New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The Debate

TaiPan

Council Member
Supposedly somewhere close to 50 million people watched the debate last night. As it was, it was rather dull. The president, remained low key, cerebral, and on his points. Governor Romney, introduced another new Romney, the compassionate Romney to the American people. I was reminded of Richard Nixon and famous HerBlock cartoon of Nixon in front of his clothes closet, trying to pick his uniform of the day.

Fire was generally lacking thoughout, with the president refusing to be baited into angry responses, and Romney determined to prove he was just plain folk.
I alternated between CNN and Current TV for coverage, and rather enjoyed the Twitter posts on Current and the approval/disapproval line chart on CNN. The President seemed to out poll the Guv. with women on CNN. which was anticipated in anycase.

What amazed me last night, was the candy store approach of Romney. It seemed like no matter what it was so long as he could tag it to the middle class, he offered up generous servings. What I heard didn't impress me much, especially when the Guv., decided to offer up the energy sources he liked, declaring his loyalty to coal. (Koch Bros. anyone?) And the Vuv was his usual specifically unspecific self. His tax program sounds like wish list for a spendthrift, and I couldn't figure out whether he was trying to espouse a revenue neutral plan, of some concoction of tax cuts that will somehow produce more revenue. Another point he raised, was his famous 12 milllion jobs promise. He reinforced it by saying they will be good paying jobs, not entry level jobs, plus apparently under his leadership everyone will be getting raises.
It kind of made me wonder whether he was running for President of the US, of CEO in Chief of American Business.

There's a Mel Gibson movie, The Patriot , in it there is a line that Gibson is constantly reminding himself of "Stay the Course". In my opinion that was the President's message to the American People. "We can get out of this together with our economy, our country and our ideals and beliefs in tact, if we only just stay the course." If that was what he wanted to do, he got the message across.

I was a bit surprised by the commentary from both CNN's, MSNBC;s, and Current's pundits. They wanted to see the president out there swing, stuffing Romney's gaffes, like the 47% remark down his throat. They thought that somehow the president needed to do that. Why ? Are they so smart and the American People so stupid that we forget in 5 minutes what people say to us when they are trying to get us to hire them to work for us ? I don't think so, had any of the pundits been participating in the debate, it would have been a shambles.

I don't think either side did a good job articulating health care. For both it was the same tired rhetoric. Romney fared a little worse I believe, because what he was describing was a troika of health care: Vouchers to buy private insurance, private insurance outright, and lastly a skeletal medicare like program. His assertion that private industry can always do it cheaper than the government can fell on deaf ears, mainly because coming out of Iraq and the monumental price gouging and profit taking by contractors in that Theater of Operations, I think proves the case that private contractors are in it for the bucks and are motivated by the profit incentive rather than any altruistic motives. The President could have done a better job of outlining how Obamacare is designed to work, that he didn't lost him some points. Even after this debate however, I still don't quite understand where Mitt Romney stands on Social Security or Health care.

Poor scores were achieved by both candidates for their responses to questions on education. Romney seemed to forget that he hasn't been governor of MA for the last 5 years, and thus is somewhat overstating the case to say he made Massachusetts schools #1 in the nation. Unfortunately, there are no comparable parameters for the President who must deal with the acutely sick condition of schools in 49 other states. All he can point to is Race to the Top, which does seem to be out performing No Child Left Behind. Mr. Romney's quip about ending Federal contributions to public TV, was uncalled for. I suppose he things Fox will pick up Sesame Street.

