Arkady
President
Since we seldom make any progress convincing one another about controversial policy issues, maybe it would be helpful to focus on some things that should be matters of bipartisan agreement, but which are, unfortunately, often ignored in practice.
Take, for example, the simple principle that the government should be staffed with people who know what they're doing. Although the president, the VP, their immediate political advisers, and the legislators are, necessarily, going to be partisan politicians, the fewer partisan politicians we have in the rest of the government, the better off we are.
For example, when a hurricane is barreling towards you, who do you want heading up FEMA? Should it be a partisan political fundraising hack, whose practical experience is as a horse judge, and who got his job as a "thank you" for his election efforts? Or should it be a non-partisan civil servant, who has years of state-level on-the-job training in emergency management and disaster recovery -- preferably from some disaster-prone region?
Or how about the Attorney General? Should the office be used as a career lifeboat for an extremist politician who was tossed out of his job by the last election, like John Ashcroft? Or should it go to someone with a long career as a prosecutor, state attorney general, district attorney, etc.?
The EPA should be headed by people who have made a career out of protecting the environment -- coming up through the ranks at the EPA, or previously heading up a state environmental agency, not by some career partisan politician looking for a comfy sinecure after ending his run in some elected position.
The Bush Administration is a particularly strong example of what not to do. Even a member of that administration, Republican John Dilulio, famously derided the style as being the rule of the "Mayberry Machievellis." During the Bush years, even roles that had typically been apolitical and technocratic were turned into political patronage jobs, and every decision was being made by the political arm of the administration.
One might almost forgive Bush if he merely put political hacks at the very top of his agencies, out of some over-valuing of partisan loyalty from those who report directly to him. But he plugged unqualified hacks throughout the government, in the kinds of deputy and staffer positions that were previously reserved for those with actual expertise in the subject area. Take Monica Goodling as the poster child for that. She was made a principal deputy director in the Justice Department, despite being a kid with embarrassing academic credentials and almost no legal experience. But she was viewed by the Bushies as loyal, since she'd gone to extremist evangelical universities and had come up in the political world by way of doing opposition research, so she was put in a position of significant power. Once there, she promptly broke the law, in the infamous US Attorneys dismissal controversy (the unprecedented mid-term firing of US attorneys who were investigating Bush administration misconduct).
I'm sure that people can find examples of partisan hackery among Democratic nominees and appointments, too, but traditionally it's much less common on the left. Democratic presidents tend to fall hard for good resumes, and make their picks accordingly. Take a look at the Supreme Court, for example, where part of the reason for the enduring majority Republican appointees have is that Republican presidents pick less distinguished, younger judges, for the partisan advantage of having someone on the court for decades. Clarence Thomas was a newly-minted judge with no notable contributions to jurisprudence when he was nominated by Bush, at age 43. His two major accomplishments were a reputation for extremist conservatism and the color of his skin. Ruth Bader Ginsburg, by comparison, was a 60 year old with 13 years on an appeals court, when she got the nod from Clinton. Stephen Breyer was 56 with 14 years of experience as an appeals court judge. Elena Kagan was unusually young for a Democrat when she was appointed (just 50), but had already been US Solicitor General and Dean of Harvard Law. Sotomayor was 55 and had been a judge for 17 years.
I believe these things have real consequences. When you have a government mostly staffed by technocrats who are more interested in what works than what fits a partisan orthodoxy or repays a political favor, things tend to go well for the country. When the government is run by the Mayberry Machievellis, things tend to go badly. This is one of the reasons that I'm happy Obama won. I disagree with him about a lot of things, but I like the fact that most of the government, on his watch, will be run by people who actually know what they're doing -- people with many years of experience honing their skills and building a knowledge base in relevant lower-level positions, before being entrusted with our fate. I hope that the GOP eventually breaks out of its reflexive political partisanship and patronage game-playing enough to follow that same pattern.
Take, for example, the simple principle that the government should be staffed with people who know what they're doing. Although the president, the VP, their immediate political advisers, and the legislators are, necessarily, going to be partisan politicians, the fewer partisan politicians we have in the rest of the government, the better off we are.
For example, when a hurricane is barreling towards you, who do you want heading up FEMA? Should it be a partisan political fundraising hack, whose practical experience is as a horse judge, and who got his job as a "thank you" for his election efforts? Or should it be a non-partisan civil servant, who has years of state-level on-the-job training in emergency management and disaster recovery -- preferably from some disaster-prone region?
Or how about the Attorney General? Should the office be used as a career lifeboat for an extremist politician who was tossed out of his job by the last election, like John Ashcroft? Or should it go to someone with a long career as a prosecutor, state attorney general, district attorney, etc.?
The EPA should be headed by people who have made a career out of protecting the environment -- coming up through the ranks at the EPA, or previously heading up a state environmental agency, not by some career partisan politician looking for a comfy sinecure after ending his run in some elected position.
The Bush Administration is a particularly strong example of what not to do. Even a member of that administration, Republican John Dilulio, famously derided the style as being the rule of the "Mayberry Machievellis." During the Bush years, even roles that had typically been apolitical and technocratic were turned into political patronage jobs, and every decision was being made by the political arm of the administration.
One might almost forgive Bush if he merely put political hacks at the very top of his agencies, out of some over-valuing of partisan loyalty from those who report directly to him. But he plugged unqualified hacks throughout the government, in the kinds of deputy and staffer positions that were previously reserved for those with actual expertise in the subject area. Take Monica Goodling as the poster child for that. She was made a principal deputy director in the Justice Department, despite being a kid with embarrassing academic credentials and almost no legal experience. But she was viewed by the Bushies as loyal, since she'd gone to extremist evangelical universities and had come up in the political world by way of doing opposition research, so she was put in a position of significant power. Once there, she promptly broke the law, in the infamous US Attorneys dismissal controversy (the unprecedented mid-term firing of US attorneys who were investigating Bush administration misconduct).
I'm sure that people can find examples of partisan hackery among Democratic nominees and appointments, too, but traditionally it's much less common on the left. Democratic presidents tend to fall hard for good resumes, and make their picks accordingly. Take a look at the Supreme Court, for example, where part of the reason for the enduring majority Republican appointees have is that Republican presidents pick less distinguished, younger judges, for the partisan advantage of having someone on the court for decades. Clarence Thomas was a newly-minted judge with no notable contributions to jurisprudence when he was nominated by Bush, at age 43. His two major accomplishments were a reputation for extremist conservatism and the color of his skin. Ruth Bader Ginsburg, by comparison, was a 60 year old with 13 years on an appeals court, when she got the nod from Clinton. Stephen Breyer was 56 with 14 years of experience as an appeals court judge. Elena Kagan was unusually young for a Democrat when she was appointed (just 50), but had already been US Solicitor General and Dean of Harvard Law. Sotomayor was 55 and had been a judge for 17 years.
I believe these things have real consequences. When you have a government mostly staffed by technocrats who are more interested in what works than what fits a partisan orthodoxy or repays a political favor, things tend to go well for the country. When the government is run by the Mayberry Machievellis, things tend to go badly. This is one of the reasons that I'm happy Obama won. I disagree with him about a lot of things, but I like the fact that most of the government, on his watch, will be run by people who actually know what they're doing -- people with many years of experience honing their skills and building a knowledge base in relevant lower-level positions, before being entrusted with our fate. I hope that the GOP eventually breaks out of its reflexive political partisanship and patronage game-playing enough to follow that same pattern.
