New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Syria

Arkady

President
John McCain wants us to get involved in the Syrian civil war. This is not surprising, since Senator McCain always wants us to get involved in wars (or to start wars, if they're not already underway). He gets lots of money from military contractors, laundered through their PACs, so of course he wants taxpayer dollars to flow to Syria by way of those military contractors. He can reasonably expect a hefty kickback in exchange for his corruption. But what I'm not as clear about is why anyone who doesn't depend on huge money from military contractors would favor the US sending weapons (much less our sons and daughters) into that war-zone.

It makes no clear difference to US national interests whether the rebels or the government wins in Syria. If we intervene, and the people on behalf of whom we intervene end up being terrible, we will have bought ourselves a nation full of people who hate us for our interference (much like, say, the US intervention on behalf of the Shah in Iran). And that's if those we intervene on behalf of win. Another possibility is that we'll get ourselves onto the wrong side of the power dynamic, and we'll feel the need to throw good money (and lives) after bad, for years, before finally giving up on our "investment." That's basically the story of Vietnam. Or it could be something like our support for the Mujahadin in Afghanistan -- where we support some horrible people because they're a convenient way to stick it to a regime we don't like, then that comes back to haunt us when that force transforms into something like Al Qaeda and the Taliban.

Unless our national interests, or those of a key ally, are very clearly helped by intervening in a matter like this, we should stay the hell out of it. We never understand these things as well as we like to tell ourselves we do (remember Iraq, and the "cakewalk" that turned into a multi-trillion-dollar debacle?), so when in doubt (and no sane person can lack doubt on this one), we should always err on the side of non-intervention in these matters.
 
The Syrian civil war is akin to a tar baby where the best course of action is to avoid it at all costs, or else you'll earn yourself a trip to the briarpatch.

Let them sort it out themselves.
 
John McCain wants us to get involved in the Syrian civil war. This is not surprising, since Senator McCain always wants us to get involved in wars (or to start wars, if they're not already underway). He gets lots of money from military contractors, laundered through their PACs, so of course he wants taxpayer dollars to flow to Syria by way of those military contractors. He can reasonably expect a hefty kickback in exchange for his corruption. But what I'm not as clear about is why anyone who doesn't depend on huge money from military contractors would favor the US sending weapons (much less our sons and daughters) into that war-zone.

It makes no clear difference to US national interests whether the rebels or the government wins in Syria. If we intervene, and the people on behalf of whom we intervene end up being terrible, we will have bought ourselves a nation full of people who hate us for our interference (much like, say, the US intervention on behalf of the Shah in Iran). And that's if those we intervene on behalf of win. Another possibility is that we'll get ourselves onto the wrong side of the power dynamic, and we'll feel the need to throw good money (and lives) after bad, for years, before finally giving up on our "investment." That's basically the story of Vietnam. Or it could be something like our support for the Mujahadin in Afghanistan -- where we support some horrible people because they're a convenient way to stick it to a regime we don't like, then that comes back to haunt us when that force transforms into something like Al Qaeda and the Taliban.

Unless our national interests, or those of a key ally, are very clearly helped by intervening in a matter like this, we should stay the hell out of it. We never understand these things as well as we like to tell ourselves we do (remember Iraq, and the "cakewalk" that turned into a multi-trillion-dollar debacle?), so when in doubt (and no sane person can lack doubt on this one), we should always err on the side of non-intervention in these matters.

Care to comment on your post now that President Peace Prize has committed to arming the Syrian "rebels"? Are you still interested in finding out "why anyone who doesn't depend on huge money from military contractors would favor the US sending weapons (much less our sons and daughters) into that war-zone."?
 
...this is going to be a F@*KING DISASTER if we get involved. Not only can we NOT AFFORD this, we CANNOT WIN. There are too many factions that despise each other for reasons that make absolutely no sense to Americans and will NOT change with a new regime - as I said, this is going to be a F@*KING DISASTER...
 
Your argument is that it doesn't matter to US national interest if Assad remains in power or if rebel forces and the Syrian majority triumph. If Assad remains in power, then the Syrian-Iranian-Hezbullah-Russian alliance remains intact with increased power. If the rebels prevail, then the Saudi-Qatari-Turkish-Jordanian-Israeli-EU-US coalition that has armed the rebels and provided political support will have increased influence at the expense of Iran, Hezbullah (Lebanon) and Russia. In my opinion, the two outcomes are not equivalent in terms of the impact on US interests because one outcome eclipses US influence while the other enhances US influence. Does US influence matter or not to US national interests? Is the M.E. geopolitically strategic or not?

I'd also take issue with your analogy that arming the rebels would be like restoring the Shah to power by overthrowing the democratically elected Mossadegh government. There is little doubt that after 2 years of internecine sectarian civil war, the majority of Syrians want Assad gone. In the case of the overthrow of Mossadegh, it was exactly the opposite -- the US and UK engineered a coup that reimposed an unpopular, once removed dictator by undermining a legitimate government.

I've been posting for some time that the Syrian war presents a foreign policy challenge that the US can not afford to ignore, and one that will only grow in terms of our future preoccupation with it. I predicted correctly that the US will not be able to avoid deepening involvement.

