Arkady
President
John McCain wants us to get involved in the Syrian civil war. This is not surprising, since Senator McCain always wants us to get involved in wars (or to start wars, if they're not already underway). He gets lots of money from military contractors, laundered through their PACs, so of course he wants taxpayer dollars to flow to Syria by way of those military contractors. He can reasonably expect a hefty kickback in exchange for his corruption. But what I'm not as clear about is why anyone who doesn't depend on huge money from military contractors would favor the US sending weapons (much less our sons and daughters) into that war-zone.
It makes no clear difference to US national interests whether the rebels or the government wins in Syria. If we intervene, and the people on behalf of whom we intervene end up being terrible, we will have bought ourselves a nation full of people who hate us for our interference (much like, say, the US intervention on behalf of the Shah in Iran). And that's if those we intervene on behalf of win. Another possibility is that we'll get ourselves onto the wrong side of the power dynamic, and we'll feel the need to throw good money (and lives) after bad, for years, before finally giving up on our "investment." That's basically the story of Vietnam. Or it could be something like our support for the Mujahadin in Afghanistan -- where we support some horrible people because they're a convenient way to stick it to a regime we don't like, then that comes back to haunt us when that force transforms into something like Al Qaeda and the Taliban.
Unless our national interests, or those of a key ally, are very clearly helped by intervening in a matter like this, we should stay the hell out of it. We never understand these things as well as we like to tell ourselves we do (remember Iraq, and the "cakewalk" that turned into a multi-trillion-dollar debacle?), so when in doubt (and no sane person can lack doubt on this one), we should always err on the side of non-intervention in these matters.
It makes no clear difference to US national interests whether the rebels or the government wins in Syria. If we intervene, and the people on behalf of whom we intervene end up being terrible, we will have bought ourselves a nation full of people who hate us for our interference (much like, say, the US intervention on behalf of the Shah in Iran). And that's if those we intervene on behalf of win. Another possibility is that we'll get ourselves onto the wrong side of the power dynamic, and we'll feel the need to throw good money (and lives) after bad, for years, before finally giving up on our "investment." That's basically the story of Vietnam. Or it could be something like our support for the Mujahadin in Afghanistan -- where we support some horrible people because they're a convenient way to stick it to a regime we don't like, then that comes back to haunt us when that force transforms into something like Al Qaeda and the Taliban.
Unless our national interests, or those of a key ally, are very clearly helped by intervening in a matter like this, we should stay the hell out of it. We never understand these things as well as we like to tell ourselves we do (remember Iraq, and the "cakewalk" that turned into a multi-trillion-dollar debacle?), so when in doubt (and no sane person can lack doubt on this one), we should always err on the side of non-intervention in these matters.