In any case, I think the president acted like he was bored and distracted with other things. His body language to me illustrated a bit of disdain for his opponent, which induced Gov. to come across a bit like an angry chihuahua. But at the end of the day if the President lost the battle, Mr. Romney lost the war. Here is the reasoning behind that statement. On Energy, a declaration that "I love clean coal." That statement is an oxymoron at the least. There is no such thing as "clean coal" It is and remains the dirtiest hydrocarbon fuel on the scale. While everyone is aware of the Koch Bros., and their large scale coal operations, Mr. Romney's comments were pure kowtowing to his munificent benefactors. On drilling, Basically Mr. Romney said he would open up everything to drilling, including all public lands. Well if that's the case, why shouldn't the American People get the benefit of those depletion allowances, talk about a boost to the economy. $10 billion a year divided amongst 314 million people, would put $32k in the pocket of every man,woman and child in the US. That's what I call priming the economic pump. Instead, Mr. Romney chose to defend the practice of depletion allowances. Holding instead that oil companies who make 4 billion a year, need this money to operate. Surprising Mr. Romney also defended the bane of Republicanism, regulation, but regulation his way. He refused to address the issue of whether or not certain banks should be labeled to big to fail, deciding instead to focus on 132 banks that did fail in the meltdown, small banks., which he well knows closed because of poor banking practice, rather than any regulatory compliance issues.

I'm also glad to know that someone finally told Mr. Romney there is a middle class in America. I was afraid that point was beyond his comprehension. Of course he hit upon the fact that the middle class has been hammered, economically. Too bad though that he didn't get the dates right. Since the Reagan Administration the middle class has been hammered, not since Barrack Obama took office. Which is reason enough for the Middle Class not to trust Romney, republicans always claim to be good middle class Americans, until you check their bank accounts.

There was more, outsourcing overseas, trickle down economics, no real plan to pay down the national debt, $8trillion in additional debt, phantom savings, supposed revenue neutral taxation,that produces more revenue, turning over to the states control of programs like medicare and medicaid, but the bottom line is that the new Romney looked very much like the old Romney, just hyped up on methamphetamine for a tv performance.

So a tactical victory for Romney may have given the President's campaign a great deal of ammunition for the more strategic victory. Romney was finally held to some modicum of specifics, that I believe can hurt him in the general campaign We shall have to wait and see what comes over the airwaves in the next week or so by way of ads..

Tai Pan


Jim Lehrer as a moderator, lost control of the debate so many times, it wasn't funny
 
I didn't watch any of the post-debate spin last night.

"at the end of the day if the President lost the battle, Mr. Romney lost the war."

That was my take on it after some thought last night. I already posted an exhaustive,for me,debate analysis on another PJ board. The gist was that I didn't hear anything from Romney that helped him close the gap with women or Hispanic/Latino voters or that fixed the reasons he's losing in OH,FLA and Nevada just to name 3 states.
 
Tai.. this is such a great post.. It would be neat if you would post it on the main Political Board!! :D
 
Tai,

This is the best post-debate analysis that I have read not only on PJ but on the blogosphere, the newspapers, news magazines, and Internet generally. Thanks!

I'll add a couple of things. First, I do think that Obama was more or less on autopilot. His autopilot was not awful. But Romney performed well enough to win the battle for public opinion. (Personally, I still thought Obama won - even on autopilot - but I accept that I am in the minority.) I also wondered whether he would not have preferred to be spending his twentieth wedding anniversary in private with Michelle. I think that Mitt may have disarmed Obama when he "sympathized" with his predicament. (I know that that won't happen again.)

Second, I don't think that we saw a new Mitt but the return of Massachusetts Mitt with a dash of Newt thrown in (for Obama bashing purposes). As you argued, this worked well tactically for Mitt. But he may well have opened himself up to lose the war. That said, Mitt was in a position where he had to win the battle to have a chance of winning the war. So he survived to fight another day. The next two weeks should be interesting.

Supposedly somewhere close to 50 million people watched the debate last night. As it was, it was rather dull. The president, remained low key, cerebral, and on his points. Governor Romney, introduced another new Romney, the compassionate Romney to the American people. I was reminded of Richard Nixon and famous HerBlock cartoon of Nixon in front of his clothes closet, trying to pick his uniform of the day.

