Arkady
President
To the best of my knowledge this is the first time in history that the Fed has bought U.S. debt
No. The Fed buys and sells US debt on a regular basis and always has. That's the way they "set interest rates." Basically, they decide a target "Federal Funds Rate" (the rate they think banks should be charging each other for overnight loans), based on the unemployment and inflation situation, then they buy and sell Treasuries (US federal debt) to try to bring about that rate, by adding or subtracting liquidity from the market (if they sell Treasuries, the cash they take in reduces liquidity and raises rates, and if they buy Treasuries, the cash they put out increases liquidity and lowers rates). It's a bit different when you're near the zero lower bound, but those are the basic mechanics of the Fed's operation.
I agree. I'm all for increasing transparency.
Yes. You won't find me arguing the market is infallible. It's very fallible, which is a major part of the case for government regulation of the market. It may well have mispriced Treasuries the same way it mispriced Real Estate. However, the likelihood is different. The big historical bubble disasters are generally associated with some novel investment that the market is inexperienced with and gets irrationally exuberant about. Under Bush, it was securitized mortgages -- a novel way of taking subprime mortgages, insuring them, dividing them into tranches and then selling them, so that what looked individually like a risky home loan wrongly looked, in aggregate, like a highly-rated cutting-edge security. Before that, it was the dotcom stocks, which were backed by novel businesses poorly understood by the market. Before that, the emerging markets of Asia. Before that, the trendy S&Ls. Over the years, other bubbles formed around things like the East India Company, land shares in new "gold rush" territories, and other "shiny new toy" baubles for investors. By comparison, Treasuries are one of the oldest and least sexy investments in this country. They're simple, fixed-rate, fixed-duration loans by a known-quantity country. If it's a bubble, it doesn't fit the historical pattern.
No. The Fed buys and sells US debt on a regular basis and always has. That's the way they "set interest rates." Basically, they decide a target "Federal Funds Rate" (the rate they think banks should be charging each other for overnight loans), based on the unemployment and inflation situation, then they buy and sell Treasuries (US federal debt) to try to bring about that rate, by adding or subtracting liquidity from the market (if they sell Treasuries, the cash they take in reduces liquidity and raises rates, and if they buy Treasuries, the cash they put out increases liquidity and lowers rates). It's a bit different when you're near the zero lower bound, but those are the basic mechanics of the Fed's operation.
The Fed is NOT transparent. This is a problem.
I agree. I'm all for increasing transparency.
The market has been blind to all the crashes that have occurred. How can you not know that.
Yes. You won't find me arguing the market is infallible. It's very fallible, which is a major part of the case for government regulation of the market. It may well have mispriced Treasuries the same way it mispriced Real Estate. However, the likelihood is different. The big historical bubble disasters are generally associated with some novel investment that the market is inexperienced with and gets irrationally exuberant about. Under Bush, it was securitized mortgages -- a novel way of taking subprime mortgages, insuring them, dividing them into tranches and then selling them, so that what looked individually like a risky home loan wrongly looked, in aggregate, like a highly-rated cutting-edge security. Before that, it was the dotcom stocks, which were backed by novel businesses poorly understood by the market. Before that, the emerging markets of Asia. Before that, the trendy S&Ls. Over the years, other bubbles formed around things like the East India Company, land shares in new "gold rush" territories, and other "shiny new toy" baubles for investors. By comparison, Treasuries are one of the oldest and least sexy investments in this country. They're simple, fixed-rate, fixed-duration loans by a known-quantity country. If it's a bubble, it doesn't fit the historical pattern.
Decay implies a net worsening. I don't see it. Although I'm well aware of deep moral lapses in the modern age (one merely needs to look to the Bush adminsitration for some glaring examples), I don't see anything as deeply infected and widespread as what we had in earlier eras with things like the subjugation of women and the institution of slavery. In those earlier eras, we were not talking about "slavery" in the sense of liberals supposedly making "slaves" of earners by taxing their property for the common good of the society. We're talking, "I'll beat you to death if I want, ni--er" slavery. We're talking "lie on the bed and if you're lucky I'll give you some ribbons and bows when I'm done having my way with you" slavery. Nothing in the modern era, in this country, matches that moral savagery.Just because you are unaware to moral decay and the concomitant consequences does not mean you are right.