Yesterday, President Obama announced that the US will begin to provide weapons to the Supreme Military Council because the Assad regime has used sarin gas against the rebels and civilians alike.

Now people will have to decide whether they support or oppose the president's policy to arm the Syrian rebels.
 
...absolutely -

The term “tar baby” is often considered a slur towards African Americans. Indeed, the term has such a derogatory history that the Oxford American dictionary revamped its definition to reflect the word’s racial undertones.
http://thinkprogress.org/politics/2...ating-with-obama-is-like-touching-a-tar-baby/

of course you said absolutely..you and the Blue dog are two in the same...akin to Lester maddox, Bull Connor, Orval Fabus, George Wallace...nice jobs ethnic slurrers!
 
Now people will have to decide whether they support or oppose the president's policy to arm the Syrian rebels.

Sorry but that is not the topic...the topic is how do we get the responsibility for the mess Obama is creating and put it on the backs of the GOP.
 
The Syrian civil war is akin to a tar baby where the best course of action is to avoid it at all costs, or else you'll earn yourself a trip to the briarpatch.

Let them sort it out themselves.

And so what do you think now that President Peace Prize has opted to arm the Syrian "rebels"?
 
Unless our national interests, or those of a key ally, are very clearly helped by intervening in a matter like this, we should stay the hell out of it.

Or allies. Staying out of it isn't really an option. The only question now is how we will manage our involvement. I hope that it turns out more like Libya than Iraq.
 
Care to comment on your post now that President Peace Prize has committed to arming the Syrian "rebels"? Are you still interested in finding out "why anyone who doesn't depend on huge money from military contractors would favor the US sending weapons (much less our sons and daughters) into that war-zone."?

Obama's a neocon. That's been obvious for years, now. He may not be quite as bloodthirsty in his neoconservatism as Graham and McCain, but he's just a friendlier face on the same pathology.
 
Or allies. Staying out of it isn't really an option. The only question now is how we will manage our involvement. I hope that it turns out more like Libya than Iraq.

...ever ask yourself, "why doesn't the Arab League do anything about the atrocities in Syria?" Think about it...
 
Your argument is that it doesn't matter to US national interest if Assad remains in power or if rebel forces and the Syrian majority triumph. If Assad remains in power, then the Syrian-Iranian-Hezbullah-Russian alliance remains intact with increased power. If the rebels prevail, then the Saudi-Qatari-Turkish-Jordanian-Israeli-EU-US coalition that has armed the rebels and provided political support will have increased influence at the expense of Iran, Hezbullah (Lebanon) and Russia. In my opinion, the two outcomes are not equivalent in terms of the impact on US interests because one outcome eclipses US influence while the other enhances US influence. Does US influence matter or not to US national interests? Is the M.E. geopolitically strategic or not?

I'd also take issue with your analogy that arming the rebels would be like restoring the Shah to power by overthrowing the democratically elected Mossadegh government. There is little doubt that after 2 years of internecine sectarian civil war, the majority of Syrians want Assad gone. In the case of the overthrow of Mossadegh, it was exactly the opposite -- the US and UK engineered a coup that reimposed an unpopular, once removed dictator by undermining a legitimate government.

I've been posting for some time that the Syrian war presents a foreign policy challenge that the US can not afford to ignore, and one that will only grow in terms of our future preoccupation with it. I predicted correctly that the US will not be able to avoid deepening involvement.

Yesterday, President Obama announced that the US will begin to provide weapons to the Supreme Military Council because the Assad regime has used sarin gas against the rebels and civilians alike.

Now people will have to decide whether they support or oppose the president's policy to arm the Syrian rebels.

Let me guess -- you supported intervention in Iraq, too, right? As you should know by now, that insane intervention didn't increase US influence or benefit our interests. It strengthened the reactionaries in Iran while sidelining the reformers, gave al Qaeda fertile Iraqi recruiting grounds to work with, cost us trillions of dollars, soured sentiments against the US throughout the Arab and Muslim worlds, drove a wedge between the US and key allies, and distracted from the hunt for Bin Laden. Why should I expect better from sticking our nose into Syria?

If I could magically remove Assad and install in his place a more pro-American leader who would be able to hold onto power without turning his people and his region against us, I'd do so. But I don't believe in magic. I've long been aware of how messy, and frequently counter-productive military interventions are -- that's why I was one of the people wise enough to oppose the Iraq invasion vocally and strongly from the start. But now, the same stooges who cheered our way into that disaster are cheering for another military adventure in the Middle East.

If you're right and the majority of people in Syria want Assad gone, then let them get rid of him. If they're able to build a strong enough coalition, on their own, with good enough leadership to do that, the process of liberating themselves will be good for forging a consensus that can create a functional state. If, instead, we use our blood and treasure to rig the contest in favor of one faction, it could easily go about as well as the take-down of Hussein (who was likewise unpopular with his people).
 
...indeed it has and has lead me to the conclusion that this is a no-win situation for the US and we should not enter this civil war...

I agree that there are no good options. That said, we do have treaty commitments to consider. This civil war is a disaster for several of our allies in the region. Outside forces are already involved. I'm afraid that this problem won't magically go away by us choosing to simply ignore it.
 
Back
Top