New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The Evolution of Hell

GordonGecko

President
Have noticed in recent religious blogging a move by some believers to try to re-define Hell as not a place of "eternal torture"....but merely "God's wastepaper basket" where unsaved souls are not punished, but are simply obliterated or "remain dead".

It seems to be a Protestant reaction against Hell, that centuries earlier effected the Catholics....the idea that sentencing somebody to "eternal torture" for agnosticism or eating meat on a Friday seems a bit "harsh". Equating that with guys like Hitler or Stalin didn't work too well for the Marketing Department at the Vatican. So....they came up with the totally non-Biblical "Purgatory", where, unless you are a right bastard, you do a couple of millenia "probation" and then get into Heaven.

Naturally Protestants have no Purgatory...but have found it difficult to resolve a "loving and forgiving God"....with one who TORTURES....for ALL ETERNITY anybody who happens to have doubts along with Nazis and pedophiles and serial killers.

So it seems to be giving rise to the popularity of "Sheol"....where the unsaved dead aren't tortured, just ...remain dead.
 
Have noticed in recent religious blogging a move by some believers to try to re-define Hell as not a place of "eternal torture"....but merely "God's wastepaper basket" where unsaved souls are not punished, but are simply obliterated or "remain dead".

It seems to be a Protestant reaction against Hell, that centuries earlier effected the Catholics....the idea that sentencing somebody to "eternal torture" for agnosticism or eating meat on a Friday seems a bit "harsh". Equating that with guys like Hitler or Stalin didn't work too well for the Marketing Department at the Vatican. So....they came up with the totally non-Biblical "Purgatory", where, unless you are a right bastard, you do a couple of millenia "probation" and then get into Heaven.

Naturally Protestants have no Purgatory...but have found it difficult to resolve a "loving and forgiving God"....with one who TORTURES....for ALL ETERNITY anybody who happens to have doubts along with Nazis and pedophiles and serial killers.

So it seems to be giving rise to the popularity of "Sheol"....where the unsaved dead aren't tortured, just ...remain dead.

This is one of my problems with religions rooted in the Bible. I don't mind a good fairy tale, but I put an emphasis on the word "good." If I'm going to imagine some sort of supernatural order to existence (absent any rational evidence for it), it's got to be a lot more intellectually and morally satisfying than what the Bible offers (and better constructed from a literary perspective, too). The Biblical notion of a Hell where everybody suffers endlessly regardless of whether he's the most horrible person in history or someone who barely made the Heaven cut is morally absurd. Similarly, the idea of a Heaven where everyone gets an infinite reward, whether he's just a schlub who barely slipped in or someone who spent a lifetime sacrificing himself for his fellow man is silly. If you modify that with Purgatory, circles of Hell, and a Paradise with various levels of honors you partly deal with those objections, but then it's pretty inelegant.

A more elegant idea would be an afterlife where you basically spend your time with people like yourself. That would make the only true sin hypocrisy. A Viking raised every morning to fight and die painfully in battle, with some days ending in glory and other in disgrace might be perfectly content with his Valhalla afterlife, while he might find the sedate afterlife of singing hosannahs to a higher power to be dull beyond belief, so as long as he's comfortable living forever among those who acted as he acted, it could be his paradise. But those of us who'd hate to live in an eternity populated with people who act the way we act would be in hell. Kind people would live with kind people, the cruel with cruel people, etc. Broad-minded people would live in a broad afterlife, narrow-minded people in a narrow one.

But ultimately I prefer the idea of reincarnation. If I were the deity, I'd integrate some manner of reincarnation into my cosmology. That provides all sorts of intellectual and moral possibilities and isn't clunky, from a literary perspective.
 
Have noticed in recent religious blogging a move by some believers to try to re-define Hell as not a place of "eternal torture"....but merely "God's wastepaper basket" where unsaved souls are not punished, but are simply obliterated or "remain dead".

It seems to be a Protestant reaction against Hell, that centuries earlier effected the Catholics....the idea that sentencing somebody to "eternal torture" for agnosticism or eating meat on a Friday seems a bit "harsh". Equating that with guys like Hitler or Stalin didn't work too well for the Marketing Department at the Vatican. So....they came up with the totally non-Biblical "Purgatory", where, unless you are a right bastard, you do a couple of millenia "probation" and then get into Heaven.

