Arkady
President
Not too long ago, the vast majority of people thought the world was flat
Yes. And scientists figured out that it wasn't countless generations before that became common knowledge among lay people like you. Lay people tend to work not from actual evidence, but from their own gut feelings. Things look flat, so they assume they must be. It looks like the sun is moving and the Earth is holding still, so they assume that's what's happening. And it seems to them that the world's just too big a place for some human exhaust fumes to fundamentally alter the climate, so they assume it must not be happening. Scientists are ahead of the curve when it comes to understanding those things because they're more structured and informed in their way of examining the questions.
My family built greenhouses, I understand how they work, no different than if you told a mechanic that he doesn't understand how a car works because the entire automotive world believes a car runs on its hood, not on its wheels
If I ever need a greenhouse built, I'd listen to the advice of someone who had experience building greenhouses, rather than, say, a geophysicist whose experience is in understanding how the greenhouse effect works on a planetary scale based on atmospheric chemicals. And, in the exact same way, when it comes time for me to understand climate change, I look to the geophysicist, not the person who has spent his days building little glass houses for gardeners.
You don't get a greenhouse effect from gas, period.
I know of exactly zero actual physicists who agree with you. And that's partly because of how easy it is to prove you're wrong with desktop experiments, where gases actually create measurable greenhouse effects.
The only way to retain heat in a gas is to build a solid ceiling to hold that heat from rising
The issue is simply the speed at which the energy radiates outward. With lower CO2 concentrations, more of the infrared radiation radiates outward at the speed of light, directly from the surface. With higher CO2 concentrations, more of it gets converted into kinetic molecular motion, when those photons strike CO2 particles and set them to vibrating. Eventually that heat will still radiate off into space. But the difference between input and output rates matters.
Think of it like a bathtub, where the faucet has been turned on to a point where it equals the speed of the drain, maintaining a given height of water in the tub. Do something that slows the drain a bit, and the height of water in the tub will rise over time. You seem to imagine that converting infrared radiation to molecular motion will cause no change in the speed at which heat leaves the system -- that it will, metaphorically, do nothing to impact the speed of that drain. Why is it that you imagine that to be so?
There is no such ceiling created in the upper atmosphere by "greenhouse" gases, that idea is looney tunes on steroids
Since no scientist has ever implied any such thing, it's odd that you'd think it needs to be debunked. I think maybe you're just getting caught up on the term "greenhouse effect" -- through your own small life experiences, you think of greenhouses as things with glass ceilings, so when you hear someone refer to the greenhouse effect, you think that they must be talking about that kind of ceiling. But that's not what scientists are talking about. "Greenhouse" is a metaphor here.
Heat rises through the lower atmosphere the same whether there is an extra 1/10th % of carbon present or not present
Incorrect. When sunlight hits surfaces, the reflected IR radiation moves at the speed of light -- rising away from the Earth at 186,000 miles per second. If one of those photons strikes a CO2 molecule and warms it up, do you think that Co2 molecule also rises away from Earth at 186,000 miles per second? Of course not. So, what makes you think heat rises the same way regardless of the presence of CO2?