some segments of society and in those precincts the victim considered morally equal to the perpetrator - an illogical equation on it's face - reflects the moral ambiguity our society faces, and, to me, the saddest part of this new reality is that it took less than 50 years to get here.

Thank you angel but again I have not bought up this subject for any personal reasons. That I have known rape gives me an insight into 'it' thats all. Well, yes we do tend to explore that which we know I supose or look at society from our particular advantage point, sortta thing. But many of us pick up a paper as I did yesterday and something brings a question to our mind.

This very point has worried me many times in my life and not just for me or even from being on the side of the victim, I know I have been guilty of thinking, 'it must have been their own fault' 'what were they doing there anyway' and so on. I may not have expressed it and it might have been fleeting but it was there, it is a part of our make up.

It is the seemingly illogical that I am wondering about, I don't believe in it myself. Or rather I don't believe that we cannot even if it is momentary know the 'truth' of a matter.

Thank you for your answer it is a good one, we seek for the truth together ;)

Generations jump, I was more like my Grandparents and my Daughter more like my Parents so a part of this extreme Rap and hip hop have to be my generations unfinished rapsody maybe ? Maybe they are showing us what we left unfinished and the consiquences of not actually finishing that which we started ? I dunno, I am sure that most will grow out of it ........all generations have the same sorts of things within 'our' outrageous behavour ...............This one is frightening though maybe as frightening as James Dean or Valentino ? Maybe the next generation will go back to Byrons and or Liszts?
 
Back
Top