Naturally Protestants have no Purgatory...but have found it difficult to resolve a "loving and forgiving God"....with one who TORTURES....for ALL ETERNITY anybody who happens to have doubts along with Nazis and pedophiles and serial killers.

So it seems to be giving rise to the popularity of "Sheol"....where the unsaved dead aren't tortured, just ...remain dead.


Sheol is an older Jewish concept. Along with the Sheol concept, however, is a belief in literal resurrection, in which the physical body will be reborn as flesh in the afterlife -- regenerating as from a seed from the Luz.

Both Muslims and Jews believe that the body will regenerate from this small spinal column bone when the Resurrection occurs.
 
But those of us who'd hate to live in an eternity populated with people who act the way we act would be in hell. Kind people would live with kind people, the cruel with cruel people, etc. Broad-minded people would live in a broad afterlife, narrow-minded people in a narrow one.
.

Remember the old Twilight Zone "Nice Place To Visit" with Larry Blyden and Sebastian Cabot...the thief who dies, thinks he goes to "Heaven" and gets everything he wants...and within months is so bored he's going crazy and asks his "guardian angel" to be sent to Hell...and is laughingly informed...he's already there?

Makes me think (even if I am dubious of an after-life) of JackDallas.....his "Heaven" being a world populated ONLY by "guys just like me". A bunch of old lily-white racists....no "lib'ruls", no Democrats, no Yankees :), naturally no non-whites, maybe not even Jews or Catholics.

And within "months" ...he starts to go stir crazy with...nobody to hate. Starts turning on guys who like one sports team more than Jack's favorite team...so the "guardian angel" says "No problem, Jack. We want you to be happy" and removes those guys...

then he turns on guys with freckles...or guys who part their hair on the opposite side of his....so the "guardian angel" removes those people.....then Jack turns on the guy who looks just like him but has on a blue shirt on instead of a green shirt....so the "angel" gets rid of him...until finally?

Jack's the only one in "Heaven".
 
Sheol is an older Jewish concept. Along with the Sheol concept, however, is a belief in literal resurrection, in which the physical body will be reborn as flesh in the afterlife -- regenerating as from a seed from the Luz.

Both Muslims and Jews believe that the body will regenerate from this small spinal column bone when the Resurrection occurs.


A concept of resurrection or eternal death (non-existance)... is easier to "sell" with the idea of a "loving God"....much more than a Hell where the souls who don't make the muster are TORTURED for all eternity.
 
A concept of resurrection or eternal death (non-existance)... is easier to "sell" with the idea of a "loving God"....much more than a Hell where the souls who don't make the muster are TORTURED for all eternity.

Especially the concept of Hell pushed by several Christian sects are horrifying. In those sects, faith in Christ is the only path to Heaven, so that the vast majority of people who have ever lived, including the vast majority alive today, will suffer the unimaginable torture of being burned alive forever and ever. No matter how good and moral and selfless you are, if you don't accept Jesus as your personal savior, that's going to be your fate.

It's hard to picture a God more evil than one who'd set up a system like that.
 
Have noticed in recent religious blogging a move by some believers to try to re-define Hell as not a place of "eternal torture"....but merely "God's wastepaper basket" where unsaved souls are not punished, but are simply obliterated or "remain dead".

It seems to be a Protestant reaction against Hell, that centuries earlier effected the Catholics....the idea that sentencing somebody to "eternal torture" for agnosticism or eating meat on a Friday seems a bit "harsh". Equating that with guys like Hitler or Stalin didn't work too well for the Marketing Department at the Vatican. So....they came up with the totally non-Biblical "Purgatory", where, unless you are a right bastard, you do a couple of millenia "probation" and then get into Heaven.

Naturally Protestants have no Purgatory...but have found it difficult to resolve a "loving and forgiving God"....with one who TORTURES....for ALL ETERNITY anybody who happens to have doubts along with Nazis and pedophiles and serial killers.

So it seems to be giving rise to the popularity of "Sheol"....where the unsaved dead aren't tortured, just ...remain dead.
2 Macc. 12:46, 1 Cor. 3:13-15 suggest the non-Biblical aspect may not be quite accurate; second, where does the Bible say that it is the sole rule of faith?
 
