New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Stand your Ground

The Zimmerman trial was quite a primer on the consequences of Florida's SYG law. It's obscene that Florida has removed any requirement by anyone to make any effort to deescalate altercations as a requirement for self-defense.

It amounts to a reasonable fear of harm or death trumping a reasonable requirement to deescalate in the eyes of the law -- a requirement that might have prevented the shooting altogether. In Florida, if you're reasonably afraid, you have a license to kill without making any effort to avoid conflict if you have a legal right to be in the locale and are not committing any illegal activity. In Zimmerman's case, he started an altercation by tracking Martin, got the short end of the fight, felt reasonable fear, pulled the trigger, and was acquitted.

All of the legal beagles got it wrong about Zimmerman mounting a classic "castle-style" self-defense, and that SYG was not a part of the trial.

Zimmerman did invoke a classic self-defense, but Florida's law inserts SYG language into all self-defense claims.
 
In Florida, if you're reasonably afraid,

or just SAY that you were afraid.......because dead men tell no tales, you win.
 
The Zimmerman trial was quite a primer on the consequences of Florida's SYG law. It's obscene that Florida has removed any requirement by anyone to make any effort to deescalate altercations as a requirement for self-defense.

It amounts to a reasonable fear of harm or death trumping a reasonable requirement to deescalate in the eyes of the law -- a requirement that might have prevented the shooting altogether. In Florida, if you're reasonably afraid, you have a license to kill without making any effort to avoid conflict if you have a legal right to be in the locale and are not committing any illegal activity. In Zimmerman's case, he started an altercation by tracking Martin, got the short end of the fight, felt reasonable fear, pulled the trigger, and was acquitted.

All of the legal beagles got it wrong about Zimmerman mounting a classic "castle-style" self-defense, and that SYG was not a part of the trial.

Zimmerman did invoke a classic self-defense, but Florida's law inserts SYG language into all self-defense claims.
I am glad that someone saw the same trial that I did. For a while there, I thought I was losing it. Thanx.
 
I am not sure what stand your ground means.. Doesn't quote sound right, here where I live we have a "castle doctrine" that gives you the right to shoot to kill unwanted intruders inside your house I have a CCL but rarely exercise the privilege. But would not hesitate to use a weapon to defend myself or my family from an assault. Note that Zimmerman did not say he fired his weapon based on stuand your ground but was in fear of his life. So all that crap ARMCX spouted is meaningless BS. But I will say that ARMCX does not strike as the kind of person that would not defend himself if someone was smashing his head on concrete pavement
 
Last edited:
I am not sure what stand your ground means.. Doesn't quote sound right, here where I live we have a "castle doctrine" that gives you the right to shoot to kill unwanted intruders inside your house I have a CCL but rarely exercise the privilege. But would not hesitate to use a weapon to defend myself or my family from an assault. Note that Zimmerman did not say he fired his weapon based on stuand your ground but was in fear of his life. So all that crap ARMCX spouted is meaningless BS. But I will say that ARMCX does not strike as the kind of person that would not defend himself if someone was smashing his head on concrete pavement
Wouldn't you
 
I am not sure what stand your ground means.. Doesn't quote sound right, here where I live we have a "castle doctrine" that gives you the right to shoot to kill unwanted intruders inside your house I have a CCL but rarely exercise the privilege. But would not hesitate to use a weapon to defend myself or my family from an assault. Note that Zimmerman did not say he fired his weapon based on stuand your ground but was in fear of his life. So all that crap ARMCX spouted is meaningless BS. But I will say that ARMCX does not strike as the kind of person that would not defend himself if someone was smashing his head on concrete pavement

It's no BS, lupe. You don't understand Florida law. Self-defense in Florida automatically includes the SYG provision whether the defendant invokes it or not.
 
It's no BS, lupe. You don't understand Florida law. Self-defense in Florida automatically includes the SYG provision whether the defendant invokes it or not.

Like I said SYG sounds not quite right. But just because there are similarities between the 2 does not make them the same in addition if you are getting the " whatever" beaten out of you and think you may suffer serious injury or die I doubt your concerns about the validity of SYG will change your mind about defending yourself with whatever means are available
 
Hey thanx Friend(I need a shortcut on your handle) but I need all the help I can get. And I think most of the people agree with your conclusion, that if you had somebody pounding on you and you had a gun, you would use it. Anyone that says he or she wouldn't, is not being honest. Does it mean we should outlaw guns, hell no. It lets the next armed robber know that his life is at risk. A shooter in a public place will never know which customer is going to end his useless life. I would like to see universal concealed carry but I'll accept what the law makers say. I don't have a choice. The only one who has a choice is the guy who attacks me, and a gun is an equalizer.
 
Like I said SYG sounds not quite right. But just because there are similarities between the 2 does not make them the same in addition if you are getting the " whatever" beaten out of you and think you may suffer serious injury or die I doubt your concerns about the validity of SYG will change your mind about defending yourself with whatever means are available


OOOOOH NOOOO you are sooooo wrong...

See lefties, when getting their balls kicked in or their breasts beaten off by a poor, disgruntled and socially mistreated criminal gladly take the wounds and the bruises for the greater cause. They would never think of harming so much as a hair on the head of the precisou Democratic Party Property even as they watch their wives get raped, their husbands beaten into a coma or their children used as sex toys. It's all a necessary sacrifice for the cause of social justice......it simply must be!
 
Like I said SYG sounds not quite right. But just because there are similarities between the 2 does not make them the same in addition if you are getting the " whatever" beaten out of you and think you may suffer serious injury or die I doubt your concerns about the validity of SYG will change your mind about defending yourself with whatever means are available

We wouldn't have SYG laws unless we first had the stoooopid, assinine, pussy whipped, idiot laws called the " Duty to retreat " laws..

This is why these new laws came into existence in the first place.

JO
 
"SYG" was a Fox/Teabaggerin' shout-out to EVERY pathetic whose lifelong dream was to engage a "righteous shoot"...no more, no less.
 
Back
Top