Fire was generally lacking thoughout, with the president refusing to be baited into angry responses, and Romney determined to prove he was just plain folk.
I alternated between CNN and Current TV for coverage, and rather enjoyed the Twitter posts on Current and the approval/disapproval line chart on CNN. The President seemed to out poll the Guv. with women on CNN. which was anticipated in anycase.

What amazed me last night, was the candy store approach of Romney. It seemed like no matter what it was so long as he could tag it to the middle class, he offered up generous servings. What I heard didn't impress me much, especially when the Guv., decided to offer up the energy sources he liked, declaring his loyalty to coal. (Koch Bros. anyone?) And the Vuv was his usual specifically unspecific self. His tax program sounds like wish list for a spendthrift, and I couldn't figure out whether he was trying to espouse a revenue neutral plan, of some concoction of tax cuts that will somehow produce more revenue. Another point he raised, was his famous 12 milllion jobs promise. He reinforced it by saying they will be good paying jobs, not entry level jobs, plus apparently under his leadership everyone will be getting raises.
It kind of made me wonder whether he was running for President of the US, of CEO in Chief of American Business.

There's a Mel Gibson movie, The Patriot , in it there is a line that Gibson is constantly reminding himself of "Stay the Course". In my opinion that was the President's message to the American People. "We can get out of this together with our economy, our country and our ideals and beliefs in tact, if we only just stay the course." If that was what he wanted to do, he got the message across.

I was a bit surprised by the commentary from both CNN's, MSNBC;s, and Current's pundits. They wanted to see the president out there swing, stuffing Romney's gaffes, like the 47% remark down his throat. They thought that somehow the president needed to do that. Why ? Are they so smart and the American People so stupid that we forget in 5 minutes what people say to us when they are trying to get us to hire them to work for us ? I don't think so, had any of the pundits been participating in the debate, it would have been a shambles.

I don't think either side did a good job articulating health care. For both it was the same tired rhetoric. Romney fared a little worse I believe, because what he was describing was a troika of health care: Vouchers to buy private insurance, private insurance outright, and lastly a skeletal medicare like program. His assertion that private industry can always do it cheaper than the government can fell on deaf ears, mainly because coming out of Iraq and the monumental price gouging and profit taking by contractors in that Theater of Operations, I think proves the case that private contractors are in it for the bucks and are motivated by the profit incentive rather than any altruistic motives. The President could have done a better job of outlining how Obamacare is designed to work, that he didn't lost him some points. Even after this debate however, I still don't quite understand where Mitt Romney stands on Social Security or Health care.

Poor scores were achieved by both candidates for their responses to questions on education. Romney seemed to forget that he hasn't been governor of MA for the last 5 years, and thus is somewhat overstating the case to say he made Massachusetts schools #1 in the nation. Unfortunately, there are no comparable parameters for the President who must deal with the acutely sick condition of schools in 49 other states. All he can point to is Race to the Top, which does seem to be out performing No Child Left Behind. Mr. Romney's quip about ending Federal contributions to public TV, was uncalled for. I suppose he things Fox will pick up Sesame Street.

In any case, I think the president acted like he was bored and distracted with other things. His body language to me illustrated a bit of disdain for his opponent, which induced Gov. to come across a bit like an angry chihuahua. But at the end of the day if the President lost the battle, Mr. Romney lost the war. Here is the reasoning behind that statement. On Energy, a declaration that "I love clean coal." That statement is an oxymoron at the least. There is no such thing as "clean coal" It is and remains the dirtiest hydrocarbon fuel on the scale. While everyone is aware of the Koch Bros., and their large scale coal operations, Mr. Romney's comments were pure kowtowing to his munificent benefactors. On drilling, Basically Mr. Romney said he would open up everything to drilling, including all public lands. Well if that's the case, why shouldn't the American People get the benefit of those depletion allowances, talk about a boost to the economy. $10 billion a year divided amongst 314 million people, would put $32k in the pocket of every man,woman and child in the US. That's what I call priming the economic pump. Instead, Mr. Romney chose to defend the practice of depletion allowances. Holding instead that oil companies who make 4 billion a year, need this money to operate. Surprising Mr. Romney also defended the bane of Republicanism, regulation, but regulation his way. He refused to address the issue of whether or not certain banks should be labeled to big to fail, deciding instead to focus on 132 banks that did fail in the meltdown, small banks., which he well knows closed because of poor banking practice, rather than any regulatory compliance issues.