It's hard to picture a God more evil than one who'd set up a system like that.

Some apologists for the "eternal Hell" version say "It's not God's fault....you chose not to accept Him, so He is FORCED to send you there".....which

A. Denotes that God is "helpless" against His Own Rules.

and/or B. That He (God) wasn't the one who created Hell. (If Satan created it, Satan could make it "nice and comfy" and remove all negative aspects to it, couldn't he?)
 
Some apologists for the "eternal Hell" version say "It's not God's fault....you chose not to accept Him, so He is FORCED to send you there".....which

A. Denotes that God is "helpless" against His Own Rules.

and/or B. That He (God) wasn't the one who created Hell. (If Satan created it, Satan could make it "nice and comfy" and remove all negative aspects to it, couldn't he?)

Is God a "Mean Girl"? Geeez, sure sounds like it...If you don't hang with me, you get to eat at the nerds table forever!
 
Some apologists for the "eternal Hell" version say "It's not God's fault....you chose not to accept Him, so He is FORCED to send you there".....which

A. Denotes that God is "helpless" against His Own Rules.

and/or B. That He (God) wasn't the one who created Hell. (If Satan created it, Satan could make it "nice and comfy" and remove all negative aspects to it, couldn't he?)
That's interesting. If you imagine a non-omnipotent God, at work in the world he didn't create, with other powers that constrain him, then it's easier to picture God as good despite the evil in both this world and the imagined evil in the next world: he's doing his best, but there's only so much he can do. But that's not really monotheistic. It's more like Manichaeism.

Interestingly, CS Lewis implicitly took that view, contrary to mainstream Christian theology, in his Narnia books. Aslan, the Christ figure, is bound by rules that the White Queen has learned about and uses against him: rules that give her the right to a betrayer (Aslan just wins because he has knowledge of even deeper rules the White Queen didn't know about, that allow him to transcend death if he sacrifices himself for the betrayer). That notion of even the Christ figure having his hands tied by rules makes narrative sense, but it creates all sorts of other theological issues: who made those rules? Doesn't this necessitate an "Emperor Beyond the Sea" who is outside of the world and the author of it in some fundamental way beyond its material creation, who is separate from and superior to the Savior/Creator being?
 
Is God a "Mean Girl"? Geeez, sure sounds like it...If you don't hang with me, you get to eat at the nerds table forever!


Worse than that....."You don't toe the line exactly as some other flawed human being tells you to toe it....I burn you in pain and agony for ETERNITY for doubting that other flawed human being."

By standard Christian dogma....if you doubt God because Jimmy Swaggert got you "saved" and then you see that Swaggart was a piece of shit (which he is) .....God TORTURES you for eternity.
 
That's interesting. If you imagine a non-omnipotent God, at work in the world he didn't create, with other powers that constrain him, then it's easier to picture God as good despite the evil in both this world and the imagined evil in the next world: he's doing his best, but there's only so much he can do. But that's not really monotheistic. It's more like Manichaeism.

Sure....that "spares" God the appearance of a sadistic monster....if He "has to follow the Rules" that bind even Himself.

And you're right...the next question is "Okay, if it wasn't God...WHO did make the Rules?"
 
Worse than that....."You don't toe the line exactly as some other flawed human being tells you to toe it....I burn you in pain and agony for ETERNITY for doubting that other flawed human being."

By standard Christian dogma....if you doubt God because Jimmy Swaggert got you "saved" and then you see that Swaggart was a piece of shit (which he is) .....God TORTURES you for eternity.

Eternity...although you might call it paradise...

 
Could you clarify what you are asking about?
Implicit in your initial post, to me, was that if something is non-Biblical, it is therefore incorrect. If the Bible does not claim to be the sole source for teaching a believer what he needs, whether it is Biblical or not would not seem to be critical.
 
Implicit in your initial post, to me, was that if something is non-Biblical, it is therefore incorrect. If the Bible does not claim to be the sole source for teaching a believer what he needs, whether it is Biblical or not would not seem to be critical.


If not the Bible, what other "sources" are authoritative???
 
If not the Bible, what other "sources" are authoritative???
Oh, come on, you know my take on this. Perhaps the church that Paul calls the pillar and foundation of truth.

I've answered two of yours now, what about the references I posted about a scriptural basis for the belief?
 
Back
Top