Arkady
President
I've been studying the Protestant Reformation lately, and one thing that I find psychologically puzzling is how intolerant the Protestants were, even amongst themselves. Since these were people who, at least nominally for reasons of conscience, had split from a powerful religious institution that enforced its orthodoxies with the threat of deadly violence, you'd think that would have been more sympathetic to those who split from their own orthodoxies. But, if anything, they were often more intolerant and more violent than the Catholic Church.
Just as an example, consider the Muenster Rebellion, when Anabapstists took over the city of Muenster for a time. While in charge, they forced people to covert to Anabaptism or die. Or consider Calvin. He rejected half the teachings of the Catholic Church, but if anyone dared to reject something from the half he hadn't rejected (e.g., trinitarianism), he'd burn that person at the stake. Or consider the Puritan separatists who moved to America. The idea that they came here for religious freedom isn't quite right. They'd moved from England to the Netherlands to secure their own religious freedom, but the move from the Netherlands to the Americas was about a desire to take that religious freedom away from others. They wanted to set up a theocratic society according to their own rules, and when people deviated from those rules (like Puritan-turned-Quaker Mary Dyer), the results weren't pretty (Dyer was hanged to death on the Boston Common).
That kind of psychology is hard for me to fathom. In my own life, I generally find that those who have some experience with being a persecuted minority are more sympathetic and less eager to persecute others when they find themselves with the power to do so. But, I suppose, the religious mind works differently.
Just as an example, consider the Muenster Rebellion, when Anabapstists took over the city of Muenster for a time. While in charge, they forced people to covert to Anabaptism or die. Or consider Calvin. He rejected half the teachings of the Catholic Church, but if anyone dared to reject something from the half he hadn't rejected (e.g., trinitarianism), he'd burn that person at the stake. Or consider the Puritan separatists who moved to America. The idea that they came here for religious freedom isn't quite right. They'd moved from England to the Netherlands to secure their own religious freedom, but the move from the Netherlands to the Americas was about a desire to take that religious freedom away from others. They wanted to set up a theocratic society according to their own rules, and when people deviated from those rules (like Puritan-turned-Quaker Mary Dyer), the results weren't pretty (Dyer was hanged to death on the Boston Common).
That kind of psychology is hard for me to fathom. In my own life, I generally find that those who have some experience with being a persecuted minority are more sympathetic and less eager to persecute others when they find themselves with the power to do so. But, I suppose, the religious mind works differently.