New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The Religious Mind

Arkady

President
I've been studying the Protestant Reformation lately, and one thing that I find psychologically puzzling is how intolerant the Protestants were, even amongst themselves. Since these were people who, at least nominally for reasons of conscience, had split from a powerful religious institution that enforced its orthodoxies with the threat of deadly violence, you'd think that would have been more sympathetic to those who split from their own orthodoxies. But, if anything, they were often more intolerant and more violent than the Catholic Church.

Just as an example, consider the Muenster Rebellion, when Anabapstists took over the city of Muenster for a time. While in charge, they forced people to covert to Anabaptism or die. Or consider Calvin. He rejected half the teachings of the Catholic Church, but if anyone dared to reject something from the half he hadn't rejected (e.g., trinitarianism), he'd burn that person at the stake. Or consider the Puritan separatists who moved to America. The idea that they came here for religious freedom isn't quite right. They'd moved from England to the Netherlands to secure their own religious freedom, but the move from the Netherlands to the Americas was about a desire to take that religious freedom away from others. They wanted to set up a theocratic society according to their own rules, and when people deviated from those rules (like Puritan-turned-Quaker Mary Dyer), the results weren't pretty (Dyer was hanged to death on the Boston Common).

That kind of psychology is hard for me to fathom. In my own life, I generally find that those who have some experience with being a persecuted minority are more sympathetic and less eager to persecute others when they find themselves with the power to do so. But, I suppose, the religious mind works differently.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
I've been studying the Protestant Reformation lately, and one thing that I find psychologically puzzling is how intolerant the Protestants were, even amongst themselves. Since these were people who, at least nominally for reasons of conscience, had split from a powerful religious institution that enforced its orthodoxies with the threat of deadly violence, you'd think that would have been more sympathetic to those who split from their own orthodoxies. But, if anything, they were often more intolerant and more violent than the Catholic Church.

Just as an example, consider the Muenster Rebellion, when Anabapstists took over the city of Muenster for a time. While in charge, they forced people to covert to Anabaptism or die. Or consider Calvin. He rejected half the teachings of the Catholic Church, but if anyone dared to reject something from the half he hadn't rejected (e.g., trinitarianism), he'd burn that person at the stake. Or consider the Puritan separatists who moved to America. The idea that they came here for religious freedom isn't quite right. They'd moved from England to the Netherlands to secure their own religious freedom, but the move from the Netherlands to the Americas was about a desire to take that religious freedom away from others. They wanted to set up a theocratic society according to their own rules, and when people deviated from those rules (like Puritan-turned-Quaker Mary Dyer), the results weren't pretty (Dyer was hanged to death on the Boston Common).

That kind of psychology is hard for me to fathom. In my own life, I generally find that those who have some experience with being a persecuted minority are more sympathetic and less eager to persecute others when they find themselves with the power to do so. But, I suppose, the religious mind works differently.

Not in all religious minds.
Again, absolutes are almost always wrong.
 
Not in all religious minds.
Again, absolutes are almost always wrong.
True enough. Still, it's a psychological puzzle.

I've also been struck by the hypocrisy of the Reformation in terms of theological reasoning. The case the more moderate Reformers (like Luther) used against the Catholic doctrines of which they disapproved was that those doctrines weren't actually in any plain reading of the Bible -- that they'd either been read into the Bible with some tortured, creative reading, or they'd just been made up out of whole cloth (e.g., papal infallibility, or some of the sacrements). Yet, when other Protestants used the exact same reasoning to reject aspects of their own theology (again, like the trinity), they freaked out. The basic message was "nobody gets to read stuff into the Bible except me."

At least there was some intellectual coherence in the Catholic position. It's like good sci-fi or fantasy fiction, in that once you grant the initial suspension of disbelief needed to set up their world (e.g., each new pope inherits the authority of Peter, acting in God's name on Earth), there aren't any glaring problems with anything else they're doing -- it all sort of flows naturally from the initial premise, even if there's no justification for the inital premise. With the Protestants, however, there seems to be a lot less intellectual coherence. The rules they claim to follow to reach some beliefs are then invalidated by them when they'd lead to other beliefs as well. In that way, it's like bad sci-fi or fantasy fiction, in that even after you've granted the initial suspension of disbelief needed to set up the world, they keep changing up the rules as you go along, taking you right out of that mindset where you could let yourself ignore the fundamental implausibility of the core premises.
 
True enough. Still, it's a psychological puzzle.

I've also been struck by the hypocrisy of the Reformation in terms of theological reasoning. The case the more moderate Reformers (like Luther) used against the Catholic doctrines of which they disapproved was that those doctrines weren't actually in any plain reading of the Bible -- that they'd either been read into the Bible with some tortured, creative reading, or they'd just been made up out of whole cloth (e.g., papal infallibility, or some of the sacrements). Yet, when other Protestants used the exact same reasoning to reject aspects of their own theology (again, like the trinity), they freaked out. The basic message was "nobody gets to read stuff into the Bible except me."

At least there was some intellectual coherence in the Catholic position. It's like good sci-fi or fantasy fiction, in that once you grant the initial suspension of disbelief needed to set up their world (e.g., each new pope inherits the authority of Peter, acting in God's name on Earth), there aren't any glaring problems with anything else they're doing -- it all sort of flows naturally from the initial premise, even if there's no justification for the inital premise. With the Protestants, however, there seems to be a lot less intellectual coherence. The rules they claim to follow to reach some beliefs are then invalidated by them when they'd lead to other beliefs as well. In that way, it's like bad sci-fi or fantasy fiction, in that even after you've granted the initial suspension of disbelief needed to set up the world, they keep changing up the rules as you go along, taking you right out of that mindset where you could let yourself ignore the fundamental implausibility of the core premises.

Definitely a puzzle and I don't have an answer.

I cannot disagree with what you are saying here. In my experience, one glaring inaccuracy was the (made up) "Thou shalt not drink alcohol" commandment made by several well known fundamentalist or evangelical religions. It is not stated in the Bible, of course, but when I questioned it, the best answer I got was that the Bible says we should not be a stumbling block to others. If an alcoholic shouldn't drink, then we shouldn't drink either so as not to tempt that alcoholic. Something like that.

Made up rules are always a puzzle to me, but the anger that I have seen walking around under the guise of Christianity is amazing and sad, and it is one (one of many) reasons I have kept my Christianity but left the Church. All churches, including the Catholic church, have been guilty of anger toward non-believers and of doling out harm to those who aren't like-minded.

Though I have left the church mentality, I still am a Christian. Our relationship with our Creator should be one of love. That does not mean that we will always turn the other cheek or be meek or be weak little doormats to be trod upon. But it does mean that we don't hate those who we disagree with and we don't deliver those "Sinners at the Hands of an Angry God" sermons to all we meet. It simply means we try to live peaceably with others and we allow for the idea that every person finds their Creator in his/her own way AND if someone doesn't choose to have a relationship with their Creator -- it is their choice and we should leave it alone.

Organized religion has been used a tool to control, to issue guilt, to manipulate people over time. There is no doubt good that can and has come from it, but at present it seems that the bad far outweighs the good and your examples show that clearly.
 
I do believe that the underlying tribalism would have still been present for all of these groups, regardless of the particular flavor of religion that they chose to practice. I don't mean to imply that religion was not a factor motivating their behavior, but that it was most likely merely one of many factors.
 
Back
Top