New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The Elephant

Zam-Zam

Senator
Everyone knows something. No one knows everything.

The Jains have an allegory that illustrates this quite well:

Five blind men are brought to an elephant and are tasked with describing the animal.

The first feels the trunk and says an elephant is a thing like a tree branch.

The second grasps a leg and says the elephant is like a pillar.

The third touches the elephant's ear and believes an elephant is like a fan.

The fourth encounters the elephant's side and declares the animal is like a wall.

Finally, the fifth grabs the tail and says the elephant is like a rope.

The five argue, each one incredulous that the other three are so foolish as to not understand what seems obvious. Each man knows a truth...None of them, however, know the whole truth.


And so it is with us. We argue, often pointlessly, each one of us convinced we are right and those not seeing it our way to be foolish deniers of the obvious truth.

None of us knows the whole truth, each knows only a part. The foolish part of us will disregard any notion that our truth is not more important and relevant than someone else's truth... How can they disagree with what we know to be true?

Something to chew on this morning.


It's all good.
 
Everyone knows something. No one knows everything.

The Jains have an allegory that illustrates this quite well:

Five blind men are brought to an elephant and are tasked with describing the animal.

The first feels the trunk and says an elephant is a thing like a tree branch.

The second grasps a leg and says the elephant is like a pillar.

The third touches the elephant's ear and believes an elephant is like a fan.

The fourth encounters the elephant's side and declares the animal is like a wall.

Finally, the fifth grabs the tail and says the elephant is like a rope.

The five argue, each one incredulous that the other three are so foolish as to not understand what seems obvious. Each man knows a truth...None of them, however, know the whole truth.


And so it is with us. We argue, often pointlessly, each one of us convinced we are right and those not seeing it our way to be foolish deniers of the obvious truth.

None of us knows the whole truth, each knows only a part. The foolish part of us will disregard any notion that our truth is not more important and relevant than someone else's truth... How can they disagree with what we know to be true?

Something to chew on this morning.


It's all good.
this is the new argument of theoretical physicists. that there's no such thing as objective reality. each observer is entitled to his or her conclusions about what took place on the subatomic level. particles can't be pinned down to a precise point in space, at a precise point in time.

now this applies to political views? everyone's views are equally valid, because they had different childhood experiences?

if this is true, we should probably just scrap the entire US constitution and all the laws passed since. Because there is no objective reality.
 
this is the new argument of theoretical physicists. that there's no such thing as objective reality. each observer is entitled to his or her conclusions about what took place on the subatomic level. particles can't be pinned down to a precise point in space, at a precise point in time.

now this applies to political views? everyone's views are equally valid, because they had different childhood experiences?

if this is true, we should probably just scrap the entire US constitution and all the laws passed since. Because there is no objective reality.

I'm not sure this is a new argument...The allegory of the elephant has been around for quite some time.

My takeaway is different than yours, but then, perhaps that's the point. I see this as a lesson in tolerance. None of us has perfect knowledge, and maybe we should not consider any viewpoint other than our own to be foolish and irresponsible. Consider if the five blind men had listened to one another....They could have pieced together a more accurate understanding of what an elephant is like.
 
this is the new argument of theoretical physicists. that there's no such thing as objective reality. each observer is entitled to his or her conclusions about what took place on the subatomic level. particles can't be pinned down to a precise point in space, at a precise point in time.

now this applies to political views? everyone's views are equally valid, because they had different childhood experiences?

if this is true, we should probably just scrap the entire US constitution and all the laws passed since. Because there is no objective reality.
spoken like a true Trump supporter
 
Everyone knows something. No one knows everything.

The Jains have an allegory that illustrates this quite well:

Five blind men are brought to an elephant and are tasked with describing the animal.

The first feels the trunk and says an elephant is a thing like a tree branch.

The second grasps a leg and says the elephant is like a pillar.

The third touches the elephant's ear and believes an elephant is like a fan.

The fourth encounters the elephant's side and declares the animal is like a wall.

Finally, the fifth grabs the tail and says the elephant is like a rope.

The five argue, each one incredulous that the other three are so foolish as to not understand what seems obvious. Each man knows a truth...None of them, however, know the whole truth.


And so it is with us. We argue, often pointlessly, each one of us convinced we are right and those not seeing it our way to be foolish deniers of the obvious truth.

None of us knows the whole truth, each knows only a part. The foolish part of us will disregard any notion that our truth is not more important and relevant than someone else's truth... How can they disagree with what we know to be true?

Something to chew on this morning.


It's all good.

While that is certainly one way to describe what goes on, I offer yet another. I was taught some 70 years ago in art class that you cannot fully see a painting if you stand with your nose up against it. You need to stand arleast 10 fweet away so that you can see the whole picture.

I've mentioned umpteen times here that people form their political opinions with only partial information. They get so locked into that opinion that they tend to discount any other possibility even when more information presents itself. Media goes to great lengths to keep us from learning beyond what they want us to incorporate into our thinking.

In addition we don't see the big picture because we tend to see it only as to how it relates to us personally. We seem to have trouble relating to how the overall picture affects those that we have no connection to. At least in the ways it covers our levels of understanding.
 
While that is certainly one way to describe what goes on, I offer yet another. I was taught some 70 years ago in art class that you cannot fully see a painting if you stand with your nose up against it. You need to stand arleast 10 fweet away so that you can see the whole picture.

I've mentioned umpteen times here that people form their political opinions with only partial information. They get so locked into that opinion that they tend to discount any other possibility even when more information presents itself. Media goes to great lengths to keep us from learning beyond what they want us to incorporate into our thinking.

In addition we don't see the big picture because we tend to see it only as to how it relates to us personally. We seem to have trouble relating to how the overall picture affects those that we have no connection to. At least in the ways it covers our levels of understanding.

I think that is a fine way to look at it. Sometimes we are too close to a thing to fully perceive it.

I also believe that five people can look at the same painting and have five different impressions of what they see, or at least what they think that they see.
 
I think that is a fine way to look at it. Sometimes we are too close to a thing to fully perceive it.

I also believe that five people can look at the same painting and have five different impressions of what they see, or at least what they think that they see.

A key bromide that wingers always overlook…

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but they are not entitled to their own facts.
 
this is the new argument of theoretical physicists. that there's no such thing as objective reality. each observer is entitled to his or her conclusions about what took place on the subatomic level. particles can't be pinned down to a precise point in space, at a precise point in time.

now this applies to political views? everyone's views are equally valid, because they had different childhood experiences?

if this is true, we should probably just scrap the entire US constitution and all the laws passed since. Because there is no objective reality.
That the truth is a holistic totality … the basis for the dialectical approach that along with materialism forms the philosophical basis for science … does not imply that there is no objective reality or that everyone’s views are equally valid. It means, rather, that many views are true—with respect to certain specified limits—and false—with respect to others, and that truth is uncovered by synthesizing the elements of truth in many worldviews with reference to the concrete facts of reality.
 

“Great Minds Discuss Ideas. Average Minds Discuss Events. Small Minds Discuss People”


-oft attributed to Eleanor Rosevelt


With that in mind, my endeavor here has been to discuss an idea without it descending into a discussion of people. I would say the results are mixed, but that is progress, I believe.

Thanks to all who participated.
 
Back
Top