I'm also glad to know that someone finally told Mr. Romney there is a middle class in America. I was afraid that point was beyond his comprehension. Of course he hit upon the fact that the middle class has been hammered, economically. Too bad though that he didn't get the dates right. Since the Reagan Administration the middle class has been hammered, not since Barrack Obama took office. Which is reason enough for the Middle Class not to trust Romney, republicans always claim to be good middle class Americans, until you check their bank accounts.

There was more, outsourcing overseas, trickle down economics, no real plan to pay down the national debt, $8trillion in additional debt, phantom savings, supposed revenue neutral taxation,that produces more revenue, turning over to the states control of programs like medicare and medicaid, but the bottom line is that the new Romney looked very much like the old Romney, just hyped up on methamphetamine for a tv performance.

So a tactical victory for Romney may have given the President's campaign a great deal of ammunition for the more strategic victory. Romney was finally held to some modicum of specifics, that I believe can hurt him in the general campaign We shall have to wait and see what comes over the airwaves in the next week or so by way of ads..

Tai Pan


Jim Lehrer as a moderator, lost control of the debate so many times, it wasn't funny
 
Well thought out and well stated, TaiPan. I especially liked...

His body language to me illustrated a bit of disdain for his opponent, which induced Gov. to come across a bit like an angry chihuahua.

I'm also glad to know that someone finally told Mr. Romney there is a middle class in America. I was afraid that point was beyond his comprehension. Of course he hit upon the fact that the middle class has been hammered, economically. Too bad though that he didn't get the dates right. Since the Reagan Administration the middle class has been hammered, not since Barrack Obama took office. Which is reason enough for the Middle Class not to trust Romney, republicans always claim to be good middle class Americans, until you check their bank accounts.

Rmoney believes the "middle class" begins at $200K minimum...
 
Tai,

This is the best post-debate analysis that I have read not only on PJ but on the blogosphere, the newspapers, news magazines, and Internet generally. Thanks!

I'll add a couple of things. First, I do think that Obama was more or less on autopilot. His autopilot was not awful. But Romney performed well enough to win the battle for public opinion. (Personally, I still thought Obama won - even on autopilot - but I accept that I am in the minority.) I also wondered whether he would not have preferred to be spending his twentieth wedding anniversary in private with Michelle. I think that Mitt may have disarmed Obama when he "sympathized" with his predicament. (I know that that won't happen again.)

Second, I don't think that we saw a new Mitt but the return of Massachusetts Mitt with a dash of Newt thrown in (for Obama bashing purposes). As you argued, this worked well tactically for Mitt. But he may well have opened himself up to lose the war. That said, Mitt was in a position where he had to win the battle to have a chance of winning the war. So he survived to fight another day. The next two weeks should be interesting.

I agree with you.. Irp.. a great job by Tai!
 
Thank you all for your kind words,. I felt very vindicated in what I wrote today based on what I heard on Lawerance O' Donnell's Last Word tonight. He quoted a Denver Reporter who compared the debate to a bullfight, with Romney as the bull constantly charging the matador. He added however, that we all know what happens at the end of the bullfight. I know where O'Donnell comes from and I know his political pedigree, so I was very comfortable being in the same boat analytically.

Addy, if you will recommend the board I will repost the message accordingly. I'm still navigating my way around over here.

Thanks again everyone

Tai Pan
 
Thank you TP... again, I think you described what went down quite accurately. My partner, who is by training and by trade, a governmental policy analyst for a multinational - reminded us that the job of the chatternig nabobs is to make this contest seem close for as long as possible- just so folks keep tuning in to them and paying their bills.

