New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The killings in Libya

TaiPan

Council Member
After just having marked the anniversary of the day thousands of Americans were killed in the Twin Towers and at the Pentagon, its a little hard to understand the brouhaha of the right on the killings of 4 people in Libya, despite the fact that one was a US Ambassador. This doesn't come from a lack of empathy, rather it comes from the already known facts of what started it in the first place. A dumb assed closet film producer from California put out a film disrespectful to Muslim beliefs. Well, people here got a little upset with Mel Gibson for his film The Passion of Christ As far as I know no one died for it, but the radical muslim extreme Arab mind works differently when it comes to their religion. They blamed the entirety of the United States for producing that film. We might ask, if this film were made in an Islamic country, would the producer still be alive ? The answer quite obviously is he would be in hiding somewhere much like Salman Rushti. Since they don't live in a society that values the principles of freedom of expression, that's not all that difficult to understand unless your are a conservative right wing extremist.

Of course according to the Republican concept of the Presidency, the president, who may not even have known about the film, was supposed to have appraised the impact, divined the resulting outcome, ( I guess he should have resurrected Nostradamus or Jeanne Dixon for that one) and done something to prevent something he didn't know was going to happen, much less where and when.

Its a little like those conspiracy theorists who are are absolutely convince that GWB had date and time forewarning of 9/11. Again, I seriously doubt that Mr. Bush was in contact with either Nostradamus or Jeanne Dixon.

I wonder today if Mr. Romney has not had a spiritual awakening. He is certainly taking tough about what he would do and would have done and could have done but the simple fact is, that all he has right now is the same information the average American does, he has not yet received his intelligence briefing on the incident. Not that that ever stops Mitt from talking like he has all of the solutions.

The U.S. Embassy in Cairo initially issued a statement that criticized the film. Romney, trailing Obama in public opinion polls on their leadership on foreign policy, quickly sent out his own statement before news of the diplomats' deaths, saying the administration's statement seemed to "sympathize with those who waged the attacks." Romney incorrectly said the statement by the embassy in Cairo came "when our grounds are being attacked and being breached" — it actually was issued before the demonstrations planned in the neighborhood entered the compound and tore down the U.S. flag.

Romney advisers said it was difficult to follow the chronology of events in Libya late Tuesday — especially because he is not yet receiving the intelligence briefings that are customary relatively soon after a nominating convention. Republican officials say he has been relying on his foreign policy advisers and news reports.

But Romney advisers maintain he was correct in immediately condemning the violence against Americans — an effort to distinguish himself from the president's tone, which Romney calls apologist on some foreign policy matters.
(1)

The point being, the election once again is playing out just like 1964, Romney the Goldwater hawk, while the Obama is the Pastoral Johnson, who is meanwhile conducting a war in Vietnam.

9/11/2001 was 10 years ago. 7 of those covered the GWB years and for those 7 years, the Bush administration was unable to bring to justice the mastermind of the attack. but 3 years after the beginning of the Obama Administration, Osama bin Laden slept with the fishes. Today the same president, promised justice for those slain in this vicious attack. Given his track record I am more inclined to believe he will deliver on that promise that Mitt Romney.

Tai Pan

(1) Sourced from the AP
 
I wonder today if Mr. Romney has not had a spiritual awakening. He is certainly taking tough about what he would do and would have done and could have done but the simple fact is, that all he has right now is the same information the average American does, he has not yet received his intelligence briefing on the incident. Not that that ever stops Mitt from talking like he has all of the solutions.

Amen...

424754_413468438713034_277735947_n.jpg
 
TaiPan, while I never saw the movie Passion of Christ, I believe it was the Jews who got upset about it because they felt they were being portrayed as the ones who had killed him rather than the Romans. Of course since I'm relying on memory I could be wrong, but I don't think it was the Muslims or Arabs who were all that upset.
 
TaiPan, while I never saw the movie Passion of Christ, I believe it was the Jews who got upset about it because they felt they were being portrayed as the ones who had killed him rather than the Romans. Of course since I'm relying on memory I could be wrong, but I don't think it was the Muslims or Arabs who were all that upset.

It angered a lot of different groups, fundamentalist Christians, Jews, the Catholic Church, and others. It was very controversial, and Gibson was criticized pretty much from a bunch of different direction. The Catholic Church considered making it a mortal sin, just to go see it, until cooler heads in the Vatican realized that their opposition was generating more rather than less interest in the film. The minute something is prohibited then it becomes a matter of personal honor to see and judge for yourself, what all the hoopla is about. Very similar was the reation to The Last Temptation of Christ, which starred Barbara Hershey as Mary Magdeline, who definitely player her role as the temptress and prostitute convincingly. The controversy in that film for Christians was the idea that Christ had sex. people protested in front of theatres, the whole 9 yards, but no buildings were burnt and no one was killed. Basically that was my comparative point in addressing the differing reactions.

Tai Pan
 
Tai,as we are now finding out the potests were caused by the Movie,but the real attack was planned by the same people who brought down the towers.They used the protest to do their dirty work and took advantage of the protest.

And the ignorance of Romney and all his neocon friends who tried to take advantage of the killings has now back fired because many see them as the liars they are from the Ireaq war and want no part of them again.

Romney proved he is not capable of being near that 3PM phone call or the red button!
 
Tai,as we are now finding out the potests were caused by the Movie,but the real attack was planned by the same people who brought down the towers.They used the protest to do their dirty work and took advantage of the protest.

