New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The flu

Well said. But the flue kills the old and weak and young children.

The flu DISPROPORTIONATELY kills the old and weak and young children, but even if you only counted those strong adults it kills, it would STILL be a vastly bigger killer than Ebola. The story I linked to was about the death of a 17-year-old who was unusually healthy before the flu killed her (she hadn't been to the doctor in more than three years, then came home with the flu one day and was dead a week later). In 2010, influenza and pneumonia killed 50,097 people in the US. That included 181 people age 15-24, 1,158 age 25-44, and 6,937 age 45-64.

http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/hus/hus13.pdf#081

Some of those were people with other sicknesses, but others were just otherwise healthy unfortunates who reacted badly to the particular flu strain and dropped dead. And some flu strains are actually deadlier for healthy people in their prime. For example, the strain that caused the 1918 flu pandemic killed as many as 100 million people in the course of a couple years, predominantly consisting of healthy young adults (the flu actually thrived in the context of a strong immune system -- using they body's own defensive "equipment" against it). It tore through the ranks of US military personnel stateside, who were all able-bodied young adult men.

Ebola kills anyone that isn't treated properly and in a timely manner.

The current outbreak is killing about 71% of those infected. That's certainly deadlier than the flu, even if you look at the flu in developing countries where even a little diarrhea can kill you, thanks to the lack of basic interventions like saline IVs. So, certainly Ebola is deadlier for those who get it. But, in the same sense, the chance of dying if untreated, from bite by a cobra or a trampling by an elephant might be well above 71%, but such risks don't prey much on my mind. The percentage chance of dying once something occurs is only one factor in the equation, and the far more consequential factor, as a practical matter, is the chance of the thing happening in the first place. You WILL get the flu. You'll get it repeatedly. And when you get it, there's a chance it will kill you. It may be a small chance of death each time, but the cumulative death toll will be far larger than for a relatively rare disease like Ebola.
 
The flu DISPROPORTIONATELY kills the old and weak and young children, but even if you only counted those strong adults it kills, it would STILL be a vastly bigger killer than Ebola. The story I linked to was about the death of a 17-year-old who was unusually healthy before the flu killed her (she hadn't been to the doctor in more than three years, then came home with the flu one day and was dead a week later). In 2010, influenza and pneumonia killed 50,097 people in the US. That included 181 people age 15-24, 1,158 age 25-44, and 6,937 age 45-64.

http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/hus/hus13.pdf#081

Some of those were people with other sicknesses, but others were just otherwise healthy unfortunates who reacted badly to the particular flu strain and dropped dead. And some flu strains are actually deadlier for healthy people in their prime. For example, the strain that caused the 1918 flu pandemic killed as many as 100 million people in the course of a couple years, predominantly consisting of healthy young adults (the flu actually thrived in the context of a strong immune system -- using they body's own defensive "equipment" against it). It tore through the ranks of US military personnel stateside, who were all able-bodied young adult men.



The current outbreak is killing about 71% of those infected. That's certainly deadlier than the flu, even if you look at the flu in developing countries where even a little diarrhea can kill you, thanks to the lack of basic interventions like saline IVs. So, certainly Ebola is deadlier for those who get it. But, in the same sense, the chance of dying if untreated, from bite by a cobra or a trampling by an elephant might be well above 71%, but such risks don't prey much on my mind. The percentage chance of dying once something occurs is only one factor in the equation, and the far more consequential factor, as a practical matter, is the chance of the thing happening in the first place. You WILL get the flu. You'll get it repeatedly. And when you get it, there's a chance it will kill you. It may be a small chance of death each time, but the cumulative death toll will be far larger than for a relatively rare disease like Ebola.

So you disagree with Obama's decision to dedicate funds and personnel to the Ebola fight?*

If not, do you think the funds and personnel dedicated to the fight were proportional to the danger?



*Hint: of course you don't.
 
So you disagree with Obama's decision to dedicate funds and personnel to the Ebola fight?*

I have no idea how much funding and how many personnel he's dedicated to the fight, so I have no basis for an opinion on that topic. If you know those things, I'd be eager to learn them.

I'm sure that whatever he did you consider it wrong, by definition, since he did it. I'm not that way. I might think he did right or that he did wrong. I decide based on the individual facts. If he set aside greatly disproportionate funding or personnel for it, then yes, I'd disagree with that.... it would strike me as a response to the political attention the outbreak was getting, rather than an effort to get the taxpayer the most bang for his buck by putting the resources to work in rough proportion to the magnitude of the threat. That said, a somewhat disproportionate response, short-term, might be warranted, as a way of nipping the problem in the bud.... it might be cheaper, over the long haul, to "overspend" a bit in the short-term, to beat down the disease, than to allow it to grow into a more chronic problem.
 
I have no idea how much funding and how many personnel he's dedicated to the fight, so I have no basis for an opinion on that topic.

Really? Six seconds of googling gave me dozens of results on that. Here's one:

http://theweek.com/speedreads/index...s-military-personnel-to-fight-ebola-in-africa

Here's another:

http://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/ebola-virus-outbreak/obama-seeks-6-billion-ebola-fight-n242181

Here's another:

http://www.wsj.com/articles/obama-s...fight-ebola-in-u-s-and-west-africa-1415215612

If he set aside greatly disproportionate funding or personnel for it, then yes, I'd disagree with that.... it would strike me as a response to the political attention the outbreak was getting, rather than an effort to get the taxpayer the most bang for his buck by putting the resources to work in rough proportion to the magnitude of the threat. That said, a somewhat disproportionate response, short-term, might be warranted, as a way of nipping the problem in the bud.... it might be cheaper, over the long haul, to "overspend" a bit in the short-term, to beat down the disease, than to allow it to grow into a more chronic problem.

Kudos for taking both sides of the issue in proactive, reflexive defense of your Great Leader.
 
Really? Six seconds of googling gave me dozens of results on that. Here's one:

http://theweek.com/speedreads/index...s-military-personnel-to-fight-ebola-in-africa

Here's another:

http://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/ebola-virus-outbreak/obama-seeks-6-billion-ebola-fight-n242181

Here's another:

http://www.wsj.com/articles/obama-s...fight-ebola-in-u-s-and-west-africa-1415215612



Kudos for taking both sides of the issue in proactive, reflexive defense of your Great Leader.
How does that compare with the spending on other disease threats? I'd want to know that to judge proportionality. I realize things like that are beside the point for you, since you opposed every move Obama would make as president from the moment you first saw him, but for someone like me, who sometimes takes positions defending him and sometimes positions attacking him, the facts actually matter.
 
How does that compare with the spending on other disease threats? I'd want to know that to judge proportionality.

Good, go find out and let me know if you think the money and personnel Obama dedicated to the Ebola fight was proportionate to the threat.
 
Good, go find out and let me know if you think the money and personnel Obama dedicated to the Ebola fight was proportionate to the threat.
Why? It was your question. If you think it was disproportionate, you should make the case for that position. You asked me if I thought it was and I said I lacked enough information to say. I still lack enough information.
 
Back
Top