Not a conspiracy per se, but more a structural conspiracy to feed the narrative of conflict that the Main Stream public (or the niche audience they cater to) wants.

Would you mind if I stole your post and reposted it on FB?
 
Thank you TP... again, I think you described what went down quite accurately. My partner, who is by training and by trade, a governmental policy analyst for a multinational - reminded us that the job of the chatternig nabobs is to make this contest seem close for as long as possible- just so folks keep tuning in to them and paying their bills.

Not a conspiracy per se, but more a structural conspiracy to feed the narrative of conflict that the Main Stream public (or the niche audience they cater to) wants.

Would you mind if I stole your post and reposted it on FB?

I would be honored if you did so.

Tai Pan
 
I too was surprised by Romney's embrace of the term "Trickle Down Government".... I understand the point they are tyring to make, but Trickle Down anything is instantly associated audibly with the much denigrated REAGAN programs harmful to the middle class. Invoking this is along the lines of invoking the term Great Society For Business - as a way of explaining how you would jump start Job Creation. It is just a set of terms that have too much political baggage and resonance to be repurposed this way... particularly in such a short time.

Telling for me was listening tothe Laura Ingram, The Schnitt, Mark Levine and HAnnitty shows today. And their focus on continuing to try and prove Romney's equivilence to Obama intellectually. If Romney had closed that deal last night, there would have been no need for that today.
 
Unfortunately they have a bit of a point, both men are Harvard & Harvard Law. The divergence, is their life experiences and how it molded each man, not intellectual inequality. There are many brilliant people who have dedicated thier lives to the betterment of manjjind, and there are many equally brilliant people who have devoted there lives to nothing but the acquisition of great wealth. What makes the difference between the two seems to be their individual life experiences.

Tai Pan
 
But I don't think Romney is all that smart. Top 1/3 of his law class but not on the Law review nor Summa...And while Romney was TAUGHT he was descriminated against, he really was not.

Obama OTOH was. - still is for that matter. IN fact if Romney wins in a close one, he will have one on whitemans affirmative action aka racism
 
Tai,I am with the others on a great post! You always do well:eek:)

IRP,I really do not think you are one of a minority.Only the pundits ranted and raved.That is what they get paid for and are not fit to watch.

Ed Schultz and his Coach performance last night was just plain silly after he and Chris ranted after the debate.neither one thought anything through,they just slobbered.When I saw that,like BD,I turned it off.
None of them saw the lying,snmirking bully I observed.Mitt's treatment of Jim Lehrer and telling him he was fired was a Donald Trump show at it's worst. I never watch that ignorant show either.

I chanced upon the Honey Boo Boo show last week. In the scant few minutes I watched she was shoveling food in her face, farted and sneezed with it running out of her nose! Who in the world would watch a show like that? I thought the Hillbilly,rich people on CMT was bad.That was a thousand times worse!Yuck! Sorry for the crude words but it revolted me.
 
He quoted a Denver Reporter who compared the debate to a bullfight, with Romney as the bull constantly charging the matador. He added however, that we all know what happens at the end of the bullfight.[/QUOTE]

YW..Tai... all of the praises for your post were deserving..
I listened to that show by O"Donnell and also thought what a great analysis.

My suggestion to post this again on Latest Political News and Domestic Policy was b/c it appears to be more active..
You can click on Home Icon at the top of the page and it is the first one listed.. This link should take you there as well, hopefully.
https://www.politicaljack.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?2-Latest-Political-News-and-Domestic-Policy

If you had rather leave your post here in this forum.. that will be just fine,, Tai!
Regardless, I hope you will continue to post your insightful posts for all of us on PJ.. I and many others like your style!!
Thanks, Tai! :D
 
But I don't think Romney is all that smart. Top 1/3 of his law class but not on the Law review nor Summa...And while Romney was TAUGHT he was descriminated against, he really was not.