And the ignorance of Romney and all his neocon friends who tried to take advantage of the killings has now back fired because many see them as the liars they are from the Ireaq war and want no part of them again.

Romney proved he is not capable of being near that 3PM phone call or the red button!

I assumed that by now, given some excellent coverage by the various news agencies, that everybody including the Romney would have figured out that two separate issues are in play here, and while Libya's attack was caused by internal politics, that for them, the movie was a cover. The Young Turks good coverage of the origin of the movie and exposing those behind it and their motives, may start to calm things down over in Egypt, as more and more agencies pick up on this globally. The subplot on this movie, those who made it, and the fact that even the actors are now frightened about reprisals, may (and boy I hope it does) lead to some criminal prosecutions here in the states, (I'm thinking Murder 2 Depraved Indifference) against those responsible. I think the courts will reject the protected speech claim that will inevitably follow for three reasons, 1) not all speech is protected, 2) that given the results of the "speech" that it was was an incitement to criminal activity resulting in the commission of that crime, and lastly 3) who really knows what is in the various laws covering national security especially since 9-11 as the "speech" here resulted in the death of a high level American diplomat.


So at this point despite the fact the Libyans have the supposed perpetrators in custody, I don't think this is over in Libya or here. I hope the Egyptians once they learn the facts will calm down enough to think it through, before anyone really gets hurt. Some of the other countries that have reacted have never been over the last several decades , even mildly pro-American, that will definitely be a different kettle of fish.

Tai Pan

Tai Pan
 
First off, any attempt to use this case as a precedent for limiting freedom of religious speech needs to be vigorously opposed as anti-democratic. Honestly, I think that's not very likely in this case, given that Christians are the favored religion in the U.S. and many outspoken Christians, as well as mainstream politicians, share the filmmaker's bigotry.

Second, I think the Johnson/Goldwater comparison is apt and very telling. As Malcolm X put it, "The wily capitalists knew that the only way to get people to run toward the fox [Obama] was to show them the wolf."
 
First off, any attempt to use this case as a precedent for limiting freedom of religious speech needs to be vigorously opposed as anti-democratic. Honestly, I think that's not very likely in this case, given that Christians are the favored religion in the U.S. and many outspoken Christians, as well as mainstream politicians, share the filmmaker's bigotry.."

Actually I wasn't going there, I was making the suggestion that however visceral the reaction
from religious groups, that those who incited it committed and act rather than speech. Since that act resulting in the murder of 4 innocent people, then the so called protected speech argument doesn't apply, and charges could be filed against the films producers and anyone else responsible for its creative content. Its kind of the fire in a crowded theatre argument, when can you yell fire in a crowded theatre ? When there is one. In this case a movie was produced with the known certainty, that it would produce a violent reaction, similar events having already proven that. Therefore the risk was known and ignored, therefore I believe that charges are warranted, at the very least, reckless endangerment.
 
Actually I wasn't going there, I was making the suggestion that however visceral the reaction
from religious groups, that those who incited it committed and act rather than speech. Since that act resulting in the murder of 4 innocent people, then the so called protected speech argument doesn't apply, and charges could be filed against the films producers and anyone else responsible for its creative content. Its kind of the fire in a crowded theatre argument, when can you yell fire in a crowded theatre ? When there is one. In this case a movie was produced with the known certainty, that it would produce a violent reaction, similar events having already proven that. Therefore the risk was known and ignored, therefore I believe that charges are warranted, at the very least, reckless endangerment.

Except that the film had nothing to do with the deaths. The deaths were in retaliation of US killing 'theirs'.

The demos were not only about the film either. What the film is doing is taking away the focus from the real issues.
 
TaiPan, that's actually my whole point. If you believe that the foreseeable violent reactions of vigilantes justify such a charge against someone based on his political expression, you are giving those vigilantes and any others a blank check to censor any views they oppose simply by threatening to riot. Unpopular speech, by religious bigots, but also by the extreme right or extreme left, often "provokes" violent attempts to silence it, and would effectively be stripped of 1st amendment protection under your proposal. For example, protesters against the Vietnam War could've been charged with "reckless endangerment" because they knew that rightists would be provoked to violent reaction.
 
Except that the film had nothing to do with the deaths. The deaths were in retaliation of US killing 'theirs'.

The demos were not only about the film either. What the film is doing is taking away the focus from the real issues.


I freely admit that the potential for prosecution is almost nil, nobody would really want to touch it, but I'd still like to see the guys who produced this monstrosity ridden out of town on a rail.

Tai Pan
 
TaiPan, that's actually my whole point. If you believe that the foreseeable violent reactions of vigilantes justify such a charge against someone based on his political expression, you are giving those vigilantes and any others a blank check to censor any views they oppose simply by threatening to riot. Unpopular speech, by religious bigots, but also by the extreme right or extreme left, often "provokes" violent attempts to silence it, and would effectively be stripped of 1st amendment protection under your proposal. For example, protesters against the Vietnam War could've been charged with "reckless endangerment" because they knew that rightists would be provoked to violent reaction.

I don't think I am going that far, but will concede the slippery stroke aspect of it. No more so that than the potential abuses of the Homeland Security Act and its little cluster of legislation. To me the first amendment means that I have to spend a lifetime defending the right of some lunatic to espouse a position that I would spend a lifetime protesting. But I am concerned that we often use the frist amendment to cover a broad range of essentially criminal behavior. It boils down to when speech becomes an act rather than speech. Hey, greater legal minds than ours have debated this before, and will continue to debate until time ends.

Tai Pan
 
Back
Top