New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The Chained CPI "Fix"

Arkady

President
Here's another take on the idea of switching to chained CPI for Social Security Cost of Living adjustments:

http://www.salon.com/2012/12/19/the_progressive_case_for_the_chained_cpi/

I'm first-tiering this, rather than slotting under my prior entry, because I missed a major point last time. The change doesn't just alter benefits payments (decreasing payouts from Social Security and countless other programs increasingly over time). It also alters other dollar figures in the rules, such as 401K limits, deductions that are indexed to inflation, etc. This would boost tax revenues in an increasing way over time in addition to reducing spending. For example, if the amount exempt from taxation for 401K contributions rose to $17,100, rather than $17,500, because of the smaller inflation adjustment from the new method, the government would collect taxes on an additional $400 of income.

The Salon article argues the progressive case for the bargain. It basically comes down to the idea that if you think we're going to be stuck cutting Social Security or Medicare (that Obama can't hope to drive a better bargain), then doing it this way is better than doing it other ways, like hiking eligibility ages.

I'd agree that there are worse ways to cut entitlements. But, even setting aside the question of why Obama can't just demand a better deal, holding the fiscal cliff tax cut expirations as a weapon, I'd argue there are definitely BETTER ways to cut benefits, too. As I pointed out, this method does very little to reduce Social Security benefits for current seniors, whereas it does a great deal to cut them for the young -- for whom the compounding effect of those small annual percentage changes will have a lot of time to become substantial. This change effectively calls for seven times the sacrifice for someone being born today than for someone retiring today. Why, exactly, is that the best cut we can do?

You could argue it would make more sense to go the other way -- to cut Social Security more for those who are old today than for young people. After all, if one is claiming to be forced to do this by a supposed fiscal crisis, then isn't it easier to argue that current old people are a lot more complicit in that crisis than current young people? If you're an old person today, then, on average, you spent decades paying a lot less in taxes than you got in the way of benefits. If someone has to bite the bullet to bring the budget into balance, shouldn't it be you -- or, at least your age cohort? Why go after those who didn't get those decades of underpaying? Why nail those who don't even have a vote, yet, with which to defend themselves?

It's perfectly possible to have the EXACT SAME dollar impact on Social Security costs, but with the opposite distribution. Simply reduce Social Security benefits by a fixed dollar amount. For example, reduce annual Social Security payments by a fixed $500 per person per year. That would reduce everyone's Social Security income, but would have a much larger impact on today's seniors than the seniors of the future (for whom $500 will be less meaningful, after adjusting for inflation). It would be shared sacrifice, but born disproportionately more by those whose generation has the most complicity in the fiscal mismanagement that supposedly required the sacrifice in the first place, rather than those who merely got born into a debt-ridden situation.

What do you think?
 
Back
Top