Obama OTOH was. - still is for that matter. IN fact if Romney wins in a close one, he will have one on whitemans affirmative action aka racism

so degs,,by your reasoning, obama was elected because there was not enough racists to stop him,,but if romney wins this one, its because the racists increased their numbers...

way to cover all your bases....
 
He quoted a Denver Reporter who compared the debate to a bullfight, with Romney as the bull constantly charging the matador. He added however, that we all know what happens at the end of the bullfight.[/QUOTE]

YW..Tai... all of the praises for your post were deserving..
I listened to that show by O"Donnell and also thought what a great analysis.

My suggestion to post this again on Latest Political News and Domestic Policy was b/c it appears to be more active..
You can click on Home Icon at the top of the page and it is the first one listed.. This link should take you there as well, hopefully.
https://www.politicaljack.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?2-Latest-Political-News-and-Domestic-Policy

If you had rather leave your post here in this forum.. that will be just fine,, Tai!
Regardless, I hope you will continue to post your insightful posts for all of us on PJ.. I and many others like your style!!
Thanks, Tai! :D



I just put it out there with a bit of an explanation for its late appearance. You are too kind with your praises. I'm glad you caught the O'Donnell show, of the bunch out there I think he is the best and he admits his bias when it shows. He is a liberal, but that shouldn't be a curse word, neither should conservative, it is the people who define the terms by abusing what they stand for who make them dark and dangerous.

Tai Pan
 
MaryAnne,

In my opinion, President Obama won the debate. I don't really care what any of the pundits have to say about it. My opinion is the only opinion that will affect my vote.
 
As it should be, the only score that really matters is the poll that will be taken on 11/06/2012.
 
By CEREBRAL, do you mean unable to think? Obama looked like he didn't know whether to scratch his watch or wind his ass. He tried again and again to morph into his pre-programmed talking points speech, and Romney cleaned his clock for him. It was one of Obama's best performances, in my opinion, because the country saw him for what he really his...a hopeless dumbass.


Supposedly somewhere close to 50 million people watched the debate last night. As it was, it was rather dull. The president, remained low key, cerebral, and on his points. Governor Romney, introduced another new Romney, the compassionate Romney to the American people. I was reminded of Richard Nixon and famous HerBlock cartoon of Nixon in front of his clothes closet, trying to pick his uniform of the day.

Fire was generally lacking thoughout, with the president refusing to be baited into angry responses, and Romney determined to prove he was just plain folk.
I alternated between CNN and Current TV for coverage, and rather enjoyed the Twitter posts on Current and the approval/disapproval line chart on CNN. The President seemed to out poll the Guv. with women on CNN. which was anticipated in anycase.

What amazed me last night, was the candy store approach of Romney. It seemed like no matter what it was so long as he could tag it to the middle class, he offered up generous servings. What I heard didn't impress me much, especially when the Guv., decided to offer up the energy sources he liked, declaring his loyalty to coal. (Koch Bros. anyone?) And the Vuv was his usual specifically unspecific self. His tax program sounds like wish list for a spendthrift, and I couldn't figure out whether he was trying to espouse a revenue neutral plan, of some concoction of tax cuts that will somehow produce more revenue. Another point he raised, was his famous 12 milllion jobs promise. He reinforced it by saying they will be good paying jobs, not entry level jobs, plus apparently under his leadership everyone will be getting raises.
It kind of made me wonder whether he was running for President of the US, of CEO in Chief of American Business.

There's a Mel Gibson movie, The Patriot , in it there is a line that Gibson is constantly reminding himself of "Stay the Course". In my opinion that was the President's message to the American People. "We can get out of this together with our economy, our country and our ideals and beliefs in tact, if we only just stay the course." If that was what he wanted to do, he got the message across.

I was a bit surprised by the commentary from both CNN's, MSNBC;s, and Current's pundits. They wanted to see the president out there swing, stuffing Romney's gaffes, like the 47% remark down his throat. They thought that somehow the president needed to do that. Why ? Are they so smart and the American People so stupid that we forget in 5 minutes what people say to us when they are trying to get us to hire them to work for us ? I don't think so, had any of the pundits been participating in the debate, it would have been a shambles.

I don't think either side did a good job articulating health care. For both it was the same tired rhetoric. Romney fared a little worse I believe, because what he was describing was a troika of health care: Vouchers to buy private insurance, private insurance outright, and lastly a skeletal medicare like program. His assertion that private industry can always do it cheaper than the government can fell on deaf ears, mainly because coming out of Iraq and the monumental price gouging and profit taking by contractors in that Theater of Operations, I think proves the case that private contractors are in it for the bucks and are motivated by the profit incentive rather than any altruistic motives. The President could have done a better job of outlining how Obamacare is designed to work, that he didn't lost him some points. Even after this debate however, I still don't quite understand where Mitt Romney stands on Social Security or Health care.

Poor scores were achieved by both candidates for their responses to questions on education. Romney seemed to forget that he hasn't been governor of MA for the last 5 years, and thus is somewhat overstating the case to say he made Massachusetts schools #1 in the nation. Unfortunately, there are no comparable parameters for the President who must deal with the acutely sick condition of schools in 49 other states. All he can point to is Race to the Top, which does seem to be out performing No Child Left Behind. Mr. Romney's quip about ending Federal contributions to public TV, was uncalled for. I suppose he things Fox will pick up Sesame Street.

In any case, I think the president acted like he was bored and distracted with other things. His body language to me illustrated a bit of disdain for his opponent, which induced Gov. to come across a bit like an angry chihuahua. But at the end of the day if the President lost the battle, Mr. Romney lost the war. Here is the reasoning behind that statement. On Energy, a declaration that "I love clean coal." That statement is an oxymoron at the least. There is no such thing as "clean coal" It is and remains the dirtiest hydrocarbon fuel on the scale. While everyone is aware of the Koch Bros., and their large scale coal operations, Mr. Romney's comments were pure kowtowing to his munificent benefactors. On drilling, Basically Mr. Romney said he would open up everything to drilling, including all public lands. Well if that's the case, why shouldn't the American People get the benefit of those depletion allowances, talk about a boost to the economy. $10 billion a year divided amongst 314 million people, would put $32k in the pocket of every man,woman and child in the US. That's what I call priming the economic pump. Instead, Mr. Romney chose to defend the practice of depletion allowances. Holding instead that oil companies who make 4 billion a year, need this money to operate. Surprising Mr. Romney also defended the bane of Republicanism, regulation, but regulation his way. He refused to address the issue of whether or not certain banks should be labeled to big to fail, deciding instead to focus on 132 banks that did fail in the meltdown, small banks., which he well knows closed because of poor banking practice, rather than any regulatory compliance issues.

I'm also glad to know that someone finally told Mr. Romney there is a middle class in America. I was afraid that point was beyond his comprehension. Of course he hit upon the fact that the middle class has been hammered, economically. Too bad though that he didn't get the dates right. Since the Reagan Administration the middle class has been hammered, not since Barrack Obama took office. Which is reason enough for the Middle Class not to trust Romney, republicans always claim to be good middle class Americans, until you check their bank accounts.

There was more, outsourcing overseas, trickle down economics, no real plan to pay down the national debt, $8trillion in additional debt, phantom savings, supposed revenue neutral taxation,that produces more revenue, turning over to the states control of programs like medicare and medicaid, but the bottom line is that the new Romney looked very much like the old Romney, just hyped up on methamphetamine for a tv performance.

So a tactical victory for Romney may have given the President's campaign a great deal of ammunition for the more strategic victory. Romney was finally held to some modicum of specifics, that I believe can hurt him in the general campaign We shall have to wait and see what comes over the airwaves in the next week or so by way of ads..

Tai Pan
Jim Lehrer as a moderator, lost control of the debate so many times, it wasn't funny
